Opinion Excerpt

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON ERWIN CHAPPEL; CARDELL THOMPSON; NORTHWEST No. 86392-4-I ASSOCIATION OF RETIRED BLACK FIRE FIGHTERS, a Washington state DIVISION ONE corporation; CLARENCE WILLIAMS, PUBLISHED OPINION Respondents/ Cross Appellants, v. DOUGLAS JOHNSON; SEATTLE BLACK FIREFIGHTERS ASSOCIATION, a non-profit corporation; JULIANA EDWARDS;