Vista Medical Center Hospital, Surgery Specialty Hospital of America, Southeast Houston and Vista Hospital of Dallas v. Texas Mutual Insurance Company

      TEXAS COURT OF APPEALS, THIRD DISTRICT, AT AUSTIN


                    JUDGMENT RENDERED DECEMBER 28, 2022



                                   NO. 03-21-00242-CV


Vista Medical Center Hospital, Surgery Specialty Hospital of America, Southeast Houston
                       and Vista Hospital of Dallas, Appellants

                                             v.

    Texas Mutual Insurance Company; Louisiana Pacific Corporation; American Home
 Assurance Co.; Texas Department of Transportation; State Office of Risk Management;
    Twin City Fire Insurance Company; Continental Casualty Company; Valley Forge
   Insurance Company; Transportation Insurance Company; Texas Hospital Insurance
Exchange; Mid-Century Insurance Company; TPCIGA for United Pacific Insurance Co.;
    TPCIGA for Legion Insurance Co.; TPCIGA for Home Indemnity Co.; TPCIGA for
     Freestone Insurance f/k/a Dallas National Insurance Co.; National Fire Insurance;
  Hartford Underwriters Insurance Co.; National Fire Insurance Co. of Hartford; ACIG
 Insurance Co.; TPCIGA for Petrosurance Casualty Co.; TASB Risk Management Fund;
    Midwest Employers Casualty Co.; TPCIGA for Lumbermens Mutual Casualty Co.;
   National American Insurance Co.; Aberdeen Insurance Co.; Highlands Casualty Co.;
TPCIGA for American Motorists Insurance Co.; Transcontinental Insurance Co.; United
   States Fire Insurance Co.; Reliance National Indemnity Co.; TPCIGA for Centennial
 Insurance Co.; American Casualty Co. of Reading, PA; Zenith Insurance Co.; Hartford
  Casualty Insurance Co.; TPCIGA for Credit General Indemnity; TPCIGA for Fremont
     Indemnity Co; TPCIGA for Paula Insurance Co.; Ace Insurance Co. of Texas; Ace
    American Insurance Co.; Lockheed Martin Corp.; Insurance Co. of the State of PA;
   International Paper Co.; Lowes Home Center, Inc.; Pacific Employers Insurance Co.;
American Zurich Insurance Co.; Fireman’s Fund Insurance Co.; American Insurance Co.;
      Federal Insurance Co.; Kmart Corp.; Great Northern Insurance Co.; Onebeacon
   Insurance Co.; Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Co.; Liberty Insurance Corp.; Liberty
Mutual Insurance Co.;American States Insurance Co. of Texas; Employers Insurance Co.
    of Wausau; Service Lloyds Insurance Co.; Texas Association of Counties RMP; LM
  Insurance Corp.; Wausau Business Insurance Co.; JC Penny Corporation, Inc.; Zurich
 American Insurance Co.; Sentry Insurance a Mutual Company; Sentry Select Insurance
 Co.; Dallas I.S.D., self-insured; Albertson’s, Inc., self-insured; RCH Protect Cooperative;
      Commerce & Industry Insurance Co.; Illinois National Insurance Co.; Fidelity &
Guaranty Insurance Co.; Facility Insurance Corp.; City of Pasadena, self-insured; City of
 Rowlett, self-insured, City of Hempstead, self-insured; Employers Mutual Casualty Co.;
   American Guarantee & Liability Ins.; Gray Insurance Co.; East Texas Educational
  Insurance Association, self-insured; Harbor Specialty Insurance Co.; New Hampshire
  Insurance Co.; Bitco General Insurance Corp., formerly Bituminous Casualty Corp.;
America First Lloyds Insurance Co.; Arrowood Indemnity Co. for Royal Insurance Co. of
America WC Solutions; Old Glory Insurance Co.; Old Republic Insurance Co.; Houston
   General Insurance Co.; Beaumont I.S.D., self-insured; Arrowood Indemnity Co. for
 Security Insurance Co. of Hartford; Target Corp.; Federated Mutual Insurance Co.; St.
 Paul Fire & Marine Insurance Co.; Indemnity Insurance Co. of North America; Dallas
   County; Bankers Standard Insurance Co.; Travelers Indemnity Co. of Connecticut;
   Travelers Casualty and Surety Co.; Travelers Indemnity Co. of America; Travelers
Property Casualty Co.; Phoenix Insurance Co.; Wausau Underwriters Ins. Co., Appellees


         APPEAL FROM THE 53RD DISTRICT COURT OF TRAVIS COUNTY
              BEFORE JUSTICES GOODWIN, BAKER, AND SMITH
                  AFFIRMED -- OPINION BY JUSTICE SMITH




This is an appeal from the judgment signed by the trial court on May 13, 2021. Having reviewed

the record and the parties’ arguments, the Court holds that there was no reversible error in the

trial court’s judgment. Therefore, the Court affirms the trial court’s judgment. The appellants

shall pay all costs relating to this appeal, both in this Court and in the court below.