Valier, Nkrumah Lamunba
Date Filed2014-12-30
DocketWR-77,638-08
Cited0 times
StatusPublished
Full Opinion (html_with_citations)
77 /
f;6~-oi
~~~~~~\filiu
\~t_~~-~. \$4lolll\
~'Ms-\ Un.lt'
\\~ \-Y\~~g
~-\- ,\ 'k\~\ooBoaMIQ.
.•
rC\J.)~
~k\\\~V-\
-~'.,·~~ '\\~Uu.,~¥-..
~"Ur\- ~~ ~(~ ~~ Abe\ Acosta. C\erk
. ..'\> \.~~~'1.., \d-~8. l lc4-~\ ~~t\
~~\.'<\. '-L-L~ '1 ~ll'
~ •.. \.r-toJ. ~-us:-~~~. \\St>~d...'S-~ . w~-ll, (p~-:0&'
~fur~:
~·~t- ~M ~hllo~ CU\.cl.~k_· ~t.M}t~ ~tt·on 1o
~ \~ ~ -~~\~ ~\1_~\\ ~ hl ~~ ·lDlUJb~i\
. ~~t_~ ~~~~~\.~tnruJ~\\\)L~l~k~ \h ~\-l~
~~-r~~~\tl~l\t)JJ$.~_ Drl~ ~~h.~~
. ~\n_u_~ ~~~t~ c.d.\-e..o:i-;tlC\ ~f ·tk.o..to~ For- C.OYL5..!~~n.
J ~~ ~~ ~\)~~~~c._ l»n\e-'\ ~rill_ to ~ru.li.u', oF
\::~ ~·~ \v'{'\ ~\-l~ ~. ~
\~ ~LL ~\~~ill~~~-~ {:\,J_~ ~k.r:- 1
~~~(
~~-~V'dtM.
.
\S~~'U\"\.~\\ \.._'U.\\_u.\\~\\ \\L-s...E~\ >,
\\~~\ \~-~ ~u.r\. \\S"DJ \SD lo~-~
"!. ~~- -rl\ ~~~- D&
\\\~ ~~\'€. \J~ "\.c't_\\~
\\~~\_~~~~-r~ ~~,~~'0~ '"'~ \\~~t.\\\._.\\\t. ~t.\'{"1-E.h
\\~'t\._~U\~\'~ \\\)\1_~~·\~ ~~~~~~~ l\J~~i..L\Lb~
~-"1-\\\ ~\\c~u~~l~ 'tt.t.\\U~t:l"\-\t lD~\r1.l1I.D\{ ·
~-.'\l~t0\_~\~~ \\\~ \\~~"'-~Ut~~-rs. ftl..G\fT~ lll\\h.E\\ "1H£
~'0.\:.,\>\\_\)t._t. ~ l_\J\U~ Dr -rRt F&u_\\~~\]\}TH: AttEN~HEMl.
\t) \\\~ \\~~D~\\~~t t~\l~\ Dr t\\~hl~~\._ ?t?~Efl~ ~~
l}0\\~~ ~D~l~'h~ \.um~\rc.Jler,,1~t~-M'b.
\Sl.\~l \'\ ,\:.~ \\~ 't:t'\ ckvttl~~·nu<xa M.I1Sci1l~-A a..nd LuA-
\'1, \.o~·-n& ~\}e..~ \:..'hl.~ kn.b~ Lbur-t m GMM\ \\Wh t.~·~ ~-ili~
\.n \\w ~ "'\~~~ '\\~\~ ~~ "1-t:> ~~~~ ~fill~"'(\
. \D\._-\:..~ \'tt~ ~~\~~rill~\\ \J~~~ l'nn.. f\~~s. ~~
~ \'M_ ~ \!,) ~'\b~~~ ~._\D 1 'S,C) (J\= \~ n:,ur-~" \\l'f\U'~l Cu\.cl
l~ ~~\: ~~ \.~~ ~~D~~ \\w~rs.rd ~ ili_tt>\i.bt.OG~ "D
~
\~ ~ ~~ ~) l'\.U.~ \)~ -\.~ ~ur·\:sUutt~ ~~
~\1~~: ~D~~~~~D\~\UL~\:h.W\.0\U~~ ·
D..~~ ~\u_. ~\..~,~~ o~ \_~~\.\_~~Dr ~.\-\l.o..n.S. DF t\u.l.Lnl4f.d~\
~' ~ ~ ~ ~'Lu-~ ~ ~~t\. wL\:.hln L\.'~~l.illillb"
·\..~ ~ ~~,u~~ t)~ \:.~~~. \1,~. tDn~.Y-..""1.\J. §'l_.
~ ~~ \)~hlC~ D~ \:.~ ~u.r\: D~ ~~\ t=lt'~ hl~td: L-t
'M_\A \:.~'. \'NL~~ ~~ ~Dn \:.'M. ~"~~ ~YLIL~ ~ruJhl
\::_~ ~~ ~\" b~ ~CN..l~ ~ C>..~Sr•llJi: Ol= l.LF~ l\_o~~ .. __
. - .· .
. -- . ·::·.:-: :·:.--<.:. :
. . / . r
\~ c\&U~c~·~n..~~~'~'~·~L"~\:.~\\~r.·r& \J.s_~~~ ·
\.l.~ t.~~-\IU:\ ~~ '0~ ~~k.c..to{\_~'L~~Q. .. . ·
. ~~~~\_\:\A~no.\ \_~ ~-i_~~. ~-~n~ ho_~ru\ Ck ~n.olli_.
-~~7"" ,~~~.\{jj~.\\.Ev~w~k~~~a~\\~tc
~.-~~t~~~~~~~~a~D-~~~'m.~~~~~o·.
\:.~ \..\: \..U~u.\.A ~ ~\...~~c~ t'M_ ~~ct.~ 1.\. '~~~
~-~) ~-~~~\..\.~,,~nD..~~'~¥~~o..·~~~t\. D'f<l. .
~\_~~~~~:~~~~~~'-'~\..~~~ ~~~D~~~.
~ ~~~ 'J.\f()...·,'-\~~ \)...~.~\\~\~ (\tt\ct)'
~~~~ '"~~~ ~w·\hl ~~v~~~~ ~~t~L~ ~
~~L~'NL\\~~~ .. ~.\'\~.~~~.w~uld~u..~~t ·: 1)
. ~~ .b~s.. \\'..~ \::~~-- w& L'r\ t.\\L~ LD..~ \f\r.\J~\.:rr, ~LL
·. \...uc.~ ~' \"\~~~~~' -t_\uu_ \"'f\r.\f~htr \fud\~ ~ C!L~tD
·~~~-~\...~'n~u.\;,eC\u~~u_~ ~~~~\::D~~ .
~ \ ~~~~-\:. ~''~ 1 \\. ~~\-~'. l\\RvDl}·L~lS-7lPcd:;l1/t). ~n~
.-~~~~.~ ~~ ~~ UL\'1\L \)\ ~ 'th~~t~hortv\thd. .
\~~~~~~en\: .. ~~~ ~~tcdn_~.:l.\\.. . .· . . . .
.... ·.
. . . . ·. ·.. ~~~u~\l~"""~~(llJ~\ili_~~ ..
~~~.\\-\.~~~~~ ~~~~.L . \\DS~~ ~a_~~-\: ~~CUJcu.~1ilit..
~ \:.~\\~¥\t·r-.~·~\ \C\.rs~ \tt.l~\':-\ ~~ U\}L\ \\~t\ ~.'t\-.\~-~'cl.Sl . •
-~-~-~ \\-~~ D\= \:.~ ~~~~~~ ·~~~~
..
~ .:
~~ ~~'-'"~ ~\.~ '"'~ ~\\~";-\:. ~\~ ~~'N\ '~. t'ru±~~
~tu\~~ \..'~ -\.~·\:'~-~u.~~ ~~ Uu.L~.~. \\S~a.s-,~~L~··
t.h \:\W~r t.~ \:~ ~-~ ~ ~ ~o.~ ~' \-.,\uL. tlnlf'l\ t.~'
'.
\
· ~CL~~~t.ll:lc..D~\"' \)~t'M..~\.~~'\=~~t\:.h~\J~\.L~
~~~~. ·.·
\~~~~~~~\"~~'C\J~D~Lf\\J~W.l.D'!\·
L .
,.
'~~ ~\~\ -tt:,·~NJ\..U. \:..~\\~~\\1~\..r>.k~\ hls_,~~'tk .
.·~ ~~~~~bc.H~\)~ >c.~\=t)\..u~\.\\~~. . .· . ·
·· . ~'~~-\h.o±chtr~~~~~D~ C.au~oM. .
\~~~~ C:i..n.cl..~~\'\1:).\\sD~~ bcu.~hru:JJ Lr\~~b~ J.~t..tth ~el.J
~~~ ~~ ~~ ~' ~u!t ~~~~ tb_ ~ u.nlaw~l ~~~
~ L~~~ WIL/t.~~ CA_~ur\: ~'~ ~~\"'\ ~~clc.nf'u-.o~ Ln.tk
\~'-\-\:.~ ~~·n.u ~u.rt ~' ~rL~ ~\D~ ~ ~~ u.~ 11 ~~?t
,, . ·:. \.
.... l ...·
~~ ~~\.~\.~~X'\ Q~ \:.~~'' ,.\..uuiu- ~v-~\.fu. ~ ~, ~ ~ ,
\c_~~ \SeA.\., 'V,.._~~ .~ ~D ~~~~ ~Ql\. C>~
\:)' ~~"'- \...~~\.2c\.l::l~ D~ ~~\J-~~t\~ D~ \:.~t.D{\~-\-u_\:l.bf\.
\0'\c.,....,~~~ ~~ ~ ~~~k~ \.ts\ C)'i \:.~ tD~~~Lb'f\ D\ \..eu.us...
~~ -~~ ~~ ~ ~~ ~~'\.~ ~~-'\:.~ Lh Jhj~
~t\.~ -\...~ D.U.D..~~ ~'C'\ ~'~ s~~ ~\:r~~ ~. ~~ v
~C)\\ r~~~ \\.~\ ~~~ U clk~ ,d.,~ l"ld. &1..~:\\~ .. \1.'\.ln\. -y:b_~~not
~~~~\..~~'rut_ ~ur-\ D~ ~~Ml \\~~ 'ruU_~: w~ €.~~~
~ ~ \...-n ~~~ t.cs.Q.. ~~ >ro c\S) t }d.b_ whc..i \\,-t\lli_ ~~.a -~(Q) ~~
\...... ~ !''
,·--;::s.. ' \ . . . \ ' ' \ . ' \. _\' \. . \ - .\\ \.
~ \0.1U\.t.SL l:;l~~, \...~\1~\.Ca:~'f\ o·y t'ru.... ~ • ..}....f\
\ \. .'
,D\.lS• \IL~ \:.'ru_~ .
~~~ ~~~'*'-~.NJ '--"'~\It:\:..~~" d1~\l~~c0IvtruL1 ~~
C.c.'n)e\\'.~\\D~ ·~t\.\}tt)~\\ D~ \i'hl_W ~ ~£..'1...~~
~~~~~~u\..~~~~D~~~~·
\)~~ ~\.~ \'\~~w-~~~~ ~ -t'fu.~ v~&\illol\ or .
il
~~~ ~t. d.~ ~~ ~~\J~~ dn{)K ~l.\:\tnu:'r o._D~-f\. D~ H.o~n lD
0
~'<-~ ~Q.~\{'bG~~\.UV~ ~l\thru3:--~0t5Y\ ~~m~r
~\\\ ~,. ~ '\:,~ ~ \U;-t_ WCA-':t ~ la> ~ ~~~ llbu± Whrl
6
0 6
c\...c.k~~ \:.~ ~' ~~ tcmm"~ \D~d~ 'r \\4 L.~l_:\~--~-..
~~ '\.DtA.S:.. ~~'dve~ ~ ~<:\..~ t.'mtt. ~~~~~-\_M t.~
6 ,
~~~ CkS~ \:.~~~~.~~w~ ~,Lt\ ~ ~~ ~3..~r.
~ •\l':,'n,c.~ ~(}.";.' -\,\ua_'~ \\. ,----:-- ~· >c,\u._'\Mru:_L~ ~ ~ \e~ clMJ:><;-" '('
~'\ ~~ ~~~L ~U~X\~ ~~ \:.\vd: ~ ~'\:, • ~ ·.. \..o~ ~Du1_A ~ o
~ _\~~~tt\\:.~~ tJA.~. & , \.JJ'wA:~ hl':i. ~~r Jtt\\\\n.u~Jt
\[~ , ( ~~vtl\.L\\ ~.. \\~·oJ %Jd.b). .
· · ~~-\. ~\" \c.~ ~L~ Dv~~~ ov ~\_ffi.~ o. ~~L~
~~~~u1_ ~ \:_~~~~Mi... D~ tthl WDu\.A~v~ ~ dl_~~. \-\~~
~~~ ~ ~ C,.. ~ \s-'LA_ ~~~t ~'{\ ¥'~~-\:.'hl._ -~ bottAI• So
~~ \:.~ \lt~~c'f\.~ ~~\;~ t..ull.~t\.()...\lS"Dln~ ~f\~d.ODS' ti)hi,lL
~~ ~c\ 'b~~~~DS\ ~~ L~t,k \~L\ \c'n. ~uti:-lbur-t.~t"l\tt\
~'-S~~~~~~~. \\~ ~~ D..~~ D~r'\ t,\\ t_\u_~
('~~<uJ\A.~D~~\..ruJLb~t>t\.()~ -\:.~\ru.u\ o.nc\ ~b.nn 'to~~ ~f\
1
~~~ .\'M.. t)~ ~~ \>~ -t'M_ ~~ o!! J.: ~~would. b..u~ ~· dl~~o
?:..
-"', : ~ ... -: .. ~ .• • f ~· ..~ .. .' • '.· .... ; ••• • ' • ... • .. • •• • •.: ·.:- •
. ·.... .,
~'~ ~~ ~ t_.~'""~~~~~ ~~~\:.~\\~~ ~LD\
~\::.'~ \..~~~~~~·\)'~~\.~.~~tL~~~~~~~~ .·
\:,~ ~~~~~~ ~ ~~~ \-\,~·"ror ~L-t.~.l\\~v~l.t{.
~'-";d..c.\: S I ·d._'\). ~~"U,~~o'l.n...o.Wicc.~'~ <:,;.~.\\~
..
'\._¥ ~ (A_~~~ c.,_~~~ ~~lli ~ ~\u_ ~~~ ~~
~c-...~~~ ~~ ~" \.iv~-~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~ M~ lli~.
-:}_) •· ~~~\~ ·~-\~ '\:'\~ ~~\1:...~~~ ~ ~~ ~~ tk w~C\
ill~~~~ eo· ~'tl. \J..y~~~~ ~ ~~-\. 1:h ~b~ ~ ~ l~R
\tD\~ ~ \"cl..lli.<:A\~1 ~~ ). ~ .. ~t> ~td.~. 1ft w~~ tt..L..D~ \=rot'\ t.~eru-
\...~ ~ ~~ ~CCl~ ~ l'·tt> \...~ \l~~\':.~~~ ~ ·\:_~-~
\':)~ \:.~ u\.,~. ~\.\,'fu... ~ ~~utS>r\ ·'f\b e:.ru., ~~ ~~ t~
~ L'f\ ~~~~~~~ D~ t.\u...'tnr CUI..& ~ ~~ ~ w .
\:.~ ~~'~ ~~ C>.. ~~~ \:.~ ~~u~\1~ ·E~
~'i-v\u.~>t:t ll~\\ ~ ll ~\\ ~\t,) tAl""'~~~~.~~ fcJ_~ ~~
~ -\...~ ~ ~ \.L~ ts~ ~::&.."'tilt~~ Dbbil\ -th e.nnu-~n csF1J.&.:
'\\~~~ ~~ -t'm.- t)'t-~~ D~ ~CUJccte..d ~ QS.3.£. • .l+· of Tit=-~
~~~ ~'f\ tl.u.l.~ ~. \~SDlo.as-~: · . _
\'M__ \\'f\~\t l\~ ~ ~~~ \.'M...t..DLLs-\: DF ~~~ ~~
~~ ~~ru:i~D~ \:~ <Wtc\._w:g_, 61: ro\ vihld-LI>n~ DF t:~f.wl'-led
~~ ~t\~L~\YC\ ~ ~vul~h\ t.csul.d ~ fu~ 1:l.IL~r.Mi-
~~~MO...~~clh~. ·
\\.
~~~~~\Jue_A ·t.vL~ ~'fu.hlts. 11 ei' CULcl ~~' c'' c.c-uld
~\:. ~~- ~ ~~ ~C.cru_~\n CU\. ()\L;:lr;J. ~~~-f\ [)\ ~
~Lb\..U~'a~ C.OrLs.td.o_r~ a-W-L~LDII. FLbJ ~ :~~ cu-ilela_
~r t.u..~ \:..~ ~ ~' \.uvJ b.~~\;::>\ ·l::hn. Uo..I.M wa.,S. Ll..nCUJ.Ct.L~ on-tk
~ y_\u,_ \'\~~ ~L~ ~ ~'€..-Vt.nuS.~WLM'l· .· .
\'no_ ~r.d~} ~ U..~ D Y t=c.l'iL ~l.d.n..nu._ b 0 bk.J;I'\ ~ e..oru.r(~D'f\
t) r ~~ \\--~ t..c.A VLb l.ckd hl.'L ton-~~~ltm.cl ~s._ wuior- Bha. b. Pro~
~ D'f -t\u.. ~ur~"'- ~. ·.
~~~ ~~rtse_.d ·Ev(dnn.t..o_ ~~hl-\ 11 ~\ ~Q~ ~'k.MW on.
~~~~\. d.bt'-\. 1 ~ t.Ur. . 'i ~t ~ &uc.l\ obh_ b '\:;;~ ~~ ~l
I
"
·-~~~ ~~ ~ ~~,-~, ~-~\:~~ ~~ 'L\::~ M~~
~~~\s~o . , .
. ~~~~~~-~~\~'V·~~~D~.D~~~
.
Q~ tt~ '('<'\.U_~~~~~\:.~~ ~~~~~\..~\>...\.~
~~ ~~ ~L~~\;~~%'~~tr~~~~~~w·~
~~~~~~~-u~.~.~~tr.~\bt--~~~,\&u.~.c...l\~
\~\\W\t~~~~\1~\ t~-\:.~~~t-D~~Gr<\1~
.
~~ ~\:.~~~t\OOCU'\UL·~~ \:.~ ~~.~ ~' &... v·l:b~C\ ·
~\'= -\.~ ~~ ~-~~\...~\h~ ~ "~'u:')M.\ ~t>' tn~ ~
~~\:.~~~\~~1\clo._~~d.n~ .. '
~\\~~t...~~~t ~~t\\~~~ ~~~~u.,~~\-'c'ruL~~~
~~~ ~'N.. ~un ~~ \s~~~ ~~q~\G M\.\S""\ ,\\~~~t: tu\l~s -~~(\~ n
~~ \~ ~~ ~~~ ~~\'\ ln ~~ ~ML~C\ WL.th
'~~,A(tL~t>tru).~ \~tcM~~~ \J~~ \k\\W\t-r,m'~ ~~
~~ \~~~~tl...~~ t_\ru\\1\\ \)~\~ ~\JS~~ ~.~~
~~~ ~u-~ ~~~\::)<'\ \U\1:\ ~ ~ ~ lov.r-t ~\ CL
~~\s-\t\.~ ~- ~~-ts.~~t-.~':>~, \R u~~~~·~·
~1'\~~(',~t.\.\\.\ ~\..~ ~~ t~ \\t\ A"·'' D~ ~ \ a.D\'\.
,~,~ . . ,· ':~ ~~~cv-~
-sn..~~~~f\
...~,\S:'ht-~~~\rilitr,~~-~~~\S\ol\~ I~
~~~\..~~ ~ -t~~~ \lfu_\: \\~ Fr\ qqg ~~~
~'Lr& ~~~\~ ~~ ~DY ~~\\~ ~~~~~
\...~~~~~ .
c.~ t>t\.lc.~~ \:.~ \\._~~~~ ~~'~\\.\.
·- . \\~~\r~
~~~ ~~ ~~ ~\~~ \\-\)~ ·- .
.
. '-\:1.~~ \lli~~~ ~~r-o.lli<.'\ ~ ~ v.""T.t.ft.uv-(l
~~~ \m.A ~~ t:Dck_\~.DD\ t \~a.tlDd. t:Ln.cl
\~ .. o·~~\~~ ~~~Dr~ ~th.L 1.trth
~\~81 .
'I
~~~~~~~~
~' ~~~~~~~~ ,\·~t_~-~.\'5'\.\o'Hl\, t~
~~~~~-\:.~CA.. ~~cs:-. ~ ~'~ ~~ ()~ ..
\\~~~ ~~t:~~\o \\~¥'~ \~ ~~ ~\~~~
~ ~~~~ ~~~~" ~~\:.~ '~~d._~tt\ ~ \~~Mtti\.~1'\
\\\.;~~ \'-NL ~~ ~~~ ~ \'M_ ~~~~ ~.
~~ \~ ~~'~"" ~~.~ ~ ~- ~~-~~ 'u_,~ ... ~D~
~\.~~-~ ~ \&__~ -~~ ~~ ~~·\~~ ~u.M-.
~~ ti\.~~\\~~ '~,';,.th~~ ~d..~&\~~\ ~.b(\ \ ~\
"\..iL'l!A_~ \~\\\ ~~ \:.'NL \\\:.~ ~ D~ ~I d.n\l{. .