Nathan, Fred Darron
Date Filed2014-12-31
DocketWR-82,414-01
Cited0 times
StatusPublished
Full Opinion (html_with_citations)
§§ /~//L/»-O /
Iv\ The
CCU¢J( C)F 'Criyy\m@~\ AQQQa\cghumi:;§§:§l%§£ggpems
E>< Pcm“f@ § nEc 31an
App\`\m+ §wm‘ N@. we -y,gf\z? S€‘YW» C"M `
. FW,J Dum)n klan
App\\`cmjrs Ob~]?wt'bm To Tl/)Ȣ 515+ ca OF{ meal
Av\$wef L T\/)P,'_\;`\`c,\ COWJFS R@_ccmme/ja fm
TO"W\€L Ho/\om‘@|£ JUSAF\"CA O)F §Q\c, COWjY § .
Now, Comesfmd Na+¥\am"Ap~p|Ic,m”r" fm H\e, above
enjh`+\eo\"mJ-' numbered C."QUS\J€, and WLS ec+¢wll ’
mak@,w\§ m O@:L@m mci in zupporf §+@+@g im
po\\ow\~v\§ -
'1., TW. SjrmLeS AJI\DN\QH Aw\fj. Ca\o{,u)e,|\ YYY\SPe;prSe/\+€z) H')O/
known acad§ x /-\ Q\\`L.o\/\+S App@,\\a+e Cou/\S¢\ On\y Vo`\§"€ 7
Supnc\"@l`ef\CJ mc +)\O/\@_ QV\`c/\€/lr@. \`v\ ”H’le. FC\/OC£C}` 1`0/) pY`OC,€€'
d\~`n@ '@Pw¥\\`dn wm m§vppor+ed lo . appl§gol:)/€. ease
law +\V_\u‘$ +he `\SSu& wa% no'f §uB-p»`c[m+ly Y`a`l$ed
03 NLO nize¢l in +M Cow_+ 015 appenls. - `
g . Tl’\e_ App§£,an+ Sjm+eo* H/\o+ |/\`\S dff€d} &)O'p€£\} (AJ&§ SGU'
anden>r) b Ap\'o@,\\o}c ch\$e\ Por' 1£@_`\|14@ 110 FQISL
irm app\§c,u \e, cash \m~ md cognizable f$$ues of wh-»
l"(/l/l C((`:A, SMPPOF+QU' bb C;Jm+\,`O/)S from `H/)@- P€,Ybof €fS
R<LCOF ` ` '
3. SW-@@ng '+\W WQS NOEV~\JM @MQ@J 103 +l%
1.
Sjrc(}€$» Ajrjfofvleg 05 +o ’H’)€, AleLCa/AB @f{gr`»/m) gur`/)L
'Hms Jr\rm. §mjrencp, mo lb Yeaf$ `i$ q denial 078 due
0(@.55 md 15 +Llere',w€o\fe \/0`\0/ k CL§ 711/mfa wa.$ _NO
V;dm, +O umw ,:/, @n_g»:D/mw, of w Ap »
\\`C_:J.._W\,JLS AMc>\¢o\\ g Cf\`mina|, v'Re_$)o<)¢/\SI)Q§mg &/10__/ v`Qu‘/pa@'
§\{+H . 366 § d/\bu$l/\ rmloam \/, 3+01+& 859 S¢W?@/ 599 (T€X
Ap~p “Hbus‘ron \:\‘l+h D`;_si‘.] |€C?ZD Te)<as D}g@$+ Cm`m\`\/)o]
L&W O‘n '108%.10 ...\_\M (:ouNL 5{)€@{.'\€\`¢&\\3., asked 'Hw,
§ij h€ Jr\'»eg had e\/IJ€/\@. j+o pfe$en)¥. amf H/)eld .r`e§?‘€@/
+\¢\P,ir CQSQ,. ` _ -
L\. T\/\e A p\\`£wjr _O@`e,c}rs +\/\ajr in absence mp 0/)3 CHLML'
fowz worn Jf\ne Soc,\"a\' Sm,mhllj A¢Jr md or app,l`gab)e
' `\O'€/\e§\b\`o\ CCLSL \&w per+m`m`n@‘b;&\/Oé,a+l`ons md
-H\L:~u'dm\`$$\`(m. uan or pfe§ef\/o ibm ma 0\|)@3€0{
Q,\/\`C)\~€/‘\CIL GALI ‘\H/IL{)()\\`€,FQS onn| 'fofo'£lur€,% xcof COV?C}'
u_(}ring (Af\`v)a\gs`\§$'»\‘rf;h\ <MU' ppa\\o`}*@ Cou/\S€," bmw
\/_\jf icde un Supporlté.c} ~Cc\c'l$ md argue/weak _H’)u$
BOCH 0{\0| V\O‘\' O{d, H/\Q, `ij`l`e,F mc -C_ch[’ i`/\ F@,o\€:l'\mj 'O`
\)`uSX' de_(,`\§\;m ‘H/\L»S 'Mw, Q\ZF\\`C,a/d' U|\€) )/10+ {`U,!e\/& H/IC `
e
efa@e,@jr`\\/Q, ossi§+mce; me @/ 40 provide ,ao|\/ws@r\`&\
`@W)o§`\)nbv) Jro AFW, SMJFQS Ca$&. ' - z z `
go 'T\M Ap \\_`aonjf AFQM~LS H’\CJL H’}@F€.`\S NO l:_\/¢`d@nce, 419 Su{L/.
gm +Ti@_ §O\@, 31»¢.+@»4;+%5 MMOWM +»m '
w\/)Ue,- wide/ma was unfng 40 have e)<`\$jredar)</{
Ym+ pfe§m+ec} due/4b Sairl wi+me$$e§"(c\i»|ufe_'h pVCS¥
eva ~‘r\n@ a\le§@d eV\`dP./\ce,~H/\e, Jr\m`al C_ow\+, Canno,+g
61
1€01~¢\ desrewm`me. .‘Wa Prob0+lbn O£Ps`ce`r$` \/emchlylm .
0\\ ga`w*m§% 110 'H.\<z_'}A§Pp\'\`r!)/HLl and O+MFS on pfoba`}`)})n\ `
+%e;` ‘Pm\@m\ 1511 ‘O@fcpr§ years 015 Q,><'pe_m`mre 51/)00//]
lead +1?)@ Co'ur+ 40 Cov)c|yc/e/ +\?\0+_1`\/) aim/nce 01[`£0!'
volaorml)"ng ‘€.\/{J€nm 01€ rm 0}/¢>9@0/1@01]€0/ U..A',"
4\/\¢ S+zrla 1001,@0‘ +o 'VY:'@@,.+ hL< burch/1 mc pfoo“€, ”
. Ap\@\i@m‘} ' &.\So 0\@`€£}5 110 +\/)ef S+LJLQS '0/10/ C|er)<$ 1007)-
uN, 40 ink/1313 SU\/L W)e/ §+0+£5 Ah§w€f md ‘p€opo$€:o}
~{1\1/10|1`/) S 'H/lu$ ‘H')P,x p)\`Ca/\+ 601/1101 mt 401/161 O@`€,c/+
Pv\br“$o jr\'w, Tf`\bi FO\AF+S Ao{op+\`o/\ 010 Sm`j) 1[;`/105/)9§
am NOv€/v\]oer §\90\*'} §-Jr\n& 09\0\\`¢0/\+ W,Q`ie.\/QJ d~-' Copy UF
`+1/)¢;- 901/110 on No\/emb@r (7`90\%- crHer *'H/); Appl§c;a+'
tim was jrfo/\SMHQJ +0 .`+14`15@ C<MWL .-
§
WV)U&»FUF€, APQ\\¢C,o/\+' Pf_a_.ré§ `Hf\_\$ Coufk FCV)`Q,£A) H/\L,RQ'
PONL€.Y`S "Ra(;or`d md `Hn@ DP\`NO_ 01C H’w__ Co¢}f+ 615/499
»Qal§ md ‘emL€f` 01 ju§+ md 1£<;`\(` r;l@,€,`\§\`on boyd
110/1 +\/1€, 1€001[5 ONJ \0100 Chd grow/1015 pFLS€/)j?d`
fn H/)@, `lmL€F€.§?Z- 01€3`0€+1`£&. '_ -
' ~ ` K §§pe/j£// §0!701`7§/€/ -
' f / ./Q//
' F(`€d le\'\on ~App\{con`,' '
l Fc_é_d Nm%m ;T D.c.:~:b _N@,Az@_z!;$l__ being prghjr@..
in Co_r\,c;ev_“o+@rj I/\ »TDC_.`§,#ID Eoga{ U/)I?L¢ dadm`e. wbj_€f
3.
132110113‘01€ 13@@1,1@ 411/101 111@ 1[0¢€901`1/19 `1$ Tf1,m,1> Cof'
1001 / j _ l
31911€11 011 136me 1(1301‘1 ‘{/M¢/
1:(`€01 DQF1ro1/1 1\10“11'10/\ /£11{31311€£/\`1'
§:`EC£.E~:12_(>€52:[|:2
I Fmd 1\|01111/1'119911`101 \/@111`1@5 001101€,@\011 1111 0
`WuL 1/ flown/1 Co~pg 010 1110 1(1)1€€ 011/13 1/1)0$ SQ.F\/ec/ 1
00 1\/1(>, 310168 AHQFH@ \/10 1:1`1‘$&3 OQSS 113 M011
on 1111§ j11/1€,._1(111;1 0103 01t ` 901/4
FF€11_H D0Fr“01/1 1\101110/1 x