Claim of Lewis v. Stewart's Marketing Corp.
In the Matter of the Claim of Michael Lewis v. Stewart's Marketing Corporation, Workers' Compensation Board
Full Opinion (html_with_citations)
Claimant sustained serious injuries to his head and right shoulder while working for the employer in 1997 and was awarded workersâ compensation benefits. In 2008, the employer sought a hearing to determine the degree and permanency of claimantâs disability. Claimant thereafter provided an updated medical report indicating that he had a permanent total disability. The employer submitted an independent medical report indicating that claimant suffered a moderate partial disability of a permanent nature and was capable of performing some type of work. The employerâs request to cross-examine claimant and his physician concerning claimantâs ability to work was denied, and the Workersâ Compensation Law Judge determined that claimant had a permanent total disability as a result of his
We reverse. The employer and carrier argue that the request to cross-examine claimant and his physician was improperly denied. It is clear that, where the employer makes a timely request to do so, it should be afforded an opportunity to obtain the testimony of the claimant and his or her physician (see 12 NYCRR 300.10 [c]; Matter of Carr v Cairo Fire Dist., 80 AD3d 810, 811-812 [2011]; Matter of Pistone v Samâs Club, 295 AD2d 875, 875 [2002]). Moreover, inasmuch as the record contains conflicting medical reports regarding the nature of claim â antâs disability, denial of the employerâs request to cross-examine claimantâs physician clearly prejudiced the employer (see Matter of Carr v Cairo Fire Dist., 80 AD3d at 812; Matter of Pistone v Samâs Club, 295 AD2d at 876; compare Matter of Robideau v Van Rensselaer Manor, 56 AD3d 866, 867 [2008]).
Rose, McCarthy, Garry and Egan Jr., JJ., concur. Ordered that decision is reversed, without costs, and matter remitted to the Workersâ Compensation Board for further proceedings not inconsistent with this Courtâs decision.