Full Opinion

Case: 25-1354 Document: 55 Page: 1 Filed: 11/20/2026 NOTE: This disposition is nonprecedential. United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit ______________________ AMERICAN HONDA MOTOR CO., INC., TESLA, INC., Appellants v. NEO WIRELESS LLC, Appellee ______________________ 2025-1354, 2025-1360 ______________________ Appeals from the United States Patent and Trademark Office, Patent Trial and Appeal Board in Nos. IPR2022- 01567, IPR2023-00793, IPR2023-00963. ______________________ Decided: November 20, 2026 ______________________ JOHN JOHNSON, Fish & Richardson P.C., New York, NY, argued for all appellants. Appellant American Honda Motor Co., Inc. also represented by JEFFREY CHUANG-WEI MOK; MICHAEL JOHN BALLANCO, TIMOTHY W. RIFFE, Wash- ington, DC. THOMAS H. REGER, II, Fish & Richardson P.C., Dallas, TX, for appellant Tesla, Inc. Also represented by TIMOTHY W. RIFFE, Washington, DC. Case: 25-1354 Document: 55 Page: 2 Filed: 11/20/2026 2 AMERICAN HONDA MOTOR CO., INC. v. NEO WIRELESS LLC PARHAM HENDIFAR, Lowenstein & Weatherwax LLP, Santa Monica, CA, argued for appellee. Also represented by KENNETH J. WEATHERWAX. ______________________ Before MOORE, Chief Judge, PROST and TARANTO, Circuit Judges. TARANTO, Circuit Judge. Neo Wireless LLC owns U.S. Patent No. 10,447,450, whose claims were held not proven unpatentable in the in- ter partes reviews (IPRs) under 35 U.S.C. §§ 311–319 now before us. In its decision jointly resolving all three IPRs, the Patent Trial and Appeal Board concluded that “a start- ing time-frequency coordinate,” a requirement of all claims, does not cover separate time and frequency coordinates. The Board relied for that construction in significant part on its previous decision declining to institute an IPR of the same claims, in which the Board agreed with Neo’s submis- sion about that claim phrase’s scope. The Board here viewed the earlier proceeding as establishing a scope-lim- iting prosecution disclaimer. Based on its claim construc- tion, the Board rejected the challenge to the ’450 patent’s claims because, it found, the asserted prior-art references used separate time and frequency coordinates and so did not teach “a starting time-frequency coordinate.” Ameri- can Honda Motor Co. Inc. v. Neo Wireless LLC, IPR2022- 01567, 2024 WL 4648090 (P.T.A.B. Nov. 1, 2024) (Deci- sion). Honda and Tesla appeal, arguing that prosecution dis- claimer does not apply and that the claim limitation is broad enough to cover separate time and frequency values. Because the meaning of “coordinate,” as used in the ’450 patent, confirms that “a starting time-frequency coordi- nate” refers to a single value, we affirm. Case: 25-1354 Document: 55 Page: 3 Filed: 11/20/2026 AMERICAN HONDA MOTOR CO., INC. v. NEO WIRELESS LLC 3 I A The ’450 patent describes a system for minimizing “control overhead” in a wireless network to improve band- width-use efficiency. See ’450 patent col. 1, lines 33–34, col. 2, lines 13–16, 45–47. Control overhead is information transmitted to inform a device of what time-frequency re- sources it is to use. See id., col. 1, lines 40–55. Several embodiments described in the ’450 patent de- pict a “way of managing multiple packet streams” that minimizes overhead by grouping resource allocations for similar applications together in a prescribed “zone” within the broader “time-frequency resource.” Id., col. 2, lines 50– 54, col. 5, lines 42–43. When allocations are grouped into zones by type, instead of being slotted less compactly throughout the overall time-frequency resource, fewer bits are needed in control overhead to direct a particular packet stream to its resource allocation. Id., col. 5, lines 32–37. Figure 6 illustrates such a grouping within the resource. Id., fig. 6. In the example, “Zone 1” is the dedicated zone for one type of application (here, voice applications), V1 (top left) represents the resource segment allocation for the first Case: 25-1354 Document: 55 Page: 4 Filed: 11/20/2026 4 AMERICAN HONDA MOTOR CO., INC. v. NEO WIRELESS LLC voice-packet stream, V2 (middle left) for the second voice- packet stream, and so on. Id., col. 6, lines 12–14. The width of each column within a zone is fixed at a predeter- mined number of subcarriers based on the proportional re- lationship between the bandwidth of a channel and the number of subcarriers within it. See id., col. 4, lines 27–29, col. 6, lines 9–10. Because the time-frequency resource is divided into zones, “a mapping . . . to [a] segment may be achieved using a one-dimensional offset with respect to the origin of the zone rather than the two-dimensional . . . mapping method” found in the prior art. Id., col. 6, lines 23–29. For example, the starting locations of the first, sec- ond, and third packet streams in Zone 1 can be given by VZI1 = 0, VZI2 = 1, and VZI3 = 9, respectively. Id., col. 7, lines 18–27. The key claim language for present purposes is the ’450 patent’s description of the portion of control overhead indi- cating where a segment begins, which it calls “a starting time-frequency coordinate.” The parties agree that inde- pendent claim 1 is representative of the claims on appeal: 1. An operating method for a wireless network comprising at least a base station and a mobile sta- tion, the wireless network employing a frame struc- ture of multiple frames for transmission, each frame comprising a plurality of time intervals, each time interval comprising a plurality of orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM) symbols, and each OFDM symbol containing a plurality of frequency subcarriers, the method comprising: assigning an identifier to the mobile station; transmitting a signal containing information from the base station to the mobile station over a segment of time-frequency resource, the seg- ment having a starting time-frequency co- ordinate and the segment comprising N time- frequency resource units within a time inter- Case: 25-1354 Document: 55 Page: 5 Filed: 11/20/2026 AMERICAN HONDA MOTOR CO., INC. v. NEO WIRELESS LLC 5 val, each unit containing a set of frequency sub- carriers in a group of OFDM symbols, where N = 2, 4, or 8; and receiving by the mobile station the transmitted signal; and recovering by the mobile station the infor- mation from the received signal based on the starting time-frequency coordinate and N in conjunction with the identifier assigned to the mobile station. Id., col. 12, lines 47–67 (emphases added). B 1 The three IPRs jointly decided here were based on pe- titions for IPRs filed in the Patent and Trademark Office (PTO) by several companies in fall 2022 and spring 2023. Earlier, on September 16, 2021, Dell Technologies, Inc. (Dell) had petitioned the PTO for an IPR of all claims of the ’450 patent (Dell IPR). In its petition, Dell argued that the claims should be deemed unpatentable for obviousness over two prior-art references. J.A. 776, 784–828. In its preliminary response, Neo argued that Dell’s asserted ref- erences did not suggest a one-dimensional time-frequency approach to reducing control overhead. J.A. 979. Neo sum- marized its contention as follows: FIG. 6 [of the ’450 patent] does not show using a time coordinate and an independent frequency co- ordinate to specify V2 . . . . Rather, consistent with the invention’s objective of reducing control over- head, FIG. 6 shows that only one time-frequency coordinate, VZI2 = 1, is needed to specify where V2 starts in both time and frequency. . . . [Dell’s] Petition incorrectly proposes that the word “coordinate” allows for a combination of two coordinates and, specifically, [that] “a starting Case: 25-1354 Document: 55 Page: 6 Filed: 11/20/2026 6 AMERICAN HONDA MOTOR CO., INC. v. NEO WIRELESS LLC time-frequency coordinate” [can] be interpreted to encompass a time coordinate plus a frequency coor- dinate. But [ ] claim [1] does not recite a time coor- dinate and a frequency coordinate; it recites a starting time-frequency coordinate. So, the con- struction contravenes the plain meaning. Based on that erroneous construction, [Dell] concludes that [the prior-art] disclosure of “a start symbol offset (8 bits)” plus “a start logical subchannel offset (6 bits)” satisfies the recited “starting time-frequency coor- dinate.” J.A. 989–90 (internal citations omitted) (emphases in orig- inal). The Board declined to institute review of the chal- lenged claims on March 16, 2022. J.A. 1066–95 (Dell IPR Denial). Two aspects of the Board’s denial are particularly relevant for present purposes. First, the Board stated that “no terms or phrases in the claims require[d] express con- struction.” J.A. 1078. Second, the Board concluded that the asserted prior-art combination failed to teach the start- ing time-frequency limitation. The Board explained that it agreed with Neo that the asserted prior art taught “only [ ] independent time and frequency coordinates and inde- pendent time and frequency units.” J.A. 1091. It added that Dell’s challenge was “premised on [its] . . . conclusory conflation of . . . separate starting time and frequency coor- dinates as the recited singular ‘starting time-frequency co- ordinate.’” J.A. 1092. 2 On September 27, 2022, Volkswagen Group of America, Inc. petitioned the Board for an IPR of all claims of the ’450 patent, relying on prior-art references that had not been the basis of Dell’s challenge. Volkswagen’s petition quoted the Dell IPR Denial’s explanation that Dell had con- flated “separate starting time and frequency coordinates as the recited singular ‘starting time-frequency coordinate.’” J.A. 172–73 (quoting J.A. 1092). But Volkswagen argued Case: 25-1354 Document: 55 Page: 7 Filed: 11/20/2026 AMERICAN HONDA MOTOR CO., INC. v. NEO WIRELESS LLC 7 that its asserted prior art, and particularly a reference called Vijayan089, did recite a singular coordinate consist- ing of the ordered pair (Symbol Period, Subband Group). See J.A. 199–202. Vijayan089 is U.S. Patent Application No. 2005/0058089. It teaches techniques for multiplexing and transmitting multiple data streams in a multi-carrier wireless communication system. J.A. 663, ¶ 3. The overall system bandwidth is “effectively partition[ed]” into fre- quency bands—“multiple orthogonal subbands”—by using some “multi-carrier modulation techniques” (e.g., orthogo- nal frequency-division multiplexing (OFDM), as described in the ’450 patent). J.A. 663, ¶ 5. Figure 7B of Vijayan089 shows the assignment of these subband partitions: J.A. 654. In a data transmission, each “frame” (transmis- sion segment) has a “predetermined time duration, which is given in units of [ ] symbol periods.” J.A. 665, ¶ 46. The resources are allocated on a time-frequency plane (the time axis in symbol periods, the frequency axis in subband groups) “where each transmission unit corresponds to one subband in one symbol period and may be used to transmit one data symbol.” J.A. 663, ¶ 9. The overall frame may Case: 25-1354 Document: 55 Page: 8 Filed: 11/20/2026 8 AMERICAN HONDA MOTOR CO., INC. v. NEO WIRELESS LLC also be partitioned into strips that have different heights, i.e., “different numbers of subband groups.” J.A. 668, ¶ 76. The Board instituted the requested IPR on May 4, 2023. In its institution decision, the Board preliminarily found that “regardless of whether [it] adopt[ed] [Neo’s] con- struction of ‘time-frequency coordinate’ as ‘one[-]dimen- sional time-frequency coordinate,’ . . . at least Vijayan089 t[aught] such a [ ] coordinate.” Volkswagen Group of Amer- ica, Inc. v. Neo Wireless LLC, IPR No. 2022–01567, 2023 WL 5059729 at *6 (P.T.A.B. May 4, 2023). The Board ex- plained that because Vijayan089’s scheme “effectively maps all of the slots in a two-dimensional (2-D) strip onto a one-dimensional (1-D) strip and then performs 2-D slot assignment using one dimension,” Vijayan089 “teaches a one-dimensional time-frequency coordinate.” Id. at *17 (citing J.A. 668, ¶ 74). 1 After receiving post-institution filings and argument, the Board in its final written decision ultimately rejected the petitioners’ challenge to the ’450 patent’s claims. Deci- sion, at *21–22. On the only issue now presented on ap- peal, the Board explained its agreement with Neo about the scope of the claim requirement of “a starting time-fre- quency coordinate,” relying in part, though not exclusively, on the Board’s 2021 Dell IPR Denial. The Board wrote: [W]e agree with Patent Owner that the Board’s de- cision denying institution in [the Dell IPR Denial], 1 After instituting Volkswagen’s IPR, the Board re- ceived (in spring 2023) a petition from American Honda Motor Co., Inc. and (in summer 2023) a petition from Gen- eral Motors LLC, Nissan North America, Inc., and Tesla, Inc. In fall 2023 the Board joined those petitioners to the Volkswagen IPR (hence the three IPRs in the caption here). At present, only Honda and Tesla remain as petitioners (now appellants). Case: 25-1354 Document: 55 Page: 9 Filed: 11/20/2026 AMERICAN HONDA MOTOR CO., INC. v. NEO WIRELESS LLC 9 finding that “a starting time-frequency coordinate” is not disclosed by separate starting time and fre- quency coordinates, constitutes a disclaimer which is binding on these proceedings. As such, we find that the ordinary and customary meaning of “a starting time frequency coordinate” excludes sepa- rate time and frequency coordinates. We further agree with Patent Owner that the ’450 Patent Specification is consistent with this construction because it discloses segments of time-frequency re- source (e.g., V1, V2, . . . Vm) each having a starting time-frequency coordinate (e.g., index VZ1 = 0, VZ2 = 1, VZ3 = 9 . . . Vm). Decision, at *8 (internal citations omitted); see also id. at *14 (“As explained above . . . , we find that separate time and frequency coordinates have been disclaimed from the ordinary and customary meaning of ‘a starting time-fre- quency coordinate.’”). Applying that understanding of the claim limitation at issue, the Board then found that petitioners had not shown that Vijayan089 meets the limitation. Specifically, the Board found, what petitioners identified in Vijayan089 as meeting the limitation in fact relied on separate time and frequency coordinates (contrary to the requirement of the claim limitation) and petitioners had pointed to no contrary passage in Vijayan089. Decision, at *14. Finally, the Board ruled that petitioners had not timely raised an argu- ment that a relevant artisan would modify Vijayan089 to “assign index numbers to all slots and identify the starting coordinate of a segment through the slot index number.” Id. (citing J.A. 9425). The Board entered final judgment on November 1, 2024. Honda and Tesla timely appealed the Board’s con- struction of “a starting time-frequency coordinate” on Jan- uary 2, 2025. We have jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1295(a)(4)(A). Case: 25-1354 Document: 55 Page: 10 Filed: 11/20/2026 10 AMERICAN HONDA MOTOR CO., INC. v. NEO WIRELESS LLC II In reviewing the Board’s decision, we resolve legal is- sues de novo and review findings of fact for substantial-ev- idence support. Incept LLC v. Palette Life Sciences, Inc., 77 F.4th 1366, 1371 (Fed. Cir. 2023). The ultimate construc- tion of a patent claim term and the proper understanding of “evidence intrinsic to the patent (the patent claims and specifications, along with the patent’s prosecution history)” are legal issues. Teva Pharmaceuticals USA, Inc. v. Sandoz, Inc., 574 U.S 318, 331 (2015). A 1 Petitioners’ principal arguments concern the legal is- sue of how properly to construe the claim limitation, “a starting time-frequency coordinate.” “As with any claim construction analysis, we begin with the claim language.” In re NTP, Inc., 654 F.3d 1279, 1288 (Fed. Cir. 2011) (citing Phillips v. AWH Corp., 415 F.3d 1303, 1312 (Fed. Cir. 2005) (en banc)). And here, the language of the contested claim phrase, “a starting time-frequency coordinate,” supports the Board’s construction. Claim 1 reads, in relevant part, “the segment having a starting time-frequency coordinate and the segment com- prising N time-frequency resource units within a time in- terval.” ’450 patent, col. 12, lines 58–60 (emphasis added). The immediately striking characteristic of the claim phrase is the absence of an “s” at the end of “coordinate.” The term “coordinate” is a singular, not plural, noun, requiring a sin- gle figure to identify its subject. See Hertz Corp. v. Friend, 559 U.S. 77, 93 (2010) (construing a statute to require a single principal place of business where “[t]he word ‘place’ is in the singular, not the plural”). The modifier in front of “coordinate” specifies the subject—time and frequency. Thus, the language on its face requires a single figure that denotes time and frequency information. Case: 25-1354 Document: 55 Page: 11 Filed: 11/20/2026 AMERICAN HONDA MOTOR CO., INC. v. NEO WIRELESS LLC 11 The ’450 specification connects the recited coordinate to a single value. The ’450 patent consistently refers to the starting location of a resource segment as its “offset.” See ’450 patent, col. 1, lines 62–64, col. 6, lines 24–29, col. 7, lines 7–9. It explains that this offset, representing the starting place of a segment, is one-dimensional. Id., col. 6, lines 22–26 (“When the zones are further subdivided into time-frequency segments in accordance with certain rules, a mapping of packet streams to segment may be achieved using a one-dimensional offset with respect to the origin of the zone rather than the two-dimensional . . . mapping [used in the prior art].” (emphasis added)). This descrip- tion highlights the distinction from the prior art, in which specifying the segment location calls for separate offsets in time and in frequency. Id., col. 1, lines 62–66 (describing the start of a prior-art segment as “[t]he resource allocation . . . identified in the time domain scale with a start symbol offset . . . and in the frequency domain scale with a start logical subchannel offset”). Moreover, the specification ex- emplifies “a starting time-frequency coordinate” as each a single value—one of VZI1, VZI2, VZI3, etc. Id., fig. 6; col. 7, lines 7–27; see Decision, at *8. This understanding fits the specification’s focus on the efficiency gain over the prior art from reducing control overhead. Petitioners’ view that the starting time-frequency coordinate “may also be identified as separate time and frequency coordinates,” Petitioners’ Opening Br. at 36, is undercut by the specification in the foregoing ways. Petitioners assert that “any location on a general x-y graph can be expressed using separate x and y coordi- nates.” Petitioners’ Opening Br. at 37. But that assertion does not establish an ordinary meaning of the singular “co- ordinate” as referring to a pair (x, y), as opposed to refer- ring to each member of that pair. Indeed, petitioners’ own language—“separate x and y coordinates”—confirms the ordinary meaning of “coordinate” when it appears in the singular. Case: 25-1354 Document: 55 Page: 12 Filed: 11/20/2026 12 AMERICAN HONDA MOTOR CO., INC. v. NEO WIRELESS LLC The foregoing supplies the textual (claim and specifica- tion) background for Neo’s statements that the required co- ordinate must be a single value, not separate time and frequency values, in its preliminary response to Dell’s 2021 IPR petition. J.A. 989–90. The Board relied on that view of the claim limitation in denying institution in March 2022. See J.A. 1088–89 (citing J.A. 989–990); J.A. 1092. Petitioners take issue with the Board’s invocation of pros- ecution disclaimer to arrive at its construction. See, e.g., Petitioners’ Opening Br. at 24–31. We reject this criticism. As we have explained, the claim and specification evi- dence points strongly in favor of the very position Neo suc- cessfully urged on the Board in the Dell IPR. In this context, Neo’s statements in the Dell IPR to the effect that “only one time-frequency coordinate, [e.g.,] VZI2 = 1, is needed to specify where [a segment] starts in both time and frequency” provide further support for the conclusion that the meaning of the claimed “coordinate” is limited to a sin- gle value. J.A. 989 (emphasis in original). Because Dell’s IPR statements are entirely consistent with the claim and specification intrinsic evidence, we need not assess whether, if they were not, the statements would support a disclaimer conclusion. Accordingly, we agree with the Board: The claims of the ’450 patent require that the starting point of a segment of time-frequency resource be specified by a single value—“a starting time-frequency coordinate”—not by separate time and frequency values. 2 Petitioners, in their reply brief to this court, seem to present a challenge to the Board’s finding that Vijayan089 fails to disclose “a starting time-frequency coordinate” even under the claim construction the Board adopted (and we affirm). See Petitioners’ Reply Br. at 10–14. This challenge is necessarily different from a challenge to the Board’s con- struction. See Mettler-Toledo, Inc. v. B-Tek Scales, LLC, 671 F.3d 1291, 1297 (Fed. Cir. 2012). It would involve our Case: 25-1354 Document: 55 Page: 13 Filed: 11/20/2026 AMERICAN HONDA MOTOR CO., INC. v. NEO WIRELESS LLC 13 substantial-evidence review of the Board’s factual finding about the teaching of Vijayan089. Sierra Wireless, ULC v. Sisvel S.p.A., 130 F.4th 1019, 1022 (Fed. Cir. 2025). Peti- tioners therefore had to present this challenge, separately and with developed argument, in its opening brief. See, e.g., Communications Test Design, Inc. v. Contec, LLC, 952 F.3d 1356, 1363 n.4 (Fed. Cir. 2020); SmithKline Beecham Corp. v. Apotex Corp., 439 F.3d 1312, 1319 (Fed. Cir. 2006). Petitioners did not do so. Their opening brief states a single issue—one of claim construction—in the statement of the issues. Petitioners’ Opening Br. at 4. There is no reference to substantial-evidence review when stating the standard of review. Id. at 23–24. The arguments that fol- low, as confirmed by the headings, are consistent with that singular focus on seeking reversal of the Board’s assertedly too-narrow claim construction based on the Board’s invoca- tion of prosecution disclaimer. Id. at 24–38. A final section of the opening brief discusses Vijayan089, but it does so only to contend that the Board’s application of its claim construction to Vijayan089 makes evident the error of the claim construction. Id. at 38–43. In this circumstance, pe- titioners have not preserved an argument that the Board reversibly erred in its reading of Vijayan089. III We have considered petitioners’ remaining arguments and find them unpersuasive. For the foregoing reasons, we affirm the Board’s decision. AFFIRMED