Cocona, Inc. v. Vf Outdoor, LLC
CourtCourt of Appeals for the Federal Circuit
Date FiledNovember 17, 2026
Docket25-1458
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Case: 25-1458 Document:75 Page:1_ Filed: 11/17/2026
Gnited States Court of Appeals
for the Hederal Circuit
COCONA, INC.,
Plaintiff-Appellant
Vv.
VF OUTDOOR, LLC, COLUMBIA SPORTSWEAR
COMPANY,
Defendants-Appellees
2025-1458, 2025-1462
Appeals from the United States District Court for the
District of Colorado in Nos. 1:16-cv-02703-CMA-SBP, 1:17-
cv-01195-CMA-SBP, Judge Christine M. Arguello.
Decided: November 17, 2026
CHAD T. NITTA, Kutak Rock LLP, Denver, CO, argued
for plaintiff-appellant. Also represented by LOGAN MURR,
HEATHER NICOLE TILLEY.
BART STARR, Sheridan Ross PC, for defendant-appellee
Columbia Sportswear Company. Also represented by
TIMOTHY S. DEJONG, Stoll, Stoll, Bernie, Lokting &
Shlachter, PC, Portland, OR.
PETER GERGELY, Merchant & Gould PC, New York, NY,
argued for all defendants-appellees. Defendant-appellee
Case: 25-1458 Document:75 Page:2_ Filed: 11/17/2026
2 COCONA, INC. v. VF OUTDOOR, LLC
VF Outdoor, LLC also represented by ANDREW O. LARSEN;
MICHAEL A. ERBELE, Minneapolis, MN; RYAN JAMES
FLETCHER, Denver, CO.
Before LOURIE, STOLL, and STARK, Circuit Judges.
STARK, Circuit Judge.
Cocona, Inc. (““Cocona’”) sued VF Outdoor, LLC d/b/a
The North Face “VF Outdoor”) and Columbia Sportswear
Company (“Columbia”) for infringing its U.S. Patent
No. 8,945,287 (°287 patent”), which claims a waterproof,
breathable material. The district court determined that
the asserted claims are invalid due to indefiniteness and
entered final judgment for VF Outdoor and Columbia. Co-
cona now appeals. We affirm.
I
A
Cocona owns the ’287 patent, entitled “Active Particle-
Enhanced Membrane and Methods for Making and Using
the Same.” The ’287 patent relates generally to a water-
proof and breathable membrane designed for use in mate-
rials such as outdoor apparel. The patent purports to
address a problem inherent in prior art waterproof materi-
als: in addition to keeping moisture out, they also trap
moisture in, which can decrease comfort for the wearer.
According to the ’287 patent, a solution is to improve the
material’s moisture transport properties. By enhancing a
membrane’s ability to allow water vapor, such as sweat, to
move through the material while also repelling liquid wa-
ter, such as rain, the performance and comfort of the mate-
rial are improved.
More particularly, the ’287 patent is directed to an ac-
tive particle-enhanced waterproof membrane. Its claims
employ active particles, such as activated carbon, in a
membrane so as to improve the vapor transfer through the
Case: 25-1458 Document:75 Page:3 _ Filed: 11/17/2026
COCONA, INC. v. VF OUTDOOR, LLC 3
membrane. This increases breathability while also en-
hancing the material’s performance with respect to other
properties, including odor absorption.
A key performance measure of the claimed membrane’s
functionality is its moisture vapor transmission rate
(MVTR”). MVTR measures “the rate at which moisture
permeates” a material and is “generally measured in grams
per square meter per day (g/m?2/day).” J.A. 3230-31 at
8:65-9:1. Every claim asserted by Cocona in this case in-
cludes a substantively identical MVTR limitation requir-
ing: “a moisture vapor transmission rate from about 600
g/m2/day to about 11000 g/m2/day.” J.A. 3231-32 at
10:51-538, 12:14-16.
The specification of the ’287 patent identifies three po-
tential methods for measuring MVTR: the Mocon method, !
the upright method, and the inverted method. J.A. 3231 at
9:1-5. The upright method is used to measure “low mois-
ture contact (indirect liquid contact with the membrane)”
while the inverted method is used to measure “high mois-
ture contact (direct liquid contact with the membrane).”
J.A. 3231 at 9:2-5. These methods, both known as “cup
methods,” can be run with water in a test dish (.e., a “cup”)
that is either upright with an air gap above the water, or
inverted with water resting directly on the material.
The ’287 patent discusses only a single specific embod-
iment. As relates to this embodiment, the specification
teaches that MVTR “may be measured” using the upright
or inverted cup method at 40 degrees Centigrade and 20%
relative humidity. J.A. 3231 at 9:7-10. The only further
teaching in the patent about how to carry out the two cup
methods is that testing can be accomplished in accordance
with the ASTM E96-94 Water method, which the parties
1 The patent says “Mocan” method, which the parties
agree 1s a typographical error.
Case: 25-1458 Document:75 Page:4 _ Filed: 11/17/2026
4 COCONA, INC. v. VF OUTDOOR, LLC
agree is a standardized testing protocol for measuring
MVTR. J.A. 3231 at 9:7-10 CMVTR by cup method may be
measured according to Water method of ASTM E96-94 at
40 degrees Centigrade and 20% relative humidity over a 24
hour period.”); see also Open. Br. 22 (“There is no dispute
that the ASTM E96[-94] method is a well-known standard
test method for measuring MVTR.”). The ASTM E96-94
standard itself, however, permits variability in testing con-
ditions. For instance, it allows for testing at temperatures
ranging from 23 to 38 degrees Centigrade and requires rel-
ative humidity “at 50 + 2 %” or “90 + 2 %” depending on
“the desired application of the material to be tested.”
J.A. 1664. It directs that the test conditions selected
should be those “that most closely approach the conditions
of use” and warns that a material’s MVTR measured “un-
der one set of test conditions may not indicate the value
under a different set of conditions.” Id.
B
Cocona filed suit in the District of Colorado, alleging
that VF Outdoor and Columbia infringed the claims of the
287 patent. VF Outdoor then petitioned the Patent Trial
and Appeal Board (“Board”) for inter partes review (“IPR”)
of claims 27-28, 30, 32-33, and 35-39. The Board instituted
an IPR and eventually issued a final written decision find-
ing all challenged claims other than claims 38 and 39 un-
patentable as obvious. We affirmed the Board. See Cocona,
Inc. v. VF Outdoor, LLC, 838 F. App’x 566, 567 (Fed. Cir.
2021).
Thereafter, this suit continued in district court, with
Cocona asserting claims 1, 38, and 39. The asserted claims
read as follows:
1. A water-proof breathable membrane comprising:
a substantially liquid-impermeable cured base ma-
terial solution comprising a first thickness;
Case: 25-1458 Document:75 Page:5 _ Filed: 11/17/2026
COCONA, INC. v. VF OUTDOOR, LLC 5
a plurality of active particles in contact with the
substantially liquid-impermeable cured base mate-
rial solution, wherein the plurality of active parti-
cles,
are capable of improving the transmission of vapor
through the substantially liquid-impermeable
cured base material solution, and
comprise a second thickness, wherein the first
thickness is at least 2.5 times larger than the sec-
ond thickness but less than an order of magnitude
larger than the second thickness;
at least one removable encapsulant in an amount
effective to prevent at least a substantial portion of
the plurality of active particles from being deac-
tivated prior to removal of the removable encapsul-
ant; wherein,
the at least one removable encapsulant is remova-
ble to reactivate at least a portion of the plurality
of active particles to improve the transmission of
vapor through the water-proof breathable mem-
brane, and
the membrane comprises a moisture vapor trans-
mission rate from about 600 g/m2/day to about
11000 g/m2/day.
27. A water-proof composition comprising:
a liquid-impermeable breathable cured base mate-
rial comprising a first thickness;
a plurality of active particles in contact with the
liquid-impermeable breathable cured base mate-
rial, the plurality of active particles comprising a
second thickness; and wherein,
the first thickness comprises a thickness at least
2.5 times larger than the second thickness but less
Case: 25-1458 Document:75 Page:6 Filed: 11/17/2026
6 COCONA, INC. v. VF OUTDOOR, LLC
than an order of magnitude larger than the second
thickness,
the active particles improve the moisture vapor
transport capacity of the composition, and
a moisture vapor transmission rate of the water-
proof composition comprises from about 600
g/m2/day to about 11000 g/m2/day.
38. The composition of claim 27 further comprising:
at least one removable encapsulant in an amount
effective to prevent at least a substantial portion of
the active particles from being deactivated prior to
removal of the removable encapsulant, and
wherein the removable encapsulant is removable
to reactivate at least a portion of the active parti-
cles to improve the moisture vapor transport capac-
ity of the composition.
39. The composition of claim 38, wherein the at
least one removable encapsulant is selected from
the group consisting of: water-soluble surfactants,
surfactants, salts, polymer salts, polyvinyl alco-
hols, waxes, photo-reactive materials, degradable
materials, bio-degradable materials, ethoxylated
acetylenic diols, starches, lubricants, glycols, corn
starch, mineral spirits, organic solvents, paraffinic
solvents, and any suitable combination thereof.
J.A. 3231 at 10:30-53; J.A. 3232 at 12:1-16, 12:52-67.
During the claim construction process, Cocona asked
that the court construe the MVTR limitation as “a moisture
vapor transmission rate from about 600 g/m2/day to about
11000 g/m?2/day determined according to ASTM E96 MVTR
cup water test method at 40 degrees Centigrade and 20%
relative humidity over a 24 hour period using the upright
method for low moisture contact and the inverted method
for high moisture contact.” J.A. 1716. The district court
rejected this proposal and instead determined that the
Case: 25-1458 Document:75 Page:7 Filed: 11/17/2026
COCONA, INC. v. VF OUTDOOR, LLC 7
three asserted claims were invalid as indefinite based on
the MVTR limitation. After the district court entered judg-
ment for VF Outdoor and Columbia, Cocona filed this
timely appeal. We have jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C.
§ 1295(a)(1).
II
“Indefiniteness is a question of law that we review de
novo.” Teva Pharms. USA, Inc. v. Sandoz, Inc., 789 F.3d
1335, 1341 (Fed. Cir. 2015). We also review the district
court’s evaluation of the intrinsic evidence de novo, while
“any factual findings about extrinsic evidence relevant to
the question ... are reviewed for clear error.” BASF
Corp. v. Johnson Matthey Inc., 875 F.3d 1360, 1365
(Fed. Cir. 2017). While the ultimate question of indefinite-
ness is one of law, a party challenging a claim as indefinite
must prove any fact critical to the finding of indefiniteness
by clear and convincing evidence. See Grace Instrument
Indus. v. Chandler Instruments Co., 57 F.4th 1001, 1008
(Fed. Cir. 2023).
Il
The sole issue presented in this appeal is whether the
asserted claims, which all recite the same MVTR lmita-
tion, are invalid as indefinite under 35 U.S.C. § 112. “[A]
patent is invalid for indefiniteness if its claims, read in
light of the specification delineating the patent, and the
prosecution history, fail to inform, with reasonable cer-
tainty, those skilled in the art about the scope of the inven-
tion.” Nautilus, Inc. v. Biosig Instruments, Inc., 572 U.S.
898, 901 (2014). Applying that standard here, we reach the
same conclusion as the district court: the asserted claims
are indefinite. Because the ’287 patent lacks the “required
guidance” as to how to measure MVTR in the context of the
patent, clear and convincing evidence establishes that a
person of ordinary skill in the art would not have reasona-
ble certainty about the scope of the MVTR limitation and
Case: 25-1458 Document:75 Page:8 _ Filed: 11/17/2026
8 COCONA, INC. v. VF OUTDOOR, LLC
the asserted claims. Dow Chem. Co. v. Nova Chems. Corp.
(Can.), 803 F.3d 620, 634 (Fed. Cir. 2015).
A
Our de novo review of the intrinsic evidence persuades
us that the claims are indefinite.
Starting with the claim language, a skilled artisan
would understand that for a product to practice the patent,
it must have an MVTR falling within a specific range:
about 600 g/m2/day to about 11,000 g/m?/day. But that
same artisan would also recognize that the claims provide
no guidance whatsoever on how to measure MVTR. In par-
ticular, the claims are utterly devoid of all of the detail Co-
cona asked the district court to read into them when it
proposed that the MVTR limitation be construed as “a
moisture vapor transmission rate from about 600 g/m2/day
to about 11000 g/m?/day determined according to ASTM
E96 MVTR cup water test method at 40 degrees Centigrade
and 20% relative humidity over a 24 hour period using the
upright method for low moisture contact and the inverted
method for high moisture contact.” J.A. 1716. The claims
give no clue as to whether to use the upright or inverted
cup method, or both, or what temperature and humidity
conditions to set for whichever test one performs. Thus, we
agree with the district court that “the claim language itself
recites a range of MVTRs without any details about how
that MVTR must be calculated.” J.A. 20.
A person of ordinary skill would then turn to the spec-
ification, but there she would again find a lack of adequate
guidance. The specification identifies three different meth-
ods for measuring MVTR: the Mocon method, the upright
cup method, and the inverted cup method.? See J.A. 3231
2 The parties dispute whether Mocon is a separate
method or instead refers to test equipment used in the up-
right and inverted cup methods. While we discern no clear
Case: 25-1458 Document:75 Page:9 _ Filed: 11/17/2026
COCONA, INC. v. VF OUTDOOR, LLC 9
at 9:1-5; see also J.A. 17 (“The specification provides a (non-
exhaustive) list of recognized testing methods designed to
test MVTR through a barrier film or sheet ... .”). The only
direction the specification gives as to when to use each
method is a statement that the upright cup method is used
for “low moisture contact” and the inverted cup method is
used for “high moisture contact.” J.A. 3231 at 9:2-4. Yet
the patent provides no indication as to how to distinguish
between “low” and “high” moisture contact.
While the specification expressly discloses only a single
embodiment, labeled Example 1, nothing about the specifi-
cation’s handling of Example 1 would tell a skilled artisan
how to measure MVTR. To the contrary, in describing this
single embodiment, the specification identifies both the up-
right and inverted cup methods and points to optional tem-
perature and humidity settings that “may be’ used.
J.A. 3231 at 9:7-13. Specifically, the patent states:
MVTR by cup method may be measured according
to Water method of ASTM E96-94 at 40 degrees
Centigrade and 20% relative humidity over a 24
hour period. The cups typically have a 25 cm? area
error in the district court’s finding that Mocon is a third
method, our conclusion that the claims are indefinite would
be the same even if only two different methods were iden-
tified in the patent, given the totality of the intrinsic (and
extrinsic) evidence.
To be clear, we are not holding, as Cocona fears, that
“because more than one method of measuring MVTR is con-
templated by the ’287 Patent, the MVTR Limitation is per
se indefinite.” Reply Br. at 1. Rather, our holding is that,
in the specific context of the ’287 patent, the intrinsic evi-
dence as a whole demonstrates, to a clear and convincing
level, that a skilled artisan would be unable to determine
with reasonable certainty the scope of the asserted claims.
Case: 25-1458 Document:75 Page:10 Filed: 11/17/2026
10 COCONA, INC. v. VF OUTDOOR, LLC
opening. For the upright cup test, approximately
10 g of purified water is placed in the cup, while for
the inverted cup, 20 g of purified water is used. The
water used is typically ultrapure and deionized.
J.A. 3231 at 9:7-13. Even for the one expressly disclosed
embodiment, then, the specification fails to inform a skilled
artisan with reasonable certainty as to whether to use the
upright or inverted cup method, or both, and whether to
use the optional (“may be”) 40 degrees Centigrade and 20%
relative humidity conditions. As the district court correctly
stated, “the specification offers one set of test conditions
that ‘may be’ used[] but .. . does not teach a [skilled arti-
san] to stick to those test conditions, and the claim lan-
guage itself does not condition its claim to MVTR results
obtained exclusively under those test conditions.” J.A. 19
n.5.
More problematically, a skilled artisan would discover
in the specification that the measured value of MVTR for
any specific material may vary dramatically depending on
whether the upright cup method or the inverted cup
method of measurement is used. The patent’s Figure 2,
which we reproduce below, shows the results of using both
methods on eight sample materials.
Sample Polyurethane Carbon Surfynol UP Cup MTVR Inverted Cup MTVR
(g) (g) 485 (g) (g/m?/day (g/m?/day
Control BC 0 | ¢ 470 6356
80 20 10 621 6631
80 40 20 697 7155
80 80 40 699 6673
771 10185
100 80 40 1256 9337
100 80 40 1113 9925
100 80 40 1139 10385
sloalapelulole
bv
°
°
@
°
»
°
FIG. 2
J.A. 3223 (emphasis added).
As can be seen, the figure reports results that can differ
by an order of magnitude (for the control and samples 1, 2,
and 4) depending on whether the upright or inverted
method is used.
Case: 25-1458 Document:75 Page:11 ~ Filed: 11/17/2026
COCONA, INC. v. VF OUTDOOR, LLC 11
Because the claimed range is so broad (about 600 to
about 11,000 g/m2/day), none of the seven tested samples
with active particles listed in Figure 2 are shown as having
an MVTR that is simultaneously within that range using
one method while also falling outside of that range using
the other. But that is precisely the situation the table re-
ports for the control sample (.e., one lacking active parti-
cles), which is shown to have an MVTR outside the claimed
range (470 g/m2/day) when measured by the upright cup
method yet has an MVTR within the claimed range (6,356
g/m2/day) when measured by the inverted cup method.
These data would do nothing to reassure a skilled artisan
as to how to discern the scope of the MVTR limitation.
That uncertainty would only become more heightened
when one of skill in the art looks to the provisional patent
application, which is incorporated by reference in the
287 patent’s specification. J.A. 3227 at 1:7-11 (‘This appli-
cation claims the benefit under 35 U.S.C. § 119) of U.S.
Provisional Application No. 60/799,426 filed May 9, 2006,
which is hereby incorporated herein by reference in its en-
tirety.”); J.A. 2270-92. There the skilled artisan would find
a version of Figure 2 (called Table 2) that shows a tested
sample containing activated carbon for which the upright
and inverted cup methods lead to findings that a particular
material both does and does not come within the claimed
MVTR range. Table 2, shown below, includes sample
41-6-4, which is reported to have an MVTR of 1,394
e/m2/day (i.e., within the claimed range) using the inverted
cup method but just 223 g/m?/day (outside the claimed
range) using the upright cup method.
Case: 25-1458 Document:75 Page:12 Filed: 11/17/2026
12 COCONA, INC. v. VF OUTDOOR, LLC
MVTR
Up Inverted
Sample Carbon Porcontage (g/m2/day” (gim2/day)
41-64-65 0,00% aTo 6356
414-1 7.24% 621 6631
41-6-2 12.63% 607 7165
41-6-3 21.71% 600 ea73
41-64 7.32% 223 1364
414-7 22.61% 771 10185
41-6-8 22.47% 1256 237
416-9 23.07% awe po25
41-86-10: 24.12% 1139 10358
Base 0.00%
41-7-1-2 7.11%
41-7-4-4 693 7042
41-7-4-6 654 8060
44-7-2-1 7.05%
41-7-2-3 633 5473
41-7-2-5 737 6132
41-7-3-1 12.62%
41-7-3-2 698 7649
41-7-3-3 739 8615
J.A. 2287 (emphasis added).
Table 2 would clearly leave a person of ordinary skill in
the art lacking reasonable certainty as to the scope of the
asserted claims. The results reported there show that “the
method chosen for calculating [MVTR] could affect whether
or not a given product infringes the claims.” Dow, 803 F.3d
at 634. Our precedents establish that “the existence of
multiple methods leading to different results without guid-
ance in the patent or the prosecution history as to which
method should be used renders the claims indefinite.” Id.
In such a situation, which is precisely what we confront
here, a person of ordinary skill in the art lacks reasonable
certainty as to claim scope. See id. at 634-35 (finding in-
definiteness where the record revealed at least three meth-
ods for measuring slope and whether samples infringe
depended on which method was used); see also Teva, 789
F.3d at 1341-44 (holding “molecular weight” is indefinite
where intrinsic evidence did not teach which one of three
known measurements was to be used and each could yield
materially different results). The claims at issue here then,
based on all the evidence, are indefinite and, thus, invalid.
Case: 25-1458 Document:75 Page:13 Filed: 11/17/2026
COCONA, INC. v. VF OUTDOOR, LLC 13
While the intrinsic evidence already proves by clear
and convincing evidence that the asserted claims are indef-
inite, the extrinsic evidence confirms this conclusion. After
evaluating competing declarations from the expert for VF
Outdoor and Columbia, Dr. Abigail Oelker, and from Co-
cona’s expert, Dr. Stephen McCarthy, the district court was
persuaded by Dr. Oelker, who opined that the ’287 patent
provides inadequate guidance to a skilled artisan as to
which method and what temperature and humidity condi-
tions to use when measuring MVTR. The district court dis-
missed Dr. McCarthy’ competing testimony as
“quintessentially conclusory” because it contained no ex-
planation as to how a skilled artisan would infer specific
testing requirements from the patent’s purely permissive
language about how MVTR “may be measured.” J.A. 22.
We find no clear error in these findings, which bolster our
conclusion that the asserted claims are indefinite.®
3 Cocona complains that the district court should not
have credited Dr. Oelker’s declaration because it purport-
edly contradicts a declaration she had previously given in
the related IPR proceeding, where she opined that certain
claims of the ’287 patent were obvious. Cocona has failed
to show that the district court clearly erred in relying on
Dr. Oelker’s declaration. In the IPR, Dr. Oelker testified
that particular prior art membranes exhibited MVTR val-
ues within the claimed range; she offered no testimony re-
garding how a skilled artisan looking at the ’287 patent
would (or would not) understand the methods and condi-
tions that should be used to measure MVTR. See generally
Intel Corp. v. Qualcomm Inc., 21 F.4th 801, 813 (Fed. Cir.
2021) “Importantly, it is not always impossible to adjudi-
cate a prior-art challenge, one way or the other, just be-
cause some aspect of a claim renders the claim indefinite.”).
Case: 25-1458 Document:75 Page: 14 _~ Filed: 11/17/2026
14 COCONA, INC. v. VF OUTDOOR, LLC
B
Cocona’s efforts to persuade us to reverse the district
court fail.
Cocona asserts that the test results reported in Fig-
ure 2 of the patent and Table 2 of the provisional are irrel-
evant because the control sample and sample 41-6-4 do not
practice the asserted claims. Even assuming Cocona’s
premises are correct,‘ we disagree with its conclusion.
Where a patent fails to specify the appropriate method of
measurement to use, and different methods could result in
the same item both meeting and not meeting a claim limi-
tation, that fact is relevant to indefiniteness, even if the
item being tested may not fully embody all limitations of
the claim. Here, the Figure 2/Table 2 evidence, in combi-
nation with the other intrinsic and extrinsic evidence we
discussed above, contributes to our conclusion that the as-
serted claims are indefinite.
Cocona fares no better with its reliance on two of our
precedents, Presidio Components, Inc. v. American Tech-
nical Ceramics Corp., 875 F.3d 1369 (Fed. Cir. 2017), and
Ethicon Endo-Surgery, Inc. v. Covidien, Inc., 796 F.3d 1312
(Fed. Cir. 2015). In these cases, we rejected indefiniteness
challenges because the patent-in-suit presented a single,
established measurement method for insertion loss, see
Presidio, 875 F.3d at 1376-77, or because the specification
provided sufficient guidance as to which of several methods
for measuring clamping pressure was to be used, see Ethi-
con, 796 F.3d at 1319. The situation presented here is ma-
terially different. As we have explained, the ’287 patent
provides no reasonable certainty as to which of its multiple
disclosed methods is to be used or what testing conditions
are to be employed under whichever method is chosen.
4 VF Outdoor and Columbia contend that sample
41-6-4 does practice the claims.
Case: 25-1458 Document:75 Page:15 Filed: 11/17/2026
COCONA, INC. v. VF OUTDOOR, LLC 15
Neither Presidio nor Ethicon suggest that claims like these
should survive an indefiniteness challenge.
Cocona also argues that the district court’s findings
based on the ASTM E96-94 standard are clearly erroneous
because they contradict the ’287 patent’s disclosures. Ac-
cording to Cocona, its patent specifies that MVTR is to be
measured at a temperature of 40 degrees Centigrade and
relative humidity of 20%, so any different values that may
be permitted by the ASTM E96-94 standard are irrelevant.
This argument fails because, as we have emphasized, the
287 patent discloses 40 degrees Centigrade and relative
humidity of 20% as non-mandatory examples of testing con-
ditions. J.A. 3231 at 9:7-9 (setting out temperature and
humidity conditions that “may be” used). As we have al-
ready observed, the ’287 patent does not require, nor even
suggest, that one must always test at 40 degrees Centi-
grade and relative humidity of 20% to evaluate whether the
claimed MVTR range is met.
Finally, Cocona insists that the district court applied
the wrong legal standard for indefiniteness. It argues that
its claims were held indefinite only because they do not
contain “mandatory guidelines” or “imperative language,”
which the court mistakenly believed were required in order
to avoid a judgment of invalidity. Cocona is correct that
patents containing permissive language and discretionary
words may survive indefiniteness challenges, see, e.g., Ak-
amat Techs., Inc. v. MediaPointe, Inc., 159 F.4th 1370, 1378
(Fed. Cir. 2025) “Language of degree . . . is indefinite un-
less, when read in light of the specification and the prose-
cution history, it provides objective boundaries for those of
skill in the art.”) Gnternal quotations and alterations omit-
ted), but the district court is not guilty of the charge lev-
elled at it. While the court’s opinion contains a single
reference each to “mandatory guidelines,” J.A. 22 (faulting
Cocona’s expert for “conclusory” testimony that “sheds no
light on why a [skilled artisan] would infer mandatory
Case: 25-1458 Document:75 Page:16 Filed: 11/17/2026
16 COCONA, INC. v. VF OUTDOOR, LLC
guidelines from merely permissive language”), and “imper-
ative language,’ J.A. 21 (noting “critical conceptual distinc-
tion between the suggestive nature of permissive language
and the mandatory quality of imperative language”), the
court articulated the proper legal standard for indefinite-
ness, J.A. 16, and applied it to the totality of the evidence,
J.A. 20-23. We are not persuaded that the passing refer-
ences Cocona attacks demonstrate that the district court
held the patent to too stringent of a standard for definite-
ness. Instead, we again discern no error.
IV
We have considered Cocona’s remaining arguments
and find them unpersuasive. Because we agree with the
district court’s judgment that the asserted claims are inva-
lid for indefiniteness, we affirm.
AFFIRMED