Fraud Free Transactions LLC v. Ping Identity Corp.
CourtCourt of Appeals for the Federal Circuit
Date FiledNovember 20, 2026
Docket25-1830
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Case: 25-1830 Document: 53 Page: 1 Filed: 11/20/2026
NOTE: This disposition is nonprecedential.
United States Court of Appeals
for the Federal Circuit
______________________
FRAUD FREE TRANSACTIONS LLC,
Plaintiff-Appellant
v.
PING IDENTITY CORP.,
Defendant-Appellee
______________________
2025-1830
______________________
Appeal from the United States District Court for the
District of Delaware in No. 1:24-cv-01218-GBW, Judge
Gregory Brian Williams.
______________________
Decided: November 20, 2026
______________________
JOHN S. LEROY, Brooks Kushman PC, Royal Oak, MI,
argued for plaintiff-appellant. Also represented by
THOMAS A. LEWRY, SANGEETA G. SHAH.
ORION ARMON, Cooley LLP, Denver, CO, argued for de-
fendant-appellee.
______________________
Before TARANTO, LINN, and CUNNINGHAM, Circuit Judges.
Case: 25-1830 Document: 53 Page: 2 Filed: 11/20/2026
2 FRAUD FREE TRANSACTIONS LLC v. PING IDENTITY CORP.
LINN, Circuit Judge.
Fraud Free Transactions (“FFT”) appeals the United
States District Court for the District of Delaware’s grant of
Ping Identity Corporation’s (“Ping”) motion to dismiss un-
der Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6), holding that
the claims of FFT’s U.S. Patents No. 11,551,215 (“’215 pa-
tent”) and No. 12,093,950 (“’950 patent”) are directed to pa-
tent-ineligible subject matter under 35 U.S.C. § 101. See
Fraud Free Transactions LLC v. Ping Identity Corp., 780
F. Supp. 3d 460 (D. Del. 2025) (“Decision”). For the follow-
ing reasons, we affirm.
BACKGROUND
The ’215 and ’950 patents (collectively, the “Asserted
Patents”), both titled “Fraud Deterrence for Secure Trans-
actions,” share a common specification. See Decision, 780
F. Supp. 3d at 464. The Asserted Patents generally concern
methods for verifying a user’s identity over a computer net-
work to “securely permit[] or deny[] users access to com-
puter programs over a computer network.” See id. The
shared specification explains that the invention “generally
relates to preventing or deterring fraudulent activity.” ’215
patent at col. 1 ll. 31–32; ’950 patent at col. 1 ll. 37–38.
The ’215 patent describes validating requests to access
software through a “fraud prevention application installed
on a predefined out-of-band mobile phone” that is separate
from the device requesting access. ’215 patent, Cl. 20. The
application obtains the user’s approval or denial through a
selectable option presented as a pop-up notification. Id. at
Cls. 20–22. The ’950 patent describes using “a plurality of
configurable rules” to evaluate characteristics of access re-
quests, including originating IP addresses, device identifi-
ers, and geographic locations, and to determine
corresponding authentication requirements. ’950 patent,
Cl. 1. The rules provide for different authentication re-
quirements depending on the circumstances of the request.
Id.
Case: 25-1830 Document: 53 Page: 3 Filed: 11/20/2026
FRAUD FREE TRANSACTIONS LLC v. PING IDENTITY CORP. 3
The parties agree that claim 22 is representative of all
of the claims of the ’215 patent and that claims 1 and 2 are
representative of all of the claims of the ’950 patent. Oral
Arg., Fraud Free Transactions LLC v. Ping Identity Corp.,
No. 25-1830, at 0:10–0:27 (Fed. Cir. Nov. 3, 2026),
https://www.cafc.uscourts.gov/oral-arguments/25-1830_11
032026.mp3. Because we write for the parties, we assume
familiarity with the representative claim language.
FFT sued Ping for infringement of the asserted pa-
tents. Ping moved to dismiss under Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 12(b)(6), arguing that the asserted patents were
directed to patent-ineligible subject matter under 35 U.S.C.
§ 101. The district court granted Ping’s motion, concluding
that the ’215 patent claims were directed to the abstract
idea of “preventing fraud by requiring identity verification
from multiple sources,” Decision, 780 F. Supp. 3d at 472,
and that the ’950 patent claims were directed to the ab-
stract idea of “adjusting identification requirements based
on the risk associated with a transaction,” id. at 468. The
district court further concluded that neither patent recited
an inventive concept sufficient to transform the abstract
ideas into patent-eligible applications. Id. at 471–72, 474–
76.
FFT appeals. We have jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C.
§ 1295(a)(1).
DISCUSSION
FFT challenges the district court’s determination that
the claims of the ’215 and ’950 patents are ineligible under
35 U.S.C. § 101 because they are directed to abstract ideas
and lack inventive concepts. We address each of the As-
serted Patents in turn.
Case: 25-1830 Document: 53 Page: 4 Filed: 11/20/2026
4 FRAUD FREE TRANSACTIONS LLC v. PING IDENTITY CORP.
I
A
The district court determined that representative
claim 22 of the ’215 patent is directed to the abstract idea
of “preventing fraud by requiring identity verification from
multiple sources.” Id. at 472. The district court reasoned
that claim 22 recites a method of controlling access to soft-
ware through multiple authentication steps without im-
proving computer functionality. Id. at 472–74. We review
the district court’s determination of patent eligibility de
novo. Universal Secure Registry LLC v. Apple Inc., 10 F.4th
1342, 1345–46 (Fed. Cir. 2021).
FFT argues that the district court oversimplified claim
22 by disregarding its asserted improvement to computer-
network security. According to FFT, the claimed “fraud
prevention application installed on a predefined out-of-
band mobile phone” provides a trusted means for approv-
ing or denying access requests originating from a separate
computing device. ’215 patent, Cl. 20. FFT contends that
the specification and prosecution history confirm that this
arrangement improves upon conventional telephone- and
text-based authentication methods, which are vulnerable
to interception or spoofing.
Ping responds that claim 22 merely implements the ab-
stract idea of identity verification using generic computer
technology. Ping contends that the claimed application
and mobile phone identify the devices and functions used
to authenticate a request without specifying how the appli-
cation improves the underlying authentication technology.
We agree with the district court that claim 22 is di-
rected to the abstract idea of “preventing fraud by requir-
ing identity verification from multiple sources.” See
Decision, 780 F. Supp. 3d at 472. The claims here invoke
computers merely as tools to perform an abstract process.
See TecSec, Inc. v. Adobe Inc., 978 F.3d 1278, 1292–93
Case: 25-1830 Document: 53 Page: 5 Filed: 11/20/2026
FRAUD FREE TRANSACTIONS LLC v. PING IDENTITY CORP. 5
(Fed. Cir. 2020) (first citing Alice Corp. Pty. Ltd. v. CLS
Bank Int’l, 573 U.S. 208, 216 (2014); then citing Uniloc
USA, Inc. v. LG Elecs. USA, Inc., 957 F.3d 1303, 1306–07
(Fed. Cir. 2020)). In Universal Secure Registry, we held
that claims directed to authenticating a user through mul-
tiple devices were abstract because they “broadly recite ge-
neric steps and results—as opposed to a specific solution to
a technological problem.” 10 F.4th at 1355. Claim 22 sim-
ilarly recites the generic steps and results of receiving a
request to access software, communicating with a fraud
prevention application installed on a predefined mobile
phone, obtaining approval or denial through that applica-
tion, and displaying a pop-up notification. ’215 patent, Cls.
20–22. Although these limitations specify the devices and
steps used to authenticate the request, they do not identify
a particular technological solution for improving authenti-
cation. Like the claims in Universal Secure Registry, claim
22 recites the idea of authentication rather than an im-
provement to the underlying technology. See 10 F.4th at
1348–58.
Nothing in the intrinsic record alters this conclusion.
FFT relies on the invention’s purportedly improved re-
sistance to spoofing and the prosecution history’s charac-
terization of the claimed arrangement as an improvement
over prior authentication methods. But neither identifies
a specific technological mechanism required by claim 22 for
achieving that improvement. As in Universal Secure Reg-
istry, the claimed use of multiple devices to authenticate a
user does not, without a specific technological solution,
transform an abstract authentication method into an im-
provement in computer functionality. See 10 F.4th at
1351–53.
Accordingly, we conclude that claim 22 is directed to an
abstract idea.
Case: 25-1830 Document: 53 Page: 6 Filed: 11/20/2026
6 FRAUD FREE TRANSACTIONS LLC v. PING IDENTITY CORP.
B
The district court also determined that claim 22 lacks
an inventive concept under Alice step two because “the
claim does no more than apply the abstract idea ‘with a
computer.’” Decision, 780 F. Supp. 3d at 474 (quoting Alice,
573 U.S. at 223). The district court reasoned that the
claim, whether its limitations are considered individually
or as an ordered combination, “invokes well-understood,
routine, [and] conventional technology” to perform identity
verification. Id. at 474–76 (alteration in original) (quoting
Alice, 573 U.S. at 225).
FFT argues that the district court failed to recognize
an inventive concept in the claimed arrangement of a fraud
prevention application installed on a predefined out-of-
band mobile phone to approve or deny access requests orig-
inating from a separate computing device. FFT contends
that this arrangement was unconventional and that, under
CosmoKey Solutions GmbH & Co. KG v. Duo Security LLC,
15 F.4th 1091 (Fed. Cir. 2021), it provides an inventive con-
cept even if out-of-band authentication was previously
known.
Ping responds that the claimed arrangement merely
uses conventional computer technology to perform identity
verification and does not supply an inventive concept. Ping
further contends that FFT has not identified sufficient fac-
tual allegations of unconventionality to avoid dismissal un-
der Rule 12(b)(6).
We agree with the district court that claim 22 of the
’215 patent lacks an inventive concept. At Alice step two,
we consider whether the claim elements, individually or as
an ordered combination, transform the abstract idea into a
patent-eligible application. Alice, 573 U.S. at 217–18. In
Universal Secure Registry, we held that combining conven-
tional authentication techniques to achieve an expected in-
crease in security does not supply an inventive concept. 10
F.4th at 1352–53. Claim 22 likewise recites conventional
Case: 25-1830 Document: 53 Page: 7 Filed: 11/20/2026
FRAUD FREE TRANSACTIONS LLC v. PING IDENTITY CORP. 7
authentication techniques—receiving an access request,
obtaining approval or denial through an application on a
predefined mobile phone, and permitting access upon ap-
proval—to achieve an expected improvement in security.
’215 patent, Cls. 20–22. These limitations, individually
and in combination, implement the abstract authentication
process without identifying an unconventional technologi-
cal arrangement that improves how authentication is per-
formed. See Universal Secure Registry, 10 F.4th at 1352–
53.
Nor does CosmoKey support FFT’s contention that the
claimed arrangement supplies an inventive concept.
There, the claims recited a specific authentication se-
quence involving activation of a normally inactive authen-
tication function within a predetermined time relationship,
communication of its activation status, and subsequent de-
activation. CosmoKey, 15 F.4th at 1098–99. Claim 22, by
contrast, requires no comparable operational constraints
beyond obtaining approval or denial through the applica-
tion on the predefined mobile phone. See BSG Tech LLC v.
BuySeasons, Inc., 899 F.3d 1281, 1290–91 (Fed. Cir. 2018)
(“If a claim’s only ‘inventive concept’ is the application of
an abstract idea using conventional and well-understood
techniques, the claim has not been transformed into a pa-
tent-eligible application of an abstract idea.”). Nor do
FFT’s general allegations of unconventionality identify a
specific technological arrangement beyond the claimed au-
thentication process that would preclude dismissal at the
pleading stage. See Universal Secure Registry, 10 F.4th at
1352–53; see also Aatrix Software, Inc. v. Green Shades
Software, Inc., 882 F.3d 1121, 1125 (Fed. Cir. 2018) (“We
have held that patent eligibility can be determined at the
Rule 12(b)(6) stage . . . . when there are no factual allega-
tions that, taken as true, prevent resolving the eligibility
question as a matter of law.”).
Case: 25-1830 Document: 53 Page: 8 Filed: 11/20/2026
8 FRAUD FREE TRANSACTIONS LLC v. PING IDENTITY CORP.
Accordingly, we conclude that claim 22 lacks an in-
ventive concept sufficient to transform the abstract idea
into a patent-eligible application.
II
A
The district court determined that representative
claims 1 and 2 of the ’950 patent are directed to the abstract
idea of “adjusting identification requirements based on the
risk associated with a transaction.” Decision, 780 F. Supp.
3d at 468. The district court reasoned that the claims recite
rules for evaluating access requests and selecting corre-
sponding authentication requirements without improving
computer functionality. Id. at 468–71.
FFT argues that the district court oversimplified the
claims by disregarding their asserted improvement to com-
puter-network security through configurable, context-de-
pendent authentication rules. According to FFT, the
claims improve upon rigid prior authentication systems by
allowing organizations to configure rules that evaluate
characteristics of individual access requests and dynami-
cally select appropriate authentication requirements.
Ping responds that the claims merely automate the ab-
stract process of evaluating security risks and adjusting
authentication requirements using generic computer tech-
nology. Ping contends that the configurable rules specify
what information to evaluate and what authentication ac-
tions to take, but not how those functions are technologi-
cally implemented.
We agree with the district court that claims 1 and 2 are
directed to the abstract idea of “adjusting identification re-
quirements based on the risk associated with a transac-
tion.” See Decision, 780 F. Supp. 3d at 468. Claim 1 recites
“a plurality of configurable rules” that evaluate character-
istics of an access request, including its originating IP ad-
dress, device identifier, and geographic location, to
Case: 25-1830 Document: 53 Page: 9 Filed: 11/20/2026
FRAUD FREE TRANSACTIONS LLC v. PING IDENTITY CORP. 9
determine whether to permit access without additional ver-
ification or require varying levels of multifactor authenti-
cation. ’950 patent, Cl. 1. Claim 2 further requires
comparing the originating IP address to “one or more des-
ignated IP addresses.” Id. at Cl. 2. In FairWarning IP,
LLC v. Iatric Systems, Inc., we held that claims applying
rules to analyze user-access records and detect improper
activity were directed to the abstract idea of “collecting and
analyzing information to detect misuse.” 839 F.3d 1089,
1093–95 (Fed. Cir. 2016).
Here, the claims similarly evaluate information accord-
ing to predefined criteria and prescribe actions based on
the results, without reciting a specific improvement to the
underlying computer technology. See id. As we explained
in FairWarning, the use of rules to analyze information
does not itself establish an improvement in computer func-
tionality. 839 F.3d at 1094–95. Although the ’950 patent
describes greater flexibility in selecting authentication re-
quirements, its claims merely specify the information con-
sidered and the resulting authentication decisions, i.e.,
“collecting and analyzing information,” rather than a tech-
nological improvement in how those decisions are imple-
mented. See id. at 1093–95.
Accordingly, we conclude that claims 1 and 2 are di-
rected to an abstract idea.
B
The district court determined that claims 1 and 2 of
the ’950 patent lack an inventive concept under Alice step
two. Decision, 780 F. Supp. 3d at 471–72. The district
court reasoned that FFT “merely restates the language of
the patent in an attempt to make the claims patent eligi-
ble” and “does not point to an inventive concept nor an ‘or-
dered combination’ that adds an inventive concept to the
patent’s abstract idea.” Id. at 471–72 (quoting Personal-
ized Media Commc’ns, LLC v. Amazon.com, Inc., 161 F.
Case: 25-1830 Document: 53 Page: 10 Filed: 11/20/2026
10 FRAUD FREE TRANSACTIONS LLC v. PING IDENTITY CORP.
Supp. 3d 325, 329 (D. Del. 2015), aff’d sub nom. Personal-
ized Media Commc’ns, L.L.C. v. Amazon.com Inc., 671 F.
App’x 777 (Fed. Cir. 2016)).
FFT argues that the district court improperly disre-
garded the unconventionality of the claimed arrangement
of configurable rules, contextual determinations, and cor-
responding authentication requirements. In particular,
FFT challenges the district court’s statement that
“whether the claims are conventional is irrelevant to this
Alice step two inquiry.” Decision, 780 F. Supp. 3d at 472
(emphasis original). FFT contends that the specification
and prosecution history establish an unconventional im-
provement over prior authentication systems and that the
district court improperly resolved factual questions at the
pleading stage.
Ping responds that the district court correctly con-
cluded that the claims lack an inventive concept because
FFT’s asserted improvement merely restates the abstract
idea itself. Ping further contends that the claimed rules do
not recite an unconventional technological implementation
and that FFT identifies no factual dispute precluding dis-
missal under Rule 12(b)(6).
Although FFT correctly observes that conventionality
is relevant to the Alice step-two inquiry, see Berkheimer v.
HP Inc., 881 F.3d 1360, 1368 (Fed. Cir. 2018), the district
court’s analysis did not rest solely on whether the claimed
authentication rules were conventional. Rather, the dis-
trict court concluded that FFT merely restated the claimed
authentication process without identifying an inventive
concept. Decision, 780 F. Supp. 3d at 471–72. And as we
have explained, “[i]t has been clear since Alice that a
claimed invention’s use of the ineligible concept to which it
is directed cannot supply the inventive concept.” BSG
Tech, 899 F.3d at 1290.
We agree that claims 1 and 2 of the ’950 patent lack an
inventive concept. FFT’s asserted improvement consists of
Case: 25-1830 Document: 53 Page: 11 Filed: 11/20/2026
FRAUD FREE TRANSACTIONS LLC v. PING IDENTITY CORP. 11
configurable rules that evaluate characteristics of access
requests and select corresponding authentication require-
ments. ’950 patent, Cls. 1–2. Even accepting FFT’s allega-
tions that these rules were unconventional, their asserted
novelty lies in the abstract authentication process itself,
not in a distinct technological implementation. See BSG
Tech, 899 F.3d at 1290–91. Nor do the claim elements, con-
sidered individually or as an ordered combination, supply
an inventive concept beyond that abstract idea. Because
FFT identifies no factual allegations that, taken as true,
would prevent resolution of eligibility as a matter of law,
dismissal was proper. See Aatrix Software, 882 F.3d at
1125. Accordingly, we conclude that the representative
claims of the ’950 patent, like that of the ’215 patent, do not
recite an inventive concept and are patent ineligible under
§ 101.
CONCLUSION
We have considered FFT’s remaining arguments and
find them unpersuasive. For these reasons, we affirm the
district court’s judgment dismissing FFT’s infringement
claims based on the patent ineligibility of the claims of the
’215 and ’950 patents under 35 U.S.C. § 101.
AFFIRMED