Jeff Mueller v. TD WISC. I, LLC
CourtCourt of Appeals of Wisconsin
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
Docket2025AP002375
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
COURT OF APPEALS
DECISION NOTICE
DATED AND FILED This opinion is subject to further editing. If
published, the official version will appear in
the bound volume of the Official Reports.
November 18, 2026
A party may file with the Supreme Court a
Samuel A. Christensen petition to review an adverse decision by the
Clerk of Court of Appeals Court of Appeals. See WIS. STAT. § 808.10
and RULE 809.62.
Appeal No. 2025AP2375 Cir. Ct. No. 2023CV1721
STATE OF WISCONSIN IN COURT OF APPEALS
DISTRICT II
JEFF MUELLER AND MARSHA MUELLER,
PLAINTIFFS-APPELLANTS,
V.
TD WISC. I, LLC, THOMAS DEMUTH AND JOHN THEISEN,
DEFENDANTS-RESPONDENTS.
APPEAL from an order of the circuit court for Waukesha County:
MICHAEL P. MAXWELL, Judge. Affirmed.
Before Lazar, P.J., Gundrum, and Grogan, JJ.
Per curiam opinions may not be cited in any court of this state as precedent
or authority, except for the limited purposes specified in WIS. STAT. RULE 809.23(3).
No. 2025AP2375
¶1 PER CURIAM. Jeff and Marsha Mueller appeal an order granting
summary judgment in favor of TD Wisc. I, LLC (“TDW”), Thomas DeMuth, and
John Theisen. The circuit court dismissed the Muellers’ complaint, concluding the
causes of action were barred by the doctrine of claim preclusion, formerly known
as res judicata.1 We affirm.
BACKGROUND
¶2 In May 2019, the Muellers and TDW entered into a purchase
agreement, wherein the Muellers agreed to purchase property from TDW for
$220,000. As part of the agreement, TDW agreed to make certain changes to the
property, such as removing buildings and concrete, sealing wells and septic
systems, and other tasks. The Muellers closed on the property in June 2019.
Fifty thousand dollars from the sales proceeds was placed in an escrow account for
TDW to use to complete the agreed-upon tasks. TDW had approximately four
months after closing to complete the tasks. TDW, however, failed to complete
them.
¶3 In April 2020, the Muellers brought suit against TDW and its
members, DeMuth and Theisen, for breach of contract, civil theft, and intentional
misrepresentation. DeMuth and Theisen moved to dismiss all causes of action
against them, and TDW moved to dismiss the causes of action for civil theft and
intentional misrepresentation.
1
“The term claim preclusion replaces res judicata.” Northern States Power Co. v.
Bugher, 189 Wis. 2d 541, 550, 525 N.W.2d 723 (1995).
2
No. 2025AP2375
¶4 The Muellers responded to the dismissal motion by filing an
amended complaint. The amended complaint only listed TDW as a defendant
(omitting DeMuth and Theisen) and alleged causes of action for breach of contract
and recission (omitting the claims for civil theft and intentional
misrepresentation).
¶5 On June 18, 2020, the circuit court entered an order that provided, in
part:
1. John Theisen and Thomas DeMuth are hereby dismissed
from this action with prejudice.
2. That Defendants’ [Dismissal] Motion of May 5, 2020 is
moot due to the Amended Complaint and, as such, the
hearing previously scheduled by this Court is removed
from the calendar and no further briefing on this matter
should be submitted.
3. Should Plaintiffs attempt to reassert the claims brought
in the original complaint the motion at the option of
defendant(s) may be renewed.
(Emphasis added.)
¶6 In July 2020, the Muellers moved the circuit court to reconsider its
dismissal of Theisen and DeMuth with prejudice. TDW opposed the motion.
TDW advised the court that when it filed its motion to dismiss, it also served a
WIS. STAT. § 802.05 (2023-24)2 safe harbor letter and draft sanctions motion
regarding the Muellers’ claims against Theisen and DeMuth. TDW argued that
Theisen and DeMuth’s dismissal with prejudice was appropriate because the
Muellers withdrew their claims against Theisen and DeMuth in the face of TDW’s
assertion that the claims were baseless in law and fact.
2
All references to the Wisconsin Statutes are to the 2023-24 version.
3
No. 2025AP2375
¶7 In September 2020, the circuit court denied the Muellers’
reconsideration motion. The Muellers did not appeal the court’s dismissal of
Theisen and DeMuth with prejudice or the denial of their reconsideration motion.
¶8 The case proceeded on the Muellers’ claims against TDW. On
June 30, 2023, the circuit court entered a stipulated judgment against TDW. The
judgment provided the Muellers with title to the property, all money remaining in
the escrow account, and an additional $170,000 plus taxable costs.
¶9 On October 26, 2023, the Muellers brought the underlying lawsuit
against TDW, Theisen, and DeMuth. The complaint alleged three causes of
action: “veil piercing”; fraudulent transfer under WIS. STAT. § 242.04; and
intentional misrepresentation. (Capitalization and emphasis omitted.) Broadly,
the complaint sought to hold Theisen and DeMuth personally liable for the
judgment entered against TDW, contained allegations that TDW had improperly
transferred the sales proceeds to others, and alleged that Theisen and DeMuth had
intentionally misrepresented that they would perform the agreed-upon tasks
regarding the 2019 purchase agreement.
¶10 TDW, Theisen, and DeMuth (collectively now, TDW) moved to
dismiss the complaint based on claim preclusion and failure to state a claim upon
which relief could be granted. The Muellers opposed the motion. Following
briefing and argument, and “for the reasons stated on the record,”3 the circuit court
denied TDW’s dismissal motion for piercing the corporate veil and fraudulent
transfer and granted the motion to dismiss for intentional misrepresentation.
3
The record does not contain a transcript of this motion hearing.
4
No. 2025AP2375
(Capitalization and emphasis omitted.) The court gave the Muellers leave to file
an amended complaint as to their claim for intentional misrepresentation, which
they did.
¶11 The case progressed, and TDW moved for summary judgment. The
motion alleged that the Muellers could not establish, as a matter of law, that
TDW’s corporate veil should be pierced or that TDW’s conveyances were
fraudulent. The motion also alleged that the Muellers’ claim for intentional
misrepresentation continued to be barred by claim preclusion.
¶12 The Muellers opposed the motion, and the circuit court held a
motion hearing. At the end of the hearing, the court questioned the Muellers on
whether their allegations should have been raised in their original action and
whether discovery in the previous litigation could have revealed certain
information. The court then took the matter under advisement and indicated it
would issue a written decision.
¶13 Approximately two weeks after the summary judgment hearing, the
Muellers wrote a letter to the circuit court regarding claim preclusion. The letter
reminded the court that it had previously denied TDW’s motion to dismiss on the
basis of claim preclusion and that TDW’s present motion only discussed claim
preclusion as to the Muellers’ claim for intentional misrepresentation. As to the
court’s questions regarding discovery in the previous litigation, the Muellers
advised the court that during the prior litigation the parties had entered into a
tolling agreement “that served to table the dispute regarding discovery of the
LLC’s financial documents until after the conclusion of the underlying litigation.”
The Muellers provided the court with a copy of the tolling agreement.
5
No. 2025AP2375
¶14 The circuit court subsequently issued a written decision granting
summary judgment in favor of TDW on the basis of claim preclusion. The court
acknowledged that it had initially denied TDW’s motion to dismiss based on claim
preclusion. However, it explained that after considering the parties’ filings,
arguments, and the record, it had determined that the Muellers’ first two causes of
action (piercing the corporate veil and fraudulent transfer) were barred by claim
preclusion. The court also determined the Muellers’ amended intentional
misrepresentation claim was similarly barred by claim preclusion. The court
dismissed the Muellers’ complaint. The Muellers appeal.
DISCUSSION
¶15 The doctrine of “claim preclusion prevents relitigation of ‘all matters
which were litigated or which might have been litigated in the former
proceedings.’” Clarke v. WEC, 2023 WI 79, ¶46, 410 Wis. 2d 1, 998 N.W.2d 370
(citation omitted). It is “‘designed to draw a line between the meritorious claim on
the one hand and the vexatious, repetitious and needless claim on the other hand.’”
Northern States Power Co. v. Bugher, 189 Wis. 2d 541, 550, 525 N.W.2d 723
(1995) (citation omitted). Claim preclusion has three requirements: “(1) an
identity between the parties or their privies in the prior and present suits; (2) an
identity between the causes of action in the two suits; and, (3) a final judgment on
the merits in a court of competent jurisdiction.” Id. at 551. We review de novo
whether claim preclusion applies to a factual scenario. Id. In this case, we agree
with the circuit court that the elements of claim preclusion have been satisfied.
¶16 First, the Muellers do not appear to dispute on appeal that the first
element of claim preclusion is satisfied (identity between the parties in the first
two actions). Instead, the Muellers’ appellate argument focuses on whether the
6
No. 2025AP2375
second and third elements of claim preclusion have been satisfied. They argue
that there is no identity between the causes of action in the two suits and there was
not a final judgment on the merits in the prior lawsuit. We disagree.
¶17 Wisconsin uses a transactional approach to determine whether two
suits involve the same cause of action. Teske v. Wilson Mut. Ins. Co., 2019 WI
62, ¶31, 387 Wis. 2d 213, 928 N.W.2d 555. “The transactional approach ‘reflects
the expectation that parties who are given the capacity to present their entire
controversies shall in fact do so.’” Id. (citation omitted). “Pursuant to this
analysis, ‘all claims arising out of one transaction or factual situation are treated as
being part of a single cause of action and they are required to be litigated
together.’” Id. (citation omitted).
¶18 Here, it is apparent that the Muellers’ causes of action in both
lawsuits arise from the same factual circumstances surrounding the 2019 purchase
agreement and TDW’s subsequent failure to complete its agreed-upon tasks. It is
from this factual situation that all of the Muellers’ claims arise. Although the
Muellers argue that different claims were alleged in the first case compared to the
present one, under the transactional approach, “it is irrelevant that ‘the legal
theories, remedies sought, and evidence used may be different between the first
and second actions.’” See id., ¶36 (citation omitted). We agree with the circuit
court that there is an identity between the causes of action in the two suits. See
Northern States, 189 Wis. 2d at 551. The second element of claim preclusion is
satisfied. See id.
¶19 The Muellers also argue that the third element of claim preclusion—
a final judgment on the merits, was not satisfied in this case. They assert the
circuit court’s dismissal of DeMuth and Theisen with prejudice in the previous
7
No. 2025AP2375
case did not constitute a dismissal on the merits because the Muellers amended
their complaint to remove these defendants. The Muellers also argue that the
judgment entered against TDW was not a judgment on the merits because it was a
stipulated judgment.
¶20 We reject both assertions. First, regarding the circuit court’s
dismissal of DeMuth and Theisen from the previous lawsuit with prejudice, we
have interpreted the phrase “with prejudice” to mean a judgment on the merits or a
judgment that precludes future claims. See State v. A.G.R., Jr., 140 Wis. 2d 843,
847, 412 N.W.2d 164 (Ct. App. 1987) (a dismissal with prejudice is tantamount to
a judgment on the merits). It seems apparent that the Muellers recognized the
significance of the dismissal-with-prejudice language in the court’s order because
they moved the court to reconsider the “with prejudice” language. The court
denied the motion, and the Muellers did not appeal. We conclude the circuit
court’s dismissal order with prejudice constituted a judgment on the merits as to
DeMuth and Theisen.4 See id.
¶21 As for the judgment entered against TDW, the Muellers appear to
argue that the stipulated judgment did not constitute a final judgment on the merits
for claim preclusion because the parties never actually adjudicated the substance
of the claims. However, a judgment on the merits does not need to be the result of
actual litigation; a stipulation also has preclusive effect. See Wisconsin Pub. Serv.
4
There are aspects of this case that are troubling. Particularly challenging is the fact that
the amended complaint removed DeMuth and Theisen from the case, which made the order to
dismiss them with prejudice unnecessary. Without that dismissal order, there would be no
decision on the merits with respect to DeMuth and Theisen, and the Muellers’ case could
continue against them. However, the Muellers did not appeal the order dismissing these two
members of TDW with prejudice. Therefore, that order satisfies the claim preclusion elements
here.
8
No. 2025AP2375
Corp. v. Arby Const., Inc., 2012 WI 87, ¶64, 342 Wis. 2d 544, 566, 818 N.W.2d
863. We conclude the third element of claim preclusion—a final judgment on the
merits in a court of competent jurisdiction—has been satisfied.
¶22 The Muellers nevertheless maintain that the circuit court erred by
dismissing its claims based on claim preclusion. They assert the court failed to
recognize that the parties entered into a tolling agreement that allowed the
Muellers to raise claims at a later date. They also fault the court for failing to
address the parties’ tolling agreement.
¶23 However, the Muellers did not mention any tolling agreement in
their summary judgment materials or during the summary judgment motion
hearing. Rather, two weeks after the hearing, the Muellers wrote to the circuit
court to assert the tolling agreement precluded application of claim preclusion.
¶24 We disagree with the Muellers that the circuit court was required,
but failed, to consider its post-hearing letter regarding the tolling agreement. See
WIS. STAT. § 802.08(2) (For summary judgment, “[u]nless earlier times are
specified in the scheduling order[5] ... the adverse party shall serve opposing
affidavits ... at least 5 days before the time fixed for the hearing.”); David
Christensen Trucking & Excavating, Inc. v. Mehdian, 2006 WI App 254, ¶20,
297 Wis. 2d 765, 726 N.W.2d 689 (“We conclude that filing opposing affidavits at
least five days prior to the date of the hearing was mandatory and that, in the
absence of an effort to enlarge time, the circuit court had no alternative but to
5
Here, the scheduling order required the Muellers to file “a responsive brief and
supporting documents, or waiver in writing” on February 3, 2025, approximately one month
before the March 4, 2025 summary judgment hearing.
9
No. 2025AP2375
consider only [the movant’s] materials in determining whether to grant summary
judgment.”). Here, the court had no obligation to consider or address post-hearing
submissions, and we do not consider the Muellers’ arguments regarding the tolling
agreement.
¶25 Finally, the Muellers argue that the circuit court’s dismissal was
improper because “the defendants only moved for summary judgment on the
claims against the individual defendants.” (Capitalization and emphasis omitted.)
We disagree. TDW’s motion for summary judgment provides:
[T]he defendants, collectively, by their undersigned
attorneys of record, hereby moves that the Court, the
Honorable Michael P. Maxwell, presiding, for an order
pursuant to the provisions of WIS. STAT. § 802.08, granting
Summary Judgment dismissing the Plaintiffs’ claims on
their merits on the 4th day of March, 2025 at 1:30 p.m. or
as soon thereafter as counsel may be heard.
(Emphasis added.)
¶26 Because all of the elements of claim preclusion have been satisfied,
the circuit court properly applied the doctrine to bar the Muellers’ current action
against TDW, Theisen, and DeMuth. We affirm the circuit court’s dismissal of
the Muellers’ action against TDW, Theisen, and DeMuth.
By the Court.—Order affirmed.
This opinion will not be published. See WIS. STAT.
RULE 809.23(1)(b)5.
10