William Wesley Ruth v. Commission for Lawyer Discipline
CourtTexas Supreme Court
Date FiledNovember 20, 2026
Docket24-0701
StatusPublished
๐ฐ News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Supreme Court of Texas
โโโโโโโโโโ
No. 24-0701
โโโโโโโโโโ
William Wesley Ruth,
Petitioner,
v.
Commission for Lawyer Discipline,
Respondent
โโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโ
On Petition for Review from the
Court of Appeals for the Fourth District of Texas
โโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโโ
PER CURIAM
The Commission for Lawyer Discipline filed this disciplinary
proceeding against William Ruth (the IOLTA proceeding), alleging that
he engaged in professional misconduct by failing to hold client funds in
a separate trust account and failing to reduce a contingency-fee
agreement to writing. While the case was pending, the Commission filed
a second proceeding (the no-contact proceeding) alleging that Ruth, who
was then representing himself in the IOLTA proceeding, violated the
disciplinary rules by communicating directly with Commission
members, who were represented by counsel. Although filed second, the
no-contact proceeding concluded first. The trial court rendered
judgment in that proceeding suspending Ruth from the practice of law
for five years based on violations of Disciplinary Rule 4.02(a), which
prohibits a lawyer, โ[i]n representing a client,โ from communicating
with persons known to be represented by another lawyer about the
subject of the representation unless the other lawyer consents or the
communication is authorized by law. While that judgment was on
appeal, the trial court presiding over the IOLTA proceeding held a bench
trial on sanctions and rendered judgment suspending Ruth from the
practice of law for eighteen months. 1 The trial court took the no-contact
proceedingโs judgment into account in imposing the suspension. See
TEX. RULES DISCIPLINARY P. R. 15.09(B)(2)(a) (listing โprior disciplinary
recordโ as an aggravating factor that may be considered in imposing a
sanction).
The court of appeals affirmed both judgments, and Ruth
petitioned for review. While this petition was pending, we reversed the
judgment in the no-contact proceeding and dismissed the case, holding
that Rule 4.02(a) does not apply to a lawyer acting pro se and that Ruth
therefore did not violate the rule in communicating with the represented
Commission members. Ruth v. Commโn for Law. Discipline, 738 S.W.3d
213, 222 (Tex. 2026) (Ruth I).
Because the IOLTA proceedingโs judgment at issue here was
already on appeal when we issued Ruth I, the impropriety of the trial
courtโs consideration of the no-contact proceedingโs judgment as an
1 Before the sanctions trial in the IOLTA proceeding, the court granted
partial summary judgment for the Commission on Ruthโs liability. Only the
sanction is at issue here.
2
aggravating factor in the IOLTA proceeding did not become apparent
until well after it occurred. That is, only when we issued Ruth I did it
become clear that the trial court should not have considered Ruthโs
โprior disciplinary recordโ as an aggravating factor in the IOLTA
proceeding but instead should have considered the โabsence of a prior
disciplinary recordโ as a mitigating factor. See TEX. RULES DISCIPLINARY
P. R. 15.09(C)(2)(a) (listing โabsence of a prior disciplinary recordโ as a
mitigating factor that may be considered in imposing a sanction).
Accordingly, without hearing oral argument, see TEX. R. APP.
P. 59.1, we grant Ruthโs petition for review, vacate the court of appealsโ
and trial courtโs judgments, and remand the case to the trial court to
redetermine the sanction in light of our opinion in Ruth I. 2 We express
no opinion about the proper outcome of that redetermination.
OPINION DELIVERED: November 20, 2026
2 Ruth asserts he is entitled to a new trial.
We leave to the trial courtโs
discretion whether an entirely new trial is necessary to determine the proper
sanction in accordance with this opinion and Ruth I.
3