In Re: The Commitment of Kenneth Patrick Calhoun v. the State of Texas
CourtTexas Court of Appeals, 2nd District (Fort Worth)
Date FiledNovember 12, 2026
Docket02-26-00355-CV
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
In the
Court of Appeals
Second Appellate District of Texas
at Fort Worth
___________________________
No. 02-26-00355-CV
___________________________
IN RE: THE COMMITMENT OF KENNETH PATRICK CALHOUN
On Appeal from the 297th District Court
Tarrant County, Texas
Trial Court No. SP-00078
Before Sudderth, C.J.; Kerr and Bassel, JJ.
Memorandum Opinion by Justice Bassel
MEMORANDUM OPINION
Appellant Kenneth Patrick Calhoun challenges his civil commitment as a sexually
violent predator (SVP), see Tex. Health & Safety Code §§ 841.001–.209 (the SVP Act),
raising a single issue arguing that legally insufficient evidence supported the jury’s
verdict, particularly the implicit finding that he suffers from a behavioral abnormality
making him likely to engage in future predatory acts of sexual violence. Because the
evidence was legally sufficient to support the jury’s verdict, we will affirm.
I. BACKGROUND
The State filed a petition to civilly commit Calhoun as an SVP. See id. § 841.041.
Calhoun had been convicted of sexual assault, aggravated sexual assault of a child under
fourteen years of age, and two counts of indecency with a child by contact. See Tex.
Penal Code §§ 21.11(a), 22.011, 22.021(a). Each is considered a sexually violent offense
for purposes of the SVP Act. See Tex. Health & Safety Code § 841.002(8)(A). The
State alleged, based on an expert clinical assessment, that Calhoun suffers from a
behavioral abnormality that makes him likely to engage in a predatory act of sexual
violence. See id. § 841.023(a).
At the jury trial, two witnesses testified: Calhoun and the State’s expert, Jason D.
Dunham, Ph.D. In addition to the testimony, the record contains Dr. Dunham’s
curriculum vitae and exhibits containing judgments from Calhoun’s four convictions.
2
A. Calhoun’s Testimony
1. Background
When he testified at trial, Calhoun was sixty-eight years old. He was born in
Iowa but left to join the Marines before finishing high school. At trial, he first denied
any disciplinary issues while enlisted, but then he acknowledged that he had spent time
in the brig for hitting a lieutenant. He served two years of a four-year enlistment but
was discharged after he “borrowed a truck from the motor pool and drove it around
town for a while and then came back.”
After being discharged from the military, Calhoun attempted suicide.1 He was
hospitalized for six months or longer and was given medication which caused him to
have seizures. Calhoun said that during the years after his hospitalization he “generally
drove around the United States on [his motorcycle], just visiting all the different
wonders that America has,” but would go back to his mother in Fort Worth when she
called him.
During this period, he was arrested for robbery in Missouri in 1977, breaking and
entering in Missouri in 1979, and stealing a car in California in 1979.2
1
Calhoun did not testify as to the details of his attempt beyond the subsequent
hospitalization.
2
The record does not detail the outcome of these arrests beyond Calhoun’s
recollection that he received probation for the offense in California.
3
2. First Conviction For a Sexually Violent Offense
While riding his motorcycle in Tarrant County in 1985, Calhoun saw a woman—
an adult—trying to fix a flat tire on her truck. At trial, he said, “Her truck was broke
down [sic], so I thought I would go and help her. While I had her on the bike riding
around, looking for a tool that we needed, I just decided I wanted to rape her.” He said
he knew it was wrong, but he did it for the “experience” because he “wondered what a
violent rape would be like, so [he] committed it, and [he’s] never done it again.” He
said he “didn’t like the violent part of it, so [he] just didn’t do that anymore.” He said,
“[Y]ou can’t really know if you like something or not if you don’t do it.”
During Calhoun’s testimony about the 1985 sexual assault, he said that he did
not recall hitting or choking the woman. The State confronted him with a statement
he made to police when he was arrested and with the transcript of a deposition taken
in this case in January 2026 in which he said he had choked her and had hit her. He
replied, “I probably did.”
In 1986, Calhoun pleaded nolo contendere to second-degree felony sexual
assault and was convicted and sentenced to eight years’ confinement. He was released
on parole after serving one year of the sentence. He began receiving sex-offender
treatment as a condition of his parole.
3. Subsequent Convictions For Sexually Violent Offenses
Within a few months after his release, Calhoun began dating a woman who had
three young daughters. Calhoun recounted at trial that the middle daughter, then age
4
eight or nine, asked a question about sex and that he then manipulated the elder
daughter, then age ten or eleven, into touching his penis over his clothes while her
mother was out of the room. He said that when he awoke from a later nap, the elder
daughter was touching him “on the crotch” and that his reaction was to smile and wink
at her. 3 This progressed quickly into two years of Calhoun’s sexually abusing the elder
daughter daily until his arrest after “two or three years of playing around.” The abuse
consisted largely of vaginal intercourse and resulted in the elder daughter’s becoming
pregnant.
Calhoun also began abusing the middle daughter around the same time because
she “wanted to know [what] her sister was doing, so she c[ould learn].” Asked how
long he had abused her, he said, “[L]et me clarify this. Starting with the first one, give
it a couple weeks for the second one to ask the question, and then continue both of
them all the way to the end.”
The youngest daughter was seven years old when Calhoun began abusing her.
He testified:
There was only just a couple of touches to her. I admit it that I did that,
but she didn’t like it so I didn’t do it. I was always - - I haven’t told you
this, but I’m going to tell you now. I gave the girls an absolute rule. You
don’t have to do anything you don’t want to do. And I made that rule
basically for me, so I wouldn’t go further than what they wanted to do,
because I didn’t want to hurt them. I didn’t realize I was hurting them,
and I was. But at that time, I was ignorant about it. And so I wanted to
keep the promise to myself that I would never hurt children. So they
At the January deposition, Calhoun recounted the story differently, omitting his
3
having manipulated the girls and also omitting the first sexual contact.
5
never had to do anything they didn’t want to do. I wish I knew I was
hurting them. But physically I was not.
During the years he was abusing the three girls, Calhoun was living with and
married to their mother and continued to have sex with her but chose to continue
abusing the girls out of “convenience.” Calhoun testified that he had not been sexually
attracted to the elder daughter but also conceded that he had thought about her while
having sex with her mother. Calhoun did not believe he had ever been sexually attracted
specifically to children but rather that his sex addiction had caused him to be sexually
attracted to “almost anybody.”
Calhoun was arrested in February 1992 for his offenses against the three girls.
In 1993, he pleaded guilty to first-degree felony aggravated sexual assault of a child
under fourteen years of age—the eldest girl—and two second-degree felony counts of
indecency with a child—the two younger girls—by contact. He was convicted and
sentenced to serve concurrent terms of thirty-five years’ incarceration for the
first-degree offense and twenty years’ incarceration for each second-degree offense.
4. Addiction, Deviance, and Continuing Education
Calhoun had used various illegal drugs “[m]any times” throughout his life but
had preferred marijuana as his “drug of choice.” He began using drugs at age twelve
and continued until 1991. He did not believe that he had ever had an issue with drug
use and had never sought substance-abuse treatment.
6
He did, however, believe that he had a sex addiction, a condition he believed to
be lifelong, and that “anybody with a sex addiction needs treatment their entire life.”
He estimated that he had learned about sex “physically” at age four and “mentally” at
age twelve. He said that he first had sex with a girl when he was nineteen years old. He
estimated that he had had between five and twelve sexual partners per week for much
of his life until he was incarcerated. He attributed this to his sex addiction.
While incarcerated, he had some minor disciplinary issues but no
sexual-misconduct infractions. He testified at trial that the last time he had masturbated
was in 1993. He was asked if he had told Dr. Dunham that the last time was in 1996
and agreed that might have been correct. He was also asked if he had said in his January
deposition that the last time had been in 2025, and he agreed that while he probably
had, he “just said that to answer [the] question.”
Calhoun testified about his efforts at self-education and rehabilitation. During
his first incarceration, he received his GED. During the second, he received an
associate of arts degree and certificates for welding, shipping and receiving, and
operation of forklifts. Although he applied, he was unable to enroll in State-provided
sex-offender treatment. 4 Therefore, beginning in about 2024, Calhoun engaged in a
religious self-study program to address addiction. In the program, he learned about
“triggers” and “way stones” that would allow him to avoid “going in the wrong
Calhoun testified that he had applied but that he was not eligible because
4
enrollment was limited to people who were to be released on parole.
7
direction,” as far as his addiction. He said that because of the program he was “not as
angry[,] . . . not as violent” as he had been before and that he now cared about people,
which he had not previously done.
Asked about his risk of sexually assaulting another child in the future, Calhoun
said that if he “[did] not continue [him]self down the path of an accountability person
and keeping [him]self straight, there’s always possibility.” He testified that his sex drive
was “[n]ot much” and that he now didn’t “seriously feel the need that [he] used to have
to have sex.”
B. Dr. Dunham’s Testimony
Dr. Dunham testified as a licensed forensic psychologist. His practice since 2005
had mainly consisted of evaluations and consultations in legal proceedings, with
emphasis on sex-offender evaluations. He had performed more than 200 such
evaluations in SVP cases.
In conducting civil commitment evaluations, Dr. Dunham reviews provided
records, interviews the individual, conducts testing, and reviews test results to evaluate
the person’s risk of reoffending. Dr. Dunham testified that in evaluating Calhoun, he
had used a methodology that accorded with his training as a forensic psychologist and
that he believed was within the accepted standards in the field of forensic psychology.
1. Record Review and Interview
In preparing to evaluate Calhoun, Dr. Dunham reviewed offense reports, police
reports, victim statements, legal documents regarding Calhoun’s convictions, military
8
records, hospital records, prison records, treatment records, deposition transcripts, past
trial transcripts, and educational records. The August 2025 interview lasted two hours
and fifteen minutes, which Dr. Dunham considered adequate time to conduct the
evaluation.
Dr. Dunham recounted his conversation with Calhoun. Calhoun had said that
he had begun offending against the three girls whom he was convicted of abusing “only
a few weeks after they met.” He told Dr. Dunham that the middle daughter had
approached him after he began abusing the elder, had asked him for sex, and had later
threatened to withhold sex from him when he would not penetrate her vagina with his
penis. Calhoun admitted that he had abused both the elder and middle girls daily “for
two years, one in the morning, one in the evening, [while] also having sex with [their
mother] at the same time,” but he stated that the girls had initiated and wanted the
contact. Dr. Dunham estimated that Calhoun’s offenses comprised “over 1,000
occurrences in two years.” He felt Calhoun’s attitude during the interview was
significant because he “laughed a couple of times” while talking about his offenses,
“spoke as if it was no big deal,” and “seem[ed] to look at it like it[ was] okay that . . .
[the girl] was not yelling or screaming or telling on him.”
Dr. Dunham characterized Calhoun’s attitude as demonstrating a cognitive
distortion, i.e., a belief used to rationalize his behavior. Dr. Dunham characterized
Calhoun’s cognitive distortion as preventing him from admitting “that he actually hurt
9
somebody physically, even though he doesn’t feel like he hurt them sexually,” which
indicated a lack of remorse about his offense.
Based on his review of the victim statements, Dr. Dunham recounted that when
the elder daughter was thirteen or fourteen years old, her doctor had discovered that
she was pregnant. Confronted with the fact, she had told her mother and the doctor
that she had been regularly having sex with Calhoun and that she planned to marry
him—and he her—and she was happy to have his child. The girl said that Calhoun told
her “that he only married her mom so he’d have sex with her” and that “it was making
love to her, but having sex with her mom.”
The elder daughter’s statements, in light of Calhoun’s attitude and cognitive
distortions, indicated to Dr. Dunham that Calhoun had engaged in “grooming”
behaviors, likely beginning very soon after meeting the girls. Dr. Dunham defined
“grooming” by sex offenders as behavior that makes a sex offense more likely to
happen, and he gave examples such as enticing a child with candy, befriending a mother
to gain access to a child, or touching children to normalize physical contact. In this
case, he noted that Calhoun tickled the girls at first and then began to fondle them and
that Calhoun told him that “they thought it was playtime, but they didn’t know what
kind of playtime I was doing.”
Of further concern to Dr. Dunham was Calhoun’s offending after receiving
sex-offender treatment while on parole for his first sexual assault. He felt that Calhoun
had not developed the tools to reduce his risk of reoffending. Although Calhoun’s
10
continuing education during his latest prison term was perhaps beneficial, Dr. Dunham
noted that the classes Calhoun had taken had not been designed to reduce the risk of
reoffending.
2. Diagnoses and Risk of Reoffending
After his review of the records and his interview with Calhoun, Dr. Dunham
formed the belief, based upon his training, education, and experience, that Calhoun has
a behavioral abnormality that makes him likely to engage in predatory acts of sexual
violence.
More specifically, Dr. Dunham determined that Calhoun suffers from the
behavioral abnormality of pedophilia, a sexually deviant attraction to children.
Dr. Dunham characterized this kind of deviance as a congenital or acquired condition
that is “chronic, lifelong[,] and they have to learn how to manage it.”
He also diagnosed Calhoun with antisocial personality disorder, characterized by
reckless behavior and a lack of concern for other people. The diagnosis was based
upon documentary evidence showing that Calhoun had a history of violence,
criminality, dishonesty, impulsiveness, and lack of remorse. Calhoun’s medical records
showed inconsistent reports of his drug use and number of sexual partners because,
according to Dr. Dunham, he “[had] a different number and different story for almost
every evaluator.” Calhoun had hit a person with a baseball bat while in school, had
stolen a truck while enlisted in the Marines, had hit a drill instructor, and had legal issues
including receipt of stolen property and burglary. Dr. Dunham’s summary was that
11
“the times he has been in society, in the community, he’s had a hard time following
rules.”
Beyond his interview and document review, Dr. Dunham also used a clinically
adjusted actuarial approach incorporating the Static-99R, an actuarial test. The Static-
99R is used to measure sex offenders’ risk of reoffending. It contains ten items to give
a baseline likelihood of reoffending, based upon comparisons with other sex offenders,
rendered in a score range between -3 and 12. The result of the test is used as a baseline
in evaluating risk of reoffending, and it must be adjusted up or down based on factors
that the test does not measure. Dr. Dunham offered two hypothetical examples of
factors that would impact the risk to reoffend but that the Static-99R’s baseline does
not measure: a direct statement by the subject that “the first day I step out of there, I’m
going to sexually assault somebody”; and the subject’s having received sex-offender
treatment.
Calhoun received a baseline score of 2, indicating an average risk of reoffending.
But Dr. Dunham believed that the evaluation underestimated the risk. He felt that
Calhoun’s age, a factor that reduced his score by three points, would be only a
positive—as opposed to protective5—factor because Calhoun still had a strong sex
Dr. Dunham differentiated “protective factors”—those that have been
5
statistically shown to decrease the risk of reoffending—from “positive factors”—those
that are beneficial and may contribute to a more stable lifestyle after prison but that are
not correlated to risk reduction by research.
12
drive and looked approachable to children.6 Dr. Dunham said the Static-99R also did
not reflect Calhoun’s level of psychopathy and so did not accurately reflect his risk of
reoffending.
Dr. Dunham characterized psychopathy as “an elevation of antisocial
personality” in “people who really lack concern for other people,” and who, “if they
feel like they can get away with something, [will] do it.” He used the Psychopathy
Checklist Revised, or PCLR, to measure Calhoun’s level of psychopathy. The PCLR is
an inventory of twenty characteristics that the analyst rates between 0 and 2 points
based on his observations. Calhoun’s PCLR returned a score of 30, a “high level of
psychopathy.” Among the characteristics Calhoun showed strongly were glibness,
conning and manipulation, and impulsivity and opportunism.
Dr. Dunham testified that Calhoun demonstrated glibness in his “superficial
charm” and “laughing about offenses, not taking them too seriously.” Dr. Dunham
noted conning and manipulative behaviors including Calhoun’s nomadic lifestyle, his
grooming behavior and the way he manipulated the girls into not reporting the ongoing
abuse,7 and an event during his enlistment in which he told a military psychiatric
Calhoun’s attorney asked Dr. Dunham if Calhoun “look[ed] like Papa Smurf.”
6
Dr. Dunham said he “was thinking Santa Claus.”
7
Contemporaneous police reports and victim statements showed that Calhoun
had told the girls that he would kill their mother and put them in an orphanage if they
reported the abuse.
13
evaluator that he was in mourning because his wife had recently died in a vehicle
collision.8 Dr. Dunham offered the 1986 sexual assault conviction, Calhoun’s failure to
hold employment, and his “bounc[ing] from place to place” as examples of impulsive
and opportunist behavior.
Dr. Dunham testified that pedophilic disorder with antisocial personality
disorder is an uncommon combination. He testified that most people diagnosed with
pedophilia are not antisocial and tend to follow rules and avoid trouble. His concern
was that Calhoun’s widely varied kinds of offenses—including violence, theft, and
sexual offenses—considered in light of his sexual deviance indicated a heightened
element of danger.
II. STANDARD OF REVIEW
At a trial on a petition from the State seeking civil commitment, the jurors shall
determine whether they believe beyond a reasonable doubt that the person is an SVP.
Id. § 841.062(a). A person is an SVP if that person “(1) is a repeat sexually violent
offender;[9] and (2) suffers from a behavioral abnormality that makes the person likely
to engage in a predatory act of sexual violence.” Id. § 841.003(a)(1), (2). “Behavioral
abnormality” is statutorily defined as “a congenital or acquired condition that, by
8
Calhoun had been unmarried and his bereavement appears to have been
fabricated to excuse misbehavior.
9
Relevant to the facts here, a repeat sexually violent offender is a person who is
convicted of more than one sexually violent offense and a sentence imposed for at least
one. Id. § 841.003(b).
14
affecting a person’s emotional or volitional capacity, predisposes the person to commit
a sexually violent offense, to the extent that the person becomes a menace to the health
and safety of another person.” Id. § 841.002(2).
A commitment proceeding under the SVP Act is the rare civil proceeding that
incorporates the “beyond a reasonable doubt” burden of proof typical of criminal cases.
See id. § 841.062; In re Commitment of Fisher, 164 S.W.3d 637, 639–41 (Tex. 2005).
Legal-sufficiency review in civil cases with this burden is consistent with review in
criminal cases: the reviewing court must determine “whether, after viewing the evidence
in the light most favorable to the [petitioner], any rational trier of fact could have found
the essential elements . . . beyond a reasonable doubt.” In re Commitment of Stoddard, 619
S.W.3d 665, 674–75 (Tex. 2020) (quoting Jackson v. Virginia, 443 U.S. 307, 319, 99 S. Ct.
2781, 2789 (1979)).
III. DISCUSSION
After the presentation of evidence and the parties’ final arguments, the jury
unanimously answered “Yes” to the charge question, “Do you find beyond a reasonable
doubt that [Calhoun] is a sexually violent predator?” Calhoun does not dispute the
evidence supporting the jury’s implicit finding of the first SVP element, that he is a
repeat sexually violent offender. See Tex. Health & Safety Code § 841.003(b). He rather
argues that legally insufficient evidence supported its implicit finding of the second, that
he suffered from a behavioral abnormality making him likely to engage in a predatory
act of sexual violence. See id. §§ 841.002(2), .003(a)(2).
15
Specifically, Calhoun argues that Dr. Dunham’s opinions were largely based
upon speculation and unsupported conclusions, that there was no evidence supporting
a finding that Calhoun currently has serious difficulty controlling his behavior, and that
the evidence of the risk of his reoffending was questionable.
A. The Bases of Dr. Dunham’s Opinions
Calhoun makes the general argument that Dr. Dunham’s opinions were based
“largely” on speculation and unsupported conclusions. We note that Dr. Dunham
testified that he based his opinion on Calhoun’s offense reports, police reports, victim
statements, legal documents regarding his convictions, military records, educational
records, treatment records, hospital records, prison records, deposition transcripts,
Static-99R and PCLR test results, and his interview with Calhoun. After considering
this information, Dr. Dunham diagnosed Calhoun with sexual deviance in the form of
pedophilia—a chronic condition affecting Calhoun’s emotional or volitional capacity
and a lifelong condition that does not diminish with time—based upon criteria in the
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition, a standard
reference book used by mental health professionals. See In re Commitment of Bryant,
No. 14-23-00642-CV, 2024 WL 3665406, at *3 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.]
Aug. 6, 2024, no pet.). Dr. Dunham also diagnosed Calhoun with antisocial personality
disorder, a condition characterized by a lifelong tendency to violate the law and social
rules and mores. Both diagnoses were based upon Dr. Dunham’s documentary review
and his observations during the interview. Dr. Dunham also testified to the unique
16
aspect of Calhoun’s personality—that he suffered from both pedophilia and antisocial
personality diagnoses—heightening the danger he presented.
Based on this information, we cannot say that the opinions underlying the
diagnoses were based solely on speculation or unsupported conclusions. See In re
Commitment of Day, 342 S.W.3d 193, 200–01 (Tex. App.—Beaumont 2011, pet. denied).
The only specific contention made by Dr. Dunham that Calhoun challenges as
being speculation or an unsupported conclusion was that Calhoun’s “grandfatherly
looks made him appealable to children.” Dr. Dunham made the statement while
explaining why he considered Calhoun likely to reoffend. But Dr. Dunham also
itemized his concerns that the classes Calhoun had been taking would not provide him
with sufficient tools to reduce his risk of reoffending, that Calhoun had offended after
receiving sex-offender treatment, that his sex offenses against the girls may have
comprised “over 1,000 occurrences in two years,” that he had ongoing thought
distortions and potential sexual arousal to children, and beyond those factors that his
appearance may make him seem approachable to those children because Dr. Dunham
didn’t “think that they would look at him and be scared of him.” When pressed on this
last point by Calhoun’s attorney, Dr. Dunham clarified that although he didn’t believe
Calhoun was deliberately trying to look approachable to children, the approachability
would nonetheless make it easier for Calhoun “if he wanted to . . . entice a child.”
Dr. Dunham believed that this approachability would temper the protective factor of
Calhoun’s age by making future offenses easier and providing more opportunity to
17
offend. See In re Commitment of Colantuono, 536 S.W.3d 549, 558–59 (Tex. App.—San
Antonio 2017, no pet.) (holding evidence of future dangerousness was sufficient which
included, inter alia, testimony that age as a protective factor was tempered by
approachability in appearance).
Calhoun disputes Dr. Dunham’s reasoning and argues that as a sex offender, he
would “be restricted from associating with random children” and had been “able to
victimize children in the past due to his close proximity to them and living in the same
household.” Then Calhoun speculates that his status as a sex offender in 2026 will
provide a barrier to access to victims that his status as a sex offender in 1991 did not.
However, there was no evidence adduced at trial about whether the conditions of his
first parole release required him to avoid children or how his conditions as a current
sex-offender registrant would be more or less restrictive than the conditions of that
earlier parole. The argument was not before the jury at trial and does not diminish the
evidentiary value of Dr. Dunham’s in-court statement that the protective factor of
Calhoun’s age is tempered by his approachable appearance or other factors that
Dr. Dunham relied upon in forming his opinions. See id.
Calhoun further argues that a “major rationale” for the adjustments to the
baseline score of 2 returned by the Static-99R that showed an average risk of
reoffending was Dr. Dunham’s belief that Calhoun had ongoing fantasies about his
victims. Calhoun argues that the only evidence of such fantasies in the record was an
incident relayed by both of the witnesses during trial.
18
Calhoun recounted that in 2019 he had been talking to three other inmates about
women and about “the girls on TV” while “watching a show where they put masks on
their faces” and that “some of the girls were dressed pretty good.” While talking about
women, he testified, his eldest child-victim had “popped into” his mind, so he cut off
the conversation and left the room. He said his “way stone” directed him away from
the conversation, and so he used that stimulus to avoid an improper conversation.
Dr. Dunham recalled having heard the story with different details. He said that
Calhoun had told him that he had been speaking with other inmates about their offenses
during a class and became sexually aroused while thinking about his eldest child-victim
and had to leave the class. Dr. Dunham did not place great credence on the details as
told to him but rather took the story to mean that Calhoun was struggling with having
fantasies of a victim. Dr. Dunham said he was unsure whether to credit the event as
having happened at all.
However, whether Calhoun had fantasies about his victims was not the only
factor considered in adjusting the baseline Static-99R score. Dr. Dunham testified that
he tempered the protective factor of age because, although sixty-eight years old,
Calhoun still had “a high sex drive, and [was] still thinking of it, you know, still talking
about other women that he finds attractive.” Dr. Dunham did state that Calhoun had
still been having sexual fantasies about his victims but also that he spoke inconsistently
about his sex drive. Dr. Dunham noted that during their interview, Calhoun said he
hadn’t masturbated in thirty-one years but that in his deposition, Calhoun said had had
19
last done so approximately one year earlier and that he thought about sex once a week.
Even assuming a jury could not credit Dr. Dunham’s statement that Calhoun had sexual
fantasies about his victims, the record shows that Dr. Dunham had additional reasons
to modify Calhoun’s baseline Static-99R score.
We cannot agree with Calhoun that insufficient evidence supported
Dr. Dunham’s opinions or that the opinions consisted only of speculation or
unsupported conclusions.
B. Calhoun’s Difficulty Controlling His Behavior
Calhoun argues that no evidence supports a finding that he “has serious difficulty
. . . controlling his behavior” and particularly that diagnoses of pedophilia or antisocial
personality disorder in the past do not indicate a likelihood of future offense. However,
the statutory question of whether a person “suffers from a behavioral abnormality that
makes the person likely to engage in a predatory act of sexual violence” is a single,
unified issue. In re Commitment of Bohannon, 388 S.W.3d 296, 303 (Tex. 2012). We cannot
separate the question of predisposition to commit a sexually violent offense as affected
by emotional or volitional capacity—i.e., serious difficulty controlling behavior—from
the question of the likelihood that the person will engage in such an act. Id. “An
increased likelihood of misconduct indicates a predisposition, and a predisposition
threatens increased likelihood.” Id. The evidence supporting the behavioral
abnormality must show a “present condition” that creates a likelihood of sexually
violent behavior in the future. Stoddard, 619 S.W.3d at 678.
20
Dr. Dunham testified that he had diagnosed Calhoun with pedophilia and
antisocial personality disorders. He testified that this is an uncommon combination of
conditions that makes Calhoun more likely to commit further offenses than would a
person diagnosed with either. See In re Commitment of K.S., 622 S.W.3d 569, 573 (Tex.
App.—Waco 2021, no pet.) (holding sufficient evidence supported SVP finding for
respondent with both diagnoses); In re Commitment of Harris, 541 S.W.3d 322, 329 (Tex.
App.—Houston [14th Dist.] 2017, no pet.) (similar); In re Commitment of Stuteville, 463
S.W.3d 543, 553–54 (Tex. App.—Houston [1st Dist.] 2015, pet. denied) (similar).
Dr. Dunham also testified that the disorders were still present at the time of trial and
continued to affect Calhoun. Calhoun also stated that, although his sex drive is less
that it had been previously, he remains a sex addict and likely would for his lifetime,
and that his “way stones” addressed a present danger of sexual offense. The evidence
before the jury was sufficient to support a finding that Calhoun’s behavioral
abnormality was a “present condition” that creates a likelihood of sexually violent
behavior in the future. Stoddard, 619 S.W.3d at 678.
Calhoun then argues that there is no evidence showing that he is part of the
“small but extremely dangerous group” of sex offenders contemplated by the statute
because “sexual deviance and antisocial orientation” are attributable to any sex
offender. But that language, contained in the SVP Act’s legislative findings, is not part
of the statute’s definition of a “sexually violent predator” and was not an element the
jury was required to find. Id.
21
C. Evidence Supporting Calhoun’s Risk of Reoffending
Calhoun argues that the evidence supporting the risk of reoffending is disputed
and that “concepts such as dangerousness, volitional control[,] and probable future
behavior can be difficult to define and measure.” He argues that Dr. Dunham identified
several risk factors that he applied without providing any numerical or statistical
measure for any of them and that he provided no data on how the passage of time
affects the risk level presented by these factors.
We note first that to form his opinion, Dr. Dunham weighed factors for and
against the likelihood that Calhoun would reoffend. He testified that the risk factors
were research-based and that they correlated highly with reoffending and that the
protective factors “counter or temper against” that risk.
Dr. Dunham identified protective factors against Calhoun’s reoffending
including his age, his lack of sexual misconduct in prison, his education while
incarcerated, and his admissions that he had committed sexual offenses and was a sex
addict. However, Dr. Dunham characterized several of these factors as positive rather
than protective, particularly Calhoun’s acknowledgement of the sexual nature of his
offenses while minimizing the violence of them, his age mitigated by his strong sex
drive and the fact that his appearance may make him approachable to victims, and the
addiction classes Calhoun had taken that did not specifically address his disorders.
The risk factors that Dr. Dunham specifically enumerated as the basis for his
opinion that Calhoun was likely to reoffend included his high level of psychopathy, the
22
violence associated with Calhoun’s first sexual assault, his choice of a random stranger
as a victim of that violent assault, his reoffending after receiving some sex-offender
treatment on parole, the short time between his release from prison for that offense
and his beginning to commit additional sex offenses, his grooming the three girls, the
extent of his offenses against them while he was married to an adult sexual partner, and
his cognitive distortions and lack of remorse and empathy for his victims.
Calhoun tries to counter the factors that Dr. Dunham enumerated by arguing
that the Static-99R evaluation is “the sole component of Dr. Dunham’s evaluation that
provides meaningful objective and statistical data.” Calhoun is correct that the
Static-99R was one of two parts of the evaluation that returned a numerical score, the
other being the PCLR test. He argues that we should therefore give greater weight to
the unadjusted baseline result of the Static-99R evaluation than to other factors.
However, the test is designed to generate a baseline score that the tester modifies
with additional factors not reflected in its questions. See In re Commitment of Mumford,
No. 05-19-00186-CV, 2020 WL 1528495, at *3 (Tex. App.—Dallas Mar. 31, 2020, no
pet.) (holding that low baseline score on Static-99R did not demonstrate evidentiary
insufficiency when considered in light of other factors and expert opinion that
respondent is an SVP who suffered from a behavioral abnormality making him likely
to engage in future acts of predatory sexual violence); In re Commitment of Manuel, No. 01-
18-00650-CV, 2019 WL 2458986, at *3 (Tex. App.—Houston [1st Dist.] June 13, 2019,
pet. denied) (“[T]he Static-99R is ‘not the final answer,’ but provides a ‘baseline’ when
23
other non-static factors are also considered.”). Dr. Dunham testified that he disagreed
with the baseline assessment that Calhoun was in the “average risk category” to
reoffend because other factors not listed in the test suggested a higher likelihood.
Ultimately, the jury is the “sole judge of the credibility of witnesses and the
weight to be given to their testimony.” Stoddard, 619 S.W.3d at 674 (quoting Golden
Eagle Archery, Inc. v. Jackson, 116 S.W.3d 757, 761 (Tex. 2003)). Viewing Dr. Dunham’s
and Calhoun’s testimonies in the light most favorable to the verdict, which we are
required to do, we conclude that a reasonable jury could have weighed the testimony
and found beyond a reasonable doubt that Calhoun suffers from a behavioral
abnormality that makes him likely to engage in a predatory act of sexual violence. See
In re Commitment of Ivie, 687 S.W.3d 526, 539–40 (Tex. App.—Eastland 2024, no pet.).
IV. CONCLUSION
Because legally sufficient evidence exists to support the jury’s verdict, we
overrule Calhoun’s sole issue and affirm the trial court’s judgment. See id.
/s/ Dabney Bassel
Dabney Bassel
Justice
Delivered: November 12, 2026
24