In Re the Dow Chemical Company, Union Carbide Corporation, and Performance Materials NOA, Inc. v. the State of Texas
CourtTexas Court of Appeals, 14th District (Houston)
Date FiledNovember 20, 2026
Docket14-26-01170-CV
JudgeChristopher; Wilson; Bridges
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Stay Lifted; Petition for Writ of Mandamus Granted in Part and Dismissed in
Part; and Memorandum Opinion filed November 20, 2026.
In The
Fourteenth Court of Appeals
NO. 14-26-01170-CV
IN RE THE DOW CHEMICAL COMPANY, UNION CARBIDE
CORPORATION, AND PERFORMANCE MATERIALS NA, INC., Relators
ORIGINAL PROCEEDING
WRIT OF MANDAMUS
113th District Court
Harris County, Texas
Trial Court Cause No. 2020-13324
MEMORANDUM OPINION
Relators The Dow Chemical Company, Union Carbide Corporation, and
Performance Materials NA, Inc. filed a petition for writ of mandamus asking this
court to vacate (1) an order compelling relators’ net worth discovery; and (2) an
order denying relator Dow Chemical’s motion to quash trial subpoenas directed to
corporate representatives. We grant the petition in part because the trial court
abused its discretion when it signed the order compelling net worth discovery from
relators and relators lack an adequate remedy by appeal. We dismiss relators’
request to vacate the trial subpoena order as moot.1
Background
Carbon monoxide killed two workers at a Pasadena, Texas facility in 2019.
Two others claimed they sustained injuries from exposure to the gas. The
underlying suit followed, involving claims of negligence and gross negligence
against relators. Relevant to the mandamus petition, the parties signed an amended
scheduling order, agreeing to conclude discovery in July 2025. The order reads:
7/15/2025 DISCOVERY PERIOD ENDS. Parties must complete all
discovery. Parties seeking discovery must serve all requests
sufficiently far in advance of the end of the discovery period so that
the deadline for responding will be within the discovery period.
The case went to trial in October 2026. Weeks into the proceedings, real parties in
interest filed a motion to obtain relators’ net worth discovery based on a claim of
gross negligence. The trial court signed the contested order compelling relators’
net worth discovery on October 30, 2026. This mandamus proceeding followed.
Net Worth Order
To obtain mandamus relief, a relator generally must show both that the trial
court clearly abused its discretion and that relator has no adequate remedy by
appeal. In re Kimco Developers, Inc., No. 14-24-00361-CV, 2024 WL 5250445, at
*2 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] Dec. 31, 2024, orig. proceeding) (mem. op.)
(per curiam). “A discovery order that compels production beyond the rules of
procedure is an abuse of discretion for which mandamus is the proper remedy.” Id.
1
Real parties in interest filed a motion seeking to dismiss relators’ request for this court to order
the trial court to vacate the trial subpoena order as moot. We grant real parties in interest’s motion.
2
It is settled that “parties lack an adequate appellate remedy from orders compelling
discovery beyond what the rules allow. Id. at *5. “[A] trial court may authorize
discovery of evidence of a defendant’s net worth if the court finds in a written
order that the claimant has demonstrated a substantial likelihood of success on the
merits of a claim for exemplary damages” on the motion of a party and after notice
and a hearing. Id. at *2; see Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 41.0115(a).
Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 191.1 provides that “except where
specifically prohibited” the parties may modify the “rules pertaining to discovery”
by agreement. In re Union Carbide Corp., No. 14-24-00187-CV, 2024 WL
3198602, at *2 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] June 27, 2024, orig. proceeding)
(per curiam) (mem. op.) (quoting Tex. R. Civ. P. 191.1). An agreement is
enforceable when it complies with the terms of Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 11.
Union Carbide Corp., 2024 WL 3198602, at *2. Rule 11 states “[u]nless otherwise
provided in these rules, no agreement between attorneys or parties touching any
suit pending will be enforced unless it be in writing, signed and filed with the
papers as part of the record, or unless it be made in open court and entered of
record.” Tex. R. Civ. P. 11. “A trial court has a ministerial duty to enforce a valid
Rule 11 agreement.” Union Carbide Corp., 2024 WL 3198602, at *2; see Fortis
Benefits v. Cantu, 234 S.W.3d 642, 651 n.58 (Tex. 2007).
Here, the parties entered an agreement to stop discovery in July 2025. Then,
despite the deal, real parties in interest filed their motion seeking relators’ net
worth discovery in October 2026 — more than a year after the discovery period
ended. The trial court failed to enforce the agreement setting the July 2025
discovery deadline when it signed the October 30, 2026 order compelling net
3
worth discovery. To determine if the trial court abused its discretion in failing to
enforce a Rule 11 agreement, we must establish whether (1) the agreement was
enforceable; and (2) the trial court had good cause to set aside the discovery
agreement. Union Carbide Corp., 2024 WL 3198602, at *1.
The parties’ agreement was in writing, signed, and filed with the trial court.
Thus, the agreement complied with the requirements of Rule 11 and was
enforceable. See Tex. R. Civ. P. 11. The parties do not argue that the agreement
was specifically prohibited or that the agreement was outside the scope of Rule
191.1. See Tex. R. Civ. P. 191; see also Union Carbide Corp., 2024 WL 3198602,
at *2; In re BP Products N. Am., Inc., 244 S.W.3d 840, 846 (Tex. 2008) (orig.
proceeding). Nothing in the record indicates the trial court had good cause to set
aside the agreement. Thus, the trial court had a ministerial duty to enforce the Rule
11 agreement, which stated: “7/15/2025 DISCOVERY PERIOD ENDS. Parties
must complete all discovery.”
The trial court abused its discretion when it failed to enforce the agreement
and ordered relators to produce net worth discovery after the discovery period
ended. Further, relators lack an adequate remedy by appeal because “[d]elaying
review until appeal . . . would defeat not only the purpose of the discovery
agreement, but also the strong public policy encouraging parties to resolve their
discovery disputes without court intervention.” Union Carbide Corp., 2024 WL
3198602, at *3; see BP Products N. Am., Inc., 244 S.W.3d at 848-49 (holding that
mandamus review was available where trial court abused its discretion in setting
aside a valid discovery agreement without good cause).
4
Conclusion
The parties signed an enforceable Rule 11 agreement that ended discovery in
July 2025. The trial court abused its discretion in failing to enforce the agreement
and compelling relators to provide net worth discovery fifteen months after the
parties chose to end discovery. We conditionally grant the petition for writ of
mandamus in part and order the trial court to vacate its October 30, 2026 order
compelling relators’ net worth discovery. We dismiss relators’ request to vacate
the order denying relator Dow Chemical’s motion to quash trial subpoenas as
moot. In addition, we lift this court’s stay.
PER CURIAM
Panel consists of Chief Justice Christopher and Justices Wilson and Bridges.
5