Estate of Arnold H. Montes, Jr. v. the State of Texas
CourtTexas Court of Appeals, 12th District (Tyler)
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
Docket12-26-00277-CV
JudgeHoyle
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
NO. 12-26-00263-CV
12-26-00277- CV
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS
TWELFTH COURT OF APPEALS DISTRICT
TYLER, TEXAS
CHAD ARNOLD MONTES, AS § APPEAL FROM THE
INDEPENDENT EXECUTOR OF THE
ESTATE OF ARNOLD H. MONTES,
JR., DECEASED,
APPELLANT
V.
FRANK RODRIGUES; CORY § COUNTY COURT AT LAW NO 1
MONTES, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS
TRUSTEE OF THE CORY LEE
MONTES TRUSTS; BLAS TOVAR;
PINEYWOODS MOTOR COMPANY;
PMC AUTO GROUP; R&M
INVESTMENTS,
APPELLEES
§ ANGELINA COUNTY, TEXAS
MEMORANDUM OPINION
Chad Arnold Montes, as Independent Executor of the Estate of Arnold H. Montes, Jr.,
Deceased, appeals the trial court’s orders issuing a temporary injunction and requiring him to
provide an updated accounting. We dismiss the case as moot.
BACKGROUND
Chad was appointed independent executor of Arnold H. Montes, Jr.’s estate. Arnold’s
estate is worth more than $10,000,000, encompassing several business interests such as
automobile dealerships, automobile financing companies, and numerous real estate properties.
Chad brought claims against Frank Rodrigues, Cory Montes, Individually and as Trustee of the
Cory Lee Montes Trusts, Blas Tovar, Pineywoods Motor Company, PMC Auto Group, and R&M
Investments (collectively Appellees), claiming they withheld funds from or otherwise defrauded
the estate. Those entities filed claims against Chad, alleging several causes of action including
theft, embezzlement, fraud, and conversion. According to Chad, Cory and the entities failed to
cooperate with discovery for several years. Cory filed several motions to remove Chad as
independent executor. Cory also demanded an accounting, which Chad provided. Appellees
asked for a temporary injunction in the alternative to removing Chad.
Following a hearing, the trial court issued a temporary injunction prohibiting Chad from
“accessing, withdrawing from, transferring, or otherwise using any funds in any estate bank,
investment account, or financial asset.” It also set a “trial on the merits—the final hearing on
Petitioner’s Motion to Remove Independent Executor” for October 22, 2026. In addition, the
trial court ordered Chad to provide a revised accounting within thirty days of the order. These
appeals followed.
MOOTNESS
Chad contends the trial court erred in ordering him to provide an updated accounting and
issuing a temporary injunction. Appellees filed a motion to dismiss in the accounting case
alleging the case is moot.
Applicable Law
Courts lack subject-matter jurisdiction to decide a moot controversy. Texas Dep’t of
Fam. & Protective Servs. v. N.J., 644 S.W.3d 189, 192 (Tex. 2022). A case may become moot at
any time, including on appeal. Id.
A case becomes moot during the pendency of the litigation “if, since the time of filing,
there has ceased to exist a justiciable controversy between the parties—that is, if the issues
presented are no longer ‘live,’ or if the parties lack a legally cognizable interest in the outcome.”
Heckman v. Williamson Cty., 369 S.W.3d 137, 162 (Tex. 2012). An issue becomes moot when:
(1) it appears that one seeks to obtain a judgment on some controversy, which in reality does not
exist; or (2) when one seeks a judgment on some matter which, when rendered for any reason,
cannot have any practical legal effect on a then-existing controversy. City of Farmers Branch v.
Ramos, 235 S.W.3d 462, 469 (Tex. App.—Dallas 2007, no pet.). Put simply, a case is moot
when the court’s action on the merits cannot affect the parties’ rights or interests. Heckman, 369
S.W.3d at 162.
2
Application
In his brief, Chad acknowledges that he provided the requested updated accounting. In
addition, the trial court held the final hearing on Cory’s motion to remove Chad as independent
executor. Chad appealed the trial court’s decision removing him as independent executor. 1
Therefore, Chad’s appeals are moot because the controversies are no longer live. See Glassdoor,
Inc. v. Andra Grp., LP, 575 S.W.3d 523, 527 (Tex. 2019) (stating that case becomes moot during
pendency of litigation if issues presented are no longer “live” or parties lack legally cognizable
interest in outcome) (quoting Heckman, 369 S.W.3d at 162); see also Valley Baptist Med. Ctr. v.
Gonzalez, 33 S.W.3d 821, 822 (Tex. 2000) (per curiam) (holding appeal of trial court’s order
became moot once appellant complied with order and court of appeals was notified of
compliance); Eckert v. Beyond Fin., LLC, No. 05-24-01274-CV, 2026 WL 2815891, at *4 (Tex.
App.—Dallas Sept. 18, 2026, no pet. h.) (when an injunction expires by its own terms, the
question of whether or not the injunction should have been granted is moot).
Chad insists that instead of simply dismissing the appeal for lack of jurisdiction, we must
vacate the lower court’s orders. In support of his argument, he cites Alsobrook v. MTGLQ
Inv’rs, LP, 656 S.W.3d 394 (Tex. 2022) (per curiam). In Alsobrook¸ the Texas Supreme Court
stated:
We have long held that “when a case becomes moot on appeal, all previous orders are [to be] set
aside by the appellate court and the case ... dismissed.” We recently reiterated this long-standing
rule. Earlier this year, we again noted our “usual practice” is “to vacate the court of appeals’
judgment when a case become[s] moot on appeal to this Court.” This is necessary because simply
dismissing the appeal “would have the effect of affirming the judgment of the lower court without
considering any assignments of error thereto.”
Alsobrook, 656 S.W.3d at 395 (internal citations omitted). The Texas Supreme Court utilized
this logic to modify the appellate court’s judgment to vacate the trial court’s final judgment and
dismiss the case. Id.
However, the premises for vacating the trial court’s judgment do not exist in this case. As
explained in Morath v. Lewis, the rationale is to prevent gamesmanship where a party who
succeeded below voluntarily drops its claims, precluding the opposing party from seeking review
1
We take judicial notice of the pending appeal (cause number 12-26-00364-CV) of the order removing
Chad as independent executor. See Humphries v. Humphries, 349 S.W.3d 817, 820, n.1 (Tex. App.—Tyler 2011,
pet. denied) (appellate court may take judicial notice of its own records in same or related proceeding involving
same or nearly same parties).
3
of an adverse outcome. 601 S.W.3d 785, 791 (Tex. 2020); see also Alsobrook, 656 S.W.3d at
395 (recognizing same concern). In addition, the rationale states that an appellate court should
set aside all previous orders because simply dismissing the appeal would have the effect of
affirming the judgment of the lower court without considering the merits of the appeal. See Tex.
Foundries v. Int’l Moulders & Foundry Workers’ Union, 248 S.W.2d 460, 461 (Tex. 1952).
However, we believe that vacating the judgment has the opposite effect—reversing the trial
court’s judgment without a merits decision—and we decline to do so in this case.
Accordingly, any decision by this Court with respect to the accounting order or the
temporary injunction would have no practical effect on the parties. As such, the appeals are
moot and any decision by this Court would constitute an improper advisory opinion.
CONCLUSION
We conclude that these appeals are moot. Accordingly, we grant Appellees’ motion to
dismiss regarding the accounting order and we dismiss both cases as moot without reference to
the merits. See TEX. R. APP. P. 43.2(f).
BRIAN HOYLE
Justice
Opinion delivered November 18, 2026.
Panel consisted of Worthen, C.J., Hoyle, J. and Davis, J.
4
COURT OF APPEALS
TWELFTH COURT OF APPEALS DISTRICT OF TEXAS
JUDGMENT
NOVEMBER 18, 2026
NO. 12-26-00263-CV
CHAD ARNOLD MONTES, AS INDEPENDENT EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF
ARNOLD H. MONTES, JR., DECEASED,
Appellant
V.
FRANK RODRIGUES; CORY MONTES, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS TRUSTEE OF THE
CORY LEE MONTES TRUSTS; BLAS TOVAR; PINEYWOODS MOTOR COMPANY;
PMC AUTO GROUP; R&M INVESTMENTS,
Appellees
Appeal from the County Court at Law No 1
of Angelina County, Texas (Tr.Ct.No. 078-22-PR)
THIS CAUSE came to be heard on the appellate record and briefs filed
herein, and the same being considered, it is the opinion of this court that the dispute is moot, it is
hereby ORDERED, ADJUDGED and DECREED by this Court that the appeal be dismissed as
moot, and that the decision be certified to the court below for observance. Costs are taxed
against the party incurring same.
Brian Hoyle, Justice.
Panel consisted of Worthen, C.J., Hoyle, J., and Davis, J.
COURT OF APPEALS
TWELFTH COURT OF APPEALS DISTRICT OF TEXAS
JUDGMENT
NOVEMBER 18, 2026
NO. 12-26-00277-CV
ESTATE OF ARNOLD H. MONTES, JR., DECEASED
Appeal from the County Court at Law No 1
of Angelina County, Texas (Tr.Ct.No. 078-22-PR)
THIS CAUSE came to be heard on the appellate record and briefs filed
herein, and the same being considered, it is the opinion of this court that the dispute is moot, it is
hereby ORDERED, ADJUDGED and DECREED by this Court that the appeal be dismissed as
moot, and that the decision be certified to the court below for observance. Costs are taxed
against the party incurring same.
Brian Hoyle, Justice.
Panel consisted of Worthen, C.J., Hoyle, J., and Davis, J.