In Re BMC Texas Sales, LLC N/K/A BFS Texas Sales, LLC v. the State of Texas
CourtTexas Court of Appeals, 9th District (Beaumont)
Date FiledNovember 19, 2026
Docket09-26-00231-CV
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
In The
Court of Appeals
Ninth District of Texas at Beaumont
__________________
NO. 09-26-00231-CV
__________________
IN RE BMC TEXAS SALES, LLC N/K/A BFS TEXAS SALES, LLC
__________________________________________________________________
Original Proceeding
457th District Court of Montgomery County, Texas
Trial Cause No. 24-03-04327
__________________________________________________________________
MEMORANDUM OPINION
Relator, BMC Texas Sales, LLC n/k/a BFS Texas Sales, LLC, filed a petition
for a writ of mandamus. BMC Texas argues no valid arbitration agreement exists
between BMC Texas and Real Party in Interest, Blakecraft, LLC, and that the trial
court clearly abused its discretion by ordering BMC Texas to join the pending
arbitration between Blakecraft and the plaintiffs, Real Parties in Interest, Kelsey and
Andrew Neidert. BMC Texas asks this Court to compel the trial court to vacate: (1)
its Order denying Nonparties’ Motion to Lift Abatement and Stay Arbitration; and
(2) its Order denying BMC Texas’s Motion to Lift Abatement and Stay Arbitration,
1
which (i) compelled BMC Texas to arbitration and ordered that all claims by and
against BMC Texas be arbitrated in AAA Case Number 01-25-0002-1658, (ii)
stayed Trial Cause Number 24-03-04327, and (iii) abated all parties’ claims pending
completion of binding arbitration. We conclude BMC Texas has not shown that it
lacks an adequate legal remedy.
Blakecraft and the Neiderts entered into a residential construction contract
that included a Builder’s Warranty administered by American Construction and
Education Services, Inc. (the “ACES Limited Warranty”). The ACES Limited
Warranty contains mediation and arbitration provisions. When the Neiderts
commenced Trial Cause Number 24-03-04327 against Blakecraft, Blakecraft filed a
motion asking the trial court to abate the case pending resolution of the disputes
through mediation and, if necessary, binding arbitration. The trial court ordered the
Neiderts and Blakecraft to submit all disputes and claims between them to mediation
in accordance with the ACES Limited Warranty, and if the dispute remained
unresolved after mediation, to binding arbitration in accordance with the
Construction Industry Arbitration Rules of the American Arbitration Association.
The order abated all trial court proceedings pending completion of mediation and, if
necessary, arbitration.
The Neiderts submitted a demand for arbitration, and AAA Case Number 01-
25-0002-1658 was commenced between the Neiderts and Blakecraft. Through a
2
Request for Joinder in the AAA case, Blakecraft sought to add BMC Texas and other
vendors and subcontractors to the arbitration proceedings. In the trial court, BMC
Texas filed a non-party Motion to Lift Abatement and Stay Arbitration arguing
Blakecraft failed to prove the existence of a valid agreement to arbitrate with BMC
Texas, failed to prove the claims fall within the scope of any such agreement, and
waived any right to compel arbitration with BMC Texas. The trial court signed an
order denying BMC Texas’s motion to lift the abatement and stay the arbitration,
and then signed a second order with additional language compelling BMC Texas to
arbitrate. BMC Texas seeks a writ of mandamus with respect to both orders.
We may issue a writ of mandamus to remedy a clear abuse of discretion by
the trial court when the relator lacks an adequate remedy by appeal. See In re
Prudential Ins. Co. of Am., 148 S.W.3d 124, 135-36 (Tex. 2004) (orig. proceeding);
Walker v. Packer, 827 S.W.2d 833, 839-40 (Tex. 1992) (orig. proceeding). We
determine the adequacy of an appellate remedy by balancing the benefits of
mandamus review against the detriments, considering whether extending mandamus
relief will preserve important substantive and procedural rights from impairment or
loss. In re Team Rocket, L.P., 256 S.W.3d 257, 262 (Tex. 2008) (orig. proceeding).
BMC Texas contends the trial court abused its discretion by ordering BMC
Texas to arbitrate whatever claims Blakecraft might have against it. Blakecraft
contends BMC Texas has an adequate remedy by appeal. “If a trial court compels
3
arbitration when the parties have not agreed to it, that error can unquestionably be
reviewed by final appeal.” In re Gulf Expl., LLC, 289 S.W.3d 836, 842 (Tex.
2009). If the arbitrator exceeds its power, a statutory mechanism exists for vacating
an arbitration award. Id. Therefore, even when a petitioner can show that the trial
court clearly abused its discretion by compelling arbitration, “mandamus is generally
unavailable” because a petitioner can “rarely” show that it lacks an adequate remedy
by appeal. Id.
BMC Texas has not shown that appeal is not an adequate remedy.
Accordingly, we deny the petition for a writ of mandamus and any motion for
temporary relief. See Tex. R. App. P. 52.8(a), 52.10.
PETITION DENIED.
PER CURIAM
Submitted on September 8, 2026
Opinion Delivered November 19, 2026
Before Johnson, Wright and Chambers, JJ.
4