In the Matter of the Estate of Yolanda M. Coco v. the State of Texas
CourtTexas Court of Appeals, 9th District (Beaumont)
Date FiledNovember 19, 2026
Docket09-24-00367-CV
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
In The
Court of Appeals
Ninth District of Texas at Beaumont
________________
NO. 09-24-00367-CV
________________
IN THE MATTER OF THE ESTATE OF YOLANDA M. COCO,
DECEASED
________________________________________________________________________
On Appeal from the County Court at Law No. 1
Jefferson County, Texas
Trial Cause No. 116559
________________________________________________________________________
MEMORANDUM OPINION
Appellant Cynthia Ann Reeves (“Cyndy”), in her capacity as Independent
Executor of the Estate of Yolanda M. Coco, Deceased, appeals the trial court’s take
nothing judgment in favor of her brothers (we collectively refer to the brothers as
Appellees), Charles X. Sanchez, Oscar I. Sanchez Jr., and James O. Sanchez. In her
sole issue, Cyndy complains the trial court erred by setting aside the jury’s
conversion damages finding because she claims there is more than a scintilla of
evidence supporting the jury’s finding. We reverse the trial court’s judgment and
remand for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.
1
PERTINENT BACKGROUND CONCERNING CONVERSION DAMAGES
Cyndy, the daughter of Yolanda M. Coco (“Coco”), filed suit in her capacity
as Independent Executor of Coco’s estate against her brothers Charles X. Sanchez
(“Charlie”), James O. Sanchez (“Jimmy”), Oscar I. Sanchez Jr. (“Oscar”) and others
who are not the subject of this appeal. Coco died on November 12, 2016, and in her
suit Cyndy alleged that prior to Coco’s death, Charlie, Jimmy, and Oscar opened a
safe in Coco’s home and removed Coco’s cash, gold and silver coins, and gold
and/or platinum bullion and divided it equally among themselves. Cyndy’s causes
of action include a conversion claim, among others, and Cyndy asserted that Charlie,
Jimmy, and Oscar assumed dominion and control over the cash and gold and silver
coins in Coco’s safe to the exclusion of Coco and in violation of Coco’s will. Cyndy
maintained that Charlie, Jimmy, and Oscar are guilty of conversion which
proximately caused damages to Coco and her estate.
During trial, Cyndy testified that Coco passed away on November 12, 2016,
and Cyndy was appointed as the independent executor of Coco’s estate. Cyndy
testified that after Coco went into hospice care, Coco began taking morphine for
pain. Cyndy testified about Coco’s purchases of gold and silver coins. The record
shows Coco’s orders, payments, and invoices as follows:
• January 14, 2011 Invoice - $9,645 – (300) 1 oz. American Silver Eagle –
Invoice stamped paid
2
• January 21, 2011 Invoice - $9,904 – (320) 1 oz. American Silver Eagle –
Invoice stamped paid
• March 10, 2011 Unsigned Order Form - $399,980.10 – (127) Raw $50 GAE
for $189,230; (4,946) Raw Maple Leafs Silver for $187,206.10; (4 )$10 LOC
for $23,544
• March 10, 2011 Payment - $399,980.10 – US Rare Coin and Bullion Reserve
• March 11, 2011 Signed Order Form - $399,973.75 – (126) $50 GAE for
$187,992; (5,000) Silver Maple Leafs for $189,450; (3) 2000 $10 Lib. of
Congress for $17,658; (125) $1 SEA for $4,873.75
• March 15, 2011 Invoice - $100,430.40 – (1,422) 1 oz. Am. Eagle Silver for
$54, 320.40; (1,000) 1 oz. Am. Eagle Silver for $38,750; (5) 1 oz. Am. Eagle
Gold for $7,360 - Invoice states paid by check
• January 12, 2011 Invoice - $2,772 – (20) 2010 Silver eagle for $660; (64)
Silver Eagle for $2,112 – Invoice states paid in cash
• March 28, 2011 Invoice - $59,831.75 – Shipped (25) Common Date $50 GAE
Bullion for $37,300; (3) 2000 $10 Liberty of Congress MS69 for $17, 658;
(125) 2011 $1 Silver Amer Eagle Bullion for $4,873.75 – Invoice states over
payment deferred $340,148.35 check with order $399,980.10
• March 28, 2011 Invoice - $59,680 – Shipped (40) Common Date $50 GAE
Bullion - Invoice states overpayment applied and a credit of $6.35
• March 28, 2011 Invoice - $59,680 – Shipped (40) Common Date $50 GAE
Bullion - Invoice states overpayment applied and a credit of $6.35
• May 1, 2014 Invoice - $57,621.60 – (40) 2014 $50 American Gold Buffalo
Early Release MS70 NGC – Invoice stamped paid
Cyndy agreed that the invoices from Exhibits 6 and 7 include a total amount of
$759,536. Concerning Coco’s one purchase of $100,430 in coins, Cyndy did not
3
know how much the seller had marked up the value of the coins to make a profit or
commission.
Cyndy explained that after Coco went into hospice on July 5, 2016, she and
her siblings met and discussed Coco’s finances. Cyndy stated her brothers voted to
divide Coco’s gold and silver coins, Cyndy disagreed because Coco was still alive
and may need the coins, and Diana abstained from voting. Cyndy testified that,
without her knowledge, her brothers divided the gold and silver coins in Coco’s safe
on July 31, 2016. Cyndy testified that her brothers claimed Coco called them on the
night of July 30 and told them to come and divide the coins. The jury viewed videos
showing her brothers dividing the coins and Cyndy testified that she and her sister,
Diana, did not receive any of the coins. Cyndy did not know the fair market value of
the coins on July 31 when her brothers took the coins.
In November, Cyndy learned her brothers had taken the coins. Cyndy
explained that she obtained a safekeeping order that ordered her brothers to return
the coins. On September 29, 2017, Charlie returned 500 one-ounce Silver American
Eagle coins, and on October 2, 2017, on Jimmy’s behalf, Charlie returned 500 Silver
Canadian Maples, 16 x 20 Silver American Eagle coins, and four one-ounce Gold
American Eagle coins. The evidence showed that in September 2017, Jimmy sold
some of the coins. Cyndy did not have the receipts for the coins that Charlie and
Jimmy returned and had not tried to calculate their value from Coco’s receipts.
4
Charlie testified that after he voted to divide Coco’s coins, Coco stated she
did not want them to divide the coins that day. Charlie explained that it was his idea
for Coco to purchase gold and silver. Charlie was present when Coco made
purchases, including the purchase of $100,430 in coins, and he explained he did not
know why there was a difference in price between the two one-ounce silver coins or
how many ounces the Silver Eagles were because they come in different ounces and
it was not listed on the receipt. Concerning the roughly seven-dollar difference
between the two work order forms dated March 11, 2011, for $399,980.10 and
$399,973, Charlie stated that the form notes Coco had a $6.35 credit. Charlie did not
know whether Coco purchased any gold and silver without his assistance and had no
knowledge of her selling any gold or silver.
Charlie testified that he and his brothers took the gold and silver coins out of
Coco’s safe. Charlie did not remember how many boxes of silver coins were in the
safe but thought there were approximately ten boxes which hold 500 silver coins
each. Charlie explained that after Jimmy received a phone call from Oscar, he and
Jimmy went to Coco’s house and divided the coins. Charlie stated that Coco gave
them permission to get the coins and gave Oscar the key and combination to the safe.
Charlie testified that he had “no idea[]” of the value of the gold and silver coins he
received from Coco’s safe. Charlie explained that the price of silver at the time Coco
gave him the coins was “probably, like, $17 or $16 an ounce, half[]” of the purchase
5
price. Charlie sold some of the coins for about $50,000, and he returned 500 Silver
American Eagle coins. Charlie also returned some gold and silver on Jimmy’s
behalf.
Charlie explained that you can find the value of gold and silver on a particular
day on the internet and that “there’s always a premium over the spot price of, you
know, what they have on the market.” When asked whether he would use
information like the price of silver for the year 2016 to determine the value, Charlie
stated he would not and explained that “if I take some in and let’s say I go to
Heartfield’s or Franklin Gold and Silver, they will quote me their price[]” because
“I don’t control that. They do.” Charlie testified that “they are going to tell me what
they are going to give me for it whether I buy it or sell it.” Charlie testified that he
probably received about 500 to 700 silver coins from the safe and that he could not
determine the number or value of the coins he received by looking at the video.
Raul Morales Jr. (“Lito”), a first cousin to Coco’s children, testified that he
was told that Coco asked Charlie and Jimmy to remove “probably close to
$500,000[]” of gold and silver from the safe. Lito explained that he believed that
from conversations with Cyndy and Charlie there was supposed to be $500,000 in
gold and silver in the safe, but they never told him an exact amount. Lito testified
that Charlie told him that he had Diana’s share of the coins.
6
Diana testified that she did not believe it was right to divide Coco’s gold and
silver coins because Coco needed them to take care of herself and her finances. Diana
explained she and her siblings viewed the gold and silver in Coco’s safe. Diana
testified that after Coco died, Charlie told her that he divided the coins among the
brothers and that he had her share until she decided whose side she supported. Diana
had not received any of Coco’s gold and silver.
Prior to resting Plaintiff’s case, Cyndy’s counsel asked the trial court to admit
Plaintiff’s Exhibits 1-68, except Exhibit 54, and the trial court admitted them without
objection. Plaintiff’s Exhibit 66–Historical gold Prices–is a chart entitled “Gold –
Daily 2016” shows:
7
Plaintiff’s Exhibit 67–Historical Silver Prices– is a chart entitled “Silver –
Daily 2016” shows:
8
Plaintiff’s Exhibit 34 shows Charlie returned the following coins: 500 Silver
American Eagle coins; Mostly 1999 but other various dates; Each one-ounce silver.
Exhibit 34 shows Charlie returned the following coins on Jimmy’s behalf: 500
Canadian Maples - Silver; 16 x 20 - American Eagles coins - Silver; 4 - Gold
American Eagles - l oz. The exhibit also includes two invoices showing Jimmy sold
some of the coins.
9
After Cyndy’s counsel rested, Appellees moved for an instructed verdict on
the issue of compensatory damages based upon lack of any testimony or competent
evidence of the fair market value of the precious metal coins as of July 2016, the
date of the alleged conversion. Appellees argued the only evidence presented was
evidence of the amount Coco paid for the coins and that there was no evidence of
the value of the metals before or after July 31, 2016, the time frame when the coins
were taken.
Cyndy’s counsel argued that in an estate case, the conversion date is the date
of death–November 12, 2016–and that Plaintiff’s Exhibits 66 and 67 shows the
market value for gold and silver in 2016 and that Plaintiff’s Exhibits 6 and 7 shows
the number and type of coins Coco purchased. Cyndy’s counsel explained that “the
math is there[]” and you just had to multiply the number and type of coins by the
value as of July 31 or November 12 based upon the charts. Cyndy’s counsel argued
there was legally sufficient evidence to make the calculations and that expert
testimony was not required. Cyndy’s counsel argued that they could also prove
damages based on Lito’s testimony that the value of the coins was $500,000, which
was told to him as an admission. The trial court noted that the admission came from
“affected, interested people.”
Appellees argued that there was no evidence because no witness had offered
testimony about “any type of calculations.” The trial court expressed concern but did
10
not feel confident in granting Appellees’ motion at that time without solid legal
authority. The trial court denied Appellees’ motion and stated that it could address
the issue later after submitting it to the jury.
Jimmy testified that during the July family meeting, he proposed splitting the
gold and silver in the safe five ways. Jimmy testified that each of them would use
their share for Coco’s care and send Cyndy payments as needed. Jimmy explained
when he talked to Coco on July 30, she told him to bring Charlie and get the gold
and silver out of her safe and that “[i]t’s yours.” Jimmy testified that he and Charlie
left Dallas, and when they arrived at Coco’s house about two o’clock in the morning
on July 31, Coco again told him to get the coins out of her house and that they were
“‘yours and your bothers.’” Jimmy stated that he, Charlie, and Oscar divided the
coins five ways and intended to share them with their sisters even though Coco just
gave them to the brothers, and the jury viewed videos that the brothers made showing
the divided coins and Coco stating she agreed that the coins should be divided.
After Jimmy testified, the trial court admitted Defendants’ exhibits.
Defendants’ Exhibit 16 is the Inventory, Appraisement and List of Claims, which is
an Inventory and Appraisement of Coco’s real and personal property as of November
12, 2016, the date of Coco’s death. The Inventory, Appraisement and List of Claims
includes claims owed to Coco’s Estate, and one claim is a $350,000 debt owed by
11
the brothers for the coins they took from the safe. The $350,000 claim includes the
following coins:
1442 pieces of 1 oz. American Silver purchased
at $38.20 per coin
1000 pieces of 1 oz. American Eagle Silver purchased
at $38.75 per coin
5 pieces of 1 oz. American Eagle Gold purchased at
$1,472.00 per coin
127 pieces of RAW $50 Great American Eagle purchased at
$1,490.00 per coin
4946 pieces of RAW Maple Leaf - Silver purchased
at $37.85 per coin.
4 pieces of $10 Library of Congress purchased at $5,886 per coin
The trial court conducted a jury charge conference, during which Cyndy did
not object to the submission of Question No. 10 concerning damages for the
conversion of the gold and silver coins located in the safe. The trial court overruled
the brothers’ objection to the submission of Question No. 10 based on there being
no evidence of the fair market value of the coins on November 12, 2016. In
determining the amount of conversion damages, the jury was instructed as follows:
What sum of money, if any, if paid in cash, would fairly and reasonably
compensate the Estate of Yolanda M. Coco for its damages, if any, that
resulted from such conduct?
Consider the following elements of damages, if any, and none other.
12
“Market value” means the amount that would be paid in cash by a
willing buyer who desires to buy but is not required to buy to a willing
seller who desires to sell but is under no necessity to sell on November
12, 2016.
In answering questions about damages, answer each question
separately. Do not increase or reduce the amount in one answer because
of your answer to any other question about damages. Do not speculate
about what any party’s ultimate recovery may or may not be. Any
recovery will be determined by the court when it applies the law to your
answers at the time of judgment. Do not add any amount for interest on
damages, if any.
Answer separately, in dollars and cents, for damages, if any.
For the market value of the gold and silver located in the safe.
During closing argument, Cyndy’s counsel argued that to determine the price
of gold and silver on a particular date, the jury could refer to Exhibits 6 and 7, which
show the number and type of coins Coco purchased, and then refer to Exhibits 66
and 67 to see what the market value of gold and silver was on November 12, 2016.
Cyndy’s counsel stated, “it’s simple math. I’ve done it for you.” Cyndy’s counsel
argued that Charlie testified that he was not aware of Coco selling any of her coins,
and that the jury should give credit for the coins Charlie and Jimmy returned.
Counsel maintained that by using the exhibits as recommended, the jury’s calculated
damages should be $630,603.
The jury found that Coco gave the contents of the safe to the brothers on or
about July 30 to July 31 because of undue influence and that Coco lacked the mental
capacity to give the safe’s contents to the brothers. After being instructed that the
13
brothers converted Coco’s property if they exercised dominion and control over
Coco’s property without her consent and to the exclusion of Coco and in violation
of Coco’s will, the jury found that the brothers converted Coco’s property contained
in the safe. Regarding conversion damages–Question No. 10–the jury found that the
market value of the gold and silver located in the safe was $630,603.
Appellees filed a Motion to Disregard Jury Finding to Question No. 10
(DAMAGES), asking the trial court to enter a judgment that Cyndy take no
compensatory damages on her conversion cause of action. Appellees argued that the
evidence supporting the jury’s damage finding was legally insufficient as a matter
of law as there was a complete absence of evidence or less than a scintilla of evidence
of the fair market value of the allegedly converted coins as of November 12, 2016,
the date of Coco’s death. Appellees stated that Cyndy failed to introduce any
valuation testimony by a lay witness or an expert numismatist involving the year,
mint, grade, population, historical pricing, or other intangibles in order to adduce
competent evidence of a coin’s fair market value on any specific date.
Cyndy filed a Response to Appellees’ Motion to Disregard, arguing that the
gold and silver coins were properly valued by the price of the metals on the
commodities market on a given day. Cyndy maintained that gold and silver are
commodities and that the value of gold and silver coins is established by the value
of the metal they contain and the recognized commodities market. Cyndy stated that
14
the receipts she presented for the coins were not offered to show the value of the
coins, but the number of coins Coco owned. Cyndy testified that the value did not
come from her but from the mathematical calculation based on the number of coins
converted and the market prices of an ounce of gold and silver on November 12,
2016. Cyndy argued that even if the evidence were insufficient to show the amount
of damages the jury awarded, it was sufficient to show some damage and thus
required a new trial.
The trial court conducted a hearing on Appellees’ Motion to disregard the
jury’s finding regarding conversion damages. Appellees argued that there was no
live witness testimony about the market value of the coins as of November 12, 2016.
They noted that it was only during closing argument that Cyndy’s counsel attempted
to make a calculation for the jury by using numbers not in evidence. They also
complained that Cyndy’s exhibits that included charts tracking the value of silver
and gold did not show the fair market value and left the jury having to speculate as
to that value.
Cyndy argued that the evidence did not have to come from a live witness, she
did not need an expert to establish fair market value, and the evidence showed the
amount of gold and silver coins Coco purchased and that Coco never sold any of the
coins. Cyndy claimed that the exhibits included charts showing the prices of gold
and silver as of November 12, 2016, and the fair market value calculations were
15
based on the low-end value depicted in the charts for that date. Cyndy explained that
she used the evidence and proposed calculations based on the evidence during
closing “to tell the jury how to do damages.” Cyndy explained that in reaching the
$630,603 damage amount the jury awarded, she took the total value of the gold and
silver coins based on a conservative estimate from a range of prices for November
and December 2016–$657,186–and deducted the value of the coins that Appellees
Charlie and Jimmy returned–$8,250 and $18,350.
The trial court stated that it had expressed concern about the state of the
evidence when it considered Appellees’ motion for an instructed verdict. The trial
court could not see how the jury based its damage award on an exhibit that included
calculations Cyndy referred to during the hearing, but that was not part of the
evidence the jury considered at trial. Cyndy maintained that after the trial court
sustained Appellees’ objection to the exhibit, she explained the methodology to the
jury during closing and told them the amounts that led to the calculations. The trial
court noted that the charts Cyndy used showed three or four significant dips or drops
in value during November 2016, and Appellees objected to using the lowest price in
November 2016 as indicated by the charts because it was not the fair market value
on November 12, 2016, which is the date the jury was instructed to consider.
Appellees reiterated that Cyndy failed to present testimony and evidence of a
fair market value of the coins or even present testimony about how to use the charts,
16
and that her “mathematical gymnastics” during closing was not competent evidence.
Appellees also complained that the charts only included a range and not a spot price
of gold or silver, which did not reflect what a seller was willing to sell for on that
date. The trial court granted the motion to disregard the jury’s finding of conversion
damages and entered a take-nothing final judgment.
ANALYSIS
In her sole issue, Cyndy complains the trial court erred by setting aside the
jury’s conversion damages finding because there was more than a scintilla of
evidence supporting the finding. We agree.
Generally, a trial court must render a judgment based on a jury’s verdict in a
case; a trial court is authorized to grant a motion to disregard a jury’s verdict only if
a directed verdict on the issue would have been proper. See Tex. R. Civ. P. 301; Fort
Bend Cnty. Drainage Dist. v. Sbrusch, 818 S.W.2d 392, 394 (Tex. 1991). When a
trial court’s decision to disregard a jury’s verdict is challenged on appeal, we review
the ruling for legal sufficiency. See Shell Oil Prods. Co. v. Main St. Ventures, L.L.C.,
90 S.W.3d 375, 387 (Tex. App.—Dallas 2002, pet. dism’d). We employ the well-
settled no-evidence standard of review. City of Keller v. Wilson, 168 S.W.3d 802,
823, 827 (Tex. 2005). We view the evidence in the light most favorable to the
verdict, crediting favorable evidence if reasonable jurors could do so and
disregarding contrary evidence unless reasonable jurors could not. Id. at 827; see
17
Senegal v. Payne, No. 09-13-00508-CV, 2015 WL 4053504, at *2 (Tex. App.—
Beaumont July 2, 2015, no pet.) (mem. op.). Evidence is legally sufficient if it
“would enable reasonable and fair-minded people to reach the verdict under review.”
City of Keller, 168 S.W.3d at 827.
Generally, when the amount of what would be reasonable is disputed, a court
is not authorized to substitute its judgment and replace the jury’s assessment of the
amount of money necessary to reasonably compensate the plaintiff for its damages.
See Pope v. Moore, 711 S.W.2d 622, 623-24 (Tex. 1986). When the evidence
presents a range of possible damage awards, “an award within that range is an
appropriate exercise of the jury’s discretion, and a reviewing court is not permitted
to speculate on how the jury actually arrived at its award.” Drury Sw., Inc. v. Louie
Ledeaux #1, Inc., 350 S.W.3d 287, 292 (Tex. App.—San Antonio 2011, pet. denied);
see Wise v. SR Dallas, LLC, 436 S.W.3d 402, 411 (Tex. App.—Dallas 2014, no pet.);
Pilgrim’s Pride Corp. v. Mansfield, No. 09-13-00518-CV, 2015 WL 794908, at *9
(Tex. App.—Beaumont Feb. 26, 2015, no pet.). A jury’s findings will not be
disregarded merely because its reasoning in arriving at a figure may be unclear.
Khorshid, Inc. v. Christian, 257 S.W.3d 748, 760 (Tex. App.—Dallas 2008, no pet.).
The fact there is nothing in the record to show how the jury arrived at a specific
amount is not necessarily fatal to the verdict. Id.
18
To prove a conversion claim, a plaintiff must show: (1) the plaintiff owned,
had possession, or entitlement to possession of property; (2) the defendant
unlawfully and without authorization assumed and exercised control over the
property to the exclusion of, or inconsistent with, the plaintiff’s rights; (3) the
plaintiff demanded the property’s return; and (4) which the defendant refused.
Guillory v. Dietrich, 598 S.W.3d 284, 292 (Tex. App.—Dallas 2020, pet. denied).
The plaintiff must also show the conversion caused an injury. United Mobile
Networks, L.P. v. Deaton, 939 S.W.2d 146, 147-48 (Tex. 1997). Proof of damages
is an essential element of a party’s conversion claim. Prewitt v. Branham, 643
S.W.2d 122, 123 (Tex. 1982). Generally, the measure of conversion damages is the
fair market value of the property converted at the time and place of conversion.
Cypress Creek EMS v. Dolcefino, 548 S.W.3d 673, 685 (Tex. App.—Houston [1st
Dist.] 2018, pet. denied). Here, the parties agreed that November 12, 2016, the date
of Coco’s death, is the date upon which Cyndy’s conversion claim against Appellees
had to be valued, and that was the date included in the jury charge.
Fair market value has been defined as the price that the property would bring
when it is offered for sale by one who desires, but is not obligated to sell, and is
bought by one who is under no necessity of buying it. Burns v. Rochon, 190 S.W.3d
263, 270 (Tex. App.—Houston [1st Dist.] 2006, no pet.). A property owner may
testify to the market value of her property if her testimony shows that she is familiar
19
with the market value and her opinion is based on that market value, and not entirely
speculative. Nat. Gas Pipeline Co. of Am. v. Justiss, 397 S.W.3d 150, 155-59 (Tex.
2012); Redman Homes, Inc. v. Ivy, 920 S.W.2d 664, 669 (Tex. 1996); Henson v.
Reddin, 358 S.W.3d 428, 436 (Tex. App.—Fort Worth 2012, no pet.); Ramin’ Corp.
v. Wills, No. 09-14-00168-CV, 2015 WL 6121602, at **12-13 (Tex. App.—
Beaumont Oct. 15, 2015, no pet.) (mem. op.) (finding property owner’s testimony
that she was familiar with the fair market value of the items and she used receipts
and the internet to determine fair market value was legally sufficient to support
damage award).
In determining fair market value, courts have considered the purchase price
the owner paid, particularly when that evidence is neither objected to nor
controverted. Burns, 190 S.W.3d at 270 (citing San Antonio Pub. Serv. Co. v.
Murray, 59 S.W.2d 851, 854 (Tex. Civ. App.—Beaumont 1933), writ dism’d, 90
S.W.2d 830 (Tex. Com. App. 1936) (finding property owner’s unobjected to
testimony about purchase price legally sufficient to support conversion damage
award). Even if unchallenged, the property owner’s testimony must support the
verdict, and conclusory or speculative statements do not. DZM, Inc. v. Garren, 467
S.W.3d 700, 703 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] 2015, no pet.). A property
owner’s testimony regarding the purchase price–standing alone–is legally
insufficient to support a property’s market value at a later date. See Landmark Int.
20
Corp. v. Texmore, Inc., No. 14-23-00889-CV, 2025 WL 454223, at **1, 3-5 (Tex.
App.—Houston [14th Dist.] Feb. 11, 2025, pet. denied) (mem. op.) (finding the
summary of records, including purchase prices related to various transactions, was
legally insufficient to support damages because the summary did not establish fair
market value of the converted copper on its face and there was no explanatory
testimony of its meaning); Garren, 467 S.W.3d at 703; Lee v. Dykes, 312 S.W.3d
191, 199 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] 2010, no pet.). The property owner must
prove a factual basis on which the opinion rests. Garren, 467 S.W.3d at 703.
Value is inherent in precious metals, and gold and silver coins have intrinsic
value based on their metal content, which is the market value. See Selgas v.
Henderson Cnty. Appraisal Dist., Nos. 12-10-00021-CV, 12-10-00050-CV, 2011
WL 5593138, at *6 (Tex. App.—Tyler Nov. 16, 2011, pet. denied) (mem. op.)
(citing Bronson v. Rodes, 74 U.S. 229, 249 (1869)). That intrinsic value is
determined by weight and purity, and the “true value of coins is affected by their
market value to numismatics and the intrinsic value of the coins’ precious metal
content.” Id. (citation omitted). The United States Secretary of the Treasury is
required by statute to sell silver and gold coins minted by the federal government at
market value. Id. (citing 31 U.S.C.S. § 5112(i)(2)(A)).
In her Response to Appellees’ Motion to Disregard, Cyndy advised the trial
court that she presented the receipts in Plaintiff’s Exhibits 6 and 7 to show the
21
number of coins Coco owned and not the value, because the value did not come from
her but from the mathematical calculation based on the number of coins converted
and the market prices of an ounce of gold or silver on November 12, 2016. While
Cyndy testified that the invoices that are part of Plaintiff’s Exhibits 6 and 7 include
a total amount of $759,536, Cyndy did not offer any testimony stating that she was
familiar with the fair market value of gold and silver coins or the amount she
believed to be the fair market value of Coco’s coins on November 12, 2016. Cyndy
likewise said she did not know the fair market value of the coins on July 31, 2016,
when her brothers took the coins from the safe. That said, Cyndy filed an Inventory,
Appraisement and List of Claims showing Appellees owed Coco’s estate $350,000
for the coins they took from the safe.
Cyndy also testified that she did not try to calculate the value of the coins that
Appellees had returned, and during closing argument, her counsel asked the jury to
subtract the value of the returned coins from the total value of Coco’s coins and to
determine both values by using the charts marked as Plaintiff’s Exhibits 66 and 67.
We note that the defendants did not object to these exhibits.
Charlie testified that he would not use information such as the price of silver
for the year 2016 to determine the value of silver because buyers like Heartfield’s
and Franklin Gold and Silver control the price and would quote him the price they
would buy or sell for. Charlie testified that he did not know the exact number of
22
silver coins that were in the safe and had “no idea[]” of the value of the gold and
silver he received from Coco’s safe. Charlie explained that the price of silver at the
time Coco gave him the coins was “probably” half of the purchase price. Lito
testified that he was told that Coco asked Charlie and Jimmy to remove close to
$500,000 of gold and silver from the safe.
Based on the record before us, we conclude that there was some evidence
before the jury showing a valuation as high as $759,536 (the purchase price of the
silver and gold invoices), as low as $350,000 (the valuation of the gold and silver
provided in the probate case on the sworn inventory), and a mid-range amount of
$500,000 which is what Lito was told was the value of the items in the safe to be
divided. After reviewing all the evidence in the light most favorable to the jury’s
verdict, we conclude there is some evidence supporting the jury’s finding that
Coco’s estate suffered $630,603 in damages. We conclude that the evidence–which
includes receipts and invoices, an inventory from the estate, and testimony
concerning the amount of coins Coco owned and the charts in Plaintiff’s unobjected
to Exhibits 66 and 67 depicting the value of gold and silver on the commodities
market–was legally sufficient to support the jury’s damage award. See Justiss, 397
S.W.3d at 155-59; City of Keller, 168 S.W.3d at 810; Landmark Int. Corp., 2025
WL 454223, at **1, 3-5. Accordingly, the trial court erred by granting Appellees’
motion to disregard the jury’s finding of $630,603 in conversion damages and
23
entering a take-nothing judgment. See Garren, 467 S.W.3d at 703-05; Lee, 312
S.W.3d at 194-99; Landmark Int. Corp., 2025 WL 454223, at **3-5.
CONCLUSION
Having determined the trial court erred by setting aside and disregarding the
jury’s finding of damages in response to Question Number 10, we reverse the trial
court’s take-nothing final judgment and remand this case to the trial court for entry
of judgment consistent with this opinion.
REVERSED AND REMANDED.
JAY WRIGHT
Justice
Submitted on July 16, 2026
Opinion Delivered November 19, 2026
Before Johnson, Wright and Chambers, JJ.
24