Valley View Holdings, LLC, Palmetto Ridge Ventures, LLC, Partnership Representative, Petitioner(s)
CourtUnited States Tax Court
Date FiledNovember 19, 2026
Docket1349-23
JudgeGoeke
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
United States Tax Court
T.C. Memo. 2026-121
HARNESS ROCK, LLC,
ORNSTEIN-SCHULER, LLC, TAX MATTERS PARTNER, ET AL., 1
Petitioners
v.
COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE,
Respondent
__________
Docket Nos. 29331-21, 1209-23, Filed November 19, 2026.
1240-23, 1349-23.
__________
Michael Todd Welty, Andrew W. Steigleder, Daniel A. Rosen, Macdonald
A. Norman, Merima Mahmutbegovic, Michael B. Coverstone, Daniel B.
Wharton, Jay R. Nanavati, David W. Foster, Tiernan B. Kane, Nathaniel
S. Pollock, and Andrew M. Weiner, for petitioners.
Kelley A. Blaine, Courtney M. Hill, Ashleigh E. Edwards, Cierra C.
Harris, Andrew J. Lorenz, Jason P. Oppenheim, and Fatima Garcia, for
respondent.
MEMORANDUM FINDINGS OF FACT AND OPINION
GOEKE, Judge: These consolidated cases involve the charitable
contribution deductions claimed for conservation easements and a fee
simple interest in vacant land in rural South Carolina. The partnerships
valued the donated easements using discounted cashflow (DCF)
analyses of hypothetical aggregate quarries. The partnerships admit
1 The following cases are consolidated herewith: Static Line Resources, LLC,
Static Line Partners, LLC, Partnership Representative, Docket No. 1209-23; Upland
Resources, LLC, Upland Partners, LLC, Partnership Representative, Docket No. 1240-
23; and Valley View Holdings, LLC, Palmetto Ridge Ventures, LLC, Partnership
Representative, Docket No. 1349-23.
Served 11/19/26
2
[*2] that they purchased the properties with the intent to donate
conservation easements but specifically sought properties that would
support valuations based on their potential use as aggregate quarries.
After concessions, the following issues remain for decision: (1) the
fair market values of the easement and the fee simple interest donated
by Harness Rock, LLC (Harness Rock), and the easement donated by
Upland Resources, LLC (Upland); 2 and (2) the liability of Harness Rock,
Upland, Static Line Resources, LLC (Static Line), and Valley View
Holdings, LLC (Valley View), for section 6662 3 accuracy-related
penalties.
We hold that Harness Rock is entitled to charitable contribution
deductions of $1,035,500 for its contribution of the easement (easement
deduction) and $1,040,000 for its contribution of the fee simple interest
(fee simple deduction), and Upland is entitled to an easement deduction
of $430,500. We hold that the 40% gross valuation misstatement penalty
applies against Harness Rock and Upland with respect to their
easement deductions because they claimed deductions that exceed 200%
of the easements’ fair market values. See § 6662(a), (h). We reject
petitioners’ arguments that (1) they are entitled to a jury trial as to their
liability for section 6662 penalties and (2) they are not liable for the
penalties under the adequate disclosure exception of section
6662(d)(2)(B). See Piton Holdings, LLC v. Commissioner, No. 637-23,
167 T.C., slip op. at 50–52 (July 15, 2026); Riddle Aggregates, LLC v.
Commissioner, No. 31104-21, 165 T.C., slip op. at 8 (Dec. 15, 2025).
FINDINGS OF FACT
The following facts are derived from the pleadings, the
Stipulations of Facts with attached Exhibits, and the testimony of fact
and expert witnesses admitted into evidence at trial. The partnerships
in these consolidated cases are South Carolina limited liability
companies (LLCs) treated as partnerships for federal tax purposes.
Harness Rock is subject to the Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act
of 1982 (TEFRA), Pub. L. No. 97-248, §§ 401–407, 96 Stat. 324, 648–71.
Its tax matters partner is Ornstein-Schuler, LLC (Ornstein-Schuler).
2 Static Line and Valley View agreed to be bound by nonpenalty decisions
herein, which, after concessions, are the valuations of the donated property interests.
3 Unless otherwise indicated, statutory references are to the Internal Revenue
Code, Title 26 U.S.C., in effect at all relevant times, regulation references are to the
Code of Federal Regulations, Title 26 (Treas. Reg.), in effect at all relevant times, and
Rule references are to the Tax Court Rules of Practice and Procedure.
3
[*3] Upland, Static Line, and Valley View are subject to the Bipartisan
Budget Act of 2015 (BBA), Pub. L. No. 114-74, § 1101, 129 Stat. 584,
625–38. Their partnership representatives are Upland Partners, LLC
(Upland Partners), Static Line Partners, and Palmetto Ridge Ventures,
LLC, respectively. 4
The conservation easements at issue in these consolidated cases
were planned and implemented by Matt Ornstein and Frank Schuler
through their company, Ornstein-Schuler. From 2012–18 Messrs.
Ornstein and Schuler implemented over 100 syndicated transactions
and organized numerous nonsyndicated transactions that were internal
deals through which they and their affiliated entities claimed easement
deductions. Harness Rock’s easement transaction is an internal deal.
I. Harness Rock Easement
Harness Rock donated an easement over 798.15 acres in
Cherokee County, South Carolina (Harness Rock property), which is in
an area dominated by low-density residences, farms, and forests. Glenn
Moose owned 772.32 acres of the Harness Rock property at the time of
his death in May 2000, which he had acquired in a series of transactions
from 1957 to 1992. He passed the property to Ada, Charles, and J. Stan
Batts (Batts devisees). In addition to the inherited property, J. Stan
Batts owned 15.5 acres that he had acquired in 1998, and the Ada Batts
Revocable Trust owned 12.6 acres that Ms. Batts had acquired in 1979,
which became part of the Harness Rock property. In total the Batts
devisees and the Ada Batts Revocable Trust (Batts family) owned 800.42
acres. In the years before the easement donation, the property was used
for riding off-road vehicles.
The easement transaction was structured as follows. On May 23,
2017, Ornstein-Schuler organized Harness Rock to facilitate a
conservation easement transaction. It also organized Palmetto Ridge,
4 The parties did not stipulate, or propose, findings of fact as to the four
partnerships’ principal places of business. The parties assert that these cases are
appealable to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, absent stipulation to
the contrary. In its Petition, Harness Rock stated that its principal place of business
was in South Carolina, which would make its case appealable to the U.S. Court of
Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, absent stipulation to the contrary. See § 7482(b)(1)(E).
In their Petitions, Upland, Static Line, and Valley View asserted their principal places
of business were in Georgia, which would make their cases appealable to the Eleventh
Circuit, absent stipulation to the contrary. We perceive that the relevant law is the
same in either circuit and, thus, do not need to determine which court of appeals would
have jurisdiction over an appeal in these cases.
4
[*4] which is affiliated with, and/or owned, directly or indirectly, by
Ornstein-Schuler, Messrs. Ornstein and Schuler, and/or Ornstein-
Schuler employees (Ornstein-Schuler affiliated entities).
On June 9, 2017, the Batts devisees entered into a purchase
agreement to sell a 98% membership interest in Harness Rock to
Palmetto Ridge for $1,825,000. On October 29, 2017, the purchase
agreement was amended to include the Ada Batts Revocable Trust as a
seller. 5 Ornstein-Schuler engaged ECS Southeast, LLP (ECS), to
perform a preliminary geotechnical exploration of the property and
Marvin Blethen to prepare a prefeasibility study and business plan for
a quarry on the property. ECS had four core holes drilled and tested the
extracted subsurface material for its suitability for construction grade
aggregate. ECS prepared a phase I environmental site assessment
report dated August 31, 2017, and a geotechnical report dated October
11, 2017, concluding that the tested subsurface rock was suitable for
general construction and met the South Carolina Department of
Transportation (DOT) standards for coarse aggregate suitable for road
construction. Mr. Blethen concluded, in a report dated November 29,
2017, that the property contained approximately 42.5 million tons of
minable aggregate that is suitable for general construction and meets
the South Carolina and North Carolina DOT standards for use in road
construction. He performed a DCF analysis of 15 years of quarry
operations and determined that the mine had a net present value of
$49.9 million.
On November 3, 2017, the Batts family transferred 800.42 acres
to Harness Rock in exchange for a 100% ownership interest. On
November 6, 2017, the family transferred a 98% interest to Palmetto
Ridge for $1,825,000 pursuant to the June 9, 2017, purchase agreement,
as amended. The Batts family retained a 2% interest. That same day
Palmetto Ridge distributed the 98% interest to other Ornstein-Schuler
affiliated entities.
On December 22, 2017, Harness Rock donated a conservation
easement over 798.15 acres of the property to the Heritage Preservation
Trust, Inc. (Heritage Trust), for the protection of a watershed area and
the preservation of open space, including farmland and forest land, for
scenic enjoyment of the public or pursuant to a clearly delineated
5 It is unclear from the record when the Batts family acquired their interests
in Harness Rock or whether they owned the interests when they entered the purchase
agreement.
5
[*5] governmental conservation policy. On December 27, 2017, it
donated its fee simple interest in the 798.15 acres to Heritage
Preservation Holdings, LLC (Heritage Holdings). 6 There is no evidence
in the record that the members of Harness Rock voted on whether to
conserve the property or to develop a quarry.
Harness Rock retained Clayton Weibel and Lucus Von Esh to
appraise the easement. Ornstein-Schuler regularly engaged Mr. Weibel
as an appraiser in its syndicated conservation easement transactions.
Messrs. Weibel and Von Esh opined that the value of the unencumbered
property was $49,810,000 (before value) and the value of the
encumbered property (after value) was $1,040,000, yielding a fair
market value for the easement of $48,770,000. They determined the fair
market value of the donated fee simple interest was $1,040,000. In their
analysis, the appraisers did not consider the $1,825,000 paid to the
Batts family for the 98% interest in Harness Rock.
Harness Rock timely filed a partnership return for its 2017
taxable year and claimed an easement deduction of $48,770,000 and a
fee simple deduction of $1,040,000. 7 It attached Form 8886, Reportable
Transaction Disclosure Statement, to its return, disclosing that it
engaged in a conservation easement transaction that is a reportable
transaction listed in I.R.S. Notice 2017-10, 2017-4 I.R.B. 544. It
subsequently filed an amended return. On August 6, 2021, respondent
issued a Notice of Final Partnership Administrative Adjustment (FPAA)
to Harness Rock for 2017 disallowing the easement deduction in its
entirety and allowing a fee simple deduction of $1,166,500. He also
asserted alternative section 6662 penalties for a gross valuation
misstatement, a substantial valuation misstatement, negligence or
disregard of rules or regulations, and a substantial understatement of
income tax. 8
6 In early December 2017 Harness Rock transferred 2.27 acres in two
transactions unrelated to the deductions at issue here.
7 The valuation dates for Harness Rock’s and Upland’s donated property
interests are December 22, 2017, and December 26, 2018, respectively (valuation
dates). For convenience, we sometimes refer to valuation years, 2017 and 2018,
respectively.
8 Respondent has conceded the section 6662A reportable transaction penalties
he asserted against the four partnerships in these consolidated cases. He has satisfied
the section 6751(b) written supervisory approval requirements for the remaining
penalties with respect to all four partnerships. See Order (Aug. 4, 2025).
6
[*6] Respondent has conceded that Harness Rock is entitled to an
easement deduction equal to the easement’s fair market value and
presented expert testimony that the fair market value is $718,500.
Petitioners presented expert testimony that the easement’s fair market
value is $38.9 million, conceding approximately $9,870,000 of the
easement deduction reported on Harness Rock’s 2017 return.
II. Upland Easement
Upland donated an easement over 204.97 acres of wooded land in
southern Cherokee County on the border of Union County, South
Carolina. The land was originally owned by Bruce Randolph and his
wife, who acquired 665.48 acres of contiguous land in the following three
purchases for $1,102,500.
Acquisition date Acreage Total price Price per acre
03/23/2005 597.92 $907,500 $1,518
09/17/2009 5.91 10,000 1,692
03/02/2017 61.65 185,000 3,001
On May 1, 2017, Ornstein-Schuler organized Static Line to
facilitate conservation easement transactions. On October 5, 2018, Mr.
Randolph entered into a purchase agreement to sell a 98% interest in
Static Line to Palmetto Ridge for $3.4 million. On October 15, 2018,
Ornstein-Schuler organized Upland and Valley View. On November 16,
2018, Mr. and Mrs. Randolph executed Static Line’s operating
agreement, which stated their ownership as 99.5% and 0.5%,
respectively. It is unclear from the record when Mr. and Mrs. Randolph
acquired their interests.
On November 19, 2018, Mr. Randolph transferred 646.03 acres of
the Randolph property to Static Line and retained 19.45 acres. The next
day Mr. Randolph sold a 98% interest in Static Line to Palmetto Ridge
for $3.4 million pursuant to the purchase agreement. Mr. and Mrs.
Randolph retained interests of 1.5% and 0.5%, respectively. That same
day Static Line entered into consulting agreements with Ornstein-
Schuler Group, LLC, and Ecoventures, LLC, for investment and
conservation donation strategies, respectively, and engaged ECS to
perform preliminary geotechnical exploration. ECS had two core holes
drilled on the property and tested the subsurface material samples.
7
[*7] On December 3, 2018, Static Line transferred 204.97 acres of the
Randolph property to Upland (Upland property) and 152.34 acres to
Valley View (Valley View property) in exchange for membership
interests. Static Line retained 288.72 acres (Static Line property). By
dividing the Randolph property into three parcels, Ornstein-Schuler
could implement three easement transactions, increasing the number of
investors while limiting the investors in each transaction. The transfer
tax affidavit for the 204.97 acres transferred to Upland listed the land’s
fair market value as $1,078,739, which approximately equals the portion
of the $3.4 million purchase price allocable to the land transferred to
Upland.
On December 4, 2018, Static Line distributed a 98% membership
interest in Upland to Palmetto Ridge, a 1.5% interest to Mr. Randolph,
and a 0.5% interest to Mrs. Randolph. On December 5, 2018, Ornstein-
Schuler issued a private offering for 965 membership units in Upland
Partners to prospective investors for $9,650,000. 9 The summary of the
offering stated that Upland Partners would use the proceeds raised in
the offering to acquire a 98% membership interest in Upland and
explained that Upland owned land over which investors could grant a
conservation easement and obtain a charitable contribution deduction
for the easement’s fair market value. The offering summary included an
appraisal valuing a potential easement at $78,780,000.
On November 30, 2018, ECS completed a phase I environmental
site assessment report, and on December 17, 2018, it completed a
geotechnical exploration report. ECS concluded that the tested
subsurface rock is suitable for general construction and met the South
Carolina DOT standards for coarse aggregate suitable for road
construction. On December 8, 2018, Kristina Sorenson, a wildlife
biologist, completed a baseline report documenting the impact of a
conservation easement on the property. On December 18, 2018, Mr.
Blethen completed a prefeasibility study and business plan for a quarry
on the property.
On December 19, 2018, Palmetto Ridge distributed its 98%
interests in Upland to three Ornstein-Schuler affiliated entities as
follows: 48.995% each to Toft Holdings, LLC, and Province Holdings,
9 The parties did not indicate the amount raised in the offering or the number
of units sold. On Form 1065, U.S. Return of Partnership Income, Schedule M–2,
Analysis of Partners’ Capital Accounts, Upland reported “purchase of LLC interest” of
$7,948,900.
8
[*8] LLC, and 0.01% to Ornstein-Schuler. 10 That same day the three
entities entered into an agreement to sell their interests to Upland
Partners. The sale occurred on December 24, 2018, for $7,973,900.
Between December 20 and 25, 2018, the members of Upland
Partners voted to grant a conservation easement. On December 26,
2018, Upland granted the easement to Heritage Trust for the protection
of relatively natural habitat and the preservation of open space,
including farmland and forest land, for scenic enjoyment of the public or
pursuant to a clearly delineated governmental conservation policy. Rick
and Douglas Kenny appraised the easement. They opined that the
highest and best use of the unencumbered property was aggregate
mining and valued the unencumbered property at $79,230,000 on the
basis of a DCF analysis of a hypothetical quarry. They opined that the
property’s after value was $450,000, resulting in a fair market value for
the easement of $78,780,000. Upland timely filed a partnership return
for 2018 and claimed an easement deduction of $78,780,000. It attached
Form 8886 to its return disclosing that it engaged in a conservation
easement transaction that is a reportable transaction listed in Notice
2017-10.
On January 13, 2023, respondent issued a Notice of Final
Partnership Adjustment (FPA) to Upland for 2018, disallowing the
easement deduction in its entirety. He also determined alternative
section 6662 penalties for a gross valuation misstatement, substantial
valuation misstatement, negligence or disregard of rules or regulations,
and a substantial understatement of income tax. Respondent has
conceded that Upland is entitled to deduct the easement’s fair market
value, which his expert determined is $430,500. Petitioners presented
an expert who valued the easement at $25,885,000, conceding
approximately $52.9 million of the easement deduction reported on
Upland’s 2018 return.
III. Static Line and Valley View Contributions
On December 18, 2018, Valley View donated a fee simple interest
in the 152.34-acre Valley View property to Heritage Holdings and
claimed a fee simple deduction of $79,280,000 on its 2018 return. On
December 27, 2018, Static Line donated a conservation easement over
the 288.72-acre Static Line property to Heritage Trust and claimed an
10 That same day Palmetto Ridge also distributed interests in Static Line to
these same three entities in the same percentages.
9
[*9] easement deduction of $78,560,000 on its 2018 return. Combined,
the three partnerships claimed charitable contribution deductions for
the donated property interests of over $236 million for the donated
property interests involving the Randolph property.
On January 13, 2023, respondent issued FPAs to Valley View and
Static Line for their 2018 taxable years disallowing their charitable
contribution deductions in their entirety. Respondent has conceded that
Static Line and Valley View are entitled to deduct the fair market values
of their contributions. Static Line and Valley View agreed to be bound
by the Court’s determinations of the fair market values of Harness
Rock’s and Upland’s easements for the amounts of their deductions.
IV. Overview of Easement Properties and the Aggregate Markets
The predominant land use in Cherokee County is low-density
residential homesites and farmland. Both properties are within the
Piedmont physiographic region, a region with geologic formations
containing documented granite deposits. In other words, they are in
areas known to be underlain by rocks suitable for use as aggregate.
Cherokee County does not have zoning laws or land-use restrictions that
prohibit operation of quarries. Quarries are legally permissible uses of
the properties although land development regulations require permits
to operate quarries and can impose limitations on the land’s use as
quarries. Both properties contain wetlands and designated flood areas
that could trigger additional permitting requirements for issues such as
discharge of dredged or fill material.
Aggregate markets are generally limited to the areas surrounding
the quarries because buyers pay transportation costs based on tons per
mile. As a result, aggregate is generally purchased from quarries close
to where it is used. According to expert testimony, approximately 90%
of aggregate is consumed within 50 miles of where it is mined because
of transportation costs. The experts agreed that population centers and
areas of population growth are key factors in aggregate demand. The
population of Cherokee County grew slowly from 2012 to the valuation
years. Most of the growth was concentrated near Gaffney. The Harness
Rock and the Upland properties are approximately 7 and 17 miles,
respectively, from downtown Gaffney. Nearby Spartanburg County has
a large population and had population growth of approximately 1%
annually in the years preceding the valuation years. The Harness Rock
and Upland properties are approximately 22 and 25 miles, respectively,
from downtown Spartanburg.
10
[*10] V. Experts
The parties engaged mining and valuation experts to assist with
the valuation of the easements. Both parties’ experts used the before-
and-after method of valuation. Petitioners’ experts used the DCF
method to determine the before value, and respondent’s expert used the
comparable sales method. 11
A. Petitioners’ Experts
Petitioners presented three experts: (1) Gregory Gold, an expert
in mineral valuation with experience in managing quarries; (2) Michael
Minix, a valuation expert; and (3) Darrell Chodorow, a valuation expert.
1. Mr. Gold
Mr. Gold estimated that the Harness Rock and Upland properties
contained approximately 103 and 44.9 million tons of economically
minable aggregate and valued the reserves at $70.7–$83.4 million and
$58.7–$69.8 million, respectively. He prepared 30-year mining plans
projecting sales of 24.5 million tons for Harness Rock and 20.9 million
tons for Upland. He determined that each quarry could serve a market
encompassing a 30-mile radius of the property (30-mile market) and
testified that aggregate demand increased significantly in each quarry’s
market in the years preceding the valuation dates. He estimated annual
aggregate demand in Harness Rock’s and Upland’s markets of
approximately 9.2 million and 6.2 million tons, respectively, in the
valuation years. Mr. Gold’s use of countywide demand may have
overstated demand in the 30-mile market because he may have included
demand beyond 30 miles.
He then assigned market capture percentages for each county at
least partially in the markets ranging from 0% to 40%, which he used to
project Harness Rock’s and Upland’s annual sales of 555,465 and
504,466 tons, respectively, representing approximately 6% and 8% of
total market demand. 12 His mining plans initially projected sales below
those amounts in the beginning years but increased sales to reach the
11 The before-and-after method determines the fair market values of the
property before and after the easement’s grant. The difference between the two values
is the fair market value of the easement. Treas. Reg. § 1.170A-14(h)(3)(i) and (ii).
12 Mr. Gold’s report for Upland contains unexplained math errors. His figures
for Upland’s share of market demand add to 410,973 tons.
11
[*11] projected sales by year 5 or 6 and assumed continued annual
growth thereafter.
To perform his DCF analyses, Mr. Gold estimated pricing and
capital, operating, and labor costs and applied a 10% discount rate. He
performed sensitivity analyses and concluded that analyzed variations
in his inputs and assumptions would not materially affect his
conclusions and that the quarries would retain positive net present
values.
2. Mr. Minix
Mr. Minix opined that mining was the highest and best use of the
properties before the grants of the easements. Relying on Mr. Gold’s
mining plans, costs, and pricing, with some modifications, he performed
DCF analyses of hypothetical quarries, concluding the quarries could
have earned a profit in three years. He determined the fair market
values of the Harness Rock and Upland properties were $40.9 million
($51,244 per acre) and $26.5 million ($129,287 per acre), respectively.
He applied higher discount rates than Mr. Gold, 15% and 15.5% for
Harness Rock and Upland, respectively.
Mr. Minix increased the market size to 50 road miles but
projected lower aggregate sales over 30 years than Mr. Gold determined,
approximately 20.6 and 15.6 million tons for Harness Rock and Upland,
respectively. Mr. Minix analyzed demand based on statewide historical
demand from 2009–17 for Harness Rock and 2009–18 for Upland. He
testified that statewide demand per person trended upwards during the
historical periods in both North and South Carolina, although he
acknowledged historical demand fluctuated. He further analyzed
historical demand relative to population growth and the issuance of
single-family building permits, finding a strong correlation to both
measures. 13 He determined that the majority of demand for each quarry
would have come from South Carolina and placed more weight on its
historical data than North Carolina’s (75% v. 25% for Harness Rock and
80% v. 20% for Upland). He estimated that both markets had demand
of 4.8 to 5.2 million tons in the valuation years. Without access to
production data from existing quarries, which was not publicly
available, he estimated market supply at between 3.5 and 4.4 million
13 Mr. Minix testified that he used statewide data because aggregate
consumption data were not available at the county level.
12
[*12] tons and opined that 4 million tons was a reasonable estimate. 14
Thus, Mr. Minix calculated that there was unmet market demand of
800,000 to 1.2 million tons in both markets.
Mr. Minix opined that after the easements’ grants, the highest
and best use of the Harness Rock property was two homesites with
agricultural and recreational use, and of Upland, recreation. To
determine the after values, he used the comparable sales method and
identified the same five South Carolina properties as comparables for
both properties: four sales of vacant, unencumbered land that sold for
$2,384–$3,806 per acre between March 2017 and July 2018 and one sale
of land encumbered by a conservation easement that sold for $2,250 per
acre in September 2014. He determined after values for the Harness
Rock and Upland properties of $2 million ($2,505 per acre) and $615,000
($3,000 per acre), respectively, resulting in fair market values for the
easements of $38,900,000 and $25,885,000, respectively.
3. Mr. Chodorow
Mr. Chodorow opined on valuation principles and the use of the
DCF method to value vacant land but did not value the easement
properties. At petitioners’ request, he addressed five issues: (1) whether
the DCF method can reliably value undeveloped land based on an
income-generating activity; he concluded it is a sound method if future
cashflows and risks can be reasonably forecasted. He testified that both
academics and practitioners use the DCF method for land valuations
and opined that the DCF method can be superior to the comparable sales
method when valuing land with favorable results from geological
exploration; (2) whether the DCF method is limited to valuing going-
concern businesses; which he concluded it is not because it can also
determine the residual land value; (3) whether a quarry operator could
earn a profit after purchasing the land for its net present value; he
concluded the operator could; (4) the appropriate discount rate for
quarries on the Harness Rock and Upland properties; he determined
were 6.7% and 7.3%, respectively; and (5) whether land value depends
on whether a quarry is owner-operated or leased; which he concluded it
does not because land value is derived from the property’s physical
characteristics and market conditions rather than a quarry’s operating
14 Mr. Minix acknowledged that the easement properties’ markets do not
perfectly coincide with the markets served by existing quarries and testified that
demand in Harness Rock’s and Upland’s markets could have been supplied, in part by
quarries outside their 50-road-mile markets, while quarries with Harness Rock’s and
Upland’s markets could have sold aggregate outside their markets.
13
[*13] structure. He explained that the operational structure allocates
financial and operational risks differently but does not impact land
value. However, he admitted that a small operator would have a
significant disadvantage in developing and operating a quarry.
B. Respondent’s Experts
Respondent presented two experts: Abner Patton, a licensed
geologist, and Leslie Sellers, a real estate valuation expert who prepared
valuations and rebuttals of Mr. Minix’s reports.
1. Mr. Patton
Respondent did not rely on most of Mr. Patton’s testimony
because of issues with the population data he used. Mr. Patton
determined that quarries could potentially operate on the properties
based on the known presence of subsurface aggregate. However, he
expressed concerns about a quarry on the Harness Rock property
because it was surrounded by more than 60 residences, raising concerns
about community opposition.
2. Mr. Sellers
Mr. Sellers determined that the highest and best use of the
unencumbered Harness Rock property was several small-acreage
homesites with supporting agriculture, recreation, and timber. For the
Upland property, he determined the highest and best use was one
residential homesite with supporting agriculture, recreation, and
timber. He opined that quarries were not the highest and best use
because they were not financially feasible. He determined that the
Harness Rock property’s highest and best use after the easement’s grant
is three homesites with accessory buildings, timber, limited agriculture,
and passive recreation, and Upland’s is recreation, timber, and limited
agriculture.
Mr. Sellers used the comparable sales method to determine both
the before and after values. He testified that comparable sales
(comparables) indicate that nearby land was primarily used for rural,
low-density homesites. For the before valuations, he identified
comparables in Cherokee County that are used for low-density
homesites and recreation and are in areas geologically mapped for
apparent aggregate resources, have similar geological subsoil, and are
classified as greenfield, with verified mineral rights. He considered
differences in market conditions, location, road frontage, size,
14
[*14] topography, and utilities between the easement properties and
comparables. For the Harness Rock property, he identified three
comparables that sold for $1,986–$2,929 per acre, which he adjusted to
$2,296–$2,806 to account for improvements and the time between the
comparable sales and the valuation dates (time differences). For
Upland, he identified five comparables that sold for $1,700–$3,550 per
acre, adjusting the prices to $1,767–$3,955 to account for time
differences. He opined that the Harness Rock and Upland properties had
before values of $2,075,500 and $615,000 ($2,600 and $3,000 per acre),
respectively. We discuss the comparables in more detail below.
For the after valuations, Mr. Sellers identified three comparables
of encumbered land in Georgia that sold for $997–$1,494 per acre from
April 2013 to December 2016. He adjusted the prices to $1,028–$1,706
per acre for Harness Rock and $1,058–$1,233 per acre for Upland to
account for time differences. He opined that the April 2013 sale for
$1,494 per acre (adjusted price of $1,706 per acre) was the most similar
to the Harness Rock property, and for Upland, he opined that all three
comparables were superior. He determined that the Harness Rock and
Upland properties had after values of $1,357,000 and $184,500 ($1,700
and $900 per acre), respectively, resulting in fair market values for the
easements of $718,500 and $430,500, respectively.
Mr. Sellers also reviewed Mr. Minix’s valuations and opined that
Mr. Minix valued speculative going concerns rather than land. Mr.
Sellers testified that Mr. Minix misapplied the DCF approach by relying
on speculative information, making unrealistic and unsupported
assumptions, and “improperly integrat[ing] components of personal
property, business enterprise value, and intangible assets.” Mr. Sellers
testified that Mr. Minix used valuation methods that are “not recognized
by the real estate appraisal profession” and did not comply with the
professional standards set forth in the Uniform Standards of
Professional Appraisal Practice.
OPINION
I. Burden of Proof
The IRS’s determinations in an FPAA or an FPA are generally
presumed correct, and taxpayers bear the burden to prove them
erroneous by a preponderance of the evidence. Rule 142(a); see also
Welch v. Helvering, 290 U.S. 111, 115 (1933); Piton Holdings, 167 T.C.,
slip op. at 22; Crescent Holdings, LLC v. Commissioner, 141 T.C. 477,
15
[*15] 485 (2013). Deductions are a matter of legislative grace, and
taxpayers have the burden of proving that they are entitled to any
deductions claimed. INDOPCO, Inc. v. Commissioner, 503 U.S. 79, 84
(1992). Section 7491(a) provides that if, in any court proceeding, a
taxpayer introduces credible evidence with respect to any factual issue
relevant to ascertaining the taxpayer’s liability for income tax and meets
other prerequisites, the Commissioner shall have the burden of proof
with respect to that issue. See Higbee v. Commissioner, 116 T.C. 438,
440–41 (2001).
Petitioners argue that we should shift the burden of proof to
respondent in these consolidated cases with respect to the fair market
values of the donated property interests. We need not decide whether
the burden has shifted to respondent under section 7491 because the
parties have provided sufficient evidence to enable us to decide all issues
by a preponderance of the evidence. See Knudsen v. Commissioner, 131
T.C. 185, 189 (2008), supplementing T.C. Memo. 2007-340; see also
Geiger v. Commissioner, 279 F. App’x 834, 835 (11th Cir. 2008) (“[T]he
burden is of practical consequence only in the rare event of an
evidentiary tie.”), aff’g T.C. Memo. 2006-271. There are no evidentiary
ties in these cases, and we decide the issues on the weight of the
evidence. See, e.g., Esgar Corp. v. Commissioner, 744 F.3d 648, 653–54
(10th Cir. 2014), aff’g T.C. Memo. 2012-35, and aff’g Tempel v.
Commissioner, 136 T.C. 341 (2011).
II. Valuation Principles
Section 170(a)(1) allows taxpayers to deduct the fair market
values of charitable contributions of property. Treasury Regulation
§ 1.170A-1(c)(2) defines fair market value as “the price at which the
property would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing
seller, neither being under any compulsion to buy or sell and both having
reasonable knowledge of relevant facts.” The fair market value of
property on a given date is a question of fact to be resolved on the basis
of the entire record. Kaplan v. Commissioner, 43 T.C. 663, 665 (1965);
see Palmer Ranch Holdings Ltd. v. Commissioner, 812 F.3d 982, 993–94
(11th Cir. 2016) (stating that the method of valuation is a question of
law and the determination of fair market value is a mixed question of
fact and law), aff’g in part, rev’g in part and remanding T.C. Memo.
2014-79. We evaluate expert valuation in the light of the expert’s
qualifications and evidence in the record. See Parker v. Commissioner,
86 T.C. 547, 561 (1986). We are not bound by an expert’s opinion and
may accept it in its entirety or accept the parts that we find reliable. See
16
[*16] Savannah Shoals, LLC v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2024-35,
at *35, aff’d, 182 F.4th 1314 (11th Cir. 2026); Oconee Landing Prop.,
LLC v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2024-25, at *58, supplemented by T.C.
Memo. 2024-73. We may determine a fair market value based on our
own examination of the evidence in the record. Savannah Shoals, T.C.
Memo. 2024-35, at *35.
Market prices typically do not exist for conservation easements.
See Symington v. Commissioner, 87 T.C. 892, 895 (1986); Excelsior
Aggregates, LLC v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2024-60, at *30.
Accordingly, the courts value easements by calculating the fair market
value of the property before and after the easement was granted. See
Treas. Reg. § 1.170A-14(h)(3)(i); see also TOT Prop. Holdings, LLC v.
Commissioner, 1 F.4th 1354, 1369 (11th Cir. 2021).
III. Highest and Best Use
Fair market value depends, in part, on the property’s highest and
best use. See Treas. Reg. § 1.170A-14(h)(3)(ii); see also Savannah Shoals,
LLC v. Commissioner, 182 F.4th at 1327; TOT Prop. Holdings, LLC v.
Commissioner, 1 F.4th at 1369. Courts presume that a property’s
current use is its highest and best use unless the landowner shows that
a different use is reasonably probable within the “reasonably foreseeable
future,” not merely “within the realm of possibility.” United States v.
69.1 Acres of Land, 942 F.2d 290, 292 (4th Cir. 1991) (quoting Olson v.
United States, 292 U.S. 246, 257 (1934)); see, e.g., United States v. L.E.
Cooke Co., 991 F.2d 336, 341 (6th Cir. 1993); United States v. Buhler,
305 F.2d 319, 328 (5th Cir. 1962); Paul-Adams Quarry Tr., LLC v.
Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2025-112, at *41–42; Beaverdam Creek
Holdings, LLC v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2025-53, at *40. We apply
this presumption “[b]ecause property owners have an economic
incentive to put their land to its most productive use.” Ranch Springs,
LLC v. Commissioner, 164 T.C. 93, 136 (2025).
A property’s highest and best use must be a reasonably probable
use for which the property is adaptable and needed or likely to be needed
in the reasonably near future. Savannah Shoals, LLC v. Commissioner,
182 F.4th at 1328; see also Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC v. 9.89 Acres
of Land, 127 F.4th 4