In Re: N.J.B., Appeal of: B.B.
CourtSuperior Court of Pennsylvania
Date FiledNovember 19, 2026
Docket448 WDA 2026
JudgeStabile
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
J-S30002-26
NON-PRECEDENTIAL DECISION - SEE SUPERIOR COURT O.P. 65.37
IN RE: N.J.B., A MINOR : IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF
: PENNSYLVANIA
:
APPEAL OF: B.B., FATHER :
:
:
:
:
: No. 448 WDA 2026
Appeal from the Decree Entered March 13, 2026
In the Court of Common Pleas of Beaver County
Orphans' Court at No: 3012-2025
BEFORE: STABILE, J., LANE, J., and BENDER, P.J.E.
MEMORANDUM BY STABILE, J.: FILED: November 19, 2026
B.B. (“Father”) appeals from the March 13, 2026, decree which
involuntarily terminated his parental rights to his daughter, N.J.B. (“Child”),
born in October 2023.1 We affirm.
We gather the relevant factual and procedural history of these
proceedings from the certified record. In October 2023, Beaver County
Children and Youth Services (“CYS” or “the Agency”) received a report alleging
that Child and Mother had both tested positive for fentanyl and marijuana at
the time of Child’s birth. See N.T., 10/14/25, at 19. At this time, Father was
____________________________________________
1 On the same date, by separate decree, the orphans’ court terminated the
parental rights of Child’s mother, M.S. (“Mother”) (collectively with Father,
“Parents”). Mother filed a notice of appeal which we address in a separate
memorandum.
J-S30002-26
participating in a drug and alcohol program due to his addiction to fentanyl.
See id. at 19-20.
CYS implemented a safety plan wherein Child initially remained in
Parents’ care. See id. In pertinent part, the Agency requested that Father
continue his drug and alcohol treatment and submit to monthly drug screens.2
See id. at 19-20, 64.
Between October 2023, and June 2024, Father was enrolled in
substance abuse treatment and appeared for monthly drug screens. See id.
at 19-20. The certified record reflects, however, that he was unsuccessful at
addressing his problems with addiction. Specifically, Father admitted that, in
January 2023, he began abusing suboxone that was prescribed to him as part
of his treatment regimen. See N.T., 9/23/25, at 72. Furthermore, Father
tested positive for fentanyl in February 2024. See id. at 73.
On June 7, 2024, Child, then eight months old, nearly drowned while
being bathed by Parents. See N.T., 10/14/25, at 17. Parents called 911, and
Child was ultimately “life-flighted” to Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh
(“CHOP”) where she also tested positive for fentanyl and xylazine. Id. at 17.
The accident was categorized as a near-fatality. See id.
____________________________________________
2 At this time, a dependency case existed in Allegheny County with respect to
Father's older son, K.D.B. Father's parental rights to K.D.B. were involuntarily
terminated on June 23, 2025. See Int. of M.B., 354 A.3d 524, at *7 (Pa.
Super. 2026) (unpublished memorandum) (affirming the involuntary
termination of Father’s parental rights to K.D.B.).
-2-
J-S30002-26
We note that Parents’ explanation for what caused Child to nearly drown
has changed over time. In addition, Parents never provided an explanation
for how Child had consumed fentanyl and xylazine. See N.T., 12/12/25, at
141-42; N.T., 10/14/25, at 18, 34-35; N.T., 9/23/25, at 72-73. Further, the
record reveals that, at the time of Child’s near-fatality, Father was on parole
in Allegheny County stemming from a prior conviction for endangering the
welfare of children (“EWOC”) with respect to another biological child, R.B.,
who is not in his custody or directly implicated in these proceedings.
On June 10, 2024, the juvenile court placed Child in the emergency
protective custody of CYS. On June 13, 2024, following a shelter care hearing,
the court maintained the legal and physical custody of Child with CYS. The
record reveals that CYS also filed a dependency petition and a motion seeking
a finding of aggravated circumstances in June 2024. In July 2024, Father
again tested positive for fentanyl, and, thereafter, he revoked the Agency’s
authorization to view the records from the screening provider. See id. at 73-
74. On August 29, 2024, Father was arrested and charged in Beaver County
with a separate count of EWOC in connection with Child’s near-fatality. See
N.T., 10/14/25, at 21; N.T., 9/23/25, at 88.
Following hearings in Child’s dependency case, by order dated
September 30, 2024, the court adjudicated Child dependent and determined
that Child was a victim of child abuse as defined by 23 Pa.C.S.A. § 6303. By
separate order, the court found that aggravated circumstances existed as to
-3-
J-S30002-26
Parents and stated that “[n]o efforts are to be made to preserve the family
and reunify Child with [Parents].” Aggravated Circumstances Order, 10/2/24;
see also 42 Pa.C.S.A. §§ 6341(c.1), 6302.
Nevertheless, the record reveals that, in late October 2024, the juvenile
court issued a permanency review order that established Child’s permanency
goal as reunification with a concurrent goal of adoption and directed CYS to
resume providing reunification services to Father. In furtherance of
reunification, the juvenile court ordered Father to, inter alia: undergo a drug
and alcohol evaluation and comply with all resulting recommendations and
attend supervised visitations with Child.
In July 2025, Father entered a guilty plea to the Beaver County EWOC
charge. See N.T., 9/23/25, at 88, 91. The criminal court sentenced Father
to one year less one day to two years less one day of incarceration, followed
by four years of probation. See id. at 82. Father remained incarcerated in
Beaver County Jail through the completion of the subject termination
hearings, with an anticipated release date of April 2026. See id. at 90.
However, the record does not reveal what Father’s potential sentence may be
regarding his still-pending parole violation in Allegheny County. See N.T.,
10/14/25, at 46.
Regarding his permanency goals, as noted above, Father was unable to
maintain sobriety or address his problems with substance abuse prior to his
incarceration in August 2024. However, the parties do not dispute that Father
-4-
J-S30002-26
was maintaining his sobriety in the cloistered environment of prison. See
N.T., 12/12/25, at 24-25. With respect to supervised visitation, visits
occurred for one hour on alternating weeks at Beaver County Jail. See N.T.,
9/23/25, at 107.
On June 16, 2025, CYS filed a petition to involuntarily terminate Father’s
parental rights to Child pursuant to 23 Pa.C.S.A. § 2511(a)(1), (2), (5), and
(b). In compliance with Section 2313(a) of the Adoption Act, the orphans’
court appointed legal interest counsel for Child.3 The orphans’ court also
appointed a separate guardian ad litem (“GAL”) to represent Child’s best
interests. Contemporaneously in July 2025, the juvenile court entered an
order that changed Child’s permanency goal to adoption, which Father did not
appeal.
The orphans’ court conducted termination hearings on September 23,
October 14, and December 12, 2025, at which time Child was two years old.
The Agency presented the testimony of Ms. Barnhart and also called Parents
as witnesses during CYS’s case in chief. Father, who was represented by
counsel, also separately testified on his own behalf. In addition, CYS and
____________________________________________
3 On October 21, 2025, Child’s legal interest counsel requested to withdraw
her representation of Child, which the orphans’ court granted. The court
subsequently appointed new legal counsel for Child. See Order, 10/27/25.
-5-
J-S30002-26
Father each introduced documentary exhibits.4 Prior to the commencement
of the first termination hearing, Father’s counsel filed a motion requesting a
formal bonding evaluation, which the orphans’ court denied following a brief
argument on September 23, 2025. See N.T., 9/23/25, at 20.
On March 13, 2026, the orphans’ court entered a decree that granted
the Agency’s petition and involuntarily terminated Father’s parental rights
pursuant to 23 Pa.C.S.A. § 2511(a)(2), (5), and (b). On April 2, 2026, Father
timely filed a notice of appeal and concise statement of errors complained of
on appeal pursuant to Pa.R.A.P. 1925(a)(2)(i) and (b). The orphans’ court
filed a responsive Rule 1925(a) opinion on May 1, 2026.
On appeal, Father presents the following issues for review:
I. Whether the orphans’ court abused its discretion and/or
erred as a matter of law in terminating Father’s parental
rights under 23 Pa.C.S.A. § 2511(a)(2), where the evidence
was insufficient to establish by clear and convincing
evidence that Father’s repeated and continued incapacity,
abuse, neglect, or refusal caused Child to be without
essential parental care, control, or subsistence necessary for
her physical or mental well-being?
____________________________________________
4 We note with displeasure that these exhibits were not included in the certified
record. While this omission does not meaningfully hamper our review, we
pointedly remind counsel that appellants bear “the responsibility to make sure
that the record forwarded to an appellate court contains those documents
necessary to allow a complete and judicious assessment of the issues raised
on appeal.” Commonwealth v. Wint, 730 A.2d 965, 967 (Pa. Super. 1999)
(citations and internal quotation marks omitted); see also Pa.R.A.P. 1921
Note (“Ultimate responsibility for a complete record rests with the party raising
an issue that requires appellate court access to record materials.”) (citation
omitted).
-6-
J-S30002-26
II. Whether the orphans’ court abused its discretion and/or
erred as a matter of law in terminating Father’s parental
rights under 23 Pa.C.S.A. § 2511(a)(5), where the evidence
was insufficient to establish by clear and convincing
evidence that the conditions which led to Child’s removal or
placement continue to exist?
III. Whether the orphans’ court abused its discretion and/or
erred as a matter of law in terminating Father’s parental
rights where it failed to properly consider Father’s
compliance with the permanency plan and progress toward
alleviating the circumstances which led to placement?
IV. Whether the orphans’ court abused its discretion and/or
erred as a matter of law by denying Father’s request for a
bonding assessment to be conducted prior to the conclusion
of the termination of parental rights hearing?
V. Whether the orphans’ court abused its discretion and/or
erred as a matter of law in terminating Father’s parental
rights pursuant to 23 Pa.C.S.A. § 2511(b) where the
evidence was insufficient to establish that termination best
serves the developmental, physical, and emotional needs
and welfare of Child?
VI. Whether the orphans’ court abused its discretion and/or
erred as a matter of law under 23 Pa.C.S.A. § 2511(b)
where it failed to consider less drastic alternatives to
termination that would preserve the parent-child
relationship while ensuring Child’s safety and stability?
Father’s Brief at 13-15 (cleaned up).5
We review decrees involuntarily terminating parental rights for an abuse
of discretion. See Interest of M.E., 283 A.3d 820, 829 (Pa. Super. 2022).
This Court has explained our inquiry, as follows:
____________________________________________
5 In lieu of a brief, the GAL filed a letter in this Court on behalf of Child
indicating her support for affirming the subject decree. Child’s legal interest
counsel did not file a brief in this appeal.
-7-
J-S30002-26
In cases concerning the involuntary termination of parental rights,
appellate review is limited to a determination of whether the
decree of the termination court is supported by competent
evidence. When applying this standard, the appellate court must
accept the trial court’s findings of fact and credibility
determinations if they are supported by the record. Where the
trial court’s factual findings are supported by the evidence, an
appellate court may not disturb the trial court’s ruling unless it
has discerned an error of law or abuse of discretion.
An abuse of discretion does not result merely because the
reviewing court might have reached a different conclusion or the
facts could support an opposite result. Instead, an appellate court
may reverse for an abuse of discretion only upon demonstration
of manifest unreasonableness, partiality, prejudice, bias, or ill-
will. This standard of review reflects the deference we pay to trial
courts, who often observe the parties first-hand across multiple
hearings.
In considering a petition to terminate parental rights, a trial court
must balance the parent’s fundamental right to make decisions
concerning the care, custody, and control of his or her child with
the child’s essential needs for a parent’s care, protection, and
support. Termination of parental rights has significant and
permanent consequences for both the parent and child. As such,
the law of this Commonwealth requires the moving party to
establish the statutory grounds by clear and convincing evidence,
which is evidence that is so clear, direct, weighty, and convincing
as to enable a trier of fact to come to a clear conviction, without
hesitance, of the truth of the precise facts in issue.
Id. at 829-30 (internal citations and quotation marks omitted).
The involuntary termination of parental rights is governed by Section
2511 of the Adoption Act, which calls for a bifurcated analysis that first focuses
upon the “eleven enumerated grounds” of parental conduct that may warrant
termination. Id. at 830; see also 23 Pa.C.S.A. § 2511(a)(1)-(11). If the
orphans’ court determines the petitioner has established grounds for
termination under one of these subsections by “clear and convincing
-8-
J-S30002-26
evidence,” the court then assesses the petition pursuant to Section 2511(b),
which focuses upon the child’s developmental, physical, and emotional needs
and welfare. In re T.S.M., 71 A.3d 251, 267 (Pa. 2013); see also 23
Pa.C.S.A. § 2511(b). This Court need only agree with the orphans’ court’s
determination as to any one subsection of Section 2511(a), in addition to
Section 2511(b), in order to affirm termination. See M.E., 283 A.3d at 830
(citing In re B.L.W., 843 A.2d 380, 384 (Pa. Super. 2004) (en banc)).
Our analysis in this case will focus upon 23 Pa.C.S.A. § 2511(a)(2) and
(b), which provide, as follows:
(a) General Rule.—The rights of a parent in regard to a child
may be terminated after a petition filed on any of the following
grounds:
...
(2) The repeated and continued incapacity, abuse, neglect
or refusal of the parent has caused the child to be without
essential parental care, control or subsistence necessary for
his physical or mental well-being and the conditions and
causes of the incapacity, abuse, neglect or refusal cannot or
will not be remedied by the parent.
...
(b) Other considerations.—The court in terminating the rights
of a parent shall give primary consideration to the developmental,
physical and emotional needs and welfare of the child. The rights
of a parent shall not be terminated solely on the basis of
environmental factors such as inadequate housing, furnishings,
income, clothing and medical care if found to be beyond the
control of the parent. With respect to any petition filed pursuant
to subsection (a)(1), (6) or (8), the court shall not consider any
efforts by the parent to remedy the conditions described therein
which are first initiated subsequent to the giving of notice of the
filing of the petition.
-9-
J-S30002-26
23 Pa.C.S.A. § 2511(a)(2), (b).
In order to satisfy Section 2511(a)(2), the petitioning party must
establish: “(1) repeated and continued incapacity, abuse, neglect or refusal;
(2) that such incapacity, abuse, neglect or refusal caused the child to be
without essential parental care, control or subsistence; and (3) that the causes
of the incapacity, abuse, neglect or refusal cannot or will not be remedied.”
In re Adoption of A.H., 247 A.3d 439, 443 (Pa. Super. 2021). The grounds
for termination under Section 2511(a)(2) due to parental incapacity are not
limited to affirmative misconduct; those grounds may include acts of refusal
and incapacity to perform parental duties. See In re S.C., 247 A.3d 1097,
1104 (Pa. Super. 2021), abrogated on other grounds by Interest of K.T.,
296 A.3d 1085, 1110 n.23 (Pa. 2023).
Further, this Court has stated that
incarceration, while not a litmus test for termination, can be
determinative of the question of whether a parent is incapable of
providing “essential parental care, control or subsistence” and the
length of the remaining confinement can be considered as highly
relevant to whether “the conditions and causes of the incapacity,
abuse, neglect or refusal cannot or will not be remedied by the
parent,” sufficient to provide grounds for termination pursuant to
[Section 2511(a)(2)].
In re Adoption of S.P., 47 A.3d 817, 830 (Pa. Super. 2012) (citations
omitted). When “a parent has demonstrated a continued inability to conduct
his . . . life in a fashion that would provide a safe environment for a child,
whether that child is living with the parent or not, and the behavior of the
parent is irremediable as supported by clear and competent evidence, the
- 10 -
J-S30002-26
termination of parental rights is justified” pursuant to Section 2511(a)(2). In
re Z.P., 994 A.2d 1108, 1118 (Pa. Super. 2010). Overall, we emphasize that
“[p]arents are required to make diligent efforts toward the reasonably prompt
assumption of full parental duties.” A.H., 247 A.3d at 443.
If the orphans’ court concludes that adequate grounds for termination
exist pursuant to Section 2511(a), the court then turns to Section 2511(b),
which requires that it “give primary consideration to the developmental,
physical and emotional needs and welfare of the child.” 23 Pa.C.S.A.
§ 2511(b); see also T.S.M., 71 A.3d at 267. Our Supreme Court has directed
that a Section 2511(b) inquiry must include consideration for the bond
between the parent and the child. See In re E.M., 620 A.2d 481, 485 (Pa.
1993). With respect to the bond analysis, we have explained:
The orphans’ court must determine whether the parent and child
share an emotional bond and assess whether the bond is
necessary and beneficial to the child, such that maintaining the
bond serves the child’s developmental, physical, and emotional
needs and welfare. If a bond exists, the court must ascertain the
effect upon the child of severing the bond. Because the severing
of any parent-child bond may be emotionally painful for a child,
the orphans’ court cannot preclude termination based solely on
evidence of an adverse or detrimental impact to the child.
Instead, focusing upon the child’s development, and mental and
emotional health, the orphans’ court should assess whether
severing the bond is the kind of loss that would predictably cause
extreme emotional consequences or significant, irreparable harm
to the child.
In re Adopt. of G.W., 342 A.3d 68, 90 (Pa. Super. 2025) (en banc) (internal
citations and quotation marks omitted). The extent of the “bond-effect
- 11 -
J-S30002-26
analysis necessarily depends on the circumstances of the particular case.” In
re Adoption of J.M., 991 A.2d 321, 324 (Pa. Super. 2010).
Nevertheless, the Section 2511(b) analysis does not end with the
evaluation of the parent-child bond. See G.W., 342 A.3d at 91. The orphans’
court must also consider:
the child’s need for permanency and length of time in foster care
. . .; whether the child is in a pre[-]adoptive home and bonded
with foster parents; and whether the foster home meets the child’s
developmental, physical, and emotional needs, including
intangible needs of love, comfort, security, safety, and stability.
Id. These considerations are all of “‘primary’ importance in the Section
2511(b) analysis” and “may contribute equally to the determination of a
child’s specific developmental, physical, and emotional needs and welfare.”
K.T., 296 A.3d at 1109. Indeed, the orphans’ court’s discretion includes
placing “appropriate weight on each factor present in the record” when
conducting “a full [Section 2511](b) analysis focused on the child.” Id. at
1113-14.
With respect to Section 2511(a)(2), Father contends that his conduct
did not warrant termination insofar as he has maintained his sobriety while
incarcerated, and, therefore, he has remedied his drug addiction. See
Father’s Brief at 20. In the alternative, Father contends that the orphans’
court failed to consider that, upon his release, Father promised to attend
inpatient substance abuse treatment. See id. at 19-22; see also N.T.,
12/12/25, at 81. Father also assails the court for failing to acknowledge that
- 12 -
J-S30002-26
he completed various programs while incarcerated. See Father’s Brief at 21-
22.
In support of its conclusion that Father’s parental rights should be
terminated pursuant to Section 2511(a)(2), the orphans’ court reasoned, as
follows:
Father has struggled with the use of illicit substances since 2016.
Over time, he has entered at least three inpatient treatment
[programs] which have all been unsuccessful. While this case was
pending, and before he was incarcerated in August of 2024, he
was undergoing treatment at Freedom House. This treatment also
was unsuccessful as Father continued to use. Father’s drug use,
while he was undergoing obviously unsuccessful treatment,
continued during a time that he was involved in dependency cases
in [Allegheny County for K.D.B. and Beaver County for Child], at
a time when a court found aggravating circumstances existed due
to his actions in exposing Child to drugs to such an extent that
only life savings measures of first responders and then CHOP staff
kept her alive, and when it was exponentially clear that continued
use of fentanyl was, as stated by Father, “death [] knocking at the
back door.” Even worse, his continued use of drugs was the very
same conduct that invited “death” into their home to call upon
Child on June 7, 2024.
No prognosis is given or arises out of the evidence that the
ongoing drug addiction of [Father] will change anytime soon. The
drug use of [Father] is unimpacted by any efforts at treatment
and has persisted. . . .
...
The court acknowledges that [] Father [has] participated in prison
programs. This is commendable, but it cannot be the decisive
factor under these circumstances. . . .
...
In this case, the lifestyle of [Father] which included rampant drug
use while [he was] on probation in Allegheny County and
continuing to commit criminal acts that endangered the welfare of
- 13 -
J-S30002-26
Child[] culminated in periods of incarceration for [Father]. Child
was only ten months old when Father was incarcerated . . . . She
is now 25 months old. Therefore, [Father has] been in jail for
[over] one-half of her life. [Father] wasted the valuable resources
that could have been used to preserve the parental relationship.
Instead, it was [his] own conduct that squandered the
rehabilitation opportunities and it was [his] conduct that led to
[his] predictable incarceration.
...
. . . Notably, a “parent’s vow to cooperate, after a long period of
uncooperativeness regarding the necessity or availability of
services, may properly be rejected as untimely or disingenuous.”
In re Z.P., 994 A.2d 1108, 1118 (Pa. Super. 2010) (citation
omitted). The orphans’ court has done that by finding that the
testimony of [] Father in that regard was not credible. . . .
Orphans’ Court Opinion, 5/1/26, at 54-60, 62 (cleaned up). Our review of the
certified record fully supports the orphans’ court’s findings.
Father acknowledged that his fentanyl abuse began in 2016. See N.T.,
9/23/25, at 71. He reported that since 2023, he has unsuccessfully attempted
three inpatient drug and alcohol rehabilitation programs. See id. at 76-77.
Father testified that, since January 2023 through the time of his incarceration
in August 2024, he had been abusing suboxone, which was then prescribed
through a substance abuse program. See id. at 72. In fact, Father conceded
that by the time of his incarceration he was in a “full blown relapse.” Id. at
86. Indeed, Ms. Barnhart testified that, in July 2024, Father tested positive
for fentanyl, naloxone, xylazine, and marijuana. See N.T., 10/14/25, at 34.
Father thereafter revoked the Agency’s authorization to view the results from
the drug screen provider. See N.T., 9/23/25, at 73-74. However, at that
- 14 -
J-S30002-26
time, Father submitted to a dual diagnosis evaluation at Freedom House but
admitted that he was not forthcoming during the evaluation, stating that he
only provided “surface level” responses. Id. Ultimately, Father testified that
he required a new evaluation to determine appropriate treatment for his drug
addiction. See N.T., 12/12/25, at 86-87.
Although the certified record reflects that Father has abstained from
drug use during his incarceration, the court acted well within its discretion in
finding incredible Father’s claims that he will maintain his sobriety upon his
release given his long history of rehabilitation failures up through and
including the time of his incarceration. Further, we agree with the orphans’
court that Father did not present any evidence with respect to his prognosis
and risk of relapse upon his release from incarceration. It is a fundamental
principle that the orphans’ court was free to believe all, part, or none of the
evidence presented by the parties. See In re R.A.M.N., 230 A.3d 423, 427
(Pa. Super. 2020) (stating that the trial court “is free to believe all, part, or
none of the evidence presented and is likewise free to make all credibility
determinations and resolve conflicts in the evidence.”).
Finally, Father testified that he would complete his Beaver County
incarceration in April 2026. See N.T., 9/23/25, at 90. However, his sentence
required him to complete an additional four years of probation, and Father
intended to reside in a halfway house upon his release. See N.T., 12/12/25,
at 81. In addition, Ms. Barnhart testified that Father’s parole violation in
- 15 -
J-S30002-26
Allegheny County remained pending at the time of the termination hearing.
See N.T., 10/14/25, at 46. Father conceded that, after his release from
prison, he did not know when he would be in a position to assume care and
custody of Child. See N.T., 12/12/25, at 81; N.T., 9/23/25, at 85.
Based upon the foregoing, we conclude that the record sufficiently
establishes that Father’s repeated and continued incapacity due to his criminal
sentence in Beaver County and pending charges in Allegheny County and his
history of illegal drug addiction has caused Child to be without essential
parental care, control, or subsistence necessary for her physical or mental
well-being. Furthermore, the record supports the orphans’ court’s conclusion
that Father’s incapacity cannot or will not be remedied. Therefore, we discern
no abuse of discretion in the orphans’ court’s decision to involuntarily
terminate Father’s parental rights pursuant to Section 2511(a)(2). Father’s
first issue fails.
Father’s second and third issues relate to Section 2511(a)(5). Because
we have concluded that the orphans’ court did not abuse its discretion with
respect to Section 2511(a)(2), we need not consider these issues. See M.E.,
283 A.3d at 830 (citing In re B.L.W., 843 A.2d 380, 384 (Pa. Super. 2004)
(en banc)).
We now address Father’s fourth and fifth issues, which challenge the
orphans’ court’s holding pursuant to Section 2511(b). Primarily, Father
argues that the court erred in denying his motion for a bonding assessment
- 16 -
J-S30002-26
between him and Child. See Father’s Brief at 30-31. Father further asserts
that the Agency did not provide any evidence regarding the impact on Child
of involuntarily terminating his parental rights. See id. Father contends that
he shares a “close bond” with Child despite his incarceration, and, therefore,
the court erred in involuntarily terminating his parental rights pursuant to
Section 2511(b). Id. at 32-35. We are not persuaded by Father’s arguments.
Initially, we find no merit in Father’s suggestion that the orphans’ court
erred in failing to order a formal bonding assessment. As aptly stated by the
orphans’ court, it is well settled that “[w]hen conducting a bonding analysis,
the court is not required to use expert testimony. Social workers and
caseworkers can offer evaluations as well. Additionally, Section 2511(b) does
not require a formal bonding evaluation.” In re Adoption of C.P.D., 324
A.3d 11, 27 (Pa. Super. 2024) (citing In re Z.P., 994 A.2d 1108, 1121 (Pa.
Super. 2010)). Here, the court acted within its discretion by relying on the
testimony of Ms. Barnhart, and, as discussed infra, the orphans’ court’s
findings are well supported in the certified record.
With respect to Section 2511(b), the orphans’ court found that Child did
not share a necessary and beneficial bond with Father. Rather, the court
found that Child shared a parental bond with her paternal grandparents, with
whom she has been placed since her removal from Parents’ custody, and who
desire to adopt her. The court reasoned, as follows:
Child is thriving while being cared for by her current foster family,
paternal grandparents. Child’s needs are being met in the current
- 17 -
J-S30002-26
foster placement and that placement provides a stable and secure
environment where she is loved and bonded with paternal
grandparents. That family is a permanency option for Child.
...
Child is loving and outgoing. She has a relationship with the
caseworker that brings Child to the visits and that bond with the
caseworker is at least as strong as the bond that Child has with .
. . Father. In that relationship with the caseworker, Child happily
asks the caseworker to play games or to play certain music.
At the conclusion of visits, Child exchanges a hug and kiss with
[Father], and then walks away with the caseworker in anticipation
of reuniting with her paternal grandparents.
The court also acknowledges that Father has a bond with Child
that is similar to the bond that she has with other people. That
bond appears to be no different than the bond that Child has with
the caseworkers and that bond does not approach the bond
between Child and her paternal grandparents. Father’s visits since
August 29, 2024[,] have been limited to one hour every other
week in a cell at the Beaver County Jail. Child has never displayed
sadness when leaving the one hour visits with Father and her
departure after the visits did not ever lead to negative behaviors
resulting from that separation. Father has no special bond with
Child from which Child would incur harm if the bond was severed.
...
Focusing upon Child’s development, and mental and emotional
health, the orphans’ court finds that the limited bond that Child
has with [Father], if severed, will not be the kind of loss that would
predictably cause extreme emotional consequences or significant,
irreparable harm to Child. Child departs from her visits with
[Father] without any evidence of sadness. There are no negative
or adverse changes in Child after the visits end. Child looks
forward to returning to her home and seeing the foster parents
when visits end. The foster parents are the individuals that Child
looks to for real love, stability, necessities, care, and all of her
other needs. She has blossomed to a healthy toddler because her
paternal grandparents have taken care of her emotional and
physical needs completely. They accepted Child into their home
only days after she nearly died from a combination of drowning
- 18 -
J-S30002-26
and exposure to fentanyl and they carefully and with love have
taken care of her since that time.
Orphans’ Court Opinion, 5/1/26, at 66-69 (cleaned up). Our review indicates
that the orphans’ court’s findings are sufficiently supported by the certified
record.
Ms. Barnhart testified that Father attended supervised visits with Child
for one hour every two weeks while incarcerated in Beaver County Jail. See
N.T., 10/14/25, at 27. Ms. Barnhart reported that, at the conclusion of visits
with Father, Child was “ready to go” and never exhibited any sadness upon
leaving Father. Id. at 36, 53-54. Ms. Barnhart also testified that although
Child would hug and kiss Father, Child displayed the same affection toward
Ms. Barnhart. See id. at 48-49.
Ms. Barnhart offered a markedly different picture with respect to Child’s
paternal grandparents. Specifically, she testified that Child loves her
grandparents and exhibited excitement to return home following visitations
with Father. See id. at 28, 48-49. Ms. Barnhart testified that the paternal
grandparents provide Child with love, stability, and safety, and thus, Child has
been thriving in their care. See id. at 48-51; see also N.T., 12/12/25, at 50-
51, 53. Ultimately, Ms. Barnhart testified that involuntary termination of
Father’s parental rights is in Child’s best interests. See id. at 51.
Based upon the foregoing, the record evidence clearly demonstrates
that Child does not share a necessary and beneficial bond with Father, and
that her developmental, physical, and emotional needs and welfare are best
- 19 -
J-S30002-26
served by termination of Father’s parental rights. Therefore, we discern no
abuse of discretion with the orphans’ court’s findings regarding Section
2511(b).
In his sixth and final issue, Father contends that the orphans’ court was
required to consider less severe alternatives to involuntary termination “where
alternatives [are] plainly available[.]” Father’s Brief at 35-36. Father assails
the court for failing to provide analysis “concerning less restrictive
alternative[s.]” Id. at 37-38. We disagree. Indeed, neither Section 2511(a)
nor (b) requires that the involuntary termination of parental rights be
predicated upon a “less restrictive alternative.” Rather, this argument is
relevant to the court’s establishment of the permanency placement goal under
the Juvenile Act, which is not before this Court. See Interest of S.S., 252
A.3d 681, 688 (Pa. Super. 2021) (recognizing that dependency proceedings
and termination proceedings are two separate, distinct proceedings “with their
own docket numbers, records, and divisions within the Court of Common
Pleas.”). Thus, as a matter of justiciability, we cannot address Father’s claim
for relief.
As such, we discern no error or abuse of discretion by the orphans’ court
involuntarily terminating Father’s parental rights pursuant to Section
2511(a)(2) and (b). Accordingly, we affirm the decree involuntarily
terminating Father’s parental rights.
Decree affirmed.
- 20 -
J-S30002-26
DATE: 11/19/2026
- 21 -