Soland, D. v. ZHB E. Bradford Twp
CourtSupreme Court of Pennsylvania
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
Docket10 MAP 2025
JudgeTodd, Chief Justice Debra
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
[J-9A-2026, J-9B-2026, J-9C-2026 and J-9D-2026]
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA
MIDDLE DISTRICT
TODD, C.J., DONOHUE, DOUGHERTY, WECHT, MUNDY, BROBSON, McCAFFERY, JJ.
DOROTHY SOLAND, DANIEL SOLAND, : No. 8 MAP 2025
MARK OUIMET, AND ANNA OUIMET :
: Appeal from the Order of the
: Commonwealth Court at No. 395
v. : CD 2022 dated February 20, 2024,
: Reversing the Decision of the
: Chester County Court of Common
ZONING HEARING BOARD OF EAST : Pleas, Civil Division, at No. 2018-
BRADFORD TOWNSHIP AND EAST : 03763-ZB dated March 23, 2022
BRADFORD TOWNSHIP BOARD OF :
SUPERVISORS AND JOHN MARSHALL : ARGUED: March 11, 2026
AND DARA GANS-MARSHALL EAST :
BRADFORD TOWNSHIP BOARD OF :
SUPERVISORS :
:
:
v. :
:
:
EAST BRADFORD TOWNSHIP ZONING :
HEARING BOARD AND JOHN :
MARSHALL AND DARA GANS- :
MARSHALL :
:
:
APPEAL OF: EAST BRADFORD :
TOWNSHIP BOARD OF SUPERVISORS :
:
:
DOROTHY SOLAND, DANIEL SOLAND, : No. 9 MAP 2025
MARK OUIMET, AND ANNA OUIMET :
: Appeal from the Order of the
: Commonwealth Court at No. 990
v. : CD 2022 dated February 20, 2024,
: Reversing the Decision of the
: Chester County Court of Common
ZONING HEARING BOARD OF EAST : Pleas, Civil Division, at No. 2018-
BRADFORD TOWNSHIP AND EAST : 03764-ZB dated March 23, 2022
BRADFORD TOWNSHIP BOARD OF :
SUPERVISORS AND JOHN MARSHALL : ARGUED: March 11, 2026
AND DARA GANS-MARSHALL :
:
:
APPEAL OF: EAST BRADFORD :
TOWNSHIP BOARD OF SUPERVISORS :
:
DOROTHY SOLAND, DANIEL SOLAND, : No. 10 MAP 2025
MARK OUIMET, AND ANNA OUIMET :
: Appeal from the Order of the
: Commonwealth Court at No. 395
v. : CD 2022 dated February 20, 2024,
: Reversing the Decision of the
: Chester County Court of Common
ZONING HEARING BOARD OF EAST : Pleas, Civil Division, at No. 2018-
BRADFORD TOWNSHIP AND EAST : 03763-ZB dated March 23, 2022
BRADFORD TOWNSHIP BOARD OF :
SUPERVISORS AND JOHN MARSHALL : ARGUED: March 11, 2026
AND DARA GANS-MARSHALL EAST :
BRADFORD TOWNSHIP BOARD OF :
SUPERVISORS :
:
:
v. :
:
:
EAST BRADFORD TOWNSHIP ZONING :
HEARING BOARD AND JOHN :
MARSHALL AND DARA GANS- :
MARSHALL :
:
:
APPEAL OF: DOROTHY SOLAND AND :
DANIEL SOLAND :
:
DOROTHY SOLAND, DANIEL SOLAND, : No. 11 MAP 2025
MARK OUIMET, AND ANNA OUIMET :
: Appeal from the Order of the
: Commonwealth Court at No. 990
v. : CD 2022 dated February 20, 2024,
: Reversing the Decision of the
: Chester County Court of Common
ZONING HEARING BOARD OF EAST : Pleas, Civil Division, at No. 2018-
BRADFORD TOWNSHIP AND EAST : 03764-ZB dated March 23, 2022
BRADFORD TOWNSHIP BOARD OF :
: ARGUED: March 11, 2026
[J-9A-2026, J-9B-2026, J-9C-2026 and J-9D-2026] - 2
SUPERVISORS AND JOHN MARSHALL :
AND DARA GANS-MARSHALL :
:
:
APPEAL OF: DOROTHY SOLAND AND :
DANIEL SOLAND
OPINION
CHIEF JUSTICE TODD DECIDED: November 18, 2026
In these consolidated appeals, we consider whether a zoning hearing board may
grant a use variance on the basis that the variance sought is de minimis, and, if so,
whether the grant of a use variance was appropriate in the instant case. For the reasons
that follow, we hold that a use variance cannot be considered de minimis, and, thus, that
the use variance granted in the instant case was improper. Accordingly, we reverse the
Commonwealth Court’s decision below.
I. Factual and Procedural History
Appellees John Marshall and Dara Gans Marshall (“the Marshalls”) own
approximately eleven acres of property in East Bradford Township (“Township”), Chester
County, Pennsylvania (the “Property”). The Property contains several structures,
including a residential home known as the Paxson House, which is occupied by the
Marshalls and their three children; a currently-unoccupied building known as the Tenant
House, which previously was used as a veterinary clinic; and a barn.
The Marshalls desire to operate a bed-and-breakfast (“B&B”) on the Property,
using the Paxson House, which, under the East Bradford Township Zoning Ordinance
(“Ordinance”), is deemed a Class I historic resource,1 as their main residence, and using
1 Pursuant to Section 115-122(A)(1)(a) of the Ordinance, Class I historic resources
include: all buildings, sites, structures, and objects listed individually in the National
Register of Historic Places; all buildings and structures classified as certified historic
(continued…)
[J-9A-2026, J-9B-2026, J-9C-2026 and J-9D-2026] - 3
the Tenant House, which is deemed a Class II historic resource,2 as the guest quarters.
Section 115-48.2(A) of the Ordinance, however, provides that “[t]he only buildings eligible
for a bed-and-breakfast estate use shall be owner-occupied Class I historic resources.”
Ordinance § 115-48.2(A). Additionally, the Ordinance specifies that a B&B must consist
of at least four, but no more than ten, guest rooms. Id. § 115-48.2(B).
Thus, in December 2017, the Marshalls filed with the East Bradford Township
Zoning Hearing Board (“ZHB”) an application for a use variance that would allow them to
locate the guest rooms of the proposed B&B in the Tenant House, and retain the Paxson
House as their private residence. At a hearing before the ZHB on January 29, 2018, the
Marshalls testified that they have three children and a large extended family which they
often host, and that the Paxson House is not large enough to accommodate their family
and the required minimum number of four guest rooms. The Township Zoning Officer,
Melissa Needles, testified that, while a B&B estate normally is located in “a historic house
on the property . . . it’s just a way to utilize a historic house.” N.T. Hearing, 1/29/18, at 11
(Reproduced Record (“R.R.”) at 90a). Needles also noted that the Property is un usual in
that it contains multiple buildings she believes are historic. Finally, the solicitor for the
ZHB opined that the existence of buildings on the Property provided “a good reason” to
structures by the Secretary of the Interior; all buildings, sites, structures, and objects
documented as contributing resources in a National Register Historic District; any
resources which have received a Determination of Eligibility by the Pennsylvania
Historical and Museum Commission; and any resources deemed by the Chester County
Historic Preservation Office to substantially meet the National Register criteria under the
Chester County Certification Program.
2 Class II historic resources include buildings, sites, structures, objects and districts
included in the historic resources inventory of the East Bradford Historical Commission
which do not meet Class I historic resource criteria, but which have been “determined to
be of historical or architectural significance to East Bradford and appropriately
documented to that effect by the East Bradford Historical Commission .” Ordinance § 115-
122(A)(3).
[J-9A-2026, J-9B-2026, J-9C-2026 and J-9D-2026] - 4
use the Tenant House for the guest rooms of the proposed B&B estate. Id. at 12 (R.R.
at 91a).
On March 16, 2018, the ZHB granted the Marshalls’ application for a use variance.
In doing so, the ZHB acknowledged that, under the Pennsylvania Municipalities Planning
Code (“MPC”), 53 P.S. § 10910.2,3 and Section 115-85 of the Ordinance,4 an applicant
3 Section 10910.2(a) provides that a variance may be granted if the ZHB makes all of the
following findings, if relevant in a given case:
(1) That there are unique physical circumstances or conditions,
including irregularity, narrowness, or shallowness of lot size
or shape, or exceptional topographical or other physical
conditions peculiar to the particular property and that the
unnecessary hardship is due to such conditions and not the
circumstances or conditions generally created by the
provisions of the zoning ordinance in the neighborhood or
district in which the property is located.
(2) That because of such physical circumstances or conditions,
there is no possibility that the property can be developed in
strict conformity with the provisions of the zoning ordinance
and that the authorization of a variance is therefore necessary
to enable the reasonable use of the property.
(3) That such unnecessary hardship has not been created by the
appellant.
(4) That the variance, if authorized, will not alter the essential
character of the neighborhood or district in which the property
is located, nor substantially or permanently impair the
appropriate use or development of adjacent property, nor be
detrimental to the public welfare.
(5) That the variance, if authorized, will represent the minimum
variance that will afford relief and will represent the least
modification possible of the regulation in issue.
53 P.S. § 10910.2(a)(1)-(5).
4 With the exception of some differences in punctuation, Section 115-85 of the Ordinance
is identical to Section 10910.2(a) of the MPC.
[J-9A-2026, J-9B-2026, J-9C-2026 and J-9D-2026] - 5
seeking a variance must demonstrate: (1) an unnecessary hardship will result if the
variance is not granted due to the unique physical circumstances or conditions of the
property; (2) because of the physical circumstances or conditions of the property, the
property cannot be developed in strict conformity with the provisions of the applicable
zoning code, and a variance is necessary to allow reasonable use of the property; (3) the
hardship is not self-inflicted; (4) the grant of a variance will not alter the essential character
of the neighborhood or be detrimental to public welfare; and (5) the variance sought is the
minimum variance that will afford relief. ZHB Opinion, 3/16/18, at 4-5 (R.R. at 19a-20a)
(citing Arter v. Philadelphia Zoning Bd. of Adjustment, 916 A.2d 1222 (Pa. Cmwlth.
2007)). The ZHB further recognized that a variance may be granted only where there are
substantial, serious, and compelling reasons. Id. at 5 (R.R. at 20a).
However, the ZHB observed that a variance may also be granted “where the
variation requested is minor, and rigid compliance is not necessary to protect the public
policy concerns of the ordinance.” Id. (quoting Lench v. Zoning Bd. of Adjustment of City
of Pittsburgh, 13 A.3d 576 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2011) (finding no abuse of discretion by the
zoning hearing board in granting homeowner a de minimis dimensional variance allowing
him to replace his roof with a new roof that would exceed the maximum allowable height
by four inches)). The ZHB concluded that the Marshalls’ request for a use variance to
allow them to locate the B&B’s guest rooms in the Ten ant House was reasonable, as the
proposed use is in keeping with “the intent and spirit of the adaptive reuse of the historic
structures upon the Property.”5 Id. at 5-6 (R.R. at 20a-21a).
5 The ZHB additionally noted that “it is a physical challenge to fit a family in the main
dwelling and also accommodate guest rooms – there simply is not enough space based
upon the testimony presented during the hearing.” ZHB Opinion, 3/16/18, at 6 (R.R. at
21a).
[J-9A-2026, J-9B-2026, J-9C-2026 and J-9D-2026] - 6
Dorothy and Daniel Soland (collectively, “the Solands”), who are neighboring
property owners,6 and the East Bradford Township Board of Supervisors (“Board”)
appealed the ZHB’s decision to the trial court.7 Following intervening procedural litigation
not relevant to the issues on which we granted review, the trial court reversed the ZHB’s
decision, finding that the Marshalls failed to satisfy the requirements for a variance under
the MPC.
Specifically, the trial court concluded that the Marshalls did not demonstrate the
existence of an unnecessary hardship that prevented the Property from being developed
in strict conformity with the Ordinance’s provisions and, further, that they neglected to
show that a variance was needed in order to permit reasonable use of the Property. In
the trial court’s view, the Marshalls’ desire to use the Tenant House to accommodate the
B&B guest rooms and maintain the Paxson House as their private residence was a self-
imposed hardship that could be overcome or avoided by reasonable reallocation of their
living space. The trial court further rejected the ZHB’s finding that the variance requested
by the Marshalls was de minimis, concluding that use variances can never be de minimis.
The Marshalls appealed to the Commonwealth Court arguing, as relevant herein, that the
de minimis doctrine may be applied to use variances, and that the ZHB properly granted
their application for a use variance in the instant case.
In a divided, published opinion, a three-judge panel of the Commonwealth Court
reversed the trial court’s decision and ordered the decision of the ZHB be reinstated. See
Soland v. Zoning Hearing Bd. of East Bradford Twp., 311 A.3d 1208 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2024)
(“Soland”). Writing for the majority, Senior Judge Bonnie Brigance Leadbetter, who was
6 Mark and Anna Quimet are also neighboring property owners who appealed the ZHB’s
decision. However, because they failed to file an appellate brief as directed, they were
not permitted to file additional briefs or argue before the court.
7 The Solands and the Township filed separate cross-appeals, and their appeals were
consolidated by the trial court. The appeals remain consolidated before this Court.
[J-9A-2026, J-9B-2026, J-9C-2026 and J-9D-2026] - 7
joined by President Judge Renee Cohn Jubelirer, concluded that a use variance can, in
fact, be de minimis. Relevant herein, the court initially observed that “[d]e minimis
variance relief has no set criteria and the grant of a de minimis variance depends upon
the circumstances of each case.” Id. at 1213. The court conceded that, “[h]istorically,
application of the de minimis variance doctrine has been exclusively applied in cases
where ‘only minor deviations from dimensional zoning ordinances have been the basis
for the variance sought.’” Id. (quoting Coyle v. City of Lebanon Zoning Hearing Bd., 135
A.3d 240, 245 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2016)). However, the court opined: “[w]hile the doctrine has
been repeatedly rejected in use variance cases, Coyle and the cases cited therein do not
create a rigid rule against applying the de minimis doctrine to use variances. Rather, they
say only that such a variance has never been approved in the past.” Id. The court further
recognized that the “theory underlying the skepticism in applying the de minimis doctrine
to use variances is that ‘the effect of a use variance on the public interest is greater than
the effect of a minor deviation from a dimensional requirement.’” Id. at 1213-14 (quoting
Coyle, 135 A.3d at 245). Nevertheless, the court concluded that “this is not necessarily
always the case,” opining that “the present case proves the point.” Id. at 1214.
Specifically, the court noted that, although the Tenant House is not classified as a
Class I historic resource, “the entire 10-acre property is listed as a Class I historic property
on the Township’s Historic Resources map and besides the Paxson House there is at
least one other Class I historic resource structure on the property (the Barn, which the
Marshalls planned to use for events).” Id. The court also remarked that the Tenant House
is not visible from the road, and that “the proposed B&B estate would be permitted under
the Ordinance as a conditional use if the Marshalls would utilize Paxson House to lodge
guests rather than the Tenant House.” Id. Thus, the court opined that the “variance
requested is more technical than substantial”; that the proposed use of the Tenant House
[J-9A-2026, J-9B-2026, J-9C-2026 and J-9D-2026] - 8
is consistent with the intent and spirit of the adaptive reuse of historic structures; and that
the variance “poses no adverse effect on the public interest.” Id.
Judge Ellen Ceisler authored a dissent, wherein she agreed with the majority that
the de minimis doctrine may be extended to apply to use variances, but disagreed that a
de minimis use variance was appropriate in the instant case. Despite observing that
Section 115-48.2(A) of the Ordinance provides that only owner-occupied Class I historic
resources may be used to house guest rooms at a B&B estate, Judge Ceisler suggested
that a use variance allowing the Tenant House, a Class II historic resource, to be used to
house the B&B guest rooms “would be an appropriate use of the de minimis variance
doctrine because Section 115-120(A) of the Ordinance expresses a public policy
determination that the public interest is served through preservation of Class II historic
resources.” Id. at 1215 (Ceisler, J., dissenting). However, Judge Ceisler found that it is
“unclear . . . what public policy interest is furthered by granting the Marshalls relief from
the owner-occupied requirements of Section 115-48.2(A),” the import of which are
demonstrated by the requirement of the submission of drawings which detail the owner’s
living areas, the guest rooms, and the common area. Id. Stating that she was “hard
pressed to differentiate a B&B that utilizes a non-owner-occupied structure for its guest
rooms from a motel,” Judge Ceisler would have affirmed the trial court’s reversal of the
ZHB’s grant of the Marshalls’ application for a use variance.
Following the denial of its application for reargument, the Board and the Solands
filed separate petitions for allowance of appeal with this Court. We granted review to
consider: (1) whether the Commonwealth Court erred in holding that the de minimis
doctrine may apply to use variances; and (2) if the de minimis doctrine may be applied to
use variances, whether the Commonwealth Court erred in finding that a use variance was
appropriate in the instant case.
[J-9A-2026, J-9B-2026, J-9C-2026 and J-9D-2026] - 9
Preliminarily, pursuant to Article I, Section 1 of the Pennsylvania Constitution,
Pennsylvania landowners generally have the right to use their property as they wish. Pa.
Const. art. I, § 1 (declaring as an inherent right the acquisition , possession, and protection
of property). This right, however, is not without limits, as “[t]he Constitution grants the
General Assembly broad and flexible police powers . . . to enact laws for the purpose of
promoting public health, safety, morals, and the general welfare.” Robinson Township,
Washington County v. Commonwealth, 83 A.3d 901, 946 (Pa. 2013). Accordingly,
pursuant to the MPC, a landowner’s rights may be reasonably restricted by zoning
ordinances enacted by municipalities pursuant to the police power granted to them by the
General Assembly. See Metal Green Inc. v. City of Philadelphia, 266 A.3d 495, 506 (Pa.
2021) (Opinion Announcing the Judgment of the Court).
Nevertheless, landowners may seek relief from compliance with a particular zoning
ordinance by requesting a variance. Critically, there are two types of variances:
dimensional variances and use variances. As we explained in Hertzberg v. Zoning Bd.
of Adjustment of City of Pittsburgh, a use variance is distinct from a dimensional variance,
in that a party seeking a dimensional variance “is asking only for a reasonable adjustment
of the zoning regulations in order to utilize the property in a manner consistent with the
applicable zoning regulations,” whereas a party seeking a use variance is proposing to
use the property “in a manner that is wholly outside the zoning regulation.” 721 A.2d 43,
47 (Pa. 1998).
The requirements for obtaining a variance are legislative in nature, 8 and are
subject to the terms of the applicable municipal zoning enactment. Metal Green, 266
8 Although the Statutory Construction Act, 1 Pa.C.S. §§ 1921-39, is not expressly
applicable to the construction of local ordinances, we apply the principles contained
therein when interpreting local ordinances. Borough of Fleetwood v. Zoning Hearing Bd.,
649 A.2d 651, 656 (Pa. 1994).
[J-9A-2026, J-9B-2026, J-9C-2026 and J-9D-2026] - 10
A.3d at 507. The party seeking a variance bears the burden of proof. Id. at 506. As set
forth in both the MPC and the Ordinance, a zoning board may grant a variance if it
determines, inter alia, that an unnecessary hardship exists which is caused by the unique
physical circumstances of the property for which the variance is sought; that the
unnecessary hardship was not created by the landowner; that a variance is needed to
enable the party’s reasonable use of the property; that the variance will not alter the
essential character of neighborhood, or substantially or permanently impair the use or
development of the adjacent property so as to be detrimental to the public’s welfare; and
that the variance is the least intrusive solution. See 53 P.S. § 10910.2(a)(1)-(5);
Ordinance § 115-85; see generally Larsen v. Zoning Bd. of Adjustment of City of
Pittsburgh, 672 A.2d 286, 289 (Pa. 1996). The failure of a zoning board to consider each
of these factors prior to granting a variance is an error of law. Larsen, 672 A.2d at 289-
90.
Notwithstanding the above, if a landowner is unable to establish the
aforementioned grounds for a traditional variance, as set forth in the MPC or the
applicable zoning ordinance, a zoning board may grant a variance where the requested
variance is de minimis. As this Court explained in Nettleton v. Zoning Bd. of Adjustment
of City of Pittsburgh:
[t]he de minimis zoning doctrine authorizes a variance in the
absence of a showing of the unnecessary hardship
traditionally required to support such relief where the violation
is insignificant and the public interest is protected by alternate
means. . . . In those cases where the de minimis doctrine
applies, there is no need to resort to any other theory of relief.
828 A.2d 1033, 1038 (Pa. 2003) (internal footnote omitted); see also Beecham
Enterprises, Inc. v. Zoning Hearing Bd. of Kennedy Twp., 608 A.2d 1018, 1020 n.4 (Pa.
1992) (observing that this Court and the Commonwealth Court have approved “de
[J-9A-2026, J-9B-2026, J-9C-2026 and J-9D-2026] - 11
minimis dimensional variances where there was no proof that without the variance the
property could not be . . . devoted to any permissible use”).
Moreover, in contrast to the established requirements for the grant of a traditional
variance, “[t]here are no set criteria for determining what will be considered de minimis.
Instead, the grant of a de minimis variance depends upon the circumstances of each
case.” Hawk v. City of Pittsburgh Zoning Bd. of Adjustment, 38 A.3d 1061, 1066 (Pa.
Cmwlth. 2012) (internal footnote and citation omitted). Indeed, the grant of a de minimis
variance “is a matter of discretion with the local zoning board.” Id. (emphasis omitted).
Nevertheless, “the de minimis doctrine is an extremely narrow exception to the heavy
burden of proof that a party seeking a variance must normally bear.” Pequea Twp. v.
Zoning Hearing Bd. of Pequea Twp., 180 A.3d 500, 505 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2018); see also
West Bradford Twp. v. Evans, 384 A.2d 1382, 1384 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1978) (“In the typical
case the party seeking a variance carries a very heavy burden, and must show that unless
the variance is granted he will suffer unnecessary hardship. Only in rare instances . . .
will this Court refrain from applying the traditional requirements for a variance.”). With
this background in mind, we turn to the arguments of the parties.
II. Arguments
Herein, the Board contends that the Commonwealth Court in this case abused its
discretion in holding that the Marshalls are entitled to a de minimis use variance because,
for over 50 years, this Court and the Commonwealth Court have limited the application of
the de minimis doctrine to dimensional variances. The Board further submits that the
panel’s determination that case law “do[es] not create a rigid rule against applying the de
minimis doctrine to use variances,” Soland, 311 A.3d at 1213, is expressly contradicted
by the decisions of this Court and the Commonwealth Court. See Board’s Brief at 31-33
(citing, inter alia, Nettleton, 828 A.2d at 1038 n.6 (“The zoning de minimis doctrine . . . is
[J-9A-2026, J-9B-2026, J-9C-2026 and J-9D-2026] - 12
limited to the grant of dimensional variance relief where the deviation is relatively minor
and strict compliance is not necessary to protect the public interest.”); Beecham
Enterprises, Inc., 608 A.2d at 1020 n.4 (observing that this Court and the Commonwealth
Court have approved “de minimis dimensional variances where there was no proof that
without the variance the property could not be . . . devoted to any permissible use”); Segal
v. Zoning Hearing Bd. of Buckingham Twp., 771 A.2d 90, 94-95 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2001)
(stating “[a] de minimis variance may be granted ‘in very limited situations where the
proposed dimensional deviations from the zoning requirement is relatively minor, and
where the insistence in rigid compliance is not absolutely necessary to preserve the public
policy to be obtained.’” (emphasis original, citation omitted)); East Allegheny Cmty.
Council v. Zoning Bd. of Adjustment of City of Pittsburgh, 563 A.2d 945, 952 (Pa. Cmwlth.
1989) (explaining that, following this Court’s decision in Pyzdrowski v. Bd. of Adjustment
of City of Pittsburgh, 263 A.2d 426, 431 (Pa. 1970) (observing that while use and
dimensional variances are controlled by the same principles, the effect on the public
interest of a use variance usually is greater than the effect of a variance necessitated by
a minor deviation from a lot restriction ), the Commonwealth Court “has applied the
doctrine of the de minimis variance only where minor deviations from dimensional zoning
ordinances have been the basis for the variance” (emphasis original)); Rollins Outdoor
Advert., Inc. v. Zoning Bd. of Adjustment, 529 A.2d 99, 103 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1987) (noting
that the de minimis doctrine “has exclusively been applied in cases where only minor
deviations from dimensional zoning ordinances have been the basis for the variances
sought”); Kensington S. Neighborhood Advisory Council v. Zoning Bd. of Adjustment of
Philadelphia, 471 A.2d 1317, 1319 (Pa. Cmwlth. 1984) (“There is no precedent . . . for
[J-9A-2026, J-9B-2026, J-9C-2026 and J-9D-2026] - 13
approving a use variance based on the ‘de minimis’ approach” (emphasis original))).9 The
Board submits that, because case law holds that the de minimis doctrine may not be
applied to use variances, the Marshalls were required to demonstrate the hardship criteria
for obtaining a traditional variance under Section 10910.2(a)(1)-(5) of the MPC.
Additionally, the Board argues that, if left in place, the Commonwealth Court’s
decision will result in a flood of new variance applications, which will place an undue
burden on zoning boards and the courts, and, further, “gut the variance directives of the
MPC, strip municipal legislative bodies of their zoning prerogatives, and imbue zoning
hearing boards and courts with the liberty to effectively re-write local codes in some
cases.” Board’s Brief at 38.
Finally, the Board argues that, even if this Court determines that the de minimis
doctrine may, in certain instances, be applied to use variances, the evidence does not
support the grant of a use variance to the Marshalls. In this regard, the Board offers that
there was no evidence presented that the Paxson House is not large enough to house
the Marshall family and the requisite number of guest rooms; rather, the Marshalls simply
stated that their preference is to locate the guest rooms in the Tenant House so that they
can retain the Paxson House for their own private use. The Board submits that this
preference does not meet the “heavy burden” of establishing an unnecessary hardship
under the MPC and the Ordinance. Id. at 41 (citation omitted). The Board further avers
that there was no evidence that there were any “unique physical circumstances or
conditions” of the Property which would preclude the Marshalls’ compliance with the
9 In their brief, the Board notes that Robert S. Ryan and John E. Ryan state in their treatise
Pennsylvania Zoning Law: “[T]he cases to date have held uniformly that a variance in a
use provision of a zoning ordinance cannot be de minimis,” and, despite the “theoretical
possibility of application to a use variance,” the possibility “seems remote enough to justify
adopting the rule that a use variance cannot be considered de minimis.” Pennsylvania
Zoning Law § 6.6.3, 2024 Supp. (1970).
[J-9A-2026, J-9B-2026, J-9C-2026 and J-9D-2026] - 14
Ordinance. Id. at 42. Moreover, the Board claims that the Marshalls were, in fact, granted
two use variances – one allowing the guest rooms of the B&B to be located in a structure
not classified as a Class I historic resource, and one permitting the guest rooms to be
located in a structure that is not owner-occupied.
The Solands, in their brief, expressly incorporate the arguments contained in the
Board’s brief. However, they emphasize that, in order for a dimensional variance to be
considered de minimis, the deviation from the zoning ordinance must be “relatively minor,”
such that strict compliance is not necessary to protect the public interest. Solands’ Brief
at 21. Maintaining that no lesser standard should be applied to use variances, the
Solands contend that the variances sought by the Marshalls are not minor, as they would
“nullif[y] the Township’s baseline [b]ed-and-breakfast estate scheme.” Id. at 22.
Specifically, the Solands assert that the variances requested by the Marshalls “strip away
those fundamental criteria” of the Ordinance that limits the location of guest rooms in a
B&B estate to owner-occupied, Class I historic resources. Id.
Further, with respect to the Commonwealth Court’s suggestion that the grant of a
de minimis variance to allow the Marshalls to use the unoccupied, Class II Tenant House
to accommodate the guest quarters is consistent with the spirit and intent of adaptive
historic repurposing, the Solands aver that the “spirit and intent” are “secondary
considerations in the de minimis context,” and the primary consideration is the extent of
deviation from the ordinance. Id. at 23. Observing that neither the ZHB, nor the
Commonwealth Court, addressed the question of the extent of deviation in the Marshalls’
requested variances, the Solands submit that, because the variances “do not merely
modify the pertinent ordinance provisions, they completely extinguish them,” the extent
of deviation is 100%. Id. at 23-24. Thus, the Solands contend that the variances sought
in the instant case are not de minimis.
[J-9A-2026, J-9B-2026, J-9C-2026 and J-9D-2026] - 15
In response to the Solands’ argument, the Marshalls emphasize that, of the 24
criteria imposed by the Ordinance, they applied for, and were granted, a variance as to
only one – Section 115-48.2(A)’s provision that “[t]he only buildings eligible for a bed-and-
breakfast estate use shall be owner-occupied Class I historic resources.” Ordinance, §
115-48.2(A). The Marshalls further argue that a variance’s degree of deviation must be
measured qualitatively, as opposed to quantitatively. In this respect, the Marshalls
maintain that their variance is “nothing more than a trifle,” because the entire Property,
including the Tenant House, is historic, and they intend to reside in the Paxson House,
“which is within close proximity to the Tenan t House.” Marshalls’ Brief in Response to
Solands’ Brief at 5.
Responding to the Board’s arguments, the Marshalls maintain that there is “no
statutory, public policy, or logical reason” to prohibit application of the de minimis doctrine
to use variances. Marshalls’ Brief in Response to Board’s Brief at 5. They highlight that
the de minimis doctrine has been applied in several areas of the law, including criminal
prosecutions, election cases, and trespass matters, and they submit that, when this Court
has determined that the doctrine does not apply, we have done so based on the express
language of the relevant statute. Id. at 8 (citing In re Amazon, Inc., 255 A.3d 191, 208
(Pa. 2021) (holding that the “all hours worked” language in the Pennsylvania Minimum
Wage Act evinced the legislature’s intent “that any portion of the hours worked by an
employee does not constitute a mere trifle,” and, therefore, the de minimis doctrine does
not apply to claims under the Act)). They further emphasize that the MPC does not
contain any language to suggest that the legislature intended to limit use of the de minimis
doctrine to only dimensional variances. Id. at 9.
The Marshalls additionally contend that, while there is a distinction between
dimensional variances and use variances, that distinction is relevant only with respect to
[J-9A-2026, J-9B-2026, J-9C-2026 and J-9D-2026] - 16
the quantum of proof an applicant must offer to satisfy the “unnecessary hardship”
requirement for a non-de minimis dimensional variance in Section 10910.2. Id. at 11.
They stress that, unlike cases involving a variance which is non -de minimis, there is no
set criteria to obtain a de minimis variance, as the right thereto is “premised upon the
insignificance of the variance and is appropriate only where rigid compliance with the
ordinance is unnecessary to protect the public policy concerns underlying the ordinance.”
Id. (citing, e.g., Nettleton, supra).
The Marshalls further aver that use and dimensional variance classifications may
fall into “grey areas,” as is the case with requests for variances from “steep slope
regulations.” Id. at 13 (citing In re Merion Ridge, LLC, 2024 WL 5038507 at *9-10 (Pa.
Cmwlth. filed Dec. 9, 2024) (unpublished memorandum) (“Requests for variances from
steep slope regulations are often considered a ‘hybrid’ request falling into a ‘grey area’
because they fit neither as dimensional variances nor use variances.”)). They submit that
the Ordinance at issue is a “prime example of the imprecision of variance classification,”
positing that “if a property could qualify as a bed-and-breakfast estate, a variance from
the [Ordinance] would not meet the accepted use variance definition because the
variance is not a proposal ‘to use property in a manner that is wholly outside zoning
regulations.’” Id. at 14 (citation omitted).
Acknowledging that appellate court case law discussing the application of the de
minimis doctrine to use variances is “sparse,” id. at 15, the Marshalls stress that neither
the MPC nor the Ordinance differentiate between use variances and dimensional
variances, and they maintain that this Court has never expressly held that there is a per
se prohibition against applying the de minimis doctrine to use variances. In this vein, the
Marshalls claim that the Board “overstates” this Court’s precedent regarding the limitation
of de minimis variance relief to dimensional variances. Id. at 16. For example, they assert
[J-9A-2026, J-9B-2026, J-9C-2026 and J-9D-2026] - 17
that our statement in Nettleton that the de minimis doctrine is limited to the grant of
dimensional variance relief was dicta because the case involved an existing
nonconformity, to which the de minimis doctrine does not apply. They further note that,
although we cited several cases in Bailey v. Zoning Bd. of Adjustment of City of
Philadelphia, 801 A.2d 492 (Pa. 2002), for the proposition that de minimis variances
generally have been granted only in cases involving a dimensional variance, Bailey
involved the Philadelphia Zoning Code rather than a variance request under the MPC.
Last, the Marshalls observe that, while this Court “addressed dimensional variance relief
under the MPC” in Beecham, we did not apply the de minimis doctrine, finding that the
applicant was seeking a non-de minimis dimensional variance. Id. at 18.
The Marshalls additionally challenge the Board’s prediction that application of the
de minimis doctrine to use variances will result in a flood of requests for use variances,
pointing to the fact that, since the Commonwealth Court’s decision in the instant case, no
other courts have cited to or applied that decision.
Finally, the Marshalls contend that the question of whether they actually occupy
the Tenant House is “a trifle,” because they could occupy the Tenant House if they so
desired. Id. at 22-23. They likewise assert that the issue of whether the Tenant House
is a Class I or Class II historic is “a trifle,” because the distinction between Class I and
Class II historic resources is “nebulous,” and the entire Property is considered historic.
Id. at 23. Thus, they argue that “[a]llowing a bed-and-breakfast estate to operate out of
a Class II historic resource, on a property designated as a Class I historic resource, is an
insignificant deviation from the . . . Ordinance and does not offend the public policy
underlying the ordinance,” such