Torrez v. Travel Centers of America
CourtCourt of Appeals of Oregon
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
DocketA186871
JudgeKamins
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
122 November 18, 2026 No. 1127
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE
STATE OF OREGON
In the Matter of the Compensation of Rosie Torrez,
Claimant.
Rosie TORREZ,
Petitioner,
v.
TRAVEL CENTERS OF AMERICA,
Respondent.
Workers’ Compensation Board
2300005BF;
A186871
Argued and submitted October 7, 2026.
Julene M. Quinn argued the cause and filed the briefs for
petitioner.
Alexander F. Sargent argued the cause for respondent.
Also on the brief was MacColl Busch Sato, PC.
Before Kamins, Presiding Judge, Lagesen, Chief Judge,
and Pagán, Judge.
KAMINS, P. J.
Reversed and remanded.
Cite as 355 Or App 122 (2026) 123
KAMINS, P. J.
Claimant seeks review of an order of the Workers’
Compensation Board awarding $9,500 in attorney fees.
Claimant had requested $13,050 in fees and now challenges
part of the reduction in fees in a single assignment of error.
Claimant contends that the board applied an incorrect legal
standard when it refused to award fees for hearing-level
counsel’s time spent assisting review-level counsel with cer-
tain tasks on review.1 For the reasons discussed below, we
reverse and remand.
We review the board’s legal conclusions for legal
error, its factual findings for substantial evidence, and its
exercise of discretion for abuse of discretion. ORS 183.482(8).
The board must award “a reasonable attorney fee” where,
as here, a request for review before the board is initiated
by an employer or insurer and the claimant prevails. ORS
656.382(2) (emphasis added). In determining a reasonable
fee, the board must consider the 12 factors given in OAR
438-015-0010(4). To facilitate our review, the board’s order
must identify the factors that are applicable and explain
how the board weighed them in its decision-making pro-
cess. See Acuna v. SAIF, 346 Or App 29, 584 P3d 322 (2025)
(reversing and remanding in part because the board’s order
did not articulate the connection between the factors consid-
ered and the conclusions drawn); Taylor v. SAIF, 295 Or App
199, 433 P3d 419 (2018), rev den, 365 Or 194 (2019) (same).
In this case, claimant sought attorney fees for her
hearing-level counsel’s time spent assisting her review-level
counsel. The board determined that “in the absence of an
explanation regarding its necessity,” hearing-level counsel’s
time spent reading and editing review-level counsel’s brief
and responding to emails from defense counsel regarding
briefing did not provide “a reasonable basis for an attorney
fee award in this case.” The board’s order also mentioned
that it was making its determination in relation to two of the
OAR 438-015-0010(4) reasonableness factors: time devoted
and complexity of the issues. However, the board did not
1
Claimant also argues that the board violated her due process rights by
awarding fees based on a rationale that her opponent did not raise. Because we
reverse for other reasons, we do not address claimant’s due process argument.
124 Torrez v. Travel Centers of America
explain how or why the complexity of the issues in this case
rendered hearing-level counsel’s involvement unreasonable.
To the extent that the board concluded that hear-
ing-level counsel’s involvement was unreasonable because
claimant had not shown that it was necessary, the board
applied an incorrect legal standard. See Bowman v. SAIF
Corp., 278 Or App 417, 374 P3d 1008 (2016) (holding that
the board committed legal error when it considered attor-
ney time spent at a particular stage of the review process
categorically unreasonable). Necessity is not one of the OAR
438-015-0010(4) reasonableness factors, and something
does not necessarily have to be “necessary” to be “reason-
able.” We therefore reverse and remand to the board to
reconsider whether claimant’s fee is reasonable. See ORS
656.382(2) (“[T]he employer or insurer shall be required to
pay the attorney of the claimant a reasonable attorney fee in
an amount set by the * * * board.”).
Reversed and remanded.