Question Submitted by: The Honorable Vicki Zemp Behenna, District Attorney, Oklahoma County
CourtOklahoma Attorney General Reports
Date FiledNovember 13, 2026
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
OSCN Found Document:Question Submitted by: The Honorable Vicki Zemp Behenna, District Attorney, Oklahoma County Question Submitted by: The Honorable Vicki Zemp Behenna, District Attorney, Oklahoma County 2026 OK AG 19 Decided: 11/13/2026 OKLAHOMA ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION Cite as: 2026 OK AG 19 , __ P.3d __ ¶0 This office has received your request for an Attorney General Opinion in which you ask, in effect, the following question: Is the Oklahoma County Criminal Justice Authority--a public trust formed to operate the Oklahoma County Detention Center--a custodian of county funds, such that the Oklahoma County Board of County Commissioners may request an audit of its "books and accounts" pursuant to title 74, section 212(I) of the Oklahoma Statutes? I. SUMMARY ¶1 While the Oklahoma County Budget Board appropriates county funds to the Oklahoma County Criminal Justice Authority ("Jail Trust") to operate the Oklahoma County Detention Center, those funds, once received by the Jail Trust, become part of its trust estate. Under title 60 of the Oklahoma Statutes and the trust instrument that created and now governs the Jail Trust, Oklahoma County has no present legal claim to, or interest in, the trust estate. As a result, funds in the Jail Trust's trust estate are not county funds for the purposes of title 74, section 212(I), and the Board of County Commissioners ("Board") therefore may not request an audit of the Jail Trust under that statute. Nevertheless, the Board has options under both title 60 and the trust instrument itself to ensure the Jail Trust properly and accurately accounts for funds expended. II. BACKGROUND ¶2 Oklahoma law provides for the formation of express trusts having public entities as their beneficiaries. 60 O.S.Supp.2025, § 176 60 O.S.2021, § 176 see also Lawson v. LeFlore Cnty. Detention Ctr. Pub. Tr. Sec. Comm'n , 2025 OK 87, ¶ 16 , 584 P.3d 1162 , 1168 ("Section 176(A) authorizes the creation of an express trust for the benefit of a county, provided it serves a lawful and proper public function or purpose of the county."); Immel v. Tulsa Pub. Facilities Auth. , 2021 OK 39, ¶ 27 , 490 P.3d 135, 144 ("[A] municipal public trust cannot do something its beneficiaries cannot do, except as authorized by statute."). The extent of a public trust's authority is also limited by the trust instrument; the trust cannot lawfully "engage in any activity or transaction that is not expressly authorized in the instruments or articles prescribing its creation except by express consent of the governmental agency . . . that created [it]." 60 O.S.2021, § 177 ¶3 At the county level, public trusts are often used to fund and operate the county jail. See, e.g. , Lawson , 2025 OK 87, ¶ 16 , 584 P.3d at 1168 (citing 60 O.S.Supp.2022, § 176 Tulsa Cnty. F.O.P., Lodge No. 188 v. Bd. of Cnty. Comm'rs of Tulsa Cnty. , 1998 OK 44 , ¶¶ 9-16, 959 P.2d 979, 981-82 . In 2019, the Board chairman created the Jail Trust as a title 60 trust, with Oklahoma County as the beneficiary. See Trust Indenture creating the Oklahoma County Criminal Justice Authority (as amended June 12, 2019) (hereafter, "Trust Indenture"). 1 Broadly speaking, the Jail Trust's purposes consist of financing and acquiring property for jail facilities and owning and operating such facilities. See TRUST INDENTURE, art. IV. ¶4 Like most public trusts, the Jail Trust may incur indebtedness to finance its operations. See TRUST INDENTURE, art. VII, VIII. However, the Trust Indenture also contemplates "[f]unding . . . from a general fund appropriation [as] determined solely by the Oklahoma County Budget Board." Id. , art. VI(3). In fact, Jail Trust operations appear to be funded almost exclusively by county appropriations. Accord 2007 OK AG 35 (opining that counties have a constitutional duty to provide for and fund operation of a county jail, whether through the county sheriff or a public trust). Recently, the Jail Trust's budget and funding levels have drawn public scrutiny, culminating in a supplemental appropriation earlier this year to cover a multimillion-dollar budget shortfall. See Oklahoma County Budget Board Meeting Minutes, p.2 (Mar. 31, 2026). ¶5 You have asked, in light of this background, whether the Board may request the State Auditor and Inspector ("State Auditor") to "examine the books and accounts" of the Jail Trust pursuant to title 74, section 212(I) of the Oklahoma Statutes. Section 212(I) empowers a board of county commissioners to make such a request as to "all or any of the officers or custodians of the various funds of the county[.]" Neither the Jail Trust nor its trustees, acting in that capacity, are "officers" of the county, a term defined by title 19 to include only "the county clerk, county commissioner, county assessor, district court clerk, county treasurer and county sheriff." 19 O.S.2021, § 161 2 III. DISCUSSION ¶6 It is well-established under Oklahoma law that a public trust is presumed to be "a legal entity separate and distinct from ... its beneficiary." 60 O.S.2021, § 176.1 3 Okla. City Zoological Tr. v. State ex rel. Pub. Emp. Rel. Bd. , 2007 OK 21 , ¶ 11, 158 P.3d 461, 466 . Accordingly, except where statute or the trust documents provide otherwise, the trust's affairs "shall be separate and independent from the affairs of the beneficiary in all matters or activities authorized by the written instrument creating such public trust including, but not limited to, the public trust's budget, expenditures, revenues and general operation and management of its facilities or functions[.]" 60 O.S.2021, § 176.1 see also id ., art. VIII(7) (same). Oklahoma County has "no legal title, claim or right to the Trust Estate, its income, or to any part thereof or to demand or require any partition or distribution thereof . . . nor the right to control or direct the actions of the Trustees pertaining to the Trust Estate or any part thereof ," except as set forth in the Trust Indenture. Id ., art. X(2) (emphasis added). ¶7 In the case of the respective entities' financial matters, the separation described above primarily ensures that debts of the public trust do not become debts of the public beneficiary, which are subject to constitutional limitations. See Bd. of Cnty. Comm'rs for Oklahoma Cnty. v. Warram , 1955 OK 198, ¶ 45 , 285 P.2d 1034, 1041 (explaining that public trust indebtedness is "clearly not of the character of obligations . . . prohibited by the constitution" because it is not "chargeable to general governmental funds, for the payment of which resort may be made to taxation"); see also Grimes v. City of Oklahoma City , 2002 OK 47, ¶¶ 19-21 , 49 P.3d 719, 726-27 (holding that public trust formed to manage sales tax revenues for benefit of local schools was constitutionally separate from its municipal beneficiary). At the same time, this office has previously suggested that this principle may not apply when the public trust receives general government funding. See 1986 OK AG 131 , ¶ 14 (concluding that constitutional limitations "clearly do not apply to the funds of public trusts which are generated outside the public treasury," but declining to "address the possible situation of the State or a subdivision appropriating money to a public trust and limitations or restrictions on these types of funds"); see also 2017 OK AG 4, ¶¶ 6-9 . ¶8 This opinion does not resolve these questions as to all public trusts. With respect to the Jail Trust, however, the answer is clear. The Trust Indenture provides that "all money . . . coming into the hands of the Trustees under this Trust Indenture" is part of the trust estate. TRUST INDENTURE, art. VI(1)(c). This explicitly includes county appropriations. Id ., art VI(3). And once part of the trust estate, the Trust Indenture also provides explicitly that Oklahoma County no longer retains any "legal title, claim or right to" those funds, "[their] income, or to any part thereof." Id. , art. X(2). 4 So while prior opinions did not reach this specific question, in this case the Trust Indenture answers it definitively. See 60 O.S.2021, § 178 see also 2004 OK AG 6 , ¶¶ 15-20 (acknowledging the primacy of a trust indenture in outlining the authority and operations of public trusts); 60 O.S.Supp.2025, § 1601.5 5 ¶9 Finally, this is not to say that the Board lacks options. Title 60 requires the Jail Trust, as a county-beneficiary public trust with assets and revenues above $50,000, to "cause an audit to be made of [its] financial statements" each year and file it with the State Auditor. 60 O.S.2021, § 180.1 60 O.S.Supp.2025, § 176 ¶10 It is, therefore, the official Opinion of the Attorney General that: Once funds are appropriated from Oklahoma County to the Jail Trust, the funds lose their identity as county funds and become part of the Jail Trust's trust estate. Because funds in the trust estate are not "funds of the county" for the purposes of title 74, section 212(I), the Board may not request an audit of the Jail Trust under that statute. The Board's audit rights related to the Jail Trust are set forth in title 60 and in the Trust Indenture. GENTNER DRUMMOND ATTORNEY GENERAL OF OKLAHOMA ETHAN SHANER DEPUTY GENERAL COUNSEL FOOTNOTES 1 Jail trusts may be created pursuant to title 60 or title 19 of the Oklahoma Statutes, and the choice of authorizing statute may result in differences in trust structure and operation. 2026 OK AG 8, ¶ 2 (citing Tulsa Cnty. F.O.P. , 1998 OK 44 , ¶¶ 15-17, 959 P.2d at 981-82 ). Because the Jail Trust was created under title 60, the conclusions reached in this opinion may not be applicable to comparable trusts formed under title 19. 2 Because the appropriated funds, once in the hands of the Jail Trust, are no longer "funds of the county," this opinion does not reach the question of whether the Jail Trust serves as a "custodian" of those funds. Nevertheless, the likely answer is no. A custodian is one who is responsible for securing and maintaining property and accounting for any changes to it. Custodian , BLACK'S LAW DICTIONARY (12th ed. 2024). For instance, the State Treasurer is "the custodian of the moneys for the state and is charged with the duty to pay warrants against this money when the same are legally presented. He must accept on behalf of the State any interest received on the deposit of state money and account for it." Winters v. Gov'rs Special Comm. , 1967 OK 249, ¶ 13 , 441 P.2d 370, 375 . The Jail Trust, by contrast, receives appropriations from Oklahoma County to carry out the functions set forth in the Trust Indenture. 3 Under section 176.1, this presumption is based on certain statutory conditions being satisfied. There is no reason to believe those conditions have not been satisfied with respect to the Jail Trust. 4 Oklahoma County's sole right to the trust estate comes "at the termination of the [Jail Trust], as provided [in the Trust Indenture], and only then, [it] shall receive the residue of the Trust Estate." TRUST INDENTURE, art. X(2). 5 The analysis and conclusion reached in this opinion hinge on specific terms of the Trust Indenture and therefore may not translate to other public trusts or entities that receive county funds. As a result, this opinion should be construed narrowly.