Davis v. Alpha Apt. Mgt., L.L.C.
CourtOhio Court of Appeals
Date FiledNovember 19, 2026
Docket116495
JudgeS. Gallagher
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
[Cite as Davis v. Alpha Apt. Mgt., L.L.C., 2026-Ohio-4586.]
COURT OF APPEALS OF OHIO
EIGHTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
COUNTY OF CUYAHOGA
GRACE DAVIS, :
Plaintiff-Appellee, :
No. 116495
v. :
ALPHA APARTMENT :
MANAGEMENT LLC,
:
Defendant-Appellant.
JOURNAL ENTRY AND OPINION
JUDGMENT: AFFIRMED
RELEASED AND JOURNALIZED: November 19, 2026
Civil Appeal from the Lakewood Municipal Court
Case No. CVI-2600016
Appearances:
Grace Davis, pro se.
Powers Friedman Linn, PLL, Thomas P. Owen, Rachel E.
Cohen, and David G. Kriedman, for appellant.
SEAN C. GALLAGHER, P.J.:
Defendant-appellant Alpha Apartment Management LLC (“Alpha”)
appeals the trial court’s decision to overrule an objection to a magistrate’s decision
and to award judgment to plaintiff-appellee Grace Davis in the amount of $6,000,
claiming Davis should only be entitled to nominal damages in this case. Upon
review, we affirm the judgment of the trial court.
There is no dispute in this small-claims case that Alpha, a landlord of
an apartment that was leased to Davis, mistakenly entered the premises and
removed Davis’s personal property. Davis provided an itemized list of items that
were improperly removed by Alpha and provided an amount for each item. The total
amount listed for all the items on her list was $6,633. Alpha offered Davis less, and
she thereafter filed a small-claims complaint to recover for her loss.
During the small-claims trial held on February 17, 2026, Davis
testified to how she determined a value for the listed items, stating she “just looked
up how much it would cost to replace the items. And then for any items that were
maybe gifted, for example . . . there were some paintings and ceramics that [my
sister] had made me, so I asked her how much it would have cost to make that again
for me.” Davis indicated that she did not have receipts for or photographs of the
items, that she had some of the items for years, and that some of the items were gifts.
She testified that she had “given reasonable replacement value.”
A maintenance worker for Alpha testified he removed bags and bins
from Davis’s apartment. The property manager for Alpha admitted the items were
mistakenly removed, but she expressed she could not “just pay [Davis] $6,000 with
no proof or photos or anything.” Davis confirmed for the court that “the values
given are values that [she] determined through [her] investigation through the
Internet and other sources.”
On March 3, 2026, the magistrate issued a decision. The magistrate
rejected Alpha’s claim that the items were not properly valued. The magistrate
found Davis “testified how items were valued,” determined that “[Davis’s] valuation
was done with due diligence and reasonable,” and incorporated the values given for
the items identified on Davis’s list. The magistrate found for Davis in the total
amount sought of $6,633 and awarded her the maximum allowable in small-claims
court of $6,000, plus interest and costs.
Alpha filed an objection to the magistrate’s decision and argued that
Davis’s valuation of the items using replacement costs was not proper and that the
magistrate failed to apply the appropriate standard regarding damages to personal
property. Alpha asserted that Davis should only be entitled to nominal damages,
not to exceed $500. A supplemental filing of the audio transcription of the small-
claims trial was timely filed. In her response to Alpha’s objection, Davis asserted,
among other arguments, that Alpha admitted to removing her personal
belongings, that Davis presented testimony and documentation establishing the
value of each item that was removed, that the magistrate determined Davis’s
valuation was reasonable, and that nominal damages were not appropriate. Alpha
filed a reply, in which it continued to maintain that Davis did not meet her burden
of proving compensatory damages in the case under the appropriate standard and
that only nominal damages should be awarded.
On April 20, 2026, the trial court issued a judgment entry. The trial
court independently reviewed the record and considered whether the magistrate
“utilized the proper valuation for [Davis’s] property that admittedly was destroyed
by [Alpha].” The trial court observed that several items included on Davis’s list, such
as “Custom Ceramic Pieces from Family,” “Framed Custom Art Pieces from Family
and Estate Sales,” and “Framed Family Pictures,” could not be replicated from a
retailer’s price. The trial court further found that “[b]oth the record and the
magistrate’s ruling reflect that [Davis] did not engage in ‘speculation or conjecture,’
nor offer a ‘mere guesstimate’ as to her damages,” and instead she “conducted a
reasonable investigation to determine the value of the items that were lost.” After
reviewing relevant case law, the trial court determined that Davis’s itemized list and
her associated testimony were deemed credible and accurate by the magistrate and
that although some courts have held that “replacement value” alone cannot support
a determination of damages, Davis “proved her damages with reasonable certainty
and likely did not rely exclusively upon replacement value.” The trial court
overruled Alpha’s objection and awarded Davis damages in the amount of $6,000
plus interest and costs. This appeal followed.
Under its two assignments of error, Alpha claims the trial court
erred (1) by awarding Davis damages that were calculated solely by replacement
value rather than market value, and (2) by awarding an amount more than nominal
damages.
We apply an abuse-of-discretion standard of review to small-claims
proceedings and to the trial court’s ruling on the objection to the magistrate’s
decision. See Gibson v. Shephard, 2017-Ohio-1157, ¶ 19 (8th Dist.). In this action,
the trial court independently reviewed the testimony and evidence provided,
considered governing case law, made factual findings that are supported by the
record, and applied a proper legal standard in determining the damages awarded.
The trial court was aware of the general rule that the measure of
damages for injury to personal property is the market value of the property at the
time it is taken, and it also understood that courts have held replacement value
alone is not enough to calculate damages, as found in Cooper v. Feeney, 34 Ohio
App.3d 282, 284 (12th Dist. 1986). However, as observed by the trial court, the
Ohio Supreme Court acknowledged in Smith v. Padgett, 32 Ohio St.3d 344, 347
(1987), that the owner of personal property is competent to testify to the market
value of such property, and the Ohio Supreme Court also noted in Bishop v. E. Ohio
Gas Co., 143 Ohio St. 541, 546 (1944), that “[t]he rule that the market value is the
measure of damages for the wrongful conversion of personal property is subordinate
to the fundamental rule that the owner must be fully compensated.” (Cleaned up.)
Id. Indeed, a market-value measure of damages “is a standard not a shackle” and
“[w]hen market value cannot be feasibly obtained, a more elastic standard is
resorted to, sometimes called the standard of value to the owner.” Id.
The trial court also followed this court’s decision in Gibson, in which
it was recognized that the rules of evidence are relaxed in small-claims actions, that
estimates are almost always used to establish damages in small-claims matters,
and that although damages cannot be based on speculation or conjecture, a
plaintiff need only prove damages with reasonable certainty. Id. at ¶ 31, 34
(citations omitted). In Gibson, this court found no abuse of discretion occurred
when a trial court awarded Gibson the amount of damages she sought for personal
property that had been improperly removed from her storage locker when she had
prepared a list of items that were taken and estimated the value of the items. Gibson,
2017-Ohio-1157, at ¶ 33-36. As with this case, in Gibson, the plaintiff did not have
receipts and had acknowledged the used condition of many of the items. Id. at ¶ 33.
Nevertheless, this did not prevent Gibson from proving her damages. Id. As this
court determined, Gibson testified regarding the list of items and their estimated
values, there was nothing to suggest she was offering the replacement price,
estimates could be used, and the property manager and landlord had an opportunity
to cross-examine Gibson regarding her list and claimed damages or to offer evidence
of an alternative valuation for the items identified on the list but failed to do so. Id.
at ¶ 33-34.
In this small-claims action, Davis testified she looked up replacement
costs for items on her list, and she believed she had given reasonable replacement
values. Davis also confirmed the values given were “determined through [her]
investigation through the Internet and other sources.” The trial court found that
Davis did not engage in speculation or conjecture, but she instead “conducted a
reasonable investigation” to determine the value of the items that were discarded
by Alpha.1 Alpha had the opportunity to cross-examine Davis, and Alpha did not
offer an alternative valuation for the items identified on Davis’s list. The trial court
also recognized that although Davis referred to values as “replacement costs,” there
were several items for which value could not be mechanically replicated from a
retailer’s price. The trial court reviewed the list and the substance of Davis’s
testimony and determined, as part of a sound reasoning process, that Davis proved
her damages with reasonable certainty and likely did not rely exclusively upon
replacement value. The trial court properly applied the governing law and correct
legal standard, and the court’s findings are supported by the record.
Upon our review, we find no abuse of discretion by the trial court in
awarding Davis $6,000 in damages. We are not persuaded by any of Alpha’s
arguments otherwise. The assignments of error are overruled.
Judgment affirmed.
It is ordered that appellee recover from appellant costs herein taxed.
The court finds there were reasonable grounds for this appeal.
It is ordered that a special mandate issue out of this court directing the
municipal court to carry this judgment into execution.
1 This case is distinguishable from Kavalec v. Ohio Express, Inc., 2016-Ohio-5925
(8th Dist.), which was not a small-claims action and wherein the testimony relating to
damages was speculative at best.
A certified copy of this entry shall constitute the mandate pursuant to Rule
27 of the Rules of Appellate Procedure.
_____
SEAN C. GALLAGHER, PRESIDING JUDGE
ANITA LASTER MAYS, J., and
TIMOTHY W. CLARY, J., CONCUR