Wengerd v. Summa Emergency Assocs., Inc.
CourtOhio Court of Appeals
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
Docket31785
JudgeManning
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
[Cite as Wengerd v. Summa Emergency Assocs., Inc., 2026-Ohio-4561.]
STATE OF OHIO ) IN THE COURT OF APPEALS
)ss: NINTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT
COUNTY OF SUMMIT )
MELISSA S. WENGERD C.A. No. 31785
Appellee
v. APPEAL FROM JUDGMENT
ENTERED IN THE
SUMMA EMERGENCY ASSOCIATES, COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
INC., et. al. COUNTY OF SUMMIT, OHIO
CASE No. CV 2023 12 5037
Appellants
DECISION AND JOURNAL ENTRY
Dated: November 18, 2026
MANNING, Judge.
{¶1} Defendant-Appellants, Summa Emergency Associates, Inc., Academic &
Community Emergency Specialists, Inc., Dr. Donald Kennedy, Dr. Paul Cornici, and Dr. Jeffrey
Wright (collectively, “Appellants”), appeal from the order of the Summit County Court of
Common Pleas. This Court affirms in part and reverses in part.
I.
{¶2} The instant appeal stems from a discovery dispute between Plaintiff-Appellee,
Melissa Wengerd, as Administratrix for the Estate of Edgar Gertsch (“the Estate”), and Summa
Emergency Associates, Inc. and Academic & Community Emergency Specialists, Inc.
(collectively, “ACES”). During the timeframe relevant to this appeal, ACES staffed the
emergency department at Wooster Community Hospital (“Wooster Community”). Dr. Wright, the
president of ACES, served as the Medical Director of the emergency department. Dr. Kennedy
served as one of its treating physicians by virtue of his employment with ACES.
2
{¶3} On December 28, 2022, Dr. Kennedy treated Mr. Gertsch for severe pain in his
right upper thigh/groin area. The Estate alleges that, while Mr. Gertsch was in the emergency
department for over five and a half hours, Dr. Kennedy only briefly met with him, did not perform
a physical exam, disregarded several abnormal lab results, and relied on an unremarkable x-ray.
The Estate alleges that Dr. Kennedy diagnosed hip strain and discharged Mr. Gertsch despite the
fact that morphine had not reduced his 10 out of 10 pain level. Dr. Kennedy provided Mr. Gertsch
with a prescription for pain relievers and instructed him to return if his condition did not improve.
Mr. Gertsch returned to the emergency department the following day when a rash appeared on his
groin. He became septic that afternoon and went into cardiac arrest that evening. He died several
hours later due to necrotizing fasciitis, an aggressive soft tissue bacterial infection.
{¶4} Relevant to this appeal, the Estate filed suit against Appellants and Wooster
Community. The suit alleged claims for medical negligence and wrongful death. Additionally, as
to ACES and Dr. Wright, it alleged claims for negligent hiring, training, retention, and supervision
and punitive damages. A discovery dispute ensued after the Estate requested the production of
certain documents. Those documents related to complaints that had been made about Dr. Kennedy.
{¶5} The Estate asked Wooster Community to produce any patient survey results, patient
reviews, patient satisfaction results, or similar items for Dr. Kennedy. It also asked Wooster
Community to produce any complaints and related documents received by the hospital’s patient
advocate(s) about Dr. Kennedy from 2014 to present as well as any follow-up communications.
The Estate asked ACES to produce certain information sent to Dr. Wright’s ACES email account.
Specifically, it asked ACES to produce from that email account all communications related to
concerns or complaints about Dr. Kennedy (1) from 2015 to present day, and (2) from 2015 to
December 28, 2022 (i.e., the day Dr. Kennedy treated Mr. Gertsch).
3
{¶6} After Wooster Community and ACES refused to produce the requested documents,
the Estate filed a motion to compel. It asked the trial court to conduct an in camera review of the
requested documents and, following its review, to compel their production. Wooster Community
and ACES opposed the motion to compel, and ACES moved for a protective order. Following
additional briefing and argument, the trial court issued a decision.
{¶7} As to Wooster Community, the court ordered the hospital to produce any patient
survey results, patient reviews, patient satisfaction results, or similar items for Dr. Kennedy that
were created before December 28, 2022. The court found the request for documents received by
the hospital’s patient advocate(s) to be a more complex issue. It determined that Wooster
Community had proven it had a peer review committee that conducted professional credentialing
and “quality review activities involving the competence of, professional conduct of, or quality of
care provided by health care providers.” Before May 2022, complaints were maintained in a
confidential file by the hospital’s Quality Department. After May 2022, complaints were logged
into a system called RLDatix. The court found that RLDatix contained a Feedback Manager
function that the Quality Department/Grievance Committee used in its peer review process.
Specifically, a Medical Review Committee within that department used the Feedback Manager to
review complaints and take any necessary corrective action regarding the medical staff. The court
found that any documents in the Feedback Manager were protected by the peer-review privilege
as well as “any documents maintained and used solely by the Medical Review Committee prior to
May 2022.” The court also recognized, however, that not every document in the possession of the
hospital’s patient advocate was a document used in the peer review process. The court ordered
Wooster Hospital to produce any patient complaints about Dr. Kennedy from 2014 through
December 28, 2022 that (1) were made to the patient advocate(s), (2) were not contained in the
4
RLDatix Feedback Manager, and (3) were not maintained or used solely by the Medical Review
Committee. Wooster Community did not appeal the trial court’s order.
{¶8} As to ACES, the trial court noted that ACES had admitted it was in possession of
emails that were responsive to the Estate’s request for the production of documents. ACES
claimed the documents were protected by the peer-review privilege because, in addition to being
the president of ACES, Dr. Wright was a member of Wooster Community’s Medical Executive
Committee. ACES also claimed that the documents were protected by the physician-patient
privilege, protected by HIPAA, and irrelevant to the litigation. The trial court found that it could
not rule on ACES’ arguments without inspecting the individual emails. Consequently, it ordered
ACES to submit the emails for in camera review.
{¶9} ACES submitted 66 pages of emails for the trial court’s inspection. Those pages
were Bates Stamped 210 through 275. Following its review, the trial court found that two pages
of the submitted emails were protected by the peer-review privilege. The court found the
remaining 64 pages discoverable and granted the Estate’s motion to compel as to those pages.
{¶10} Appellants now appeal from the trial court’s order compelling the production of
email pages Bates Stamped 210-214 and 217-275. They raise one assignment of error for review.
II.
ASSIGNMENT OF ERROR
THE TRIAL COURT ERRED IN GRANTING [THE ESTATE’S] MOTION TO
COMPEL AND DENYING [ACES’] MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER[.]
{¶11} In their assignment of error, Appellants argue that the trial court erred when it
ordered ACES to produce email pages Bates Stamped 210-214 and 217-275. They argue that those
pages are protected by the peer-review privilege as well as the physician-patient privilege/HIPAA.
5
{¶12} This Court generally reviews discovery orders under the abuse of discretion
standard. Li v. Du, 2022-Ohio-917, ¶ 7 (9th Dist.). “However, if the discovery issue involves an
alleged privilege, as in this case, it is a question of law that must be reviewed de novo.” Ward v.
Summa Health Sys., 2010-Ohio-6275, ¶ 13. “The party claiming the privilege has the burden of
proving that the privilege applies to the requested information.” Giusti v. Akron Gen. Med. Ctr.,
2008-Ohio-4333, ¶ 17 (9th Dist.). “[A]ny statutory privilege must be strictly construed against the
party seeking to assert it and may be applied only to those circumstances specifically named in the
statute.” Ward at ¶ 15.
Peer-Review Privilege
{¶13} “The peer-review privilege applies to ‘[p]roceedings and records within the scope
of a peer review committee of a health care entity.’” Stull v. Summa Health Sys., 2024-Ohio-5718,
¶ 17, quoting R.C. 2305.252(A). A “peer review committee” is
a utilization review committee, quality assessment committee, performance
improvement committee, tissue committee, credentialing committee, or other
committee that does either of the following:
(a) Conducts professional credentialing or quality review activities involving the
competence of, professional conduct of, or quality of care provided by health care
providers, including both individuals who provide health care and entities that
provide health care;
(b) Conducts any other attendant hearing process initiated as a result of a peer
review committee’s recommendations or actions.
R.C. 2305.25(E)(1)(a)-(b). Included within the definition of a peer review committee is a “board
or committee of a hospital . . . or other health care entity when reviewing professional
qualifications or activities of health care providers, including both individuals who provide health
care and entities that provide health care[.]” R.C. 2305.25(E)(2)(c).
{¶14} The peer-review privilege protects proceedings and records “arising out of matters
that are the subject of evaluation and review by the peer review committee.” R.C. 2305.252(A).
6
The purpose of the statutory privilege “is to protect the integrity of the peer-review process in order
to improve the quality of health care.” Giusti at ¶ 14. Nevertheless, the privilege “does not
necessarily expand to everything a peer-review committee touches.” Stull at ¶ 20.
{¶15} The peer-review privilege does not protect information, documents, or records
“otherwise available from original sources . . . merely because they were produced or presented
during the proceedings of a peer review committee . . . .” R.C. 2305.252(A). Those items simply
must be acquired from the original source rather than “from the peer review committee’s
proceedings or records.” Id. Notably, “it is possible for the health care entity itself to be the
original source . . . .” (Emphasis in original.) Cousino v. Mercy St. Vincent Med. Ctr., 2018-Ohio-
1550, ¶ 28 (6th Dist.). Accord Spurgeon v. Mercy Health-Anderson Hosp., LLC, 2020-Ohio-3099,
¶ 16 (1st Dist.).
[A] health care entity must produce documents responsive to a document request if
it created the document, the document was not generated by and/or exclusively for
a peer review committee, and the document is available outside of any peer review
committees’ records (i.e., employees, affiliates, officers, or directors of the health
care entity can access the document for non-peer review purposes).
(Emphasis omitted.) Bansal v. Mt. Carmel Health Sys., Inc., 2009-Ohio-6845, ¶ 16, fn. 3 (10th
Dist.). Accord Large v. Heartland-Lansing, 2013-Ohio-2877, ¶ 39 (7th Dist.) (“Documents that .
. . were not originally prepared exclusively for the [peer review] committee and are also accessible
to staff of the facility in their capacities as employees or managers of the facility, separate and
apart from any role on a review committee, are not in any way protected by the privilege.”).
{¶16} “A party claiming the peer-review privilege . . . must show that a peer-review
committee existed and that it actually investigated the incident.” Giusti at ¶ 17. The party also
must “show that each of the documents over which it asserts the privilege is a ‘‘record[ ] within
the scope of a peer review committee.’’” Meade v. Mercy Health-Regional Med. Ctr., LLC, 2019-
7
Ohio-438, ¶ 11 (9th Dist.), quoting Bansal v. Mt. Carmel Health Sys., Inc., et al., 2009-Ohio-6845,
¶ 15 (10th Dist.), quoting R.C. 2305.252(A). “[D]etails about the creation, purpose, and use of a
record, rather than the content of the record itself, indicate whether it is a ‘record[] within the scope
of a peer review committee,’ R.C. 2305.252(A).” Stull at ¶ 32. “When a party fails to present this
evidence, it fails to carry its burden[,] and the peer review privilege does not apply.” Meade at ¶
11.
{¶17} Before turning to the Bates Stamped pages the trial court ordered ACES to produce,
we begin by summarizing the evidence upon which the parties relied in the trial court. Jarrod Stahl
submitted an affidavit as Wooster Community’s Director of Quality Management; a role he had
held since September 2022. Mr. Stahl averred that the hospital used a computer software program
named RLDatix to log and track patient complaints. He explained that RLDatix had a Feedback
Manager function that the hospital used for quality and peer review purposes. According to Mr.
Stahl, every staff member at Wooster Community had access to RLDatix for the purpose of
entering patient complaints into its Feedback Manager. Once a complaint was entered, however,
only certain users could view it and information related to it. Mr. Stahl averred that, for physician
complaints, only users with a Ticket Manager role had access to all uploaded complaints. That
role was assigned to members of the hospital’s Quality Department/Grievance Committee and its
Risk Manager. Mr. Stahl further averred that individual users could gain access to a specific
complaint if assigned an Investigator role as part of the peer-review process. He explained that
the Investigator role would give the user access to an assigned physician complaint for the purpose
of performing work on behalf of the Grievance Committee or other peer review committee.
{¶18} Dr. James Mooney submitted an affidavit as Wooster Community’s Medical
Director of Quality; a role he had held since May 2022. He explained that he was involved in the
8
peer-review process and would oversee physician complaints. For about 14 months before he
became Medical Director of Quality, Dr. Mooney assisted the former Vice President of Quality in
the handling of such matters. He identified at least four other members of the Quality Department:
the Vice President of Quality Management, the Director of Quality Management (i.e., Mr. Stahl),
the Quality Coordinator, and the Patient Experience and Relations Coordinator (formerly known
as the Patient Advocate). He averred that patient complaints reported to the Quality Department
were treated as confidential peer review and quality assurance materials.
{¶19} Dr. Mooney averred that Wooster Community formalized the patient complaint
process following his appointment as Medical Director in May 2022. He stated that, before that
time, the Quality Department confidentially maintained and handled all physician complaints. If
the complaint warranted remediation, corrective action, or suspension of a medical staff member,
an additional committee became involved. Dr. Mooney explained that, before December 2022,
the Medical Review Committee was responsible for investigating and addressing those complaints.
He stated that the Medical Review Committee was a subcommittee of the Medical Executive
Committee, the governing body for physicians. Dr. Mooney averred that, after December 2022,
the Medical Executive Committee began directly addressing complaints formerly handled by the
subcommittee.
{¶20} Dr. Mooney averred that, after the patient complaint process became formalized in
the wake of his appointment, the Quality Department/Grievance Committee relied on RLDatix.
He stated that physician complaints reported to the Patient Advocate would be entered into
RLDatix’s Feedback Manager. Dr. Mooney averred that the Quality Department/Grievance
Committee reviewed every complaint entered by the Patient Advocate for purposes of reviewing
physician competence, professional conduct, and/or quality of care. Physician complaints would
9
then be forwarded to him and the Quality Coordinator for further action. He stated that he and the
Quality Coordinator would review all reported physician complaints on a weekly basis to
determine the appropriate track for handling the complaint. He averred that some complaints
warranted further investigation “by the Quality Department/Grievance Committee via referral to
the appropriate peer review committee.” He stated that, “[b]ased on the complaint, any
investigation, and outcome of that investigation process, the matter [could] then be referred to the
Department Head with instructions for addressing the matter with the physician including
awareness or coaching or it [could] be referred to Medical Executive Committee[] if formal
intervention by it [was] necessary.” Regarding the documents the Estate asked Wooster
Community to produce, Dr. Wright averred that any documentation related to and all complaints
received by the Patient Advocate about Dr. Kennedy were treated as confidential under quality
assurance and peer-review statutes.
{¶21} Dr. Jeffrey Wright, the President of ACES, testified by deposition and later
completed an affidavit. Dr. Wright testified that ACES staffed Wooster Community. Although
he was employed by ACES, Dr. Wright served as the Medical Director of Wooster Community’s
Emergency Department by virtue of the staffing contract. In that role, he would act as a liaison
between the hospital and ACES, handle staffing complaints, review quality issues, and oversee the
medical care in the department. He testified that he was also a member of the hospital’s Medical
Executive Committee due to his role as Medical Director (i.e., the department head for the
Emergency Department). He stated that the Medical Executive Committee met monthly to “go[]
over stuff with the hospital and . . . coordinat[e] care between the different departments and things
like that.”
10
{¶22} Dr. Wright testified that Wooster Community had a peer review committee for the
department, a quality committee for the entire hospital, and a Medical Review Committee. While
he would receive feedback from peer-review, Dr. Wright testified that he was “not on the peer-
review committee, per se.” If an official complaint was filed against a physician in the emergency
department, Dr. Wright testified that he would be notified through his ACES email account. He
testified that he would receive those emails from Dr. Mooney “or the people on his staff for quality,
which would be [the Vice President of Quality Management] or [the Quality Coordinator] . . . .”
He testified that he sometimes also received informal complaints from the nursing staff and other
departments who might have an issue with one of his staff. He confirmed that he had received
informal complaints about every physician in his group, including Dr. Kennedy.
{¶23} Dr. Wright testified that, if he received an email with a formal complaint, he would
review the complaint, review the chart, usually speak with those involved, and possibly follow up
with the patient or the patient’s family. Afterwards, he would report back to the Quality
Department to notify the department that he had spoken with those involved. For informal
complaints, Dr. Wright testified that he would generally speak with the chair of the department
that raised the complaint.
{¶24} In his affidavit, Dr. Wright averred that ACES was responsible for various duties
related to Wooster Community’s Emergency Department, including risk management, corporate
compliance, accreditation functions, and “Medical Staff quality performance improvement
activities . . . .” He wrote that, “[a]s part of its quality performance improvement obligations,
ACES [had] adopted a formal complaint resolution process by which it [would] receive,
investigate, and address patient complaints, and take action as warranted.” Dr. Wright did not
11
clearly explain whether that formal complaint resolution process existed separate and apart from
the process Wooster Community employed.
{¶25} Dr. Wright averred that, as part of his duties as Medical Director of the Emergency
Department, he served on the hospital’s Medical Executive Committee. He stated that the
committee met monthly to discuss a variety of issues. According to Dr. Wright, one function of
the committee was to review physician complaints that had been filed by patients and forwarded
to the committee via the quality and peer-review process. He indicated that, following its review,
the committee would make a recommendation as to how to handle those complaints.
{¶26} Dr. Wright averred that, in his role as Medical Director, he sometimes received
physician complaints formally through the quality and peer-review process or informally through
oral statements. Regarding formal complaints, Dr. Wright indicated that he would either be
notified of the final outcome of a complaint or asked to “take further action in connection with [the
hospital’s] quality and peer review process.” Such actions entailed reviewing all information sent
through peer review, reviewing any charts or labs, conducting any interviews, following up with
the complainant, and communicating any resolution.
{¶27} Finally, Dr. Wright averred that formal patient complaints could be a factor the
Medical Executive Committee considered when deciding whether to grant a practitioner clinical
privileges at the hospital. He explained that those complaints still would have had to be presented
to the Medical Executive Committee through the quality and peer-review process. According to
Dr. Wright, any formal patient complaints about Dr. Kennedy were “maintained in a separate and
confidential file which [he] did not have access to unless provided to [him] through [the hospital’s]
quality and peer review process, or to be considered by the [Medical Executive Committee] as part
of the credentialing process.”
12
{¶28} Registered Nurse Brett Connors, the former Patient Advocate for Wooster
Community, testified by deposition. He testified that the hospital created a full-time Patient
Advocate position in January of 2022. For two years before that point, Nurse Connors worked as
a part-time Patient Advocate in addition to his other duties. He testified that, at that time, he aided
the former Vice President of Quality, who was the only other individual who performed patient
advocate work. He testified that, in his role as Patient Advocate, he would act in an ombudsman
role for the hospital by speaking with patients, directors, and staff, addressing patient concerns,
and attempting to find resolutions for those patients.
{¶29} Nurse Connors testified that, in October 2022, he was given additional
responsibilities through the Quality Department. Specifically, he was asked to screen medical
charts and pass along any concerns to Dr. Mooney, the Medical Director of Quality. Nurse
Connors testified that the Quality Department would notify him which charts they wanted him to
review. He stated that he eventually began receiving feedback from Dr. Mooney and emailing
letters to physicians on his behalf. He testified that Dr. Mooney would be cc’d on those emails,
and the emails would include a standard reference to the content being protected/privileged. Nurse
Connors did not recall sending any such emails/letters before 2023.
{¶30} Nurse Connors testified that he could be alerted to patient concerns by several
means, including phone calls, in person conversations, emails, patient surveys, and Google alerts.
He testified that he would enter patient complaints into RLDatix “for the most part” but “wouldn’t
necessarily enter something that was able to be resolved in real[-]time with a quick conversation.”
He denied that he would directly notify a physician when he received a formal complaint about
the physician and entered it into RLDatix. Nevertheless, he acknowledged that he had addressed
real-time complaints directly with physicians and supervisors. He testified that, for real-time
13
physician complaints, he had both spoken to the physician “as the advocate” and had entered the
complaints into RLDatix. He stated that he essentially “wore two hats” during his time as Patient
Advocate. He explained that he would receive complaints as an advocate but enter complaints
into the RLDatix while fulfilling his duties to the Quality Department.
{¶31} Nurse Connors testified that he never served on a peer review committee, was not
familiar with Wooster Community’s peer review committees, and was not involved with anything
related to the Medical Executive Committee or its former subcommittee, the Medical Review
Committee. Nurse Connors also was not aware of Dr. Wright being on any committee outside of
being head of the Emergency Department. He could not recall any time before 2023 when he
notified Dr. Wright of a complaint about Dr. Kennedy.
{¶32} The privilege log ACES submitted with its initial motion for protective order/brief
in opposition to the motion to compel was extremely limited. It only consisted of three columns:
(1) a Bates Stamp column identifying groups of Bates Stamped pages by number, (2) a
privilege/objection column listing the statutes under which ACES was claiming privilege, and (3)
a column identifying the specific request for production to which ACES was responding. The log
consisted of two rows with the Bates Stamped pages being split into two groupings. ACES did
not offer any description of the Bates Stamped pages, either by individual page or grouping. Nor
did its affiants/witnesses specifically address any of the Bates Stamped pages in their respective
affidavits/depositions. With that in mind, we turn to the Bates Stamped pages.
Bates Stamped Pages 210-213
{¶33} Bates Stamped Pages 210-213 consist of an email and related attachments. The
email was sent by Nurse Connors to Dr. Wright. It was dated after May 2022, the point at which
Wooster Community began using RLDatix. The email notified Dr. Wright that a patient had left
14
negative comments on the hospital’s public website and on a survey. The email was not labeled
confidential, did not reference quality, peer review, the Medical Executive Committee, or Dr.
Mooney, and did not ask Dr. Wright to take any action. By comparison, the only email pages the
trial court found to be privileged (i.e., Bates Stamped Pages 215-216) contained an explicit
reference to the fact that the pages had been generated for peer-review purposes and were
privileged/protected. Bates Stamped Pages 210-213 contained no such reference.
{¶34} As previously noted, a party claiming peer-review privilege bears the burden of
showing that a peer review committee actually investigated an incident and that each allegedly
privileged document is a record within the scope of the committee. Giusti, 2008-Ohio-4333, at ¶
17 (9th Dist.); Meade, 2019-Ohio-438, at ¶ 11 (9th Dist.). ACES essentially sought to fulfill that
burden by producing evidence that, in general, Wooster Community kept confidential all formal
patient complaints reported to the Quality Department and/or entered into the RLDatix Feedback
Manager. Their affiants/witnesses testified extensively about that process. Yet, no affiant or
witness testified as to whether the complaint at issue in Bates Stamped Pages 210-213 was actually
investigated or whether the email sent by Nurse Connors to Dr. Wright was a record within the
scope of the peer review committee.
{¶35} Nurse Connors indicated that, in his role as Patient Advocate, he “wore two hats”
because he would input information for the Quality Department but also speak with patients and
hospital staff, address patient concerns, and attempt to find resolutions for those patients. While
he would enter patient complaints into RLDatix “for the most part,” he admitted there were
instances where he had addressed real-time complaints informally. He also indicated that, even if
he entered a complaint into RLDatix, he also might address it directly with a physician while acting
“as the advocate.” Nurse Connors confirmed that he did not have any role on the peer review
15
committee or the Medical Executive Committee. He also confirmed that he was not aware of any
role Dr. Wright played at the hospital apart from being head of the Emergency Department.
{¶36} Upon review, ACES failed to set forth evidence that a peer review committee
actually investigated the complaint referenced in Bates Stamped Pages 210-213 or that those pages
were a record within the scope of that committee. See Giusti, 2008-Ohio-4333, at ¶ 17 (9th Dist.);
Meade, 2019-Ohio-438, at ¶ 11 (9th Dist.). When examining whether a record is within the scope
of a peer review committee, details about its creation, purpose, and use are critical. Stull, 2024-
Ohio-5718, at ¶ 32. Neither Nurse Connors nor any other witness provided any details about the
purpose or use of the email Nurse Connors sent to Dr. Wright. There was no evidence that the
email was generated in connection with RLDatix or was sent on behalf of Dr. Mooney. There was
no evidence that the email was generated in connection with the Medical Executive Committee.
Moreover, there was no evidence that Dr. Wright, who admitted he was not a member of the peer
review committee, had been assigned an Investigator role in connection with the complaint
referenced in the email. Even if the complaint resulted in a confidential investigation, the peer-
review privilege does not protect documents that were not generated by and/or exclusively for a
peer review committee and are available from an outside source. Bansal, 2009-Ohio-6845, at ¶
16, fn. 3 (10th Dist.); R.C. 2305.252(A). ACES failed to establish that Nurse Connors’ email was
created by or for a peer review committee such that it did not constitute an original source. See
Spurgeon, 2020-Ohio-3099, at ¶ 16 (1st Dist.); Cousino, 2018-Ohio-1550, at ¶ 28 (6th Dist.)
(hospital itself can be an original source). Accordingly, the trial court did not err by concluding
that Bates Stamped Pages 210-213 were not protected by the peer-review privilege.
16
Bates Stamped Page 214
{¶37} Bates Stamped Page 214 consists of an email. The email was sent by Nurse
Connors to Dr. Wright. It was dated after May 2022, the point at which Wooster Community
began using RLDatix. The email notified Dr. Wright that Nurse Connors had received a phone
complaint. It also provided details about the complaint. The email was not labeled confidential,
did not reference quality, peer review, the Medical Executive Committee, or Dr. Mooney, and did
not ask Dr. Wright to take any action.
{¶38} For the same reasons outlined above, we must conclude that ACES did not satisfy
their burden with respect to Bates Stamped Page 214. They did not set forth any evidence that a
peer review committee actually investigated the complaint referenced in Nurse Connors’ email or
that his email was a record within the scope of that committee. See Giusti, 2008-Ohio-4333, at ¶
17 (9th Dist.); Meade, 2019-Ohio-438, at ¶ 11 (9th Dist.). Neither Nurse Connors nor any other
witness provided any details about the purpose or use of the email Nurse Connors sent to Dr.
Wright beyond merely notifying him that a patient had complained. There was no evidence that
the email was generated in connection with RLDatix or the Medical Executive Committee. Even
if the complaint referenced in the email resulted in a confidential investigation, ACES failed to
establish that the email was created by or for a peer review committee such that it did not constitute
an original source. See Spurgeon, at ¶ 16 (1st Dist.); Cousino, 2018-Ohio-1550, at ¶ 28 (6th Dist.)
(hospital itself can be an original source). Accordingly, the trial court did not err by concluding
that Bates Stamped Page 214 was not protected by the peer-review privilege.
Bates Stamped Pages 217-222
{¶39} Bates Stamped Pages 217-222 consist of an email thread. The thread included
emails between Nurse Connors, Dr. Wright, and Dr. Kennedy. It began with an email from Nurse
17
Connors, sharing a complaint he received from a patient. The thread included related responses
from Dr. Wright and Dr. Kennedy. The emails were dated before May 2022, the point at which
Wooster Community began using RLDatix. None of the emails were labeled confidential or
referenced quality, peer review, the Medical Executive Committee, or Dr. Mooney.
{¶40} For the same reasons outlined above, we must conclude that ACES did not satisfy
their burden with respect to Bates Stamped Pages 217-222. They did not set forth any evidence
that a peer review committee actually investigated the complaint referenced in the email thread or
that the email thread was a record within the scope of that committee. See Giusti at ¶ 17; Meade
at ¶ 11. Neither Nurse Connors nor any other witness provided any details about the purpose or
use of the email thread. There was no evidence that the thread was generated in connection with
the Quality Department or Medical Executive Committee. Even if the complaint referenced in the
thread resulted in a confidential investigation, ACES failed to establish that the email thread was
created by or for a peer review committee such that it did not constitute an original source. See
Spurgeon at ¶ 16; Cousino at ¶ 28 (hospital itself can be an original source). Accordingly, the trial
court did not err by concluding that Bates Stamped Pages 217-222 were not protected by the peer-
review privilege.
Bates Stamped Pages 223-237
{¶41} Bates Stamped Pages 223-237 consist of email threads. The threads included
emails between Wooster Community’s Director of Marketing & Public Relations, Dr. Wright,
Nurse Connors, another staff member, and Dr. Kennedy. The threads began with an email from
the Director of Marketing & Public Relations, forwarding a negative review to Nurse Connors and
another staff member. The latter forwarded the original email to Dr. Wright who in turn forwarded
it to Dr. Kennedy while also corresponding with Nurse Connors. Each of the emails in the thread
18
were dated before May 2022, the point at which Wooster Community began using RLDatix. None
of the emails were labeled confidential or referenced quality, peer review, the Medical Executive
Committee, or Dr. Mooney.
{¶42} Upon review, ACES did not satisfy their burden with respect to Bates Stamped
Pages 223-237. They did not set forth any evidence that a peer review committee actually
investigated the complaint referenced in the email threads or that the threads were a record within
the scope of that committee. See Giusti at ¶ 17; Meade at ¶ 11. Neither Nurse Connors nor any
other witness provided any details about the purpose or use of the email threads, and the threads
originated from the Director of Marketing & Public Relations. There was no evidence that the
Director of Marketing & Public Relations or the other staffing member on the emails were involved
in the peer review process. Even if the complaint referenced in the email threads resulted in a
confidential investigation, ACES failed to establish that the email threads were created by or for a
peer review committee such that they did not constitute an original source. See Spurgeon at ¶ 16;
Cousino at ¶ 28 (hospital itself can be an original source). Accordingly, the trial court did not err
by concluding that Bates Stamped Pages 223-237 were not protected by the peer-review privilege.
Bates Stamped Pages 238-243
{¶43} Bates Stamped Pages 238-243 consist of email threads. The threads included
emails between the former Vice President of Quality and Patient Safety, Dr. Wright, Nurse
Connors, and Dr. Kennedy. The threads began with an email from the former Vice President of
Quality and Patient Safety, notifying Dr. Wright of a phone complaint she received. The Vice
President specified that she was acting in the role of Patient Advocate while Nurse Connors was
unavailable. Each of the emails in the thread were dated before May 2022, the point at which
19
Wooster Community began using RLDatix. None of the emails were labeled confidential or
referenced quality, peer review, or the Medical Executive Committee.
{¶44} For reasons previously outlined, ACES did not satisfy their burden with respect to
Bates Stamped Pages 238-243. They did not set forth any evidence that a peer review committee
actually investigated the complaint referenced in the email threads or that the threads were a record
within the scope of that committee. See Giusti at ¶ 17; Meade at ¶ 11. Neither the originator of
the thread nor any other witness provided any details about the purpose or use of the email threads.
There was no evidence that the thread was generated in connection with the Quality Department
or Medical Executive Committee. Even if the complaint referenced in the threads resulted in a
confidential investigation, ACES failed to establish that the email threads were created by or for a
peer review committee such that they did not constitute an original source. See Spurgeon at ¶ 16;
Cousino at ¶ 28 (hospital itself can be an original source). Accordingly, the trial court did not err
by concluding that Bates Stamped Pages 238-243 were not protected by the peer-review privilege.
Bates Stamped Pages 244-253
{¶45} Bates Stamped Pages 244-253 consist of email threads. The threads included
emails between Nurse Connors, Dr. Wright, another staff member, and Dr. Kennedy. The threads
began with an email from Nurse Connors, notifying Dr. Wright of a complaint he received from a
patient’s family member. Nurse Connors also cc’d another staff member. Dr. Wright responded
and forwarded the original email to Dr. Kennedy. The thread also contained additional responses.
Each of the emails in the t