Connelly v. Connelly
CourtOhio Court of Appeals
Date FiledNovember 19, 2026
DocketL-25-00313
JudgeWillamowski
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
[Cite as Connelly v. Connelly, 2026-Ohio-4572.]
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF OHIO
SIXTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
LUCAS COUNTY
WILLIAM CONNELLY,
CASE NO. L-25-00313
PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE,
v.
CARRIE CONNELLY, OPINION AND
JUDGMENT ENTRY
DEFENDANT-APPELLANT.
Appeal from Lucas County Common Pleas Court
Domestic Relations Division
Trial Court No. DR2012 1096
Judgment Affirmed
Date of Decision: November 19, 2026
APPEARANCES:
Carrie A. Connelly, Appellant
Patricia A. Kovacs for Appellee
Case No. L-25-00313
WILLAMOWSKI, J.
{¶1} Defendant-appellant Carrie Connelly (“Mother’) brings this appeal
from the judgment of the Court of Common Pleas of Lucas County, Domestic
Relations Division, modifying child support between Mother and plaintiff-appellee
William Connelly (“Father”). On appeal Mother claims that the trial court erred by
1) considering facts not properly before the trial court to justify the deviation and 2)
granting an extreme downward deviation in child support. For the reasons set forth
below, the judgment is affirmed.
{¶2} The parties divorced in 2013 and a shared parenting plan was
implemented in regards to their two children (born 2007 and 2010). As part of the
order, the decree ordered Father to pay Mother $1,745.48 per month in child
support. The amount was a deviation from the guideline calculation of $1,894.34
per month. On October 27, 2023, Father filed a motion to vacate the shared
parenting plan and to designate him as the residential parent and legal custodian of
the children. Mother filed a response on November 29, 2023, requesting that
Father’s motion be dismissed, requested a modification of child support, and
requested an award of attorney fees. Father then requested a guardian ad litem
(“GAL”) be appointed and the trial court did so on January 25, 2024. On June 7,
2024, Father filed a motion to amend his motion to vacate indicating he no longer
wished to vacate the shared parenting plan, just to modify it and requesting that his
-2-
Case No. L-25-00313
child support be decreased. The trial was held on June 24, 2024, with both children
being interviewed in camera. Testimony was presented by Father, Mother, and the
GAL. The trial court issued a decision on July 22, 2024. The decision modified the
shared parenting schedule to be one where the parties alternated weeks. The trial
court then ordered a deviation in support of $1,407.37 per month due to the equal
parenting time. Father was then ordered to pay Mother $140.71 per month. Mother
appealed from the judgment.
{¶3} While the first appeal was pending, Mother filed a motion to reallocate
the tax credits. A hearing was held on this motion on September 19, 2025. At the
beginning of this hearing, the parties agreed the purpose of the hearing was “solely
regarding the allocation of the children for tax purposes.” Tr. 5. The trial court
ruled on this motion on October 1, 2025.
{¶4} On October 28, 2025, this Court affirmed the modification of parenting
time schedule, but reversed and remanded the deviation in child support due to the
trial court having overlooked making certain findings of fact and conclusions of law.
Connelly v. Connelly, 2025-Ohio-4929 (6th Dist.) (“Connelly I”). The trial court
entered a new judgment making the required findings of fact and conclusions of law
on November 21, 2025. The trial court again ordered a deviation and ordered Father
to pay Mother $140.71 per month. Mother appealed from this judgment and raised
the following assignments of error.
-3-
Case No. L-25-00313
First Assignment of Error
The trial court erred by violating the basic concept of due process
when using facts from a hearing unrelated to child support, held
while the first appeal was pending.
Second Assignment of Error
The trial court abused its discretion by granting an extreme
downward deviation in child support that is unsupported by the
record and contrary to law.
{¶5} In the first assignment of error, Mother alleges that the trial court erred
by considering information from a hearing not related to child support and held
while the first appeal was pending to support the deviation. When a trial court is
determining child support for a shared parenting order, the trial court must consider
the circumstances of the parties and enter the amount calculated in the child support
worksheet in its journal entry. R.C. 3119.22. The decision whether to deviate from
the calculated amount is left to the sound discretion of the trial court. Hurdelbrink
v. Hurdelbrink, 45 Ohio App.3d 5 (6th Dist. 1989). To deviate from this amount,
the trial court must then determine that the calculated amount would be unjust or
inappropriate and not in the child’s best interest. R.C. 3119.22. The trial court must
also enter findings of fact supporting that determination. R.C. 3119.22. The failure
to provide the required findings is reversible error. Connelly I, supra. Upon
remand, the trial court must take up the matter at the point where the first error was
committed. Miller v. Miller, 114 Ohio App. 234 (6th Dist. 1960). A new hearing
-4-
Case No. L-25-00313
is not required if the issue can be resolved without further evidence. Flynn v. Flynn,
2004-Ohio-3881 (10th Dist.).
{¶6} In this case, the trial court made the required findings to deviate from
the calculated amount of child support. While considering the deviation factors
under R.C. 3119.23, the trial court did note that Father had paid for a trip to Spain
for the children that cost approximately $10,000. This was in response to the “in
kind contributions” factor under R.C. 3119.23(I). This information was learned
from the tax exemption hearing and arguably should not have been considered by
the trial court as it was information from a hearing which was limited to the
allotment of the tax exemption. However, “[i]t is axiomatic that an error must be
prejudicial to warrant a reversal of a judgment based upon that error.” Hunley v.
Hunley, 2020-Ohio-5053, ¶ 60 (12th Dist.). An error is not deemed prejudicial if
no change in the result would result from the avoidance of the error. Goins v.
Oliverio, 2010-Ohio-3849 (9th Dist.).
{¶7} In this case, even assuming that the trial court erred by considering
information from a second hearing not for the purpose of determining child support,
we cannot find that the error was prejudicial. First, the hearing was one at which
Mother was present and was able to present evidence regarding her in kind
contributions and cross-examine Father’s presentation of evidence. Second, the
statements to which Mother points were only a minimal part of the facts found when
the trial court considered the statutory factors for deviation. Several other factors
-5-
Case No. L-25-00313
were included, such as the testimony that they each purchased “clothing and other
associated expenses of the children when they are in their care and custody and in
their home.” October 28, 2025 Judgment Entry. Based upon the record before it,
the trial court determine that not allowing a deviation “would be unjust and
inappropriate and not in the best interest of the children.” Oct. 28, 2025 Judgment
Entry. The trial court based this conclusion on the facts that the parents split the
parenting time equally and noted that not deviating would reduce Father’s gross
income from $147,293.84 to $128,717.00 while raising Mother’s income from
$118,211.00 to $136,787.00. The trial court also noted that Father was responsible
for paying 55% of expenses for the children while Mother was responsible for 45%.
Additionally, we note that the amount of deviation did not change from that ordered
in Connelly I to this order. Based upon the record before us we do not find that the
trial court committed prejudicial error by mentioning a fact from a later hearing.
The first assignment of error is overruled.
{¶8} Mother’s second assignment of error challenges the trial court’s
decision to deviate from the calculated child support amount. As noted above, the
decision as to whether to deviate from the calculated amount is left to the sound
discretion of the trial court. "Absent an abuse of discretion, a trial court's decision
on whether or not to deviate from the child support guidelines will not be reversed."
Kitchen v. Kitchen, 2006-Ohio-6542, ¶10 (12th Dist.). An abuse of discretion
“implies that the court’s attitude is unreasonable, arbitrary or unconscionable.”
-6-
Case No. L-25-00313
State v. Adams, 62 Ohio St.2d 151, 157 (1980). An abuse of discretion is a judgment
that is against reason and evidence. State v. Hancock, 2006-Ohio-160, ¶ 130.
{¶9} Initially, we note that Father’s obligation on the worksheet was
$1,548.08 and Mother’s obligation was $1,266.67, for a difference of $281.41 a
month. Mother’s obligation was subject to a deviation of 100% so that she pays no
support. Father’s obligation was deviated by approximately 90% and he was
ordered to pay support of $140.71 per month. Thus, the net difference between what
Mother would have received with no deviation is $140.70.
{¶10} In support of her argument, Mother claims that the trial court was
misinterpreting the evidence before it. A review of the record shows that the trial
court’s findings are supported by the evidence in the record from the June 2024
hearing (excluding the information discussed above). The trial court previously
erred by failing to “make a finding that the failure to deviate was not in the best
interest of the children or that a failure to deviate would be unjust or inappropriate
and did not set forth any findings of fact supporting the decision.” Connelly I at ¶
12. The trial court has now made the required finding. The trial court also attached
a copy of the worksheet, stated the calculated amount in the journal entry, and made
findings of fact supporting the determination. Thus, the trial court has met all of the
statutory requirements to deviate from the amount of child support. Mother’s
disagreeing with the trial court’s determination as to what facts were important is
not a basis for finding that the trial court erred. A reviewing court will not overturn
-7-
Case No. L-25-00313
the findings of fact by a trial court if the record contains some competent, credible
evidence supporting them. Bell v. Bell, 2017-Ohio-7956. As there is some
competent, credible evidence to support the factual determinations of the trial court,
we do not find the trial court erred in making its factual findings. Nor do we find
that the trial court’s judgment was unreasonable, arbitrary, or unconscionable. The
second assignment of error is overruled.
{¶11} Having found no error prejudicial to appellant in the particulars
assigned and argued, the judgment of the Court of Common Pleas of Lucas County,
Domestic Relations Division, is affirmed.
Judgment Affirmed
ZIMMERMAN, P.J. and WALDICK, J., concur.
-8-
Case No. L-25-00313
JUDGMENT ENTRY
For the reasons stated in the opinion of this Court, the assignments of error
are overruled and it is the judgment and order of this Court that the judgment of the
trial court is affirmed with costs assessed to Appellant for which judgment is hereby
rendered. The cause is hereby remanded to the trial court for execution of the
judgment for costs.
It is further ordered that the Clerk of this Court certify a copy of this Court’s
judgment entry and opinion to the trial court as the mandate prescribed by App.R.
27; and serve a copy of this Court’s judgment entry and opinion on each party to the
proceedings and note the date of service in the docket. See App.R. 30.
John R. Willamowski, Judge
William R. Zimmerman, Judge
Juergen A. Waldick, Judge
DATED:
/hls
Judges William R. Zimmerman, John R. Willamowski, and Juergen A.
Waldick, from the Third District Court of Appeals, sitting by assignment of
the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Ohio.
-9-