State ex rel. Copeland v. Michael
CourtOhio Court of Appeals
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
Docket32061
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
[Cite as State ex rel. Copeland v. Michael, 2026-Ohio-4560.]
STATE OF OHIO ) IN THE COURT OF APPEALS
)ss: NINTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT
COUNTY OF SUMMIT )
STATE OF OHIO EX REL. YVETTE C.A. No. 32061
COPELAND
Relator
v.
JUDGE KATHRYN MICHAEL ORIGINAL ACTION IN
MANDAMUS AND
Respondent PROCEDENDO
Dated: November 18, 2026
PER CURIAM.
{¶1} Relator, Yvette Copeland, filed a petition seeking writs of procedendo and
mandamus to order Respondent, Judge Kathryn Michael, to rule on her application to qualify as
an indigent litigant under R.C. 2323.211 in Summit County Court of Common Pleas Case No. CV-
2026-01-0138. Judge Michael moved to dismiss. Ms. Copeland did not respond. Because Ms.
Copeland’s petition does not demonstrate that Judge Michael has a clear duty to act or that Judge
Michael has refused to render a judgment or has unnecessarily delayed proceeding to judgment,
the motion to dismiss is granted.
{¶2} When this Court reviews a motion to dismiss under Civ.R. 12(B)(6), we must
presume that all of the factual allegations in the petition are true and make all reasonable inferences
in favor of the nonmoving party. State ex rel. Seikbert v. Wilkinson, 69 Ohio St.3d 489, 490 (1994).
A petition can only be dismissed when, having viewed the complaint in this way, it appears beyond
2
doubt that the relator can prove no set of facts that would entitle her to the relief requested.
Goudlock v. Voorhies, 2008-Ohio-4787, ¶ 7.
{¶3} To establish that she is entitled to a writ of mandamus, Ms. Copeland must
demonstrate that she has a clear right to the relief requested, that Judge Michael has a clear legal
duty to provide that relief, and that she does not have an adequate remedy in the ordinary course
of law. State ex rel. Manley v. Walsh, 2014-Ohio-4563, ¶ 18. “Procedendo is the appropriate
remedy when a court has refused to render a judgment or has unnecessarily delayed proceeding to
judgment.” Lloyd v. Wiest, 2023-Ohio-869, ¶ 2 (9th Dist.). In order to establish that she is entitled
to a writ of procedendo, Ms. Copeland must demonstrate that she has a clear legal right to require
Judge Michael to proceed, the judge has a clear legal duty to proceed, and there is no adequate
remedy available in the ordinary course of law. State ex rel. Ward v. Reed, 2014-Ohio-4512, ¶ 9.
{¶4} Ms. Copeland’s petition maintains that she filed a financial disclosure form in
connection with the underlying civil case on April 8, 2026, along with a motion to restrict public
access. She alleges that Judge Michael had a duty arising under R.C. 2323.311(B)(4) to approve
or deny the application and, if denied, to allow her thirty days to pay the relevant fees. Ms.
Copeland maintains that she could not obtain service of her amended complaint without paying
service fees, which she could not do without a ruling on her motion to waive costs. She asserts
that the underlying case was dismissed without prejudice on July 30, 2026, without a ruling on her
motion. That judgment assessed costs against her, which remain unpaid.
{¶5} Judge Michael has moved to dismiss, arguing that Ms. Copeland did not file the
affidavit of indigency required by R.C. 2323.311. Instead, Judge Michael argues that Ms.
Copeland filed a motion requesting leave to file an affidavit of indigency form under seal, which
was denied in a magistrate’s order that resolved all outstanding motions. Because the affidavit of
3
indigency was never filed, Judge Michael maintains that Ms. Copeland did not comply with R.C.
2323.311, and consequently, that there was no duty for her to rule.
{¶6} As a general rule, a court cannot rely on evidence or allegations that are outside the
complaint when considering a motion to dismiss under Civ.R. 12(B)(6). State ex rel. Ames v.
Baker, Dublikar, Beck, Wiley & Mathews, 2023-Ohio-2668, ¶ 16. In original actions, however, “a
court may take notice of the docket and record in a closely related case to determine whether the
current complaint states a claim for relief.” State ex rel. Neguse v. McIntosh, 2020-Ohio-3533, ¶
18. When the filings in a closely related case demonstrate that “a central allegation of the . . .
petition was not true,” a motion to dismiss should be granted. Id., citing Klick v. Snavely, 119
Ohio St. 308, 309-310 (1928).
{¶7} R.C. 2323.311, which is the basis for Ms. Copeland’s claim that Judge Michael has
a duty, provides that “[i]n order to qualify as an indigent litigant, the applicant shall file with the
court in which a civil action or proceeding is filed an affidavit of indigency in a form approved by
the supreme court. . . .” R.C. 2323.311(B)(1). A judicial officer’s obligations, as set forth in R.C.
2323.311(B)(4), do not attach until the applicant has done so. Ms. Copeland’s complaint maintains
that “On April 8, 2026, Relator hand-delivered for filing a Completed Civil Fee-Waiver Affidavit
and Order (Form 20), together with a public motion requesting restricted treatment and supporting
financial information submitted in a sealed envelope.” The docket, however, indicates that neither
the April 8, 2026, public filings nor the sealed filings include an affidavit of indigency required by
R.C. 2323.311(B)(1). It also appears from the docket that Ms. Copeland did not file an affidavit
of indigency at any other point.
{¶8} The docket in the underlying civil case, which is a “closely related case,” therefore
demonstrates that a central allegation of Ms. Copeland’s petition is not true. See McIntosh at ¶ 18.
4
Because Ms. Copeland did not file a financial disclosure form in the underlying case, she cannot
demonstrate that Judge Michael has a clear legal duty to provide the relief that she requested or
that Judge Michael has unnecessarily delayed a ruling. It therefore appears beyond doubt that Ms.
Copeland can prove no set of facts that would entitle her to the relief requested, and Judge
Michael’s motion to dismiss is granted.
{¶9} The motion to dismiss is granted, and Ms. Copeland’s petition is dismissed. All
outstanding motions are denied. Costs taxed to Ms. Copeland. The clerk of courts is hereby
directed to serve upon all parties not in default notice of this judgment and its date of entry upon
the journal. See Civ.R. 58(B).
JILL FLAGG LANZINGER
FOR THE COURT
SUTTON, J.
STEVENSON, J.
CONCUR.
APPEARANCES:
YVETTE COPELAND, Pro Se, Relator.
ELLIOT KOLKOVICH, Prosecuting Attorney, and JENNIFER M. PIATT, Assistant Prosecuting
Attorney, for Respondent.