In re A.B.
CourtOhio Court of Appeals
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
DocketC-260167
JudgeCrouse
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
[Cite as In re A.B., 2026-Ohio-4559.]
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS
FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT OF OHIO
HAMILTON COUNTY, OHIO
IN RE: A.B. : APPEAL NO. C-260167
TRIAL NO. F/13/0412 X
:
:
JUDGMENT ENTRY
:
:
This cause was heard upon the appeal, the record, the briefs, and arguments.
For the reasons set forth in the Opinion filed this date, the judgment of the trial
court is affirmed.
Further, the court holds that there were reasonable grounds for this appeal,
allows no penalty, and orders that costs be taxed under App.R. 24.
The court further orders that (1) a copy of this Judgment with a copy of the
Opinion attached constitutes the mandate, and (2) the mandate be sent to the trial
court for execution under App.R. 27.
To the clerk:
Enter upon the journal of the court on 11/18/2026.
Pursuant to App.R. 30, the clerk is directed to send all parties, or their
counsel if represented, a copy of the court’s judgment and note such action
on the docket.
By:_______________________
Administrative Judge
[Cite as In re A.B., 2026-Ohio-4559.]
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS
FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT OF OHIO
HAMILTON COUNTY, OHIO
IN RE: A.B. : APPEAL NO. C-260167
TRIAL NO. F/13/0412 X
:
:
OPINION
:
:
Appeal From: Hamilton County Juvenile Court
Judgment Appealed From Is: Affirmed
Date of Judgment Entry on Appeal: November 18, 2026
Blake P. Somers LLC, and Blake P. Somers, for Appellant Paternal Aunt,
McCaslin, Imbus & McCaslin, and Christina S. Yager, for Appellee Mother.
OHIO FIRST DISTRICT COURT OF APPEALS
CROUSE, Presiding Judge.
{¶1} Appellant, the paternal aunt (“Aunt”) of A.B., appeals from the trial
court’s entry overruling her objections to, and adopting, a magistrate’s decision
denying her petition for nonparent visitation or companionship time with A.B.
{¶2} In three assignments of error, Aunt challenges the trial court’s denial of
her petition and argues that the trial court abused its discretion by imposing a blanket
no-contact order between herself and A.B. While we do not doubt Aunt’s love for A.B.,
on the record before us we find no abuse of discretion in the trial court’s denial of
Aunt’s petition for nonparent visitation or companionship time or in its imposition of
a no-contact order. For the reasons set forth below, we overrule Aunt’s assignments of
error and affirm the trial court’s judgment.
I. Factual and Procedural History
{¶3} Aunt filed a petition for nonparent visitation or companionship time
with A.B. in April 2024. The petition alleged that after A.B.’s parents divorced and
entered a shared-parenting plan in 2013, Aunt had exercised much of the parenting
time accorded to Father in the plan, and that she continued to exercise that parenting
time after Father passed away in 2019. The petition further alleged that Mother cut off
all contact between A.B. and Aunt in 2024, and that the cessation of contact was
detrimental to A.B. and was not in A.B.’s best interest.
{¶4} In November 2024, while Aunt’s petition was pending, a juvenile court
magistrate ordered weekly phone or video calls between Aunt and A.B. On December
20, 2024, Mother filed a motion to suspend the calls.
{¶5} On that same date, Aunt filed a motion for the magistrate to conduct an
in-camera interview with A.B. and to hold Mother in contempt for failing to comply
with the magistrate’s order that A.B. participate in weekly phone calls with Aunt.
3
OHIO FIRST DISTRICT COURT OF APPEALS
{¶6} On February 11, 2025, the magistrate issued an order denying Mother’s
motion to suspend the phone calls. But the order modified the magistrate’s previous
order regarding the phone calls to provide that if A.B. protests a call going forward,
the call shall not occur. The order also stated that the magistrate had conducted an in-
camera interview with A.B.
{¶7} The following evidence was presented at a two-day trial before the
magistrate on Aunt’s petition. Aunt exercised the parenting time that had been
accorded to Father in the shared-parenting plan both before and after Father’s death
in 2019. Aunt cared for A.B. on weekends and holidays, and A.B. regularly went on
out-of-state family vacations with her. Aunt also often provided transportation for
Mother, A.B., and Mother’s other child, L.H. Mother was not always comfortable with
this arrangement and felt that Aunt often overstepped. Despite Mother’s concerns, she
continued to allow A.B. to see Aunt after Father’s death as long as A.B. was willing.
Mother ultimately decided to eliminate A.B.’s visitation time with Aunt after learning
from an attorney that she was not legally required to allow it and after she learned of
A.B.’s wishes on the matter.
{¶8} A.B., 13 years old at the time of trial, has been diagnosed with ADHD,
mixed-receptive-and-speech disorder, and anxiety. While A.B. completed various
childhood milestones at an early age, she started to regress on these accomplishments
when she was two and a half. She began to have difficulty recalling the alphabet and
counting, among other tasks. A.B. started to exhibit manic behaviors at age eight. Her
manic behaviors had worsened in the year preceding the trial, and they included
talking to herself and hearing voices. Mother attributed A.B.’s behavior to the fact that
she did not want to see Aunt.
{¶9} At the time of trial, Mother was unemployed because of her own health
4
OHIO FIRST DISTRICT COURT OF APPEALS
issues and because she needed to always be available for A.B. Mother herself suffered
from anxiety, ADHD, and a panic disorder.
{¶10} A.B. was not resistant to visits with Aunt as a child, but in 2023 she
began to go back and forth on whether she wanted to see Aunt. A.B. began to throw
fits when told it was time to visit with Aunt, including throwing herself on the ground,
pulling her hair, and stomping. A.B. never expressed her equivocation regarding
visitation directly to Aunt. Rather, A.B.’s wishes were communicated through Mother.
Aunt stated that at no point in the fall of 2023 did Mother directly express any
concerns regarding A.B. spending time with her. Sometime in 2023, Mother told Aunt
that A.B. was going to stay home with Mother for the holidays, rather than visit with
Aunt. According to Mother, Aunt became upset, insulted Mother, and called her
names.
{¶11} Aunt’s visitation with A.B. ceased in January 2024. After Aunt’s last visit
with A.B., two incidents occurred in February and March 2024, both involving Aunt
showing up at A.B.’s school. Aunt and Mother each testified about these incidents.
{¶12} According to Aunt, the day before the February incident, she had been
driving Mother, A.B., and L.H. to an appointment. In Mother’s presence, she asked
A.B. if A.B. would like her to bring cupcakes to school the following day, which was
Valentine’s Day. A.B. said yes. Aunt explained that this was a tradition between her
and A.B., and that Mother had never previously objected to it. Aunt testified that she
received a text message from Mother the day after she dropped off the cupcakes asking
her not to visit A.B. at school because it was distracting to A.B. With respect to the
March incident, Aunt testified that she was in the area near A.B.’s school on March 6.
Because it had been raining for a week, and because A.B.’s rain boots had been at
Aunt’s house for several months, Aunt decided to drop off the boots to A.B. while she
5
OHIO FIRST DISTRICT COURT OF APPEALS
was at school. Aunt asserted that she was invited into the school through a side door
by a teacher, and that she was contacted by the school later the same day and told not
to return. Aunt also testified that Mother sought a domestic violence civil protection
order against her following this incident, but it was denied.
{¶13} Mother, in turn, testified that after the February incident, A.B. had
returned home from school upset that Aunt had shown up with cupcakes. Mother
stated that she was unaware that Aunt had planned to do this, and that she messaged
Aunt asking her not to go to A.B.’s school again. Mother testified that after the March
incident when Aunt again showed up at A.B.’s school, A.B. began cutting herself.
{¶14} Although Aunt reached out to Mother multiple times after these
incidents, Mother would not allow her to see A.B. In June 2024, Aunt stopped by
Mother’s house to drop off clothing for A.B. Aunt arrived at the same time that A.B.
exited from her school bus. Mother shielded A.B. from Aunt and ushered A.B. and her
sister into their apartment. Against Mother’s wishes, Aunt attempted to hand the
clothing bag to A.B., followed A.B. up the stairs to the apartment, and hugged A.B.
Mother called the police, who came to the scene and spoke with Aunt.
{¶15} According to Mother, after this incident, A.B. began using purse straps,
pant legs, pillowcases, charging cords, and sheets to choke herself. Mother testified
that A.B. would hide things around her room that she could use to harm herself.
{¶16} Aunt and A.B. last spoke during a court-mandated phone call on
November 17, 2024. According to Aunt, A.B. seemed talkative and happy on the call,
but Mother took the phone from A.B. and told Aunt not to discuss certain things, such
as Thanksgiving plans, because it upset A.B. For the next 15 weeks, Aunt called every
Sunday and was told by Mother that A.B. did not wish to speak to her.
{¶17} Mother testified that only one phone call with Aunt took place because,
6
OHIO FIRST DISTRICT COURT OF APPEALS
when given the choice, A.B. elected not to engage in any further calls. Mother’s
testimony addressed the impact of the telephone calls with Aunt on A.B.’s mental
health. She stated that after she told A.B. about the court-ordered weekly calls, A.B.
began choking herself two-to-three times per day and her medications had to be
increased. A.B. was hospitalized at Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center
(“CCHMC”) on December 10, 2024, and was released one week later. According to
Mother, the doctors at the hospital had observed signs of schizophrenia in A.B.,
including the fact that she saw and heard things that were not there. Mother testified
that A.B. had “mellowed out” after being released from the hospital, but that her
hallucinations increased and she reverted to old behavior when she had to participate
in the in-camera interview with the court. Mother then provided an in-depth account
of A.B.’s hallucinations and stated that A.B.’s evaluation for childhood-onset
schizophrenia was ongoing.
{¶18} Aunt testified that she had concerns for A.B.’s well-being because A.B.
was being isolated from Aunt and other paternal family members, had started a new
school, and Mother was incorrectly informing A.B.’s doctors that Aunt and Father had
mental illnesses. According to Aunt, Mother will not respond to her messages but did
allow A.B. to see another aunt on the paternal side of her family. Aunt contended that
she had no concerns about A.B.’s mental health prior to 2024, that A.B. has never
harmed herself while in Aunt’s care, that A.B. was never depressed while she was in
Aunt’s care, and that Mother never told Aunt that A.B. was exhibiting these behaviors.
Aunt believed A.B.’s isolation from her paternal family members caused the behaviors.
{¶19} Mother explained that A.B. has a difficult time expressing her wants and
needs, but that she is able to do so with Mother. Mother contended that forcing A.B.
to spend time with Aunt is physically and mentally painful for A.B., and that it results
7
OHIO FIRST DISTRICT COURT OF APPEALS
in self-harm. According to Mother, even the mention of Aunt upsets A.B. Mother
stated that A.B. is easily influenced, but that she is not influenced by Mother’s distrust
of Aunt because Mother is careful not to push her feelings for Aunt onto A.B. Mother
further testified that she and her daughters had to move in March 2025 so that A.B.
could feel safe, but that A.B. was still paranoid that Aunt would find them. Mother also
stated that she would not be open to a reintroduction plan for Aunt and A.B., because
it would be potentially harmful for A.B.
{¶20} Aunt presented testimony from three witnesses about her relationship
with A.B. A paternal cousin testified that A.B. always appeared comfortable and
content with Aunt, that Aunt was a positive influence in A.B.’s life, and that Aunt
always respected Mother’s wishes as a parent. This cousin also testified that after she
had to cancel a planned outing with A.B., which Mother had approved, Mother stopped
responding to her attempts at contact and eventually blocked her. Another paternal
aunt testified that Mother had allowed her to visit with A.B. around Easter 2024. She
testified that A.B. seemed comfortable and happy during the visit and had been happy
to see her, but that she had felt intimidated by the way that Mother looked at her as
she observed the visit. This witness also testified that Aunt was a positive influence on
A.B.’s life. Last, Aunt’s friend C.W. testified that A.B. is safe and happy with Aunt, that
the two were very close, and that Aunt respects Mother’s judgment.
{¶21} K.V., a multiple disabilities teacher at A.B.’s high school, testified about
the incident in March 2024 when Aunt visited A.B. at school. She stated that she found
A.B. and Aunt sitting together in the hallway outside her classroom and heard A.B. tell
Aunt that Aunt was not supposed to be at the school. K.V. testified that she was unsure
how Aunt had entered the school. She stated that she had not been worried about
A.B.’s safety with Aunt, but that A.B. seemed confused.
8
OHIO FIRST DISTRICT COURT OF APPEALS
{¶22} Mother’s friend S.F. testified that Mother and A.B. have a close
relationship and that, since entering junior high, A.B. has become withdrawn and
quiet and her mental state has worsened.
{¶23} The final witness to testify was Dr. Caitlyn Garcia, an outpatient
psychiatrist with CCHMC, who had begun treating A.B. in January 2025. Dr. Garcia
testified that there was no evidence that Aunt had caused direct trauma to A.B. But
she explained that when a child’s wishes are not respected and they are not able to
decide with whom they have contact, it can result in secondary trauma. Dr. Garcia
stated, “as the level of contact between [A.B.]’s aunt and [A.B.] increases, her clinical
picture seems to be worsening.” Dr. Garcia further described A.B. as paranoid about
people knowing where she lives, disorganized, fearful, and disheveled. Dr. Garcia
stated that A.B. needed residential treatment, and that her medications were not
currently effective. She explained that the goal was to give A.B. therapy that would aid
her in explaining what she finds so distressing about Aunt. Dr. Garcia further stated,
“at this point I don’t know if it is really productive to continue the visitation
considering how much worse [A.B.] seems to be getting with ongoing visitation.”
{¶24} Dr. Garcia testified that A.B. has PTSD stemming from her
communication with Aunt, and that she has no reason to believe the recent lack of
communication between A.B. and her paternal family members is a cause of A.B.’s
trauma. She explained, “as contact has been limited with video chats and calls, she
appears to improve.” Dr. Garcia testified that if she was able to discover why Aunt is
so distressing for A.B., then potentially family therapy or supervised visitation could
be possible. She concluded, “I think until we can figure out why [A.B.] suddenly
stopped wanting to have visitation, I think it will continue to be very distressing for
her to have visitation.”
9
OHIO FIRST DISTRICT COURT OF APPEALS
{¶25} During the trial, Mother filed a second motion to suspend phone calls
between Aunt and A.B. The motion asserted, in accordance with the testimony offered
at trial, that A.B.’s mental health deteriorated after the calls were initiated and she was
admitted to a psychiatric unit at CCHMC. The magistrate issued an order granting
Mother’s motion.
{¶26} The magistrate issued a decision denying Aunt’s petition for nonparent
visitation or companionship time on July 7, 2025. The magistrate considered the
factors set forth in R.C. 3109.051(D) and determined that an award of companionship
time to Aunt was not in A.B.’s best interest. Aunt filed objections to the magistrate’s
decision.
{¶27} On September 29, 2025, Mother filed a motion for an interim order that
Aunt have no contact with A.B. during the pendency of the objections. The motion
alleged that Aunt had shown up at A.B.’s school on the first day of school and had been
ordered to leave by a school official. It further alleged that Aunt and other paternal
family members had shown up at Mother’s house on September 19, 2025, and shouted
profanities and banged on Mother’s door. The trial court issued an entry granting
Mother’s motion.
{¶28} On March 4, 2026, while the trial court’s ruling on objections was still
pending, Mother filed a motion for an ongoing order that Aunt have no contact with
A.B.
{¶29} On March 17, 2026, the trial court denied Aunt’s objections and adopted
the magistrate’s decision. In its entry, the court also granted Mother’s motion for an
ongoing order that Aunt have no contact with A.B., stating, “Given the significant
challenges facing the child, the Court finds that prohibiting [Aunt] from having contact
with the child is in the child’s best interest.”
10
OHIO FIRST DISTRICT COURT OF APPEALS
{¶30} Aunt now appeals.
II. Nonparent Visitation and Companionship Time
{¶31} In her first assignment of error, Aunt argues that the trial court abused
its discretion “by concluding that [her] relationship with A.B. was detrimental without
findings sufficient to support complete severance of all contact.” And she argues in her
second assignment of error that the trial court abused its discretion by failing to
properly apply R.C. 3109.11 and 3109.051(D) and by failing to meaningfully consider
the longstanding relationship between herself, A.B., and the paternal family. We
address these assignments of error together.
{¶32} A trial court is authorized to grant visitation or companionship time to
a nonparent if it is in the best interest of the child. See R.C. 3109.11 and 3109.051(B).
We review a trial court’s decision to grant or deny a nonparent’s motion for visitation
or companionship time for an abuse of discretion. In re Flynn, 2021-Ohio-4456, ¶ 15
(10th Dist.). An abuse of discretion occurs when “a court exercis[es] its judgment, in
an unwarranted way, in regard to a matter over which it has discretionary authority.”
Johnson v. Abdullah, 2021-Ohio-3304, ¶ 35. It is “more than a mere error of
judgment,” and “implies that the court’s attitude is arbitrary, unreasonable, or
unconscionable.” (Cleaned up.) Gipson v. Mercy Health Sys. of S.W. Ohio, 2025-Ohio-
2208, ¶ 12 (1st Dist.).
{¶33} In determining whether a grant of visitation or companionship time to
a nonparent is in a child’s best interest, a trial court should consider the factors set
forth in R.C. 3109.051(D), including, as relevant to this appeal:
(1) The prior interaction and interrelationships of the child with the
child’s parents, siblings, and other persons related by consanguinity or
11
OHIO FIRST DISTRICT COURT OF APPEALS
affinity, and with the person who requested companionship or visitation
. . .;
(2) The geographical location of the residence of each parent and the
distance between those residences, and if the person is not a parent, the
geographical location of that person’s residence and the distance
between that person’s residence and the child’s residence;
(3) The child’s and parents’ available time, including, but not limited to,
each parent’s employment schedule, the child’s school schedule, and the
child’s and the parents’ holiday and vacation schedule;
(4) The age of the child;
(5) The child’s adjustment to home, school, and community;
(6) If the court has interviewed the child in chambers . . . regarding the
wishes and concerns of the child as to . . . companionship or visitation
by the grandparent, relative, or other person who requested
companionship or visitation . . ., the wishes and concerns of the child,
as expressed to the court;
(7) The health and safety of the child;
(8) The amount of time that will be available for the child to spend with
siblings;
(9) The mental and physical health of all parties;
(10) Each parent’s willingness to reschedule missed parenting time and
to facilitate the other parent’s parenting time rights, and with respect to
a person who requested companionship or visitation, the willingness of
that person to reschedule missed visitation;
...
12
OHIO FIRST DISTRICT COURT OF APPEALS
(15) In relation to requested companionship or visitation by a person
other than a parent, the wishes and concerns of the child’s parents, as
expressed by them to the court;
(16) Any other factor in the best interest of the child.
{¶34} The magistrate thoroughly considered each of these factors in her
decision, which was adopted by the trial court. Contrary to Aunt’s assertion, the
magistrate did not fail to consider the longstanding relationship between Aunt and
A.B. Rather, the magistrate found that Aunt had historically been involved in the care
of A.B., and she set forth the various activities Aunt and A.B. had engaged in together.
{¶35} The magistrate further found that A.B. was currently experiencing
significant mental-health challenges. The magistrate noted A.B.’s physical and verbal
resistance to visiting Aunt, and she found that Aunt’s unannounced visits at A.B.’s
home and school caused A.B. to increase her attempts at self-harm, which included
choking and cutting herself.
{¶36} The magistrate discussed Dr. Garcia’s opinion that A.B. experienced
secondary trauma when her wishes regarding contact with Aunt were not respected
and that A.B.’s clinical picture worsened as her contact with Aunt increased. And the
magistrate noted Dr. Garcia’s statement that A.B. could not verbalize exactly what she
found so distressing about Aunt because of her low I.Q., but that Dr. Garcia attributed
A.B.’s decline in mental-and-behavioral health to changes in levels of visitation with
Aunt.
{¶37} The magistrate ultimately determined that a grant of visitation time
with Aunt was not in A.B.’s best interest, finding that the detrimental impact on A.B.
of such visitation had been established. In denying Aunt’s objections to the
magistrate’s decision, the trial court acknowledged that the record did not show that
13
OHIO FIRST DISTRICT COURT OF APPEALS
Aunt had sought to cause, or had intentionally caused, harm to A.B. Regardless, it
found that, for reasons A.B. was unable to disclose, Aunt’s presence was harmful to
A.B.
{¶38} We find no abuse of discretion in the trial court’s determination that a
grant of visitation or companionship time to Aunt was not in A.B.’s best interest. We
agree that the record contains no indication that Aunt took any specific action that
caused A.B.’s distress or that Aunt harmed or attempted to harm A.B. The record
demonstrates that Aunt cares greatly for A.B. and values their relationship.
{¶39} Nonetheless, the record demonstrates that contact with Aunt caused
A.B. great distress. A.B. began cutting herself after Aunt showed up at her school in
March 2024. A.B.’s attempts at self-harm turned to choking herself after the June
2024 incident when Aunt showed up at A.B.’s home. After the phone calls with Aunt
were initiated in November 2024, A.B.’s attempts at self-harm increased and she was
hospitalized. When contact with Aunt ceased, A.B.’s condition “mellowed,” until she
had to participate in the in-camera interview. The evidence presented at trial
supported Dr. Garcia’s opinion that A.B.’s distress increased as contact with Aunt
increased.
{¶40} On this record, we find no abuse of discretion in the trial court’s
determination that a grant of visitation or companionship time to Aunt was not in
A.B.’s best interest, and we overrule Aunt’s first and second assignments of error.
{¶41} In her third assignment of error, Aunt argues that the trial court abused
its discretion by imposing a blanket no-contact order without considering less
restrictive alternatives or explaining why complete severance of a longstanding
familial relationship was necessary. Aunt argues that the trial court could have ordered
supervised visitation or family therapy.
14
OHIO FIRST DISTRICT COURT OF APPEALS
{¶42} The record reflects that A.B. suffered extreme mental distress and
engaged in self-harming behaviors. Dr. Garcia testified that contact with Aunt was the
cause of A.B.’s distress, while acknowledging that A.B.’s low I.Q. prevented her from
being able to verbalize precisely what about Aunt caused this distress. Dr. Garcia
further testified that A.B.’s clinical picture appeared to worsen as her contact with
Aunt increased and that it was not productive to continue visitation with Aunt. She
unequivocally stated that “until we can figure out why [A.B.] suddenly stopped
wanting to have visitation, I think it will continue to be very distressing for her to have
visitation.” Dr. Garcia explained that A.B. needed a period of stability so that she could
more clearly explain what she found distressing about visiting with Aunt.
{¶43} Given Dr. Garcia’s testimony, we find no abuse of discretion in the trial
court’s imposition of a no-contact order between Aunt and A.B. Aunt’s third
assignment of error is overruled.
III. Conclusion
{¶44} Having overruled Aunt’s assignments of error, we affirm the trial court’s
judgment.
Judgment affirmed.
BOCK and MOORE, JJ., concur.
15