Full Opinion

[Cite as Ponzurick v. Parisi, 2026-Ohio-4543.] IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF OHIO ELEVENTH APPELLATE DISTRICT TRUMBULL COUNTY BARBARA PONZURICK, CASE NO. 2026-T-0033 Plaintiff-Appellant, Civil Appeal from the - vs - Niles Municipal Court CYNTHIA M. PARISI, Trial Court No. 2025 CVF 01285 Defendant-Appellee. OPINION AND JUDGMENT ENTRY Decided: November 16, 2026 Judgment: Affirmed Daniel G. Keating, Keating Law Office, 170 Monroe Street, N.W., Warren, OH 44483 (For Plaintiff-Appellant). Stephen A. Turner, Turner, May & Shepherd, 185 High Street, N.E., Warren, OH 44481 (For Defendant-Appellee). ROBERT J. PATTON, J. {¶1} Plaintiff-appellant, Barbara Ponzurick (“Ponzurick”), appeals from the judgment of the Niles Municipal Court dismissing her complaint against defendant- appellee, Cynthia M. Parisi (“Parisi”). {¶2} Upon review, we conclude that Ponzurick failed to prove by a preponderance of the evidence that she was entitled to relief. Therefore, the trial court’s decision dismissing her claims pursuant to Civ.R. 41(B)(2) is consistent with the manifest weight of the evidence. {¶3} Accordingly, the decision of the Niles Municipal Court is affirmed. Substantive and Procedural Facts {¶4} Ponzurick initially filed suit against Brendan Wolford dba Demo Pros and Parisi and her company, CWS L.L.C., in Niles Municipal Court Case No. 2024 CVF 00186A. Default judgement was obtained against Wolford on Ponzurick’s claims in the amount of $13,224.20. The judgment remains unsatisfied.1 {¶5} On October 16, 2025, Ponzurick filed a complaint against Parisi alleging two causes of action: general contractor liability and a violation of the Ohio Consumer Sales Practices Act as set forth in R.C. Ch. 1345. {¶6} According to the complaint, Ponzurick is the owner of real property located in Mineral Ridge, Ohio (“the Property”). In 2022, the Property was damaged by a flood. The damage was covered under Ponzurick’s homeowners’ insurance policy. Parisi agreed to do the repair work and Ponzurick paid her $6,000. According to Ponzurick, Parisi “subcontracted the job to Brendan Wolford d/b/a Demo Pros.” Ponzurick stated that the work was negligently performed. According to the Complaint, Wolford removed trim, damaged trim, and lost pieces of trim during the repair. Ponzurick presented a quote from Zinz Construction to repair the trim in the amount of $2,931.05 along with a prayer for triple damages and attorney fees. Ponzurick alleged that Parisi violated R.C. Ch. 1345 “by representing that the work to be performed . . . would be quality workmanship” and “[t]hat the original oak wood trim would be utilized following installation of the floor and drywall.” {¶7} On December 3, 2025, Parisi filed a motion to dismiss pursuant to Civ.R. 12(B)(6). The trial court denied the motion the following day. On March 10, 2026, 1. It is unclear what, if anything, the trial court decided as to the claim against Parisi and her company. PAGE 2 OF 10 Case No. 2026-T-0033 Ponzurick filed a motion for leave to file amended complaint instanter seeking to update the amount of damages to $9,350 based upon an estimate prepared by 12 Gage Renovations along with a prayer for triple damages and attorney fees. The trial court granted Ponzurick’s motion the same day. {¶8} The case proceeded to a bench trial on March 10, 2026.2 Ponzurick provided the following Statement of the Evidence as the Record on appeal: This case was initiated by the Appellant on October 16, 2025, alleging faulty and negligent repairs at her home following flood damage. The original prayer for relief was $2,931.05, along with a claim for triple damages and attorney fees, pursuant to the Ohio Consumer Sales Practices Act. The prayer for relief was based upon an estimate by Zinz Construction, several years ago. The Complaint alleged that [Parisi] subcontracted the work to Brendan Wolford a/k/a Demo Pros, LLC. Three checks were given to [Parisi] totaling $6,000.00. A judgment was previously obtained in the Niles Municipal Court under Case No. 2025 CVF 01285 against Brendan Wolford d/b/a Demo Pros in the amount of $2,931.05 as compensatory damages, plus $8.793.15 as triple damages under the Ohio Consumer Sales Practices Act and $1,500.00 as attorney fees. The judgment remains unsatisfied. This matter proceeded to Trial on March 10, 2026. A Motion for Leave to File an Amended Complaint was filed on March 9, 2026 and granted on the day of the Trial. The Amended Complaint requested compensatory damages of $9,350.00, reflecting the inspection and estimate of Appellant's expert witness, Gage McCracken of 12 Gage Renovations, LLC., along with a prayer for triple damages and attorney fees. ... The Plaintiff Appellant testified that all of her dealings were with . . . Parisi. The first floor of [Ponzurick]'s home had been flooded, an insurance claim was made through Erie Insurance, the [Ponzurick]'s Home Owners carrier. 2. This court does not have transcripts. We only have Appellant’s Statement of the Evidence as the Record on Appeal filed June 22, 2026. PAGE 3 OF 10 Case No. 2026-T-0033 [Ponzurick]’s expert witness, Gage McCracken of 12 Gage Renovations, LLC, testified and presented pictorial exhibits demonstrating the faulty work. Mr. McCracken testified that the baseboard that was removed had not been marked so that it could be reinstalled in the proper places, thereby resulting in mismatched and incomplete baseboard re-installation, all demonstrated by the exhibits introduced into evidence. [Ponzurick]’s home remains unrepaired. [Parisi]s son, Brendan Wolford, testified that the [Ponzurick] had hired him to perform the work, and that the baseboard woodwork had already been removed by him prior to beginning the work, he further claimed that the baseboard was in bad condition. Dkt. 90. {¶9} On March 10, 2026, the trial court determined that Ponzurick “failed to prove her case by a preponderance of the evidence. [Ponzurick] previously obtained a judgment against the witness, Brendan Wolford, in the Niles Municipal Court, and never joined the defendant in that case.” The trial court then dismissed the case with prejudice. {¶10} Ponzurick appeals. The Appeal {¶11} On appeal, Ponzurick raises a single assignment of error for review: “The trial court erred in rendering judgment in favor of the defendant.” Specifically, Ponzurick contends that the trial court erred when it determined that Wolford was an independent subcontractor and not an agent of Parisi. {¶12} Generally, we may not “construct the legal arguments in support of an appellant's appeal.” Whitehall v. Ruckman, 2007-Ohio-6780, ¶ 19 (10th Dist.), quoting State ex rel. Petro v. Gold, 2006-Ohio-943, ¶ 94 (10th Dist.). “If an argument exists that can support [an] assignment of error, it is not this court's duty to root it out.” Moyer v. PAGE 4 OF 10 Case No. 2026-T-0033 Robinson, 2023-Ohio-764, ¶ 36 (11th Dist.), quoting Lloyd v. Thornsbery, 2018-Ohio- 2893, ¶ 15 (11th Dist.), quoting Cardone v. Cardone, 1998 WL 224934, *8 (9th Dist. May 6, 1998). {¶13} Ponzurick’s brief cites to and relies upon a single Ohio case, State Farm Fire & Cas. Co. v. Capital Roofing L.L.C., 2020-Ohio-642, for her position that the trial court erred in failing to find Ponzurick vicariously liable for the damages caused by Wolford. Ponzurick provides this court with no analysis regarding this assignment of error. See App.R. 16(A)(7). It appears from the context of the argument, in conjunction with the trial court’s journal entry that Ponzurick takes issue with the lower court’s decision pursuant to Civ.R. 41(B). {¶14} Civ.R. 41(B)(2) provides: After the plaintiff, in an action tried by the court without a jury, has completed the presentation of the plaintiff's evidence, the defendant, without waiving the right to offer evidence in the event the motion is not granted, may move for a dismissal on the ground that upon the facts and the law the plaintiff has shown no right to relief. The court as trier of the facts may then determine them and render judgment against the plaintiff or may decline to render any judgment until the close of all the evidence. If the court renders judgment on the merits against the plaintiff, the court shall make findings as provided in Civ. R. 52 if requested to do so by any party. {¶15} “A dismissal under division (B) of this rule and any dismissal not provided for in this rule, except as provided in division (B)(4) of this rule, operates as an adjudication upon the merits unless the court, in its order for dismissal, otherwise specifies.” Civ.R. 41(B)(3). {¶16} As this court explained in Internatl. Language Bank, Inc. v. Law Office of Zukerman, Daiker & Lear, 2008-Ohio-5940, ¶ 27 (11th Dist.): PAGE 5 OF 10 Case No. 2026-T-0033 In ruling on a Civ.R. 41(B)(2) motion, it is the function of the trial court to review the evidence and the law. Levine v. Beckman (1988), 48 Ohio App.3d 24, 27. As the motion is made subsequent to the plaintiff resting, the trial court is not required to construe the evidence in favor of the non-moving party, but may weigh the evidence and render judgment. See, e.g., Central Motors Corp. v. Pepper (1979), 63 Ohio App.2d 34, 47-49. Where the evidence produced is insufficient to sustain the plaintiff’s burden in the matter, the trial court may dismiss the case. Ramco Specialties, Inc. v. Pansegrau (1998), 134 Ohio App.3d 513, 520. A dismissal will not be set aside unless it is erroneous as a matter of law or against the manifest weight of the evidence. Clarke v. Warren Cty. Bd. of Commrs., 150 Ohio App.3d 14, 2002- Ohio-6006, at ¶ 8. {¶17} In considering whether a civil judgment tried to the bench is against the manifest weight of the evidence, an appellate court applies the same standard as is used in reviewing a criminal judgment. Mark's Pro Servs., L.L.C. v. Pearlman, 2026-Ohio-2765, ¶ 12 (11th Dist.), citing Eastley v. Volkman, 2012-Ohio-2179, ¶ 17. “Weight of the evidence concerns ‘the inclination of the greater amount of credible evidence, offered in a trial, to support one side of the issue rather than the other. . . . Weight is not a question of mathematics, but depends on its effect in inducing belief.’” (Emphasis deleted.) State v. Thompkins, 1997-Ohio-52, ¶ 24, quoting Black’s Law Dictionary (6th Ed. 1990). “‘The [appellate] court, reviewing the entire record, weighs the evidence and all reasonable inferences, considers the credibility of the witnesses and determines whether in resolving conflicts in the evidence, the [trier of fact] clearly lost its way and created such a manifest miscarriage of justice that the [judgment] must be reversed and a new trial ordered.’” (Emphasis added.) Thompkins at ¶ 25, quoting State v. Martin, 20 Ohio App.3d 172, 175 (1st Dist. 1983). “‘A finding of an error in law is a legitimate ground for reversal, but a difference of opinion on credibility of witnesses and evidence is not.’” Ultimate Salon & PAGE 6 OF 10 Case No. 2026-T-0033 Spa, Inc. v. Legends Const. Group, 2019-Ohio-2506, ¶ 30 (11th Dist.), quoting Seasons Coal Co., Inc. v. Cleveland, 10 Ohio St.3d 77, 81 (1984). {¶18} “[A] court of appeals [must] be guided by a presumption that the findings of the trier-of-fact were indeed correct . . . . The underlying rationale of giving deference to the findings of the trial court rests with the knowledge that the trial judge is best able to view the witnesses and observe their demeanor, gestures and voice inflections, and use these observations in weighing the credibility of the proffered testimony.” Seasons Coal Co., Inc., at 80. The Supreme Court of Ohio has clarified the scope of appellate court’s review for manifest weight in State v. Reillo, Slip Opinion No. 2026-Ohio-2701: [A]ppellate courts reviewing a manifest-weight challenge must still give some deference to a fact-finder’s credibility determinations. See In re Z.C., 2023-Ohio-4703, ¶ 14, citing Seasons Coal Co., Inc. v. Cleveland, 10 Ohio St.3d 77, 80 (1984). An appellate court sits as the thirteenth juror only when evidence contradicts a fact-finder’s findings, see State v. Martin, 2022-Ohio-4175, ¶ 26, or when a witness’s testimony is so inconsistent as to material facts, so impeached, or so fantastical as to make it patently unbelievable. Without conflicting testimony or evidence that completely discredited E.C., the Eighth District had nothing to weigh. Reillo at ¶ 3. {¶19} Generally, an employer or principal is vicariously liable for the torts of its employees or agents under the doctrine of respondeat superior, but not for the negligence of an independent contractor over whom it retained no right to control the mode and manner of doing the contracted-for work. Clark v. Southview Hosp. & Family Health Ctr., 68 Ohio St.3d 435, 438 (1994), citing Councell v. Douglas, 163 Ohio St. 292, 295-296 (1955); accord Johnson v. Mentor Harbor Yachting Club, 2026-Ohio-601, ¶ 56 (11th Dist.). “‘This doctrine of liability depends on the existence of control by a principal (or PAGE 7 OF 10 Case No. 2026-T-0033 master) over an agent (or servant). . . .’” Id., quoting Natl. Union Fire Ins. Co. of Pittsburgh, PA v. Wuerth, 2009-Ohio-3601, ¶ 20. {¶20} Ponzurick does not cite to any evidence in the record to support the allegation that Parisi was vicariously liable for the damages caused by Wolford. App.R. 16(A)(7). {¶21} According to the trial court’s entry, Ponzurick testified that she had flooding in her home. Parisi was her cleaning lady. Ponzurick explained that she hired Parisi to perform the work. Ponzurick testified she gave the keys to Parisi and then went on vacation when the repairs were performed. According to Ponzurick, the work was negligently performed. Ponzrick testified that there were holes in the wall and the baseboards were removed, damaged, and not reinstalled. Ponzurick submitted a revised estimate for damages at $9,350 which was more than $3,000 over the original request. Ponzurick testified that she received a judgment against Wolford for the alleged damages in question. Ponzurick testified that Parisi and Wolford were performing the work according to what Parisi told her. She also testified that the damages were caused by Parisi and Wolford. {¶22} Gage McCracken was called as an expert witness for Ponzurick. McCracken testified to the negligently performed repairs and opined that the total amount of damages of $9,350. {¶23} Parisi called Wolford, who testified that Ponzurick hired him to perform the work. According to Wolford, the baseboard was removed prior to him beginning the work, that the baseboard was old and in bad condition. Wolford testified that the checks were PAGE 8 OF 10 Case No. 2026-T-0033 written to Parisi for Wolford’s convenience due to a bank account change. Wolford admitted that judgment was obtained against him for the same negligent repairs. {¶24} Upon review of the record, there are no conflicts within the evidence. The trial court is in the best position to make credibility determinations. There is no evidence in the record that Parisi performed the repairs or otherwise controlled or directed Wolford in any way. Wolford testified that he was hired by Ponzurick and that he performed the work. Ponzurick obtained judgment for the same negligent repairs against Wolford in a separate case. Accordingly, Ponzurick failed to prove by a preponderance of the evidence that she was entitled to relief on either claim. Therefore, the trial court’s decision is consistent with the manifest weight of the evidence. Ponzurick’s sole assignment of error is without merit. {¶25} The judgment of the Niles Municipal Court is affirmed. MATT LYNCH, P.J., EUGENE A. LUCCI, J., concur. PAGE 9 OF 10 Case No. 2026-T-0033 JUDGMENT ENTRY For the reasons stated in the opinion of this court, appellant’s assignment of error is without merit. It is the judgment and order of this court that the judgment of the Niles Municipal Court is affirmed. Costs to be taxed against the appellant. JUDGE ROBERT J. PATTON PRESIDING JUDGE MATT LYNCH, concurs JUDGE EUGENE A. LUCCI, concurs THIS DOCUMENT CONSTITUTES A FINAL JUDGMENT ENTRY A certified copy of this opinion and judgment entry shall constitute the mandate pursuant to Rule 27 of the Ohio Rules of Appellate Procedure. PAGE 10 OF 10 Case No. 2026-T-0033