Full Opinion

[Cite as In re J.E.R., 2026-Ohio-4584.] COURT OF APPEALS OF OHIO EIGHTH APPELLATE DISTRICT COUNTY OF CUYAHOGA IN RE J.E.R., : : No. 116365 A Minor Child : : [Appeal by D.J., Mother] : JOURNAL ENTRY AND OPINION JUDGMENT: AFFIRMED RELEASED AND JOURNALIZED: November 19, 2026 Civil Appeal from the Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas Juvenile Division Case No. FA22112844 Appearances: D.J., pro se. KATHLEEN ANN KEOUGH, J.: Appellant-mother D.J. (“mother”) appeals the juvenile court’s decision denying her custody motions regarding her minor child, J.E.R. (“the child”). For the reasons that follow, we affirm the juvenile court’s decision. I. Procedural History and Background In December 2022, the child’s father initiated this case by requesting shared parenting of the child. The juvenile court granted father parenting time until September 2023, when mother filed a motion alleging that father had burnt the child. After an investigation, no criminal charges were filed against father, and Summit County Children Services was unable to complete their investigation because mother was uncooperative. As a result, in November 2023, the juvenile court reinstated father’s parenting time. Father subsequently filed a motion to show cause against mother, alleging that mother was withholding the child. After mother failed to appear in court on two occasions and she could not be located, father moved for emergency custody of the child. In January 2024, the juvenile court granted father temporary custody of the child and appointed a custody evaluator. Mother moved to modify custody and subsequently for full custody, contending father should not receive any visitation. Following an August 2024 magistrate’s hearing on mother’s motions for custody, at which the child’s guardian ad litem (“GAL”) stated that custody to the father was in the child’s best interest, the magistrate denied mother’s motions, granted legal custody to father, and granted mother supervised visitation. On September 16 and 19, 2024, the juvenile court overruled mother’s untimely objections and adopted the magistrate’s decision. In its order, the court expressly stated that “this court will not modify this Order regarding supervised parenting time until Mother has complied with these Court orders,” which required mother to (1) “enroll in cognitive behavioral therapy . . . follow any recommend[ations] . . . and show proof of compliance”; (2) “successfully complete an anger management program”; and (3) “successfully complete a parenting education class to understand age-appropriate behaviors for the child.” On July 15, 2025, mother filed a motion for temporary custody and a motion to modify the September 16, 2024 custody order. In both of her motions, mother averred that father and paternal grandmother neglected or abused the child by making harmful and intimidating threats. According to mother, the child’s paternal grandmother and father have a history of child abuse and there are multiple police and child protective services reports. Mother further averred that the child told her that he was hit in his mouth for talking too much — “he also says that ‘mimi,’ his [paternal] grandmother tells him to ‘shut up’ because he is talking too much.” Mother further averred that on June 26, 2025, the child had a round prominent scar on the inside of his left arm and had unexplained scars on his body. She claimed that “whenever she asks [the] child where these sores [and] scars came from he says ‘he fell.’” Mother also said that on July 10, 2025, the child had severe peeling on his feet and the palms of his hands which, according to mother, were never addressed by the child’s pediatrician. Mother also claims in her motions that on May 5, 2025, the child’s pediatrician documented in the child’s MyChart account that “toilet training initiated, and resisting a bit.” According to mother, “the child is 33 months old, and still wearing diapers when he should be wearing pullups.” On August 8, 2025, mother filed a motion to show cause against father, alleging that father violated the September 16, 2024 custody order when he refused to allow her parenting time on July 24, 2025, and August 7, 2025. On August 20, 2025, mother filed an emergency motion for temporary custody and suspension of father’s custody and parenting time, contending that 2. [The child] disclosed to mother that [his] paternal grandmother has physically disciplined [the child] by “popping him in the mouth” and telling [the child] to “shut up.” 3. A Safe and Sound visitation supervisor personally witnessed the child make these same disclosures. Safe and Sound has documented these statements in its records (Exhibit B). 4. Mother personally observed a circular scar on the child’s left arm, raising further concern for the child’s safety while in father’s household. 5. The child’s maternal grandmother also witnessed the scar and heard the child state that he was “popped in the mouth” and told to “shut up.” 6. Father has repeatedly canceled [sic] mother’s supervised visits at Safe and Sound Visitation Center. Mother has preserved voicemails from Safe and Sound documenting Father’s cancellations (Exhibit A). 7. These incidents demonstrate a willful failure by father to protect the child from harm and to comply with the Court’s visitation orders, placing the child at immediate risk of harm. Concurrent with this motion for emergency custody, mother filed a “motion for contempt,” requesting that the juvenile court hold father in contempt for the same reasons stated in her motion for emergency custody. On August 22, 2025, mother filed another motion for contempt, alleging that father has “interfered with her parenting time and misrepresent[ed] a personal note as a ‘court order.’” In support, mother stated that on August 21, 2025, father delivered to the visitation center a handwritten note prohibiting “her and maternal grandmother from providing food, clothing, or gifts to the minor child during visitation, except for items supplied by father.” According to mother, father falsely represented that the note was “from the courts,” and directly contradicted the visitation center’s written policy that nonresidential parents are permitted to bring snacks and gifts during visitation. Mother alleged that father’s restriction occurred as a result of her reporting concerns about the child’s safety. Attached to her motion was the handwritten note by father and a policy-excerpt from the visitation center. The juvenile court conducted a hearing on mother’s motions, maternal grandmother’s request for companionship time with the child, and father’s request for attorney fees. During the hearing, the juvenile court received testimony from mother, father, maternal grandmother, and the child’s GAL, and accepted exhibits from the parties. At the close of the hearing, the juvenile court permitted the parties to submit written closing arguments. On March 26, 2026, the juvenile court issued its written decision, denying mother’s motions for temporary custody, emergency custody, and to modify the September 16, 2024 custody order. The court found that although mother had completed the ACT Raising Safe Kids program and anger management, she had not completed all the “requirements” from the September 2024 custody order. The court further expressed concern that mother “still needs to show more consistency and benefit from the services.” The court also noted that notwithstanding her failure to complete the court-ordered requirements, mother had not demonstrated a change in circumstances sufficient to warrant a modification of custody pursuant to R.C. 3109.04(E)(1)(a). II. The Appeal Mother now appeals, raising the following four assignments of error, which will be addressed out of order and together where appropriate: I. The trial court erred and abused its discretion in determining the best interest of the child, particularly as it relates to the child’s health and safety. II. The trial court erred and abused its discretion by ignoring material evidence that would have affected the outcome of the case. III. The trial court committed reversible error and violated appellant’s due process rights under the Fourteenth Amendment by failing to rule on [mother’s] properly filed motion. IV. The trial court abused its discretion in its overall determination of custody. A. Pending Motion In her third assignment of error, mother claims that the juvenile court erred and violated her constitutional rights “by failing to rule on [mother’s] properly filed motion.” Mother does not identify what motion remains pending before the juvenile court. Aside from setting forth caselaw excerpts, mother does not make any substantive argument from which this court could glean what pending motion is the basis for mother’s assigned error. Accordingly, mother has failed to comply with App.R. 16(A)(7), which states that the appellant’s brief shall include “[a]n argument containing the contentions of the appellant with respect to each assignment of error presented for review and the reasons in support of the contentions, with citations to the authorities, statutes, and parts of the record on which appellant relies.” We therefore summarily overrule her assignment of error. See App.R. 12(A)(2).1 B. Custody Determination In her first, second, and fourth assignments of error, mother challenges the juvenile court’s decision denying her custody-based motions. We can glean from her assignments of error that mother claims that the juvenile court abused its discretion by failing to consider, acknowledge, or address certain evidence mother believes was material, relevant, and competent, to wit: documentation that she completed her court-ordered programs, and evidence discounting father’s parenting and character. She generally asserts that the juvenile court did not consider the best interest factors found in R.C. 3109.04(F)(1) and thus the court’s decision is not in the child’s best interest. The juvenile court denied mother’s motions for two reasons — (1) mother’s failure to complete or consistently benefit from her court-ordered programs, and (2) she failed to demonstrate a change in circumstances sufficient to warrant a modification of custody. Accordingly, even if this court agreed that mother’s documentary evidence showed compliance with the court-ordered programs, mother was still required to demonstrate a change of circumstances of 1 We recognize, however, that the juvenile court did not issue a ruling on mother’s motions to show cause; as of the writing of this opinion, those motions are still pending and thus not before this court for consideration. These pending motions do not affect our jurisdiction to consider mother’s assignments of error pertaining to custody. See generally In re I.L.J., 2019-Ohio-5241, ¶ 51 (8th Dist.) (pending motion to show cause does not affect appellate jurisdiction when the court’s judgment contained other appealable orders). the child or father, as residential parent, before the court could grant mother’s motions to modify custody. R.C. 3109.04(E) governs the modification of a prior decree allocating parental rights and responsibilities. Under R.C. 3109.04(E)(1)(a), a court shall not modify a prior decree allocating parental rights and responsibilities unless it finds, based on facts that have arisen since the prior decree or that were unknown to the court at the time of the prior decree, that there has been a change in the circumstances of the child or the child’s residential parent and that the modification is necessary to serve the best interest of the child. R.C. 3109.04 does not define “change . . . in the circumstances.” Ohio courts, however, have held the phrase to mean “‘an event, occurrence, or situation which has a material and adverse effect upon the child.’” In re D.M., 2006-Ohio- 6191, ¶ 35 (8th Dist.), quoting Rohrbaugh v. Rohrbaugh, 136 Ohio App.3d 599, 604- 605 (7th Dist. 2000). The Ohio Supreme Court has held that for a juvenile court to make the threshold finding of a change in circumstances, “the change must be a change of substance, not a slight or inconsequential change. The nomenclature is not the key issue.” Davis v. Flickinger, 1997-Ohio-260, ¶ 11. The Davis Court explained: “The clear intent of that statute is to spare children from a constant tug of war between their parents who would file a motion for change of custody each time the parent out of custody thought he or she could provide the children a ‘better’ environment. The statute is an attempt to provide some stability to the custodial status of the children, even though the parent out of custody may be able to prove that he or she can provide a better environment.” Id., quoting Wyss v. Wyss, 3 Ohio App.3d 412, 416 (10th Dist. 1982). In deciding whether a change-of-circumstances has occurred, a juvenile judge “must have wide latitude in considering all the evidence,” and we review the court’s determination for an abuse of discretion. In re E.R.P., 2012-Ohio- 1053, ¶ 19 (8th Dist.). A juvenile court’s finding whether a change in circumstances occurred under R.C. 3109.04 should not be reversed absent an abuse of discretion. Davis, 1997-Ohio-260, at paragraph one of the syllabus. “When applying the abuse- of-discretion standard, an appellate court’s role is to ascertain whether the award of custody is supported by competent and credible evidence.” In re D.M., 2011-Ohio- 3918, ¶ 25 (12th Dist.), citing Davis. Our review of the record reveals that the juvenile court’s decision is supported by competent and credible evidence. The allegations mother set forth in her motions as justification to award her legal custody of the child were repetitive of the reasoning she previously raised in 2023 and 2024 when she opposed father’s request for shared parenting, parenting time, and legal custody. Accordingly, her motions and trial testimony were not based on materially new facts or circumstances that arose since the September 2024 custody order. We therefore agree with the juvenile court that mother failed to demonstrate a change in circumstances sufficient to warrant a modification of custody; a best-interest analysis was therefore unnecessary. Based on the foregoing, we do not find that the juvenile court abused its discretion in denying mother’s motion for temporary custody, emergency custody, and to modify custody. Mother’s first, second, and fourth assignments of error are overruled. Judgment affirmed. It is ordered that appellee recover from appellant costs herein taxed. The court finds there were reasonable grounds for this appeal. It is ordered that a special mandate issue out of this court directing the common pleas court, juvenile division, to carry this judgment into execution. A certified copy of this entry shall constitute the mandate pursuant to Rule 27 of the Rules of Appellate Procedure. KATHLEEN ANN KEOUGH, JUDGE EMANUELLA D. GROVES, P.J., and ANITA LASTER MAYS, J., CONCUR