CKE Props., LLC v. Sodoma L., P.C.
CourtCourt of Appeals of North Carolina
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
Docket24-785
JudgeJudge Christopher Freeman
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
An unpublished opinion of the North Carolina Court of Appeals does not constitute
controlling legal authority. Citation is disfavored, but may be permitted in accordance with
the provisions of Rule 30(e)(3) of the North Carolina Rules of Appellate Procedure.
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF NORTH CAROLINA
No. COA24-785
Filed 18 November 2026
Mecklenburg County, No. 23CVS012463-590
CKE PROPERTIES, LLC, Plaintiff,
v.
SODOMA LAW, P.C.; AMY E. SIMPSON; ELIZABETH TEMPLE; GARY L.
MCFADDEN, in his official capacity as Mecklenburg County Sheriff; KIMBERLY
WILLIAMS, individually and in her official capacity as deputy sheriff of Mecklenburg
County; PLATTE RIVER INSURANCE COMPANY; FIDELITY BROKERAGE
SERVICES (NORTH CAROLINA) LLC; and BANK OF AMERICA, N.A., Defendants.
Appeal by plaintiff from orders entered 1 May 2024, 2 May 2024, and 3 June
2024 by Judge Karen Eady-Williams in Mecklenburg County Superior Court. Heard
in the Court of Appeals 28 August 2025.
Law Office of Thomas D. Bumgardner, PLLC, by Thomas D. Bumgardner, and
Plumides, Romano & Johnson, PC, by Richard B. Johnson, for plaintiff-
appellant.
Poyner Spruill LLP, by Steven B. Epstein, for defendants-appellees Sodoma
Law, P.C., Amy E. Simpson, and Elizabeth Temple.
Womble Bond Dickinson (US) LLP, by Sean F. Perrin, for defendants-appellees
Gary L. McFadden, Kimberly Williams, and Platte River Insurance Company.
McGuireWoods LLP, by Michael S. Mestre, Dylan M. Bensinger, and Kelly A.
Warlich, for defendant-appellee Bank of America, N.A.
No brief filed for defendant Fidelity Brokerage Services (North Carolina) LLC.
CKE PROPERTIES, LLC V. SODOMA LAW, P.C.
Opinion of the Court
FREEMAN, Judge.
Plaintiff appeals from the trial court’s orders granting defendants’ Rule
12(b)(6) motions to dismiss. On appeal, plaintiff argues that it (1) stated a claim for
each claim as to each defendant (2) and did not assert an insurmountable defense on
the face of its brief for any defendant. After careful review, we affirm.
I. Factual and Procedural Background
Andrea Kirby Crowell is a member of CKE Properties, LLC, along with two
other members, Gentry Kirby and Carolina Kirby. In 2014, Andrea Crowell initiated
divorce proceedings with her husband, William Crowell. William was represented by
Amy E. Simpson of Sodoma Law, P.C. He had Alzheimer’s disease, so his daughter,
Elizabeth Temple, communicated with Simpson and the firm on William’s behalf.
In July 2016, the Honorable Judge Mann of Mecklenburg County District
Court presided over the trial on the equitable division of the Crowells’ marital
property and entered a written order to that effect. Andrea Crowell appealed, and on
16 August 2019, the Supreme Court of North Carolina vacated the trial court’s order
and remanded the case. Crowell v. Crowell, 372 N.C. 362, 371 (2019) (Crowell I).
On 16 July 2021, the trial court entered an amended equitable distribution
order and authorized William’s attorneys to collect $424,294.00 from Andrea Crowell.
Andrea Crowell appealed the amended judgment.
-2-
CKE PROPERTIES, LLC V. SODOMA LAW, P.C.
Opinion of the Court
William Crowell died on 30 April 2022. On 9 May 2022, the trial court entered
an attachment order, listing accounts from which William Crowell’s attorneys could
collect. This attachment order included an account with Bank of America in the name
of CKE Properties, LLC, which is the account that is the subject of this appeal.
William’s legal team caused writs of execution to be issued. One of the writs
of execution included “accounts listed in the attachment order” in the description of
things to be collected. Another referred to “Exhibit A,” which likewise identified
accounts listed in the attachment order. Mecklenburg County Sheriff Garry
McFadden and Deputy Sheriff Kimberly Williams levied on the writs. Bank of
America thereafter released $122,440.15 from plaintiff’s account.
On 6 June 2023, this Court vacated and remanded the trial court’s amended
equitable distribution order. See Crowell v. Crowell, 289 N.C. App. 112 (2023)
(Crowell II). On 1 August 2023, this Court vacated the attachment order for lack of
subject matter jurisdiction. See Crowell v. Crowell, 290 N.C. App. 1 (2023) (Crowell
III).
On 19 July 2023, plaintiff sued defendants Sodoma Law, P.C., Amy Simpson,
and Elizabeth Temple (collectively the Sodoma defendants), for (1) wrongful
execution and seizure, (2) conversion, (3) fraud, (4) abuse of process, (5) negligence,
(6) gross negligence, and (7) punitive damages. Plaintiff also sued Sheriff Garry
McFadden, in his official capacity, Deputy Sheriff Kimberly Williams, in her
-3-
CKE PROPERTIES, LLC V. SODOMA LAW, P.C.
Opinion of the Court
individual and official capacity, and Platte River Insurance Company 1 (collectively
the Sheriff defendants) for (1) wrongful execution and seizure, (2) conversion, (3)
negligence, and (4) gross negligence; and Bank of America, N.A., for (1) wrongful
execution and seizure, (2) conversion, (3) negligence, and (4) gross negligence.2 3
On 15 September 2023, the Sodoma defendants moved to dismiss all of
plaintiff’s claims against them for failure to state a claim upon which relief may be
granted because they “enjoyed absolute immunity to engage in such alleged conduct.”
The Sheriff defendants moved to dismiss all of plaintiff’s claims against them on 20
September 2023, alleging that: (1) “[a]ll official capacity claims against Kimberly
Williams [were] barred because they [were] duplicative of the official capacity claims
against Sheriff Garry McFadden”; (2) “[a]ll individual capacity claims against
Kimberly Williams [were] barred by public official immunity”; (3) “[p]laintiff’s claims
in their entirety should be dismissed because there [wa]s no liability for law
enforcement serving a valid writ on its face, and law enforcement has no duty to go
1 Plaintiff alleges that Platte River Insurance Company is liable for the actions of McFadden
and Williams under N.C.G.S. § 58-76-5 because Platte River provided the bond for the sheriffs.
2 Plaintiff also asserted claims of civil conspiracy, injunctive relief, and declaratory judgment
against the Sodoma defendants. On appeal, plaintiff did not contend that the trial court erred by
dismissing its claims for injunctive relief and declaratory relief. Plaintiff asserted that the trial court
erred by dismissing its derivative claim of civil conspiracy. Although plaintiff cites cases in support of
its argument, plaintiff addressed this claim entirely in a footnote and failed to make a sufficient
argument in support of the claim. Therefore, to the extent that the argument was proffered on appeal,
we deem it abandoned. N.C. R. App. P. 28(b)(6).
Further, plaintiff asserted claims of unfair and deceptive trade practices, injunctive relief, and
declaratory relief against defendant Bank of America, but it did not argue these claims in its brief.
Accordingly, we do not address these claims.
3 Plaintiff also named Fidelity Brokerage Services (North Carolina) as a defendant. On 29
May 2024, plaintiff voluntarily dismissed all its claims against Fidelity.
-4-
CKE PROPERTIES, LLC V. SODOMA LAW, P.C.
Opinion of the Court
beyond the face of the writ of execution;” and (4) [p]laintiff’s claim against Platte
River Insurance Company fails because there [wa]s no underlying liability for its
principal, Sheriff McFadden, and because [p]laintiff failed to bring a claim pursuant
to N.C.G.S. § 58-76-5.” On 4 October 2023, Bank of America moved to dismiss
plaintiff’s claims against it. Bank of America alleged: (1) plaintiff failed to state a
claim for wrongful execution and seizure because Bank of America “was obligated to
comply with a valid writ of execution and a valid notice of levy”; (2) plaintiff failed to
state a claim for conversion because “plaintiffs d[id] not allege that [Bank of America]
received or withheld any funds stemming from its processing of writ of execution and
notice of levy”; and (3) “[p]laintiff’s cause of action for negligence / gross negligence
. . . fail[ed] to state a claim against [Bank of America]” and were “barred by the
economic loss doctrine.”
The trial court heard arguments on all motions to dismiss on 16 November
2023. The court subsequently entered written orders granting each motion to
dismiss. On 1 May 2024, the court concluded that all of plaintiff’s claims against the
Sodoma defendants arose “out of statements and conduct occurring in the course of
judicial proceedings, to wit, the Underlying Domestic Action.” Because the claims
were “sufficiently relevant to the underlying judicial proceeding to be afforded the
protection of absolute immunity,” the trial court held that “the face of Plaintiff’s
Amended Complaint disclose[d] an insurmountable bar to recovery and . . . fail[ed] to
state a claim for which relief may be granted against the Sodoma defendants.”
-5-
CKE PROPERTIES, LLC V. SODOMA LAW, P.C.
Opinion of the Court
On 2 May 2024, the court granted the Sheriff defendants’ motion to dismiss,
concluding that for the wrongful execution and seizure claims, “a Sheriff’s deputy has
no duty to look beyond the face of a writ order, and the claim is barred by
governmental/public official immunity,” and that the negligence and gross negligence
claims were barred by “governmental/public official immunity.” On 3 June 2024, the
court dismissed plaintiff’s claims against Bank of America with prejudice.
Plaintiff timely appealed each order.
II. Jurisdiction
The trial court’s orders granted defendants’ motions to dismiss with respect to
all of plaintiff’s claims, and we have jurisdiction to review these final judgments of a
superior court pursuant to N.C.G.S. § 7A-27(b)(1) (2025).
III. Standard of Review
We review “de novo legal conclusions of a trial court, including orders granting
or denying a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim upon which relief can be
granted under Rule 12(b)(6) . . . .” Sykes v. Health Network Sols., Inc., 372 N.C. 326,
332 (2019). “Motions to dismiss brought under Rule 12(b)(6) test the legal sufficiency
of a complaint.” Legal Impact for Chickens v. Case Farms, LLC, 299 N.C. App. 43, 47
(2025) (cleaned up). We review “whether the allegations of the complaint, if treated
as true, are sufficient to state a claim upon which relief can be granted under some
legal theory.” Taylor v. Bank of Am., N.A., 382 N.C. 677, 679 (2022) (quoting Bridges
v. Parrish, 366 N.C. 539, 541 (2013)). “We treat factual allegations as true and ignore
-6-
CKE PROPERTIES, LLC V. SODOMA LAW, P.C.
Opinion of the Court
legal conclusions.” Legal Impact for Chickens, 299 N.C. App. at 47–48. This Court
should affirm a trial court’s order granting a 12(b)(6) motion to dismiss if “(1) the
complaint on its face reveals that no law supports the plaintiff’s claim; (2) the
complaint on its face reveals the absence of facts sufficient to make a good claim; or
(3) the complaint discloses some fact that necessarily defeats the plaintiff’s claim.”
Newberne v. Dep’t of Crime Control & Pub. Safety, 359 N.C. 782, 784 (2005) (cleaned
up).
“Where a trial court has reached the correct result, the judgment will not be
disturbed on appeal even where a different reason is assigned to the decision.” Eways
v. Governor’s Island, 326 N.C. 552, 554 (1990); see also Orlando Residence, Ltd. v. All.
Hosp. Mgmt., LLC, 375 N.C. 140, 154–55 (2020) (holding that the Business Court
correctly dismissed the party’s crossclaims under Rule 12(b)(6), but on different
grounds than those relied upon by the Business Court).
IV. Discussion
On appeal, plaintiff argues the trial court erred by dismissing its claims
against all defendants. We address each argument in turn.
A. Sodoma Defendants
First, plaintiff argues the trial court erred by dismissing its claims against the
Sodoma defendants. We disagree. Although the trial court relied on absolute
privilege or immunity, we may affirm a correct result on any ground supported by the
record and the law. See Eways, 326 N.C. at 554. Here, the claims fail because the
-7-
CKE PROPERTIES, LLC V. SODOMA LAW, P.C.
Opinion of the Court
facts alleged do not establish wrongful conduct by the Sodoma defendants in
obtaining execution on the court orders that were then in effect.
1. Wrongful Execution and Seizure
Our case law states, “no valid levy can be made on property not owned by the
judgment debtor.” Cmty. Credit Co. v. Norwood, 257 N.C. 87, 91 (1962). Our
precedent also recognizes that persons who procure, direct, or assist in a wrongful
levy may be liable to the injured property owner. Mica Indus., Inc. v. Penland, 249
N.C. 602, 605 (1959). Those principles, however, assume a wrongful levy.
Here, the amended complaint and the court orders incorporated into the
execution process show that, when the collection occurred, the district court had
entered an amended equitable distribution order and an attachment order identifying
CKE’s Bank of America account as the account from which collection could be made.
This Court later reversed the amended equitable distribution order and vacated the
attachment order. See Crowell II, 289 N.C. App. at 112. However, at the time the
Sodoma defendants pursued execution, these orders were valid and authorized
collection from the account.
Plaintiff relies on our later rulings vacating those orders. Our reversals do not
turn the Sodoma defendants’ earlier reliance on those orders into a wrongful levy.
Our statutes allow property to be collected under a judgment that is later reversed
and authorizes restitution following reversal. N.C.G.S. § 1-297 (2025). However,
plaintiff does not seek this relief on appeal.
-8-
CKE PROPERTIES, LLC V. SODOMA LAW, P.C.
Opinion of the Court
Since the orders were valid at the time of execution, there was not a wrongful
execution or seizure. Accordingly, plaintiff failed to allege facts showing that the
Sodoma defendants wrongfully executed or seized plaintiff’s property, and the trial
court properly dismissed this claim.
2. Conversion
“Conversion is defined as ‘an unauthorized assumption and exercise of the
right of ownership over goods or personal chattels belonging to another, to the
alteration of their condition or the exclusion of an owner’s rights.’ ” Gallimore v. Sink,
27 N.C. App. 65, 67 (1975) (quoting Wall v. Colvard, Inc., 268 N.C. 43, 49 (1966)).
Conversion requires that “there must be ownership in the plaintiff and a wrongful
conversion by defendant.” Id.
Even assuming plaintiff adequately alleged an ownership interest, its
allegations do not establish a wrongful conversion by the Sodoma defendants. As
stated above, the collection efforts were authorized by court orders that were valid at
the time and that expressly identified plaintiff’s account. Because the amended
complaint does not allege the necessary wrongful deprivation, plaintiff failed to state
a claim for conversion.
3. Fraud and Abuse of Process
“Fraud requires a ‘(1) [f]alse representation or concealment of a material fact,
(2) reasonably calculated to deceive, (3) made with intent to deceive, (4) which does
in fact deceive, (5) resulting in damage to the injured party.’ ” Hudgins v. Wagoner,
-9-
CKE PROPERTIES, LLC V. SODOMA LAW, P.C.
Opinion of the Court
204 N.C. App. 480, 486 (2010) (quoting Forbis v. Neal, 361 N.C. 519, 526–27 (2007)).
Plaintiff argues that the Sodoma defendants falsely represented that they possessed
legal authority to collect from CKE’s accounts. But the facially valid order supplied
authority to pursue the identified accounts at the time those representations were
made. Plaintiff therefore has not alleged a false representation of material fact
sufficient to sustain its fraud claim.
Plaintiff’s abuse-of-process claim fails for the same reason. “Protection against
wrongful litigation is afforded by a cause of action for either abuse of process or
malicious prosecution. The legal theories underlying the two actions parallel one
another to a substantial degree, and often the facts of a case would support a claim
under either theory.” Stanback v. Stanback, 297 N.C. 181, 200 (1979). Misusing the
legal system for an ulterior purpose is actionable as abuse of process. Pinewood
Homes Inc. v. Harris, 184 N.C. App. 597, 602 (2007) (holding that the underlying
complaint stated a cause of action for abuse of process by alleging defendant sought
an injunction to coerce plaintiffs to pay a judgment for which they were not
responsible); Chidnese v. Chidnese, 210 N.C. App. 299, 310–11 (2011) (holding that
the underlying complaint supported abuse of process when defendant initiated a
criminal case to harass plaintiff without a lawful basis and defendant’s attorney
knowingly provided false information to the court to gain an advantage over plaintiff).
Although abuse of process protects against misuse of the legal system for an
ulterior purpose, the conduct plaintiff alleges here was the use of writs of execution
- 10 -
CKE PROPERTIES, LLC V. SODOMA LAW, P.C.
Opinion of the Court
to collect from accounts identified in facially valid court orders. Because the amended
complaint does not allege that those writs were used beyond the scope authorized by
those orders, it does not state an actionable abuse-of-process claim.
4. Negligence, Gross Negligence, and Punitive Damages
Negligence consists of four elements: (1) legal duty, (2) breach of that duty, (3)
actual and proximate causation, and (4) injury. Mabrey v. Smith, 144 N.C. App. 119,
122 (2001). Gross negligence is “wanton conduct done with conscious or reckless
disregard for the rights and safety of others.” Est. of Graham v. Lambert, 385 N.C.
644, 658 (2024).
Plaintiff argues that the Sodoma defendants acted with both negligence and
gross negligence by pursuing a judgment against CKE’s account. But because the
facially valid orders expressly identified CKE’s account as the account subject to
collection, plaintiff’s complaint fails to establish that the Sodoma defendants
breached a duty or showed wanton disregard by pursuing the actions authorized by
those orders. The negligence and gross-negligence claims were therefore properly
dismissed.
Punitive damages are only recoverable if the claimant proves the defendant
engaged in fraud, malice, or willful or wanton conduct. N.C.G.S. § 1D-15(a) (2025).
Because plaintiff failed to state an underlying claim against the Sodoma defendants
for fraud, malice, or willful or wanton conduct, the trial court properly dismissed the
punitive damages claim.
- 11 -
CKE PROPERTIES, LLC V. SODOMA LAW, P.C.
Opinion of the Court
Because plaintiff’s claims against the Sodoma defendants fail on the grounds
discussed above, we need not reach the parties’ arguments concerning absolute
privilege or immunity.
B. Sheriff Defendants
Plaintiff next argues the trial court erred by dismissing its claims against the
Sheriff defendants. We disagree.
By statute, a “sheriff, by himself or his lawful deputies, shall execute and make
due return of all writs and other process to him legally issued and directed, within
his county . . . or in any other place where he may lawfully execute the same.”
N.C.G.S. § 162-14 (2025). A sheriff levying a writ “cannot enquire upon what
evidence the judicial officer proceeded, or whether he committed an error or
irregularity in his decision.” Welch v. Scott, 27 N.C. 72, 76 (1844). Further, law
enforcement officers “cannot be deemed to act maliciously when they enforce a court
order that is valid on its face” and “are not expected to go beyond the face of the order.”
Thomas v. Sellers, 142 N.C. App. 310, 313 (2001) (quoting Jacobs v. Sherard, 36 N.C.
App. 60, 65 (1978)).
Here, the writs and accompanying materials identified the accounts to be
levied upon, including plaintiff’s account. The Sheriff defendants executed the writs
as directed. Plaintiffs argue that under Mica Indus., the Sheriff defendants can be
held liable because they executed the writ. 249 N.C. at 602. However, Mica does not
require that result. In Mica, the sheriff levied on property belonging to an entity
- 12 -
CKE PROPERTIES, LLC V. SODOMA LAW, P.C.
Opinion of the Court
other than the judgment debtor without process, directing seizure of that entity’s
property. Id. at 603–05. Here, by contrast, the process itself identified the account
that plaintiff argues was wrongfully seized. Neither Mica nor any of our other case
law required the Sheriff defendants to determine whether the district court correctly
included that account in its orders before executing the writs.
Because the Sheriff defendants’ execution of the writs was not wrongful,
plaintiff cannot state valid claims against them for wrongful execution and seizure or
for conversion. For the same reason, plaintiff has not alleged a breach of duty
supporting negligence or gross negligence. Further, plaintiff has not alleged
underlying neglect, misconduct, or misbehavior by the Sheriff defendants; therefore,
its derivative claim against Platte River Insurance Company likewise fails. In the
absence of any neglect, misconduct, or misbehavior by an officer, an insurance
company cannot be liable. N.C.G.S. § 58-76-5 (2025). We therefore affirm the order
dismissing the claims against the Sheriff defendants without reaching the parties’
remaining immunity arguments.
C. Bank of America
Finally, plaintiff argues the trial court erred by dismissing its claims against
Bank of America. Again, we disagree.
Where a judgment requires the payment of money or the
delivery of real or personal property it may be enforced in
those respects by execution, as provided in this Article.
Where it requires the performance of any other act a
certified copy of the judgment may be served upon the
- 13 -
CKE PROPERTIES, LLC V. SODOMA LAW, P.C.
Opinion of the Court
party against whom it is given, or upon the person or officer
who is required thereby or by law to obey the same, and his
obedience thereto enforced. If he refuses, he may be
punished by the court as for contempt.
N.C.G.S. § 1-302 (2025).
“After the issuing of an execution against property, all persons indebted to the
judgment debtor, or to any one of several debtors in the same judgment, may pay to
the sheriff the amount of their debt, or as much thereof as is necessary to satisfy the
execution . . . .” N.C.G.S. § 1-359(a) (2025). We have held that a bank may pay to the
sheriff’s office an amount from a bank account “when it is notified that there is an
outstanding writ of execution against its depositor,” and that Section 1-359 “provides
the defendant with a complete defense to plaintiff’s action.” Faught v. Branch
Banking & Tr. Co., 53 N.C. App. 132, 134 (1981).
The writs served on Bank of America identified the account as property from
which the funds were to be collected to satisfy the judgment. Both the Sheriff
defendants and Bank of America complied. Thus, plaintiff has not alleged a wrongful
act supporting its wrongful execution claim nor the wrongful deprivation necessary
for conversion. See Gallimore, 27 N.C. App. at 67. Nor has plaintiff alleged a breach
of duty supporting negligence or gross negligence where the alleged breach consists
of Bank of America’s compliance with a then-valid writ of execution. Accordingly, the
trial court properly dismissed the claims against Bank of America. Because these
claims fail on that basis, we need not address Bank of America’s alternative argument
- 14 -
CKE PROPERTIES, LLC V. SODOMA LAW, P.C.
Opinion of the Court
under the economic loss rule.
V. Conclusion
The trial court properly dismissed plaintiff’s claims against the Sodoma
defendants, the Sheriff defendants, and Bank of America under Rule 12(b)(6).
Accordingly, we affirm the trial court’s orders.
AFFIRMED.
Judges COLLINS and MURRY concur.
Report per Rule 30(e).
- 15 -