Full Opinion

NOT FOR PUBLICATION WITHOUT APPROVAL OF THE TAX COURT COMMITTEE ON OPINIONS TAX COURT OF NEW JERSEY MALA SUNDAR Richard J. Hughes Justice Complex PRESIDING JUDGE P.O. Box 975 Trenton, New Jersey 08625-0975 609 815-2922, Ext. 54630 Fax 609 376-3018 November 13, 2026 Kyung T. Rhee Plaintiff, Self-Represented Sean Joseph Brennan, Esq. Dilworth Paxson, LLP Attorney for Defendant Re: Kyung Rhee v. Borough of Little Silver Block 66, Lot 17, 44 Paag Circle Docket No. 008052-2025 Dear Mr. Rhee and Counsel: This is the court’s opinion after trial in the above-captioned matter. The only issue is the valuation of the above-captioned property (Subject) for tax year 2025. For the reasons stated below, the court finds that the adjustments to the proffered comparables, are net opinions of both plaintiff’s appraiser and the defendant’s assessor. As a result, the court cannot determine the comparables’ adjusted sale prices. This in turn, does not allow for a weighing of those adjusted prices for a value conclusion. For these reasons, the complaint is dismissed.1 1 The day after trial, defendant withdrew its counterclaim. PROCEDURAL HISTORY For tax year 2025, the Subject was assessed at $3,710,900 (allocated $2,170,200 to land and $1,540,700 to improvements), which plaintiff challenged before the Monmouth County Board of Taxation (County Board).2 The County Board left the assessment unchanged, and issued a judgement coded 2B [presumption of correctness not overcome]. Plaintiff timely appealed the County Board’s judgment to this court alleging that the Subject was over-assessed. Defendant, Borough of Little Silver (Borough), which did not contest the assessment at the County Board, filed a counterclaim alleging that the Subject was under-assessed. It withdrew this after trial. FACTS Plaintiff owns the Subject, a lot measuring 1.16 acres improved by a single- family home built in 2015 and located in the defendant taxing district (Borough). The house has a gross living area (GLA) of 4,176 square feet (SF), with four bedrooms, four full and two half bathrooms, a full walkout unfinished basement, two-car garage, patio and balconies.3 The house is raised in the rear and has an 2 The County Board’s website, Open Public Records Search System, shows the prior year’s assessment as $2,585,300 (allocated $1,559,200 to land and $1,026,100 to improvements). 3 Per the Subject’s property record card (PRC) in evidence, the GLA is 4,112 SF, bathrooms total 4.1, with one fireplace. Pictures of the Subject’s exterior and interior were the same in plaintiff’s appraiser’s report and the Borough’s exhibits. 2 unobstructed view of Shrewsbury River. At the rear is a dock and a partial bulkhead. Plaintiff’s appraiser described the Subject as a waterfront property with a panoramic view of the river and with riparian rights. At trial, plaintiff proffered testimony of a real estate appraiser who prepared a report. The court accepted the appraiser as an expert in real estate appraisal, and his report in evidence, both without objection by the Borough. The Borough’s assessor, who was qualified, without objection, as an expert in appraisal of residential properties, testified first to rebut the appraiser’s choice of comparables and nature/amount of adjustments, and then to proffer his set of comparables, with adjusted sale prices, and value conclusion. Plaintiff’s Appraiser’s Value Conclusion The appraiser concluded that the Subject’s value under the market approach was $2,700,000. His comparables consisted of the following four sales of single- family homes in the Borough, in proximity to the Subject and to the October 1, 2024, valuation date: Address Sale Date Sale Price 1 9 Paag Lane 08/2023 $3,170,000 2 680 Little Silver Point Rd 08/2024 $2,201,500 3 61 Winding Way 12/2023 $2,500,000 4 67 Rivers Edge Dr 09/2024 $1,585,000 3 He made adjustments for (a) time +¼ % per month based on his market analysis of the past year which showed an increase in residential property values; (b) condition; (c) location at 10% of sales price; (d) lack of panoramic water views, i.e., not waterfront at 5% of sales price; (e) lot size (at $100,000 per acre as computed by the court4) based on an extraction method as he testified; (f) GLA (at $115 per SF or PSF, rounded); and (g) amenities (bathroom, bedroom, garage count; basement; patio and/or balcony; fireplace; inground pool). Based on the respective adjusted sale prices ($3,008,500; $2,462,500; $2,669,500 and $2,075,000), he concluded the Subject’s value as $2,700,000. When asked why he did not consider the sale of the 52 Paag Circle, a house two doors down the Subject, which sold in August of 2022 for $4,700,000, he replied that the sale was two years before the assessment date, had superior features such as a much larger lot and GLA, and an inground pool (in addition to being skillfully marketed by the homeowners, one of whom was a realtor, the other being a property developer), which would require a large quantum of adjustments. This was so, he stated, even though he used Sale 1 which was sold one year prior to the valuation 4 For example, his comparable 1 (Paag Lane) was shown as having a lot size of 2.32 acres as compared to the Subject’s 1.16 acres. His adjustment was -$116,000 for the 1.16-acre difference. This translates to $100,000 per acre ($116,000 ÷ 1.16 acres = $100,000 per acre). 4 date, was larger than the Subject, and had a pool, for which he duly made adjustments. When asked why he excluded certain comparables in his own appraisal used for refinancing of the Subject, he stated that there were no limitations there as were here in terms of proximity to the assessment date or to the Subject. The one, an active listing, was used to show the market and due to the banks’ need of at least four comparables.5 When asked why he adjusted at $25,000 for the lesser baths in Sale 2 but at $15,000 for the same in the refinancing appraisal, he replied that it was due to the ranch style, and in any event, the adjusted sale price was the same in both appraisals. He agreed there were some mathematical inaccuracies in computing his market adjustment, however he maintained that they were insignificant, and that the market was stable when he appraised the Subject. He did not view the Subject as superior due to it being raised, although he agreed that it is a plus factor in severe flood zones (his report noting that the Subject and Sales 1 and 2, were in a flood zone). He disagreed that a property’s chronological age merits adjustments. Instead, he stated that the effective age of the property (i.e., condition) is relevant. 5 Plaintiff’s appraiser had prepared an appraisal for the Subject’s refinancing concluding its value at $2,700,000 as of 11/14/2024. That appraisal report, admitted into evidence, included two additional properties, one of which, 15 Mitchell Place, was used by the Borough’s assessor in his comparable grid. The other was 11 Pine Drive, which was an active listing. 5 Borough’s Assessor’s Rebuttal and Value Conclusion The Borough’s assessor testified that the Subject is in the most desirable section of the Borough, commanding the highest prices, as evidenced by a tree-lined street, the entrance to which is through a pair of “giant” stone columns with fencing on either side, and since most homes here have panoramic, i.e. unobstructed views, of the Shrewsbury River. He thus questioned the credibility of plaintiff’s appraiser’s Sales 3 and 4 since they were land-locked. As to the commonly used sales (9 Paag Lane and 680 Little Silver Point Road), and per his conversations with the listing agents, he stated neither was raised, had the usable lot, or panoramic views of the Shrewsbury River like the Subject (although they did have some water views), and the dwelling area’s alignment was inferior. These negative features, he said, would merit higher adjustments, thus, in placing lower weight to their adjusted sale prices. He then testified as to his set of comparables which were contained in a grid, with adjustments that were listed on a sheet with two columns, one identifying the item being adjusted and the second column listing the quantum of adjustment (instead of an appraisal report required to be, and is prepared by appraisers, qualified and accepted as experts in real estate appraisal). His comparable sales were: Address Sale Date Sale Price 1 15 Mitchell Place 11/13/2024 $3,205,000 2 52 Paag Circle 08/26/2022 $4,700,000 3 9 Paag Lane 08/18/2023 $3,170,000 6 4 670 Little Silver Point Rd 08/28/2023 $3,700,000 5 680 Little Silver Point Rd 08/23/2024 $2,201,500 Like plaintiff’s appraiser, he adjusted for (a) time but at 0.5% per month; (b) lot size but at $500,000 per acre of “uplands”; (c) GLA but at $250 PSF; (d) location/view, which he termed “neighborhood” to include the type of water view and Paag Circle’s desirability at 5% to 20%; and (e) amenities (number of bedrooms, bathrooms, garages; basement; fireplace; inground pool; patio/deck). His additional amenities meriting adjustments were for cabana; elevator; dock and bulkhead, his grid noting the Subject having an elevator, dock, bulkhead, and two fireplaces. He placed the most weight to the adjusted prices of Sales 1, 2, and 4 due to moderate adjustments and their being most like the Subject as to location (Sale 2 being two properties away from the Subject), lot size, and dwelling features. He gave lesser weight to Sales 3 and 5, the commonly used comparables, due to the higher magnitude of adjustments (GLA for instance) and “site influences.” Based on the respective adjusted sale prices of Sales 1 to 5 ($3,742,250; $4,545,250; $3,495,150; $3,788,750; and $3,319,975), he concluded the Subject’s implied value as $3,884,029, rounded to $3,875,000. 7 ANALYSIS Standard of Review A party challenging an assessment, or a county board of taxation’s judgment should, after overcoming the presumption of correctness, persuade the court that the assessment should be changed (i.e., determine a property’s true value). MSGW Real Estate Fund, LLC v. Mountain Lakes Borough, 18 N.J. Tax 364 (Tax 1998); Borough of Rumson v. Peckham, 7 N.J. Tax 539 (Tax 1985). The burden of persuasion “is met only when the court can conclude by a preponderance of the credible evidence that plaintiff’s opinion of value represents the true value of the subject property.” Id. at 550 (citation omitted). The court finds that plaintiff overcame the threshold burden of overcoming the presumption of correctness, since his appraiser’s report and testimony raised a debatable question in this regard, and further since the appraiser used an accepted valuation methodology for single-family homes. The court will now examine the proffered evidence to determine whether the plaintiff met his second burden, and persuade the court that the Subject’s assessment should change to $2,700,000. After examining the evidence presented here, the court is unpersuaded that a change in assessment is warranted. 8 Highest and Best Use Plaintiff’s appraiser concluded that the Subject’s highest and best use (HBU) was its current use. There was no such analysis by the Borough’s assessor, nor any objection to plaintiff’s appraiser’s conclusion. The court thus agrees with plaintiff’s appraiser’s opinion of the Subject’s HBU. Valuation The resolution of the matter hinges upon the credibility of the chosen comparables, and the adjustments made to their sale prices. As to comparables: plaintiff’s appraiser’s Sales 3 and 4 (61 Winding Way and 67 Rivers Edge Drive) are land locked. Therefore, and as shown by his total 15% adjustment for inferior location and lack of water views, these two comparables merit the least weight. Similarly, the assessor’s Sale 2 (52 Paag Circle) merits the least weight. Its significant sale price is an outlier, and speaks more to its larger lot size, GLA, and amenities, rather than its suitability as a comparable due to its close proximity to the Subject and location in Paag Circle. In addition, its sale was the farthest from the assessment date as compared to the other sales used by the assessor. As to adjustments, a significant problem is that neither the appraiser nor the assessor provided objective data to support their assertions that their adjustments were market-derived (plaintiff’s assessor being more candid by noting that some adjustments required a degree of subjectivity). Such data is needed for the court to 9 decide (a) whether an adjustment is warranted; and (b) whether the adjustment quantum is credible (the assessor being qualified as an expert is not exempt from this requirement). Here, for instance, if the court had to choose between plaintiff’s appraiser’s choice of +0.25% per month for time (although his report initially notes that the market was generally stable) over the assessor’s +0.50% per month, it would need to see the data supporting these amounts (e.g., a list of usable closed sales of single-family homes in the Borough for the past year), to decide which adjustment amount is justifiable. Nothing was provided to the court in this regard. Similarly, the appraiser’s report and the assessor’s grid were bereft of any objective data supporting their respective lot size difference adjustments at $100,000 per acre (appraiser) or $500,000 per acre of uplands (assessor).6 While plaintiff’s appraiser testified that he used an extraction method as the basis for the lot size difference 6 The assessor’s pictures of each property showed web-driven area measurements, from which he presumably determined how much is “uplands.” For instance, the common comparable 9 Paag Lane is listed as having 97,800 SF or 2.24 acres but per the assessor has 1.3 acres of uplands because there are “large wetlands/marsh area.” He performed this exercise for his comparables 1, 2 and 4 each with a larger acreage at 1.19; 1.59; and 1.26 acres respectively but computed at 0.78; 1.11; and 0.9 acres of “uplands.” The lower amount when compared to the Subject’s computed “uplands” of 1.1 acres (when the actual acreage is 1.21 acres) justified lack of adjustments for lot size differences (except for 680 Little Silver Point Rd which was 0.24 acres per its square foot of 112x93). Reducing lot sizes to what the assessor deems uplands is problematic since he is not qualified to make that determination and there is an absence of facts/formal opinion in this regard (such as, from the Department of Environmental Protection, or an expert in environmental issues). 10 adjustment, there was nothing in his report in this regard, nor did he provide any such data during trial.7 The GLA adjustment ($115 PSF versus $250 PSF) suffers from the same lack of objective data. All this means that the appraiser and assessor proffered net opinions. See Greenblatt v. Englewood City, 26 N.J. Tax 41, 55 (Tax 2010) (“adjustments must have a foundation obtained from the market, and where appropriate, supported by cost manuals,” thus, “naked assertions as to dollar amount adjustments do not carry the day”). Other issues on adjustments are as follows: Unclear is plaintiff’s appraiser’s adjustment of -$15,000 for “Above Grade” for his Sale 3 and 4. If this was a typographical error, then $15,000 should be added back to those comparables’ value conclusion. Also unclear is why plaintiff’s appraiser excluded the Subject’s dock, partial bulkhead, elevator and fireplace as amenities (each listed on the assessor’s grid). Such amenities could have an impact on the sale prices of comparables which may or did not have such amenities. Further confusing the issue is a physical characteristic that could have been easily verified but apparently was not: the Subject’s PRC reports one fireplace. The assessor’s grid reports the Subject as having two fireplaces. The appraiser’s report 7 An abstraction method under the cost approach to valuation is where land value is estimated from sales of improved properties and an “appraiser subtracts the contributory value or depreciated cost of the improvements from the sale price yielding an indicated land value for the property.” Local Property Div. of Taxation, Real Property Appraisal Manual for New Jersey Assessors, 26 (3d ed. 2021). 11 for refinancing states the Subject as having a wood burning stove in the living room. Similarly, the Subject’s PRC does not indicate the existence of an elevator, but the refinancing appraisal report shows this amenity. The adjustments for physical amenities also lacked data (such as cost data from a reliable publication used by real estate appraisers as appropriate depreciated). Although, for the most part, the appraiser’s and assessor’s quantum of adjustments were not significantly different, the court cannot deem this a sufficient reason to adopt just those adjustments to decide the Subject’s value. Without credible and objective data to conclude the appropriate adjusted sale prices of each of the proffered comparables, the court cannot weigh the adjusted sale prices to conclude a justified value opinion. See American Cyanamid Co. v. Wayne Twp., 17 N.J. Tax 542, 581 (Tax 1998) (“without . . . adjustments [to the comparables’ sale prices], the sales provide no meaningful indication of the value of the subject property”); Greenblat, 26 N.J. Tax at 54-55 (“an expert’s opinion is only as good as the data upon which the expert relied”). The court is fully aware that it has a responsibility to find value. Ford Motor Co. v. Edison Twp., 127 N.J. 290, 311-13 (1992). It is also aware that it should not place too difficult a burden on the experts to demonstrate value. Glen Wall Assocs. v. Wall Twp., 99 N.J. 265, 273 (1985). However, this does not mean that the court can overlook problems with the proffered evidence. See F.M.C. Stores Co. v. 12 Borough of Morris Plains, 100 N.J. 418, 430 (1985) (the court can only determine the true value of the property based upon “the evidence before it and the data that are properly at its disposal”). Nor can the court do its own research for objective data in this regard, and decide the case. See e.g. Washington Shopping Center, Inc. v. Washington Twp., 32 N.J. Tax 259, 279 (Tax 2021) (a court should “base its decision” only on the record before it). Therefore, the complaint is dismissed. An Order and Final Judgment will be simultaneously entered with this opinion. Very Truly Yours, /s/ Mala Sundar Hon. Mala Sundar, P.J.T.C. 13