Matt Marino v. Board of Review
CourtNew Jersey Superior Court Appellate Division
Date FiledNovember 19, 2026
DocketA-3720-24
StatusUnpublished
๐ฐ News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
NOT FOR PUBLICATION WITHOUT THE
APPROVAL OF THE APPELLATE DIVISION
This opinion shall not "constitute precedent or be binding upon any court ." Although it is posted on the
internet, this opinion is binding only on the parties in the case and its use in other cases is limited. R. 1:36-3.
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
APPELLATE DIVISION
DOCKET NO. A-3720-24
MATT MARINO,
Appellant,
v.
BOARD OF REVIEW,
DEPARTMENT OF LABOR AND
WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT,
and SETON HALL UNIVERSITY,
Respondents.
___________________
Submitted October 13, 2026 โ Decided November 19, 2026
Before Judges Gilson and DeAngelis.
On appeal from the Board of Review, Division of
Unemployment Insurance, Department of Labor and
Workforce Development, Docket No. 302284.
Matt Marino, self-represented appellant.
Jennifer Davenport, Attorney General, attorney for
respondent Board of Review (Sookie Bae-Park,
Assistant Attorney General, of counsel; Rimma
Razhba, Deputy Attorney General, on the brief).
PER CURIAM
Claimant Matt Marino appeals from a July 16, 2025 final agency decision
by the Board of Review (Board), which found that he was ineligible for
unemployment benefits between May 22, 2022 and August 27, 2022. The Board
determined that Marino was employed by an educational institution and had
reasonable assurance that he would be employed for the fall semester of 2022.
Because there was no credible evidence that Marino had reasonable assurance
of reemployment under N.J.S.A. 43:21-4(g)(1), we reverse and remand,
directing the Board to provide Marino with unemployment benefits between
May 22, 2022 and August 21, 2022.
I.
From the fall of 2019 through the spring of 2023, Marino worked as a
part-time adjunct instructor at Seton Hall University (Seton Hall). During that
period, he did not work for Seton Hall in the spring semesters of 2020 and 2021.
Marino stopped working for Seton Hall following the spring semester of 2023
because he was not rehired for the fall semester. Instead, he was employed by
three other educational institutions.
On May 22, 2022, Marino filed a claim for unemployment benefits,
seeking benefits for the summer months of 2022. On July 14, 2022, a deputy of
A-3720-24
2
the Division of Unemployment Insurance (Division) sent Marino a letter
denying his claim based on a determination that he was ineligible for benefits
between the academic terms because he had reasonable assurance of
employment with Seton Hall for the fall semester.
Marino appealed that decision. After a series of procedural delays, on
November 20, 2024 the Appeal Tribunal (Tribunal) held a hearing on Marino's
application for benefits. Marino, who was the only witness to appear, testified
that he was a part-time adjunct professor at Seton Hall and during the spring
semester of 2022, he taught two classes and was paid $6,200. He explained that
the 2022 spring semester ended on May 9, 2022, and he was not told he would
be teaching during the fall semester until mid-August 2022, two weeks before
the semester began on August 29, 2022. Additionally, Marino testified that he
worked as a part-time adjunct professor for Seton Hall in the spring semester of
2023, and he was not rehired by Seton Hall for the 2023 fall semester. Instead,
during the fall 2023 semester Marino worked as a part-time adjunct professor
for three other higher educational institutions.
In a written decision dated November 20, 2024, the Tribunal determined
that Marino was ineligible for benefits between May 22, 2022 and August 27,
2022, because he had reasonable assurance of reemployment with an educational
A-3720-24
3
institution. Marino appealed that decision to the Board. On February 10 , 2024,
the Board determined there was insufficient evidence that Marino had
reasonable assurance of employment for the fall 2022 semester and remanded
for a new hearing. 1
The Tribunal held the second hearing on April 17, 2025. Two witnesses
testified: Marino and Michael Chialastri, a Deputy of the Division. No one from
Seton Hall appeared at the hearing or provided information to the Tribunal.
Marino testified that he had worked for Seton Hall between the fall of
2019 and the spring of 2023. Regarding 2022, he explained that he had worked
as a part-time professor in the spring and fall semesters, but he was not told he
would be working in the fall semester until August 15, 2022, two weeks before
the semester started on August 29, 2022. Marino also testified that during the
time that he worked for Seton Hall, the University did not let him know that he
would be teaching for the next semester until a week or two before the semester
started.
1
Marino had also applied for unemployment benefits between the 2023 spring
and 2023 fall semesters. The Board reversed the Tribunal's denial of an award
for that period and awarded Marino benefits from May 21, 2023, through June
24, 2023 in accordance with N.J.S.A. 43:21-4(g)(1) because Marino "did not
have reasonable assurance of reemployment with an educational institution."
The Board also instructed Marino to pursue benefits for the period after June 24,
2023.
A-3720-24
4
Deputy Chialastri explained that educational institutions, such as Seton
Hall, are supposed to submit an electronic spreadsheet to the Division ten days
before the end of a semester. The spreadsheet should list the employees who
were and who were not returning. For those employees who were returning to
work at the school the next year, the University was supposed to provide a
description of how each employee was given reasonable assurance of
reemployment. Deputy Chialastri explained that Seton Hall did not provide any
information to the Division regarding Marino.
On April 22, 2025, the Tribunal issued a written decision denying Marino
benefits for the summer of 2022. The Tribunal found that Marino had been
employed as an adjunct instructor with Seton Hall from the fall of 2019 through
the spring of 2023. The Tribunal also found that during each fall semester,
Marino taught two courses and was paid $6,200. The Tribunal also determined
that it was the practice of Seton Hall to notify Marino of his fall courses in the
middle of August.
The Tribunal noted that because Seton Hall had failed to provide
information to the Division on whether Marino had reasonable assurance of
being rehired there was a rebuttable presumption that he did not have reasonable
assurance. See N.J.S.A. 43:21-4(g)(9). Nevertheless, the Tribunal reasoned the
A-3720-24
5
presumption had been overcome because Marino had a history of being
reemployed each fall semester between 2019 and 2022. Thus, the Tribunal
concluded that the totality of circumstances demonstrated Marino had
reasonable assurance of reemployment and accordingly he was ineligible for
benefits under N.J.S.A. 43:21-4(g)(1) and N.J.A.C. 12:17-12.4(a).
Marino appealed the Tribunal's decision to the Board. On July 16, 2025,
the Board issued a decision affirming the Tribunal's determination.
II.
On this appeal, Marino argues that he did not have reasonable assurance
that he would return to work for the fall 2022 semester and, accordingly, he
should have been granted benefits under N.J.S.A. 43:21-4(g). He also contends
that the Board and Tribunal erred in finding that he had reasonable assurance of
reemployment. We agree that the record does not contain credible evidence that
Marino would be reemployed by Seton Hall for the 2022 fall semester before
August 15, 2022. Accordingly, under the governing law, Marino was entitle d
to unemployment benefits from May 22, 2022 until the week following the
August 15, 2022 offer. See N.J.A.C. 12:17-12.4(b) (explaining "[w]here
reasonable assurance is subsequently given to the individual . . . any ineligibility
A-3720-24
6
. . . begins the first calendar week following the date the individual received
reasonable assurance of recall").
Generally, an appellate court's review of an administrative agency
decision is limited. See Sullivan v. Bd. of Rev., Dep't of Lab., 471 N.J. Super.
147, 155-56 (App. Div. 2022). In matters involving unemployment benefits, we
accord particular deference to the Board's experience in the application of the
Unemployment Compensation Law. See Brady v. Bd. of Rev., 152 N.J. 197,
210 (1997). Accordingly, courts will not reverse an agency's decision unless it
is "'arbitrary, capricious, or unreasonable' or is unsupported 'by substantial
credible evidence in the record.'" Sullivan, 471 N.J. Super. at 156 (quoting
Henry v. Rahway State Prison, 81 N.J. 571, 579-80 (1980)).
We accord less deference when we construe statutes. While we give
respect to an agency's interpretation of a statute in its area of expertise, we
review statutory interpretation issues de novo. Ardan v. Bd. of Rev., 231 N.J.
589, 604 (2018) (explaining that while "an appellate court is 'in no way bound
by the agency's interpretation of a statute or its determination of a strictly legal
issue'" (quoting US Bank, N.A. v. Hough, 210 N.J. 187, 200 (2012)), we
recognize that "a state agency brings experience and specialized knowledge to
its task of administering and regulating a legislative enactment within its field
A-3720-24
7
of expertiseโ (quoting In re Election Law Enf't Comm'n Advisory Op. No. 01โ
2008, 201 N.J. 254, 262, (2010))).
The Unemployment Compensation Law (the Law), N.J.S.A. 43:21 -1 to -
71, governs unemployment compensation in New Jersey. The Law is intended
to provide income to workers when they are "out of work through no fault or act
of [their] own.โ Ardan, 231 N.J. at 601 (quoting Yardville Supply Co. v. Bd. of
Rev., 114 N.J. 371, 375 (1989)). The Law has specific provisions concerning
people who work for educational institutions. See N.J.S.A. 43:21-4(g). The
Division also has regulations that address the eligibility of employees of
educational institutions. See N.J.A.C. 12:17-12.4.
Under the Law, an employee of an educational institution is ineligible for
benefits between academic years or terms if that employee "has reasonable
assurance" that he or she will be employed by the educational institution in the
following academic year or term in the same capacity and under substantially
the same conditions and compensation. See N.J.S.A. 43:21-4(g)(1). In that
regard, the Law states:
With respect to service performed . . . for an educational
institution, benefits shall not be paid based on such
services for any week of unemployment commencing
during the period between two successive academic
years, or during a similar period between two regular
terms, . . . to any individual if such individual performs
A-3720-24
8
such services in the first of such academic years (or
terms) and if there is a contract or a reasonable
assurance that such individual will perform services in
any such capacity for any educational institution in the
second of such academic years or terms[.]
[N.J.S.A. 43:21-4(g)(1).]
N.J.S.A. 43:21-4(g) "is tailored to meet the unique ten-month term of
educational employment." Charatan v. Bd. of Rev., 200 N.J. Super. 74, 79 (App.
Div. 1985). The "intent of the law was to address those work circumstances that
naturally entail periods of unemployment subsequent to the end of an academic
term and prior to the assured renewal of employment at the start of the next
academic term." Weber-Smith v. Bd. of Rev., 337 N.J. Super. 319, 323 (App.
Div. 2001).
The Law explains that "in order for there to be a 'reasonable assurance' all
of" six requirements must be met. N.J.S.A. 43:21-4(g)(5). Those requirements
include that "[t]he educational institution has made an offer of employment in
the following academic year or term that is either written, oral, or implied;" the
offer is not contingent on factors within the institution's control; and the
employee will be given substantially the same salary and terms of employment.
Ibid.
A-3720-24
9
To assist the Division in determining when a claimant is or is not eligible
for unemployment benefits, the Law requires educational institutions to furnish
the Division with certain information "no less than 10 business days prior to the
end of the academic year or term[.]" N.J.S.A. 43:21-4(g)(7). That information
includes "[a] list of all employees who the educational institution has concluded
do not have a reasonable assurance of employment in the following academic
year or term," and "for each employee that the educational institution maintains
does have a reasonable assurance of employment in the following academic year
or term, a statement explaining the manner in which the employee was given a
reasonable assurance of employment." N.J.S.A. 43:21-4(g)(7)(A), (B). When
an educational institution fails to provide the required information to the
Division, there is "a rebuttable presumption that the claimant does not have a
reasonable assurance of employment in the following academic year or term."
N.J.S.A. 43:21-4(g)(9).
In this matter, there is nothing in the record that establishes that Marino
had reasonable assurance of reemployment for the 2022 fall semester before
August 15, 2022. Marino testified that when the spring 2022 semester ended on
May 9, 2022, he did not have assurance of reemployment for the fall semester.
There are no facts indicating that he had a contract or that anyone at Seton Hall
A-3720-24
10
made an offer of employment in writing, orally, or implicitly. Indeed, Deputy
Chialastri testified that Seton Hall did not provide any information concerning
Marino. Therefore, there was a rebuttable presumption that Marino had not been
given reasonable assurance of reemployment. See N.J.S.A. 43:21-4(g)(9).
Nothing in the record overcame that presumption. The Board and
Tribunal relied on the fact that Marino had previously been rehired each fall
semester between 2020 and 2022. While the Tribunal found that that was a
three-year history, the limited pattern did not constitute reasonable assurance
under the Law. In that regard, Marino was not rehired by Seton Hall for the Fall
semester of 2023. So, there were insufficient facts from which a finding of
reasonable assurance of reemployment could be made under the governing
statutory provision. See N.J.S.A. 43:21-4(g)(5), (7).
The Board contends that there is evidence in the record supporting the
determination that Marino had reasonable assurance of reemployment because
he was rehired on August 15, 2022, and returned to work for Seton Hall on
August 29, 2022. The Board also cites to Marino's work history at Seton Hall.
Although the Law requires an assessment of the totality of circumstances,
N.J.S.A. 43:21-4(g)(5)(F), it also requires that certain facts be present to support
a finding of reasonable assurance. Those facts include (1) the existence of a
A-3720-24
11
written, oral, or implied offer of employment for the following semester or term,
N.J.S.A. 43:21-4(g)(5)(A); (2) the offer is for employment in the same capacity
with substantially the same economic terms, N.J.S.A. 43:21-4(g)(5)(C), (D); and
(3) the offer is not contingent on factors that are within the educational
institution's control, N.J.S.A. 43:21-4(g)(5)(E). None of those facts were found
and none of those facts could be found on the record developed at the two
hearings. Indeed, the only evidence in the record was the testimony of Marino.
Marino consistently testified that he was not given reasonable assurance of
reemployment between any semester, including between the spring and fall
semesters of 2022.
Accordingly, we conclude that there was insufficient credible evidence in
the record to support the Board's finding that Marino had reasonable assurance
of employment for the fall semester of 2022 before August 15, 2022. The
Board's determination of ineligibility is, therefore, reversed and the matter is
remanded to the Board for purposes of calculating the amount of benefits to
which Marino is entitled for the period between May 22, 2022 and August 21,
2022. See N.J.A.C. 12:17-12.4(b).
Reversed, vacated, and remanded. We do not retain jurisdiction.
A-3720-24
12