Full Opinion

BY THE COURT ____________________________________ TOWNSHIP OF ABERDEEN, : TAX COURT OF NEW JERSEY : Plaintiff, : DOCKET NO. 010234-2026 : v. : : Civil Action MONMOUTH COUNTY BOARD : OF TAXATION; DIRECTOR, DIV. OF : TAXATION, : ORDER : Defendants. : ____________________________________: This matter having been opened to the court by application of plaintiff, through its counsel, Middleton Law, seeking relief by way of preliminary injunction by way of an Order to Show Cause why defendants should be restrained and enjoined from requiring, approving, or implementing an annual reassessment for tax year 2027, for reasons set forth in the certifications appended to the application; AND defendants having duly opposed the application through their counsel, the Attorney General of New Jersey (James J. Robinson, Jr., Deputy Attorney General, appearing); AND the court having carefully considered the pleadings and the respective oral arguments proffered by counsel for the parties, and for the reasons set forth in the accompanying Statement of Reasons; IT IS on this 22nd day of November 2026 ORDERED as follows: 1. The October 16, 2026, Order of temporary stay as to the issuance of the notices of assessment for tax year 2027 will remain STATUS QUO. 2. The issues raised in the complaint will be bifurcated so that the court will first hear and decide the allegations as to the 2027 reassessment. The hearing is scheduled for December 10, 2026, which will be held in-person in the Tax Court. 3. The remaining issues will be tried at a later date but within such time so that any orders for reassessment for 2028 and later years need not be subject to repeated litigation and stay applications. The trial will consolidate all pending complaints with the same causes of action, namely, Docket Numbers 000363-2019; 010016-2024; 010017-2024; 010019-2024; and 010020-2024. A separate Consolidation Order will be entered in this regard after a conference with counsel for the parties in all the pending matters, including the instant matter. /s/ Mala Sundar Hon. Mala Sundar, P.J.T.C. 2 Aberdeen Twp. v. Monmouth County Bd. of Taxation et al., Docket No. 010234-2026 STATEMENT OF REASONS BACKGROUND On September 1, 2026, plaintiff, Township of Aberdeen (Aberdeen) filed a complaint asking that this court (1) set aside and void the June 30, 2026, and August 13, 2026, respective approvals of defendants, the Monmouth County Board of Taxation (County Board) and the Division of Taxation (Taxation), of the Form AFR-A 1 filed by Aberdeen’s assessor where he proposed to conduct a reassessment for tax year 2027; (2) enjoin Aberdeen’s assessor from implementing or certifying to the 2027 assessments, as being a reassessment, if and until the statutory and regulatory prerequisites have been satisfied; (3) dissolve the ADP and the annual reassessment program implemented by the County Board under the aegis of the Real Property Assessment Demonstration Program (ADP), N.J.S.A. 54:1-101 to - 106; and (4) allow Aberdeen to withdraw from the ADP. The 182 allegations in support of these reliefs are that (i) neither Aberdeen’s assessor nor defendants have ever followed any of the regulatory requirements of an annual reassessment found in N.J.A.C. 18:12A-1.14(i), which among others, requires the assessor to determine that there is a need for an annual reassessment; (ii) the same non-compliance is also evidenced as to the AFR-A for tax year 2027 (the assessor submitting the form under duress/threat of employment loss and license revocation/suspension); (iii) Aberdeen’s Chapter 123 ratio is at 110.37% for tax year 2026, thus, there is no justifiable statutory or regulatory basis for the County Board to order Aberdeen perform a reassessment for tax year 2027; (iv) as a five-year program, the ADP expired in 2018, thus, there is no statutory basis for the permanent continuation of the annual reassessment program 1 AFR-A stands for “Application for Annual Reassessment Program.” 3 and should be dissolved along with the ADP; and (v) the ADP and the annual reassessment program implemented by the County Board violates the Uniformity Clause of the New Jersey Constitution due to its disparate treatment of Monmouth County residents subject to the ADP as compared to other New Jersey counties which do not participate in the ADP. 2 On October 9, 2026, Aberdeen applied for Interim Injunctive Relief and Temporary Restraints by way of an Order to Show Cause (OTSC) for the County Board (or its Administrator) and Taxation to be restrained and enjoined from requiring, approving, and implementing a 2027 annual assessment for Aberdeen. On October 16, 2026, the court issued an Order temporarily staying the issuance of a preliminary tax list to the County Board and of the notices of assessment to the taxpayers by Aberdeen’s assessor for tax year 2027 until after the court decided the merits of Aberdeen’s application for injunctive relief. Response and reply briefs were duly filed, after which the court heard oral arguments on November 20, 2026. 3 2 Aberdeen amended the complaint on September 23, 2026, to include Taxation and Aberdeen’s assessor as additional defendants, and to include the AFR-A approved by Taxation on August 13, 2026. It removed the assessor as a party by a second amended complaint of October 16, 2026. 3 Another complaint with the identical cause of action was filed against the County Board by Matawan Borough on September 2, 2026, (Docket No. 010248-2026), where, as here, Matawan sought temporary restraints by way of an OTSC. The court issued an identical stay order on October 16, 2026. On November 6, 2026, the court issued a fully executed consent order that Aberdeen, Matawan, Taxation and the County Board would “coordinate” the two cases (Docket Nos. 010234-2026 and 010248-2026) “for purposes of discovery and motion practice on common pretrial issues.” Also pending are the consolidated complaints filed against the County Board by taxing districts, Avon-By-The-Sea (Docket No. 000363-2019); Wall Township (Docket No. 010016- 2024); Manasquan Borough (Docket No. 010017-2024); Belmar Borough (Docket No. 010019- 2024); and Marlboro Township (Docket No. 010020-2024). These complaints broadly challenge the implemented annual reassessment program, and in some cases, the constitutionality of the ADP, but unlike here, do not include an allegation as to, and relief for, tax year 2027 specifically. 4 ANALYSIS (A) The ADP The Legislature enacted the ADP by L. 2013, c. 15, § 1 (effective January 25, 2013). It was intended “to evaluate the efficacy and functionality of a municipal system of real property assessment directed by a county tax board through the county tax administrator pursuant to a revised assessment, and assessment appeal, calendar.” N.J.S.A. 54:1-104(a). As complementing the county-based real property assessment system pilot program undertaken pursuant to the provisions of” N.J.S.A. 54:1-86, the Legislature expected to “evaluate the effectiveness of each system of real property assessment, and to determine whether the current statutory system of real property assessment function should be revised Statewide.” N.J.S.A. 54:1-104(a). 4 An ADP-participant county must “commence the demonstration program under a plan developed by the county tax administrator of” that County, and “approved by the county board of taxation,” with such plan being submitted to Taxation and the Division of Local Government Services. N.J.S.A. 54:1-104(c)(2). Taxation can “take any action as is deemed necessary and consistent with the intent of” the ADP law, “to implement its provisions, including but not limited to the authority to waive any provisions of statutory law and regulations that may be inconsistent with the intent or application of” such law. N.J.S.A. 54:1-104(g). In 2016, Taxation promulgated N.J.A.C. 18:12A-1.14(i). The regulation listed several requirements, including mandating an assessor to complete an “application for annual 4 N.J.S.A. 54:1-86 to -96, is called the “Property Tax Assessment Reform Act” whereby the Legislature established a “county tax assessment system.” Under this law, “the entire real property assessment function formerly performed by” an assessor was “transferred to the county through the appointment of a county assessor and deputy county assessors.” N.J.S.A. 54:1-104(a). 5 reassessment” on Form AFR-A. N.J.A.C. 18:12A-1.14(i)(1). Prior to the filing of this form, “an assessor must notify, in writing, the mayor and local governing body, the county board of taxation, and the county tax administrator of the basis for the assessor's determination that the proposed reassessment is needed.” N.J.A.C. 18:12A-1.14(i)(2). The County Board should, within 45 days after review of the AFR-A, forward the same to Taxation and the assessor, “with a notation of approval or disapproval,” and within 45 days of receipt of this notated form, Taxation should indicate its approval or disapproval “as to whether the assessor may proceed with the reassessment program.” N.J.A.C. 18:12A-1.14(i)(3); (4). (B) Temporary Restraints The grant of preliminary injunctive relief is discretionary, thus, examined on appeal under an abuse of discretion standard. Rinaldo v. RLR Inv., LLC, 387 N.J. Super. 387, 395 (App. Div. 2006). See also Crowe v. De Gioia, 90 N.J. 126, 132 (1982) (a stay requires “the most sensitive exercise of judicial discretion”). To obtain injunctive relief, a movant/applicant should show that: (1) an injunction is needed to prevent irreparable harm; (2) the legal right underlying plaintiff’s claim is settled; (3) there exists a reasonable probability of ultimate success on the merits; and (4) the balance of the hardship to the parties favors the issuance of the requested relief. Id. at 132-34. Each element of this four- part test must be proven. Waste Mgmt. of N.J., Inc. v. Union Cnty. Utils. Auth., 399 N.J. Super. 508, 520 (App. Div. 2008). Each prong need not be weighed equally nor inflexibly. Ibid. (“a court may take a less rigid view . . . when the interlocutory injunction is merely designed to preserve the status quo”). This would allow for relief “even if the claim appears doubtful when a balancing of the relative hardships substantially favors the movant, or the irreparable injury to be suffered by the movant in the absence of the injunction would be imminent and grave, or the 6 subject matter of the suit would be impaired or destroyed.” Waste Mgmt. of N.J., Inc. v. Morris Cnty. Mun. Utils. Auth., 433 N.J. Super. 445, 454 (App. Div. 2013). Aberdeen posits that it meets all the criteria, and more since the temporary stay would be for the public good. Defendants posit that Aberdeen fails three of the four Crowe tests, namely, that the law is unsettled; there is no irreparable harm since the County Board has until May 2027 to revise any assessment changes without the need to print additional assessment notices; and the balance of equities favor defendants because carrying the 2026 assessments into 2027 would harm taxpayers under Chapter 123 and “cascade” through the County Board’s appeal and apportionment calendar. However, they are not opposed to the relief being limited to retaining the status quo of the stay currently in place. The court finds that Aberdeen has met the Crowe tests. The court agrees with Aberdeen that lifting the temporary stay so that its assessor can mail notices of assessment for tax year 2027 to the 7,000+ taxpayers before the merits of its complaint are decided will cause them irreparable harm, namely widespread confusion, inconvenience and added expense. This would be in addition to Aberdeen’s assessor having to respond to the innumerable queries from these members of the public in this regard. Aberdeen persuasively points out that if assessment notices were sent now - whether using the 2026 assessment amounts or the 2027 reassessment amounts - risks forcing the municipality to send a second set of notices if the court later rules against the chosen approach. This will (i) most definitely confuse the taxpayers as to which is the correct assessment notice and why; (ii) which appeal deadline controls since both notices will contain instructions on when, where, and how to appeal the assessment; and (iii) cause those taxpayers who may have already exercised their appeal rights to re-incur additional expense towards filing (very likely without a 7 refund of, or credit for the filing fees paid for appeal of the first notice), retaining counsel, and/or an appraiser. Adding to this confusion would be if judgments were to be issued either by the County Board (on petitions filed by taxpayers) or by this court (on direct appeals filed by taxpayers) based on the first set of assessment notices (whether due to settlement or otherwise). Would those judgments have to be voided if the court decides those notices were invalid? These issues are completely avoidable if only one set of assessment notices are mailed to the 7,000+ taxpayers of Aberdeen after this court decides the matter on its merits, who will then have 45 days to appeal the same whether to the County Board or to this court. See e.g. Crowe, 90 N.J. at 133 (“In certain circumstances, severe personal inconvenience can constitute irreparable injury justifying issuance of injunctive relief.”). Taxation and the County Board (via certifications) contend that the 2027 assessment list is only finalized in May of 2027, thus, can be changed up until that time. 5 This broad-based argument fails to address, let alone acknowledge the undoubted uncertainty and confusion (thus, harm) visited on the taxpaying public were the stay to be now lifted and allow for two assessment notices to be mailed to Aberdeen taxpayers. Ignoring these consequences does not eliminate their logically undeniable existence. Nor does the court find persuasive their contentions that the alleged harm could have easily been avoided had Aberdeen promptly filed a complaint in time for the issue to be resolved without disruption to the statutory deadlines for filing preliminary/final assessment lists and appeals (see 5 An assessor must first file a preliminary assessment list with the County Board by November 1 of the pretax year, N.J.S.A. 54:4-35(b), and then mail each taxpayer, the “of the preliminary assessment and preceding year’s taxes” by November 15 of the pretax year. N.J.S.A. 54:4-38.1(b). A final assessment list should be filed with the County Board by May 5 of the tax year. N.J.S.A. 54:4-35(b). 8 n.5, n.7). The complaint was filed shortly after Aberdeen’s assessor received the Taxation- approved Form AFR-A. The application for stay was filed within a month thereafter. Both these filings were prior to the start of the November deadlines. The court does not agree with defendants’ contention that the allowance of changed assessment notices under N.J.S.A. 54:4-38(b) eliminates any claims of irreparable harm. 6 At issue here is not one or two specific assessment notices to be sent to one or two taxpayers, but rather, Aberdeen having to issue new changed assessment notices to each taxpayer in Aberdeen. N.J.S.A. 54:4-38(b) does not establish that Aberdeen’s claim of harm is illusory, nor is it a persuasive basis for deciding that the public good is better served by denying the stay. The resultant confusion of two sets of assessment notices to the entirety of Aberdeen’s taxpayers were the temporary restraints to be denied, easily outweighs the slightly compressed timeline for completion of the steps prior to the finalization of the tax list by the assessor (May 5, 2027), and by the County Board (May 25, 2027), while refuting defendant’s opposition to the stay that the statutory deadlines are inflexible. 7 For this same reason, and absent facts or specific dates in either defendant’s certification, their contention that a stay will cause a negative impact on equalization or apportionment, is unpersuasive. The ability to still comply with the appeal deadlines, and even final assessment list 6 After the preliminary assessment is sent to taxpayers by November 15 of the pretax year, the assessor must “notify each taxpayer by mail within 30 days of any change to the assessment.” N.J.S.A. 54:4-38.1(b). The change of assessment notice must include “the prior assessment and the current assessment” with the appeal deadline and rights “printed in boldface type.” Ibid. 7 Taxpayers can appeal their assessments to the County Board by “January 15, or 45 days from the date the bulk mailing of notification of assessment is completed in the taxing district, whichever date is later.” N.J.S.A. 54:3-21(a)(2). If the assessment “exceeds $1,000,000,” they can appeal the same to the Tax Court instead but by “April 1, or 45 days from the date the bulk mailing of notification of assessment is completed in the taxing district, whichever date is later.” Ibid. A county board of taxation must “hear and determine all . . . appeals within three months after the last day for filing such appeals.” N.J.S.A. 54:3-26. The county board can request an extension of this period from Taxation “for . . . good cause shown.” N.J.S.A. 54:3-26.1. 9 deadlines, show that there is little to no prejudice or harm to the defendants if the stay remains status quo. Aberdeen also noted that there is no impact on tax collection if the stay were to be granted. Neither defendant contradicted this assertion. The equities, on a balance, clearly favor Aberdeen’s request for such relief pending the outcome of a final hearing. The court also agrees with Aberdeen that it has a reasonable probability of succeeding on the merits of the case. Nowhere in their opposition do defendants contend or even suggest that the procedural requirements for an annual reassessment under N.J.A.C. 18:12A-1.14(i) were fully and formally adhered to. There is no certification that the County Board required a reassessment after it determined “the need therefor.” N.J.S.A. 54:1-104(f). Neither is there any assertion or evidence that these requirements were waived by Taxation. See N.J.S.A. 54:1-104(g) (Taxation and the Division of Local Government Services are authorized to “waive any provisions of statutory law and regulations that may be inconsistent with the intent or application of the” ADP). Rather, the defendants’ certifications assert that once a municipality begins an annual assessment program, it must necessarily continue to do so, i.e., an annual reassessment must continue every year because they are done every year. The regulation, however, conditions a reassessment upon the assessor’s determination of a need for one. N.J.A.C. 18:12A-1.14(i)(2). Aberdeen’s argument on probability of success on merits is also credible given that its Chapter 123 ratio for 2026 to be over 100% as determined by Taxation. Aberdeen’s coefficient of deviation is about 11%. Taxation concedes that these factors render the 2026 assessments stable and equitable. Why then, Aberdeen persuasively asks, is there a need to reassess all properties for 2027? The opposition’s response that Chapter 123 cannot be the standard because the 15% corridor allows for inaccurate assessments, does not eliminate or dilute Aberdeen’s probability of success on the merits for purposes of the Crowe analysis. Rather, it appears to be a general 10 criticism of the remedial statute (providing the 15% corridor to resolve discrimination claims as to local property tax burdens) which apparently can be overcome by an annual reassessment each year (even if the Chapter 123 ratio is 100% as it is for Aberdeen). Defendants’ argument (sans any specific fact-based data or even legal authority) that annual reassessments capture added assessments which were omitted to be imposed, does not state a case for Aberdeen being likely to fail on the merits. A completely separate statutory scheme governs added assessments, and case law also permits imposing an omitted added assessment. See N.J.S.A. 54:4-63.2; Appeal of N.Y. State Realty & Terminal Co., 21 N.J. 90, 97 (1956). An assessor should file an added assessment list by October 1 “following” the completion of the improvements. N.J.S.A. 54:4-63.5. This obligation is entirely independent of the ADP law. Thus, here, Aberdeen’s assessor certified that he complied with this independent statutory requirement by filing such list on September 21, 2026, as to 109 parcels within Aberdeen, and that since Aberdeen’s ratio is at 100%, these added/omitted assessments are at their market value. Defendants point to no materially controverted facts to undermine Aberdeen’s arguments on likelihood of success on the merits. Rather they express why broadly, and generally, annual reassessments should be the preferred mechanism each year regardless of what the statute and regulation require. While this may at most, cast a “mere doubt as to the validity of” Matawan’s contentions, it does not suffice to form “an adequate basis for refusing to maintain the status quo” of a temporary stay. Crowe, 90 N.J. at 133. Aberdeen correctly contends that the law is not unsettled as to establishing a need for an annual reassessment. The ADP allows the County Board to require “implementation of a revaluation or reassessment . . . at such time that [it] . . . determines the need therefor.” N.J.S.A. 54:1-104(f). The regulations plainly require such determination to be made by an assessor, among 11 several other procedural requirements. N.J.A.C. 18:12A-1.14(i)(2). Aberdeen has provided certifications to show non-compliance with the same. Defendants have not shown anything to the contrary. That the consequences of such non-compliance are being litigated for the first time, or that the instant complaint may be the first challenge to an annual reassessment, does not render the law unsettled. Governmental entities have a duty to turn square corners. F.M.C. Stores Co. v. Borough of Morris Plains, 100 N.J. 418, 426 (1985). An administrative agency is likewise bound by, and may not disregard, the regulations it has promulgated. County of Hudson v. Dep’t of Corr., 152 N.J. 60, 70 (1997). A right to challenge a governmental act has always been available to anyone, even to another local or state government agency/entity. Aberdeen is correct that for these very reasons, the protection of the public interest is of particular significance, such interest being an assurance that governmental entities are performing annual reassessments in accordance with the dictates of the law and the implementing regulations. CONCLUSION For the above reasons, the court finds that it is appropriate to grant Aberdeen’s request for temporary relief of maintaining the status quo of the current stay pending the outcome of a final hearing. So as to minimize disruption to the appeal deadlines for tax year 2027, and issuance of a final assessment in May of 2027, the court will bifurcate the issues in Aberdeen’s complaint. The issue as to the validity of requiring a reassessment for 2027 will be first heard and decided. The hearing as to this is scheduled for December 10, 2026. The court will issue its decision soon thereafter and no later than December 14, 2026. This way the notices of assessment can be issued on December 15, 2026, thus, preserving the procedural time frames to the greatest 12 extent possible so as to provide sufficient time for appeals to be filed, county board judgments to be issued, and the final assessment list for tax year 2027 to be filed. The remaining issues will be heard thereafter at a trial to be held in 2027 but within the time for the parties to act appropriately as to a reassessment for tax year 2028 and thereafter based on the court’s decision. This will save time and expense for the parties and the taxpayers in avoiding repeated litigation and stay applications. Because there are other pending complaints on the identical issues, including the propriety of continuing the ADP, the court will consolidate those cases and issues for the trial (Docket Numbers 000363-2019; 010016-2024; 010017-2024; 010019-2024; and 010020-2024). A separate consolidation order will be issued in this regard, including the instant matter. 13