Spencer v. City of Henderson
CourtNevada Supreme Court
Date FiledNovember 20, 2026
Docket89007 c/w 88629
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEVADA
SONG SPENCER, AN INDIVIDUAL; No. 88629
AND JAMES SPENCER, AN
INDIVIDUAL,
Appellants,
vs.
CITY OF HENDERSON, A MUNICIPAL
CORPORATION AND A POLITICAL
SUBDIVISION OF THE STATE OF
NEVADA,
Respondent.
SONG SPENCER, No. 89007
Appellant,
vs.
CITY OF HENDERSON, A MUNICIPAL
CORPORATION AND A POLITICAL
SUBDIVISION OF THE STATE OF
NEVADA,
Respondent.
ORDER OF AFFIRMANCE
These are consolidated appeals from a district court dismissal
order and a post-judgment order denying attorney fees in a civil forfeiture
proceeding. Eighth Judicial District Court, Clark County; Nadia Krall,
Judge.
Respondent City of Henderson filed a civil forfeiture complaint
against $21,563 seized from appellants James and Song Spencer’s home
pursuant to a search warrant. In that complaint, the City named and
served James as a claimant. James and Song filed answers and asserted
counterclaims against the City, alleging the seized money lawfully belonged
to Song and contesting the constitutionality of Nevada’s civil forfeiture
scheme. About a month later, the City returned the money plus interest to
Song, and the district court thereafter dismissed the civil forfeiture
complaint as moot. It also dismissed the Spencers’ counterclaims after
concluding counterclaims are not cognizable in an in rem forfeiture action.
Song moved for attorney fees as sanctions under NRS 18.010 and
NRS 7.085, and the district court denied that motion.1
The district court properly dismissed the Spencers’ counterclaims
On appeal, the Spencers first argue that counterclaims are
permitted in Nevada civil forfeiture actions and that the district court erred
in dismissing them. We review this statutory interpretation question de
novo. See Slade v. Caesars Ent. Corp., 132 Nev. 374, 376, 373 P.3d 74, 75
(2016).
Nevada’s civil forfeiture scheme is found in NRS 179.1156–.121.
NRS 179.1156. Civil forfeiture falls within NRS Chapter 179, “Special
Proceedings of a Criminal Nature,” despite being a civil action. See State v.
Clark, 114 Nev. 319, 321, 956 P.2d 83, 84 (1998) (noting forfeiture
proceedings against a vehicle were civil in rem proceedings). Special
proceedings are governed by the statutes that create them and are strictly
limited to the procedures those statutes provide. See, e.g., Preferred
Equities Corp. v. State Eng’r, 119 Nev. 384, 388, 75 P.3d 380, 383 (2003)
(explaining water law proceedings “are special in character” and “strictly
1We note Song did not properly move to intervene. See NRCP 24;
Aetna Life & Cas. Ins. Co. v. Rowan, 107 Nev. 362, 363, 812 P.2d 350, 350
(1991) (“[A] proposed intervenor does not become a party to a lawsuit unless
and until the district court grants a motion to intervene.”). However, the
City did not protest Song’s participation below, and the district court treated
her as a participant, so we treat the issue as waived. Cf. Pelletier v. Pelletier,
103 Nev. 408, 410-11, 742 P.2d 1027, 1028 (1987) (addressing the merits
where the nonparty proceeded in the case below with the “apparent consent
of the parties”)
2
limit[ed]” to the method of procedure provided by statute (internal
quotations omitted)); 1A C.J.S. Actions § 283 (addressing special
proceedings); see also Leigh-Pink v. Rio Props., LLC, 138 Nev. 530, 536, 512
P.3d 322, 327 (2022) (explaining a statute’s plain language controls).
Though NRS 179.1171(1) incorporates the Nevada Rules of Civil Procedure
as the rules of practice in a forfeiture action, those “rules do not govern
procedure and practice in any special statutory proceeding insofar as they
are inconsistent or in conflict with the procedure and practice provided by
the applicable statutes.” NRCP 81(a); see NRS 179.1171(1) (stating that the
NRCP apply “except as otherwise provided in NRS 179.1156 to 179.1205,
inclusive).
The civil forfeiture statutes establish a special statutory
proceeding that, by its terms, is purely in rem. See United States v. Obaid,
971 F.3d 1095, 1099 (9th Cir. 2020) (recognizing civil forfeitures are in rem
proceedings). NRS 179.1171(4) expressly declares: “A proceeding for
forfeiture is in rem.” Consistent therewith, both NRS 179.1171(3)(a) and
NRS 179.1171(4) require the seizing agency to file its forfeiture complaint
in the district court in the county where the property is located. And,
collectively, the forfeiture statutes demonstrate civil forfeiture proceedings
are narrowly anchored to the disposition of the res. See, e.g., Chapman v.
Deutsche Bank Nat’l Tr. Co., 129 Nev. 314, 318, 302 P.3d 1103, 1106 (2013)
(explaining an in rem proceeding “is one taken directly against the property,
and has for its object the disposition of the property” (internal quotations
omitted)). For example, NRS 179.1164 and NRS 179.1165 describe the
property subject to forfeiture and address its seizure. NRS 179.1173
governs court proceedings for the property’s forfeiture, and NRS 179.1175
and NRS 179.118 regulate the disposition and distribution of property
declared forfeited. Civil forfeitures take priority over other civil actions and
3
require the property’s return within seven business days if a court
determines it is not subject to forfeiture. NRS 179.1173(1), (8).
The only parties to a forfeiture proceeding are “the plaintiff”
and “any claimant”—defendants and counterclaimants are not
contemplated. NRS 179.1171(7). The statutes give claimants the right to
answer the complaint and serve objections to written interrogatories, but
say nothing of other actions. NRS 179.1171(6). Significantly, nothing in the
statutes contemplates action or relief in the civil forfeiture itself beyond the
disposition of the res. See, e.g., Obaid, 971 F.3d at 1098 (explaining in rem
jurisdiction). And though NRS 179.1171 provides that a forfeiture
complaint should be treated as a counterclaim to a first-filed claim for
delivery action, it does not contemplate the converse—the filing of
counterclaims for damages or affirmative relief requiring in personam
jurisdiction in a first-filed forfeiture action. NRS 179.1171(2). Instead,
consistent with the pure in rem nature of the action, the only relief afforded
a successful claimant is the return of the property plus interest. NRS
179.1173(8). Cf. UMLIC VP LLC v. Matthias, 364 F.3d 125, 134 (3d Cir.
2004) (addressing mortgage foreclosure actions and explaining that “money
damages are not acquired through in rem proceedings”).
Here, the City’s civil forfeiture action against the $21,563
became moot when the City returned that money plus interest to Song. See
Valdez-Jimenez v. Eighth Jud. Dist. Ct., 136 Nev. 155, 158, 460 P.3d 976,
981 (2020) (explaining an action is moot once there is no longer a live
controversy that a judgment can redress). The Spencers nevertheless
sought to pursue special and punitive damages through their constitutional
and tort counterclaims based on alleged violations that, if resolved, would
require the district court to move beyond its statutory authority to
adjudicate the rights to the property to the vindication of personal rights.
4
See NRS 179.1171(4). Even Song’s claim for delivery counterclaim2 is not a
pure in rem claim but rather a mixed action in which she seeks special
damages of attorney fees. See Fredericks v. Tracy, 33 P. 750, 751 (Cal. 1893)
(describing a claim and delivery action as a mixed action: in rem as to the
wrongfully taken property, and in personam as to the damages); Preston A.
Blair Co. v. Rose, 51 P.2d 209, 211 (Idaho 1935) (same); 77 C.J.S. Replevin §
5 (same). As such, it too sought relief beyond that which the civil forfeiture
statutes permit.
The district court therefore did not err by dismissing the
counterclaims, nor by dismissing the civil forfeiture action as moot. In view
of the foregoing, we need not reach the Spencers’ additional arguments
regarding Song’s entitlement to seek special damages of attorney fees on her
claim for delivery counterclaim or the constitutionality of Nevada’s
forfeiture scheme. Nor need we reach the Spencers’ argument in their reply
brief regarding mootness exceptions. See, e.g., Khoury v. Seastrand, 132
Nev. 520, 530 n.2, 377 P.3d 81, 88 n.2 (2016) (noting we need not address
appellate arguments asserted for the first time on reply). We note, however,
that nothing in this order bars claimants from pursuing their tort and
constitutional claims in a separate action.3
The district court properly denied Song’s request for attorney fees
2While we do not resolve this issue, we also note that this
counterclaim may be statutorily barred, as the City brought its forfeiture
complaint within 60 days. See NRS 179.1171(2) (explaining the property is
subject to a claim for delivery action “only if” the government does not file
the forfeiture complaint within 60 days); NRS 31.840 (allowing a claim for
delivery “[e]xcept as provided in NRS 179.1171”).
3The parties represented at oral argument that a separate action has
been filed but stayed pending resolution of this appeal.
5
Song also challenges the denial of her request for attorney fees
as statutory sanctions under NRS 18.010(2)(b) and NRS 7.085. The district
court’s decision is reviewed for an abuse of discretion. Stubbs v. Strickland,
129 Nev. 146, 152, 297 P.3d 326, 330 (2013). NRS 18.010(2)(b) allows the
district court to award attorney fees to a prevailing party where the
complaint “was brought or maintained without reasonable ground or to
harass the prevailing party.” Similarly, NRS 7.085 permits an attorney fees
award against counsel who either files or maintains an action that is “not
well-grounded in fact[,] not warranted by existing law,” or who
“[u]nreasonably and vexatiously” extends that litigation in court. The
purpose of these statutes is to punish and deter claims that “overburden
limited juridical resources, hinder the timely resolution of meritorious
claims and increase the costs of engaging in business and providing
professional services to the public.” NRS 7.085(2); NRS 18.010(2)(b). These
sanctions “target[ ] only how the litigation itself is conducted, not what the
parties did before the litigation commenced.” In re Execution of Search
Warrants for: 12067 Oakland Hills, Las Vegas, Nev. 89141, 134 Nev. 799,
803, 435 P.3d 672, 676 (Ct. App. 2018) (addressing NRS 18.010(2)(b)).
Further, a claim is only frivolous or groundless if there is no credible
evidence to support it. Capanna v. Orth, 134 Nev. 888, 895, 432 P.3d 726,
734 (2018).
The district court found, among other things, that the forfeiture
action was grounded in fact and warranted under existing law, that the City
reasonably relied on the result of the police investigation conducted
pursuant to a search warrant issued upon a finding of probable cause, that
Song was not prejudiced by the City’s failure to name her as a claimant or
serve her personally, and that the City’s post-filing actions were not
frivolous. The record supports the district court’s findings and weighs
6
against the Spencers’ arguments. Further, many of the Spencers’
arguments go to the Henderson Police Department’s pre-litigation conduct
rather than the City’s litigation decisions. Some arguments—such as that
the City threatened criminal contempt—are simply belied by the record.
And though the Spencers speculate about the officers’ motives and
knowledge, and fault the City for not naming Song as a claimant initially,
the record does not support that the City’s decision to file a forfeiture
complaint against the seized cash was not based on credible evidence at the
time, or that the forfeiture complaint was unreasonably or vexatiously
maintained during the three months it was pending.
Accordingly, we
ORDER the judgments of the district court AFFIRMED.
Herndon, C.J.
Pickering, J. Parraguirre, J.
Bell, J. Stiglich, J.
Cadish, J. Lee, J.
cc: Hon. Nadia Krall, District Judge
Thomas J. Tanksley, Settlement Judge
Spartacus Law Firm
McDonald Carano LLP/Las Vegas
McDonald Carano LLP/Reno
Henderson City Attorney
7
Institute for Justice/Arlington VA
American Civil Liberties Union of Nevada/Las Vegas
Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck, LLP/Las Vegas
Federal Public Defender/Las Vegas
Eighth District Court Clerk
8