Capparelli v. Schwartz
CourtCourt of Appeals of Nevada
Date FiledNovember 20, 2026
Docket92176-COA
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF NEVADA
ANTONIA LEE CAPPARELLI, No. 92176-COA
Appellant,
vs.
JEREMIE SCHWARTZ,
Respondent.
ORDER OF AFFIRMANCE
Antonia Lee Capparelli appeals from an order of the district court
modifying a child custody arrangement. Second Judicial District Court,
Washoe County; Hon. Sandra A. Unsworth, Judge.
Capparelli and respondent Jeremie Schwartz were never married
but share two minor children. One child was born in 2010, and one child was
born in 2011. Capparelli filed a petition to establish custody, and the parties
later reached an agreement concerning the outstanding custody issues. The
district court thereafter entered an order awarding the parties joint legal and
physical custody of the children.
Disputes arose between the parties, and Capparelli subsequently
filed several motions seeking modification of the custody arrangement. In
2018, the district court entered an order modifying the physical custody
arrangement and awarding Capparelli primary physical custody of the
children. The parties later acknowledged that Schwartz moved to
Pennsylvania in 2018 while Capparelli remained in Nevada with the children.
Following Schwartz’s relocation to Pennsylvania, Capparelli again moved to
modify the custody arrangement, and the district court entered an order in
2019 awarding Capparelli sole legal custody of the children.
In December 2024, Schwartz returned to Nevada and resided in
Fernley. Capparelli, in January 2025, filed a motion in which she sought,
among other things, a modification of the custody arrangement considering
Schwartz’s return to Nevada.
Schwartz subsequently moved to modify custody, explaining that
modification of custody was warranted as Capparelli was recently arrested for
an act of domestic violence involving a different romantic partner. The district
court issued an order temporarily awarding Schwartz with sole legal custody
and primary physical custody of the children due to Capparelli’s arrest. The
district court also set an evidentiary hearing concerning modification of the
custody arrangement and related issues.
Both parties testified at the hearing and discussed their
communication issues and difficulties coparenting the children. The parties
also introduced documents depicting their text messages, as well as medical
and school records concerning the children. Schwartz explained the
circumstances concerning his move to Pennsylvania and his recent return to
Nevada. Schwartz also explained that, since his return to Nevada and prior to
Capparelli’s arrest, Capparelli did not permit him to have much parenting time
with the children and limited his contact with them. In addition, Capparelli
discussed her mental health breakdown that occurred on Mother’s Day 2025
and some of the circumstances concerning her arrest. Capparelli also
explained that the related criminal proceedings were ongoing. Capparelli
noted her mental health difficulties and that those issues impacted the
children in several ways.
2
Both parties discussed an apparent suicide attempt by the eldest
child. The parties also explained that, as the child was receiving care in a
hospital, they engaged in an argument in the presence of hospital staff.
Schwartz explained his deep concern for the child’s mental health, as
Schwartz’s brother had died by suicide, and Schwartz indicated his desire to
help the child with his mental health difficulties. Capparelli also discussed her
strained relationship with the child and acknowledged she texted Schwartz
that the child had abusive behaviors. However, Capparelli testified that she
has a good relationship with the youngest child, and Schwartz acknowledged
that his relationship with the youngest child had deteriorated recently. The
district court later separately interviewed the children and incorporated the
information gained from those interviews into its ultimate custody decision.
The district court subsequently entered a written order in which it
noted that Capparelli acknowledged Schwartz’s return to Nevada constituted
a change in circumstances and that she accordingly sought a change in the
parenting time schedule. The court also reviewed NRS 125C.0035(4)’s best
interest factors and found, based on those factors, that it was in the children’s
best interest to modify the custody arrangement. The court explained that the
oldest child expressed his desire to reside primarily with Schwartz and that
the youngest child expressed her desire to reside primarily with Capparelli.
The district court further found that three of the remaining best interest
factors favored Schwartz while the remaining factors were either neutral or
not relevant.
In particular, the district court noted that documents introduced
at the hearing demonstrated that Capparelli sought to exclude Schwartz from
the children’s lives. The court also focused on the oldest child’s mental health
3
issues and noted that Schwartz was best positioned to care for the child. In
addition, the court expressed its concern for Capparelli’s mental health issues
and noted that Capparelli failed to recognize that her relationship with the
oldest child was extremely damaged. In addition, the district court noted that
the parties each accused the other of committing acts of domestic violence but
had provided such limited information that it was unable to find that either
party committed an act of domestic violence.
Based on those findings, the district court determined it was in the
children’s best interest to award Schwartz primary physical custody of the
oldest child and to award the parties joint physical custody of the youngest
child. It also elected to award the parties joint legal custody of the children but
awarded Schwartz final decision-making authority concerning the oldest
child’s medical issues and most school-related issues. This appeal followed.
Capparelli raises several arguments concerning the district court’s
decision to modify the physical custody arrangement. Capparelli argues the
court abused its discretion by modifying custody without finding that there was
a substantial change in circumstances warranting such a modification.
Capparelli also argues the court did not properly evaluate the best interest
factors and that its findings were not based upon substantial evidence. In
addition, Capparelli asserts the district court mischaracterized the parties’
communication issues, disregarded documentary evidence, and relied upon
uncorroborated sources when reaching its decisions.
This court reviews district court decisions concerning child custody
for an abuse of discretion. Ellis v. Carucci, 123 Nev. 145, 149, 161 P.3d 239,
241 (2007). In reviewing child custody determinations, this court will affirm
the district court’s factual findings if they are supported by substantial
4
evidence, “which is evidence that a reasonable person may accept as adequate
to sustain a judgment.” Id. at 149, 161 P.3d at 242. When making a custody
determination, the sole consideration is the best interest of the child. NRS
125C.0035(1); Davis v. Ewalefo, 131 Nev. 445, 451, 352 P.3d 1139, 1143 (2015).
Further, “we presume that the district court properly exercised its discretion
in determining the best interests of the child.” Flynn v. Flynn, 120 Nev. 436,
440, 92 P.3d 1224, 1226-27 (2004).
To establish that a custodial modification is appropriate, the
moving party must show that “(1) there has been a substantial change in
circumstances affecting the welfare of the child, and (2) the child’s best interest
is served by the modification.” Romano v. Romano, 138 Nev. 1, 5, 501 P.3d 980,
983 (2022) (internal quotation marks omitted), abrogated in part on other
grounds by Killebrew v. State ex rel. Donohue, 139 Nev. 401, 404-05, 535 P.3d
1167, 1171 (2023). The party requesting modification bears the burden to
satisfy both prongs. Ellis, 123 Nev. at 150-51, 161 P.3d at 242-43. A court may
award one parent primary physical custody if it determines that joint physical
custody is not in the best interest of the child. NRS 125C.003(1).
Here, Schwartz and Capparelli both testified at the evidentiary
hearing concerning Schwartz’s return to Nevada in 2024 and how that decision
impacted the children. As explained previously, the district court noted in its
written order that Capparelli previously acknowledged that Schwartz’s return
to Nevada constituted a change in circumstances and that she sought a
modification of the parenting time arrangement following his return. The
court’s findings concerning Schwartz’s return to Nevada are supported by
substantial evidence in the record, see Ellis, 123 Nev. at 149, 161 P.3d at 242,
and this court will not second guess a district court’s resolution of factual issues
5
involving conflicting evidence, see Grosjean v. Imperial Palace, Inc., 125 Nev.
349, 366, 212 P.3d 1068, 1080 (2009). Moreover, Capparelli fails to
demonstrate that Schwartz’s return to Nevada did not constitute a substantial
change in circumstances affecting the welfare of the children, and she is
accordingly not entitled to relief.
Turning to Capparelli’s challenge to the district court’s findings
concerning the NRS 125C.0035(4) best interest factors, we conclude she is not
entitled to relief. “Failure of the district court to properly consider any best
interest factor and make specific findings constitutes an abuse of discretion.”
Soldo-Allesio v. Ferguson, 141 Nev., Adv. Op. 9, 565 P.3d 842, 849 (Ct. App.
2025); see also Lewis v. Lewis, 132 Nev. 453, 459-60, 373 P.3d 878, 882 (2016)
(“In determining the best interest of the child, the court shall consider and set
forth its specific findings concerning [the best interest factors].”). Moreover,
“[e]valuating the child’s best interest in determining custody is designed to
place the child’s welfare and developmental needs at the forefront of all child
custody decisions, ensuring that the outcomes support their physical,
emotional, and psychological well-being.” Soldo-Allesio, 141 Nev., Adv. Op. 9,
565 P.3d at 848-49. However, the NRS 125C.0035(4) best interest factors are
non-exhaustive and should be considered along with any other relevant
information the district court deems significant. See Ellis, 123 Nev. at 152, 161
P.3d at 243.
Here, the district court made extensive findings concerning the
evidence presented at the evidentiary hearing, including information
pertaining to the NRS 125C.0035(4) best interest factors, and it tied those
findings into its custody decision. See Davis, 131 Nev. at 451, 352 P.3d at 1143
(explaining the district court’s “order must tie the child’s best interest, as
6
informed by specific, relevant findings respecting the [best interest factors] and
any other relevant factors, to the custody determination made”). The court
noted the children’s preferences. See NRS 125C.0035(4)(a). The court found
that, based upon the documentary evidence and the parties’ testimonies,
Capparelli interfered with Schwartz’s relationship with the children and
sought to erase him from their lives but also noted Schwartz exhibited hostility
toward Capparelli. See NRS 125C.0035(4)(c), (d). In addition, the district court
considered evidence related to the oldest child’s mental health and
developmental issues, explained that the oldest child has significant needs in
those areas and that the youngest child also has difficulties and found that
neither party cooperated with the other to meet the needs of the children. See
NRS 125C.0035(4)(e).
The district court next reviewed the evidence presented concerning
the parties’ physical and mental health, expressing its concern regarding
Capparelli’s mental health issues. See NRS 125C.0035(4)(f). The court further
reviewed whether the parties were able to meet the physical, developmental,
and emotional needs of the children, and found that factor strongly favored
Schwartz. See NRS 125C.0035(4)(g). In particular, the court reviewed
Capparelli’s text messages concerning the oldest child and found they
demonstrated she did not recognize his needs. In addition, the court noted the
information presented concerning the parties’ relationship with the children
and found that Capparelli’s relationship with the oldest child was damaged
and that Schwartz’s hostility toward Capparelli impacts the children. See NRS
125C.0035(4)(h). Moreover, the court found that the children have a half-
sibling who resides with Capparelli and the court wished for the children to
maintain a relationship with their half-sibling. See NRS 125C.0035(4)(i). In
7
addition, the district court did not find that there was a history of parental
abuse, but it expressed concern regarding Capparelli’s behavior on the recent
Mother’s Day. See NRS 125C.0035(4)(j).
Notably, the district court found there was insufficient evidence
presented for it to find either party committed an act of domestic violence
discussed under NRS 125C.0035(4)(k). See Soldo-Allesio, 141 Nev., Adv. Op.
9, 565 P.3d at 849 (explaining that a district court must consider “whether
domestic violence has been proven by a preponderance of the evidence in
determining which custody arrangement is in the child's best interest”).1 The
court found that there had been no acts of abduction. See NRS 125C.0035(4)(l).
Finally, the district court expressed its concern that Capparelli continually
sought to use the suicide of Schwartz’s brother as a weapon and barred her
from discussing that issue with the children.
The factual findings made in support of these determinations are
supported by substantial evidence. See Ellis, 123 Nev. at 149, 161 P.3d at 242.
To the extent Capparelli argues that the district court should have weighed the
evidence differently, this court is not at liberty to reweigh the evidence. See
1The district court also recognized that NRS 125C.0035(5)’s rebuttable
presumption against awarding a parent physical custody did not apply as
domestic violence had not been proven by clear and convincing evidence.
Capparelli states that the court held her to a higher burden of proof than was
appropriate, apparently referencing the district court’s findings concerning the
rebuttable presumption under NRS 125C.0035(5). However, the district court
correctly recognized that NRS 125C.0035(5)’s rebuttable presumption against
awarding a parent physical custody applies when the commission of an act of
domestic violence “has been established by clear and convincing evidence.”
Soldo-Allesio, 141 Nev., Adv. Op. 9, 565 P.3d at 848. Capparelli therefore is
not entitled to relief based upon this argument.
8
Grosjean, 125 Nev. at 366, 212 P.3d at 1080. Considering the foregoing, we
conclude that Capparelli does not demonstrate the district court abused its
discretion2 in reaching the aforementioned decisions.
Capparelli also contends that procedural irregularities resulted in a
denial of In
due process.
light of the In addition,
foregoing, weshe contends
conclude thatthat she wasisprejudiced
Capparelli by
not entitled
errors concerning the exclusion of relevant evidence, inconsistent treatment
to relief. Accordingly, we
of objections, and reliance upon matters outside of the record. However,
Capparelli does not
ORDER theprovide cogent
judgment argument
of the districtin support
court 2
of these statements.
AFFIRMED.
As a result, we need not consider these issues. See Edwards v. Emperor’s
Garden Rest., 122 Nev. 317, 330 n.38, 130 P.3d 1280, 1288 n.38 (2006)
(providing that appellate courts need not consider issues that are not
supported by cogent argument).
Moreover, insofar as Capparelli raises arguments that are not
Bulla,
specifically addressed C.J.order, we have considered the same and
in this
conclude that they do not present a basis for relief.
Gibbons, J. Westbrook, J.
cc: Hon. Sandra A. Unsworth, District Judge
Antonia Lee Capparelli
9
Jeremie Schwartz
Second District Court Clerk
10