The Recreation and Park Commission for The Parish of East Baton Rouge v. Sid J. Gautreaux, III
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
Date FiledNovember 20, 2026
Docket2026 CA 0297
StatusUnknown
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
STATE OF LOUISIANA
FIRST CIRCUIT
HE RECREATION AND PARK COMMISSION FOR
THE PARISH OF EAST BATON ROUGE
VERSUS
SID J. GAUTRE AUX, 111, IN HIS CAPACITY AS
tiSHERIFF OF EAST BATON ROUGE PARISH
Consolidated with
2026 CA 0298
VERSUS
SID J. GAUTREAUX, 1119 IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY
AS SHERIFF OF EAST BATON ROUGE PARISH AND
EX OFFICIO COLLECTOR OF EAST BATON ROUGE
AD VALOREM TAXES
Consolidated with
2026 CA 0299
SID J. GAUTREAUX, 1119 IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY
AS SHERIFF OF EAST BATON ROUGE PARISH AND
EX OFFICIO COLLECTOR OF EAST BATON ROUGE
VERSUS
THE CITY OF BATON ROUGE/ PARISH OF
EAST BATON ROUGE, ET AL.
Judgment Rendered:
On Appeal from the
19th Judicial District Court
In and for the Parish of East Baton Rouge
State of Louisiana
Case Nos, 725439 c/ w 727552 c/ w 741325
Honorable Wilson E. Fields, Judge Presiding
Murphy J. Foster, III Counsel for Plaintiff/Appellant
Jude C. Bursavich Recreation and Park Commission
Nicole Gould Frey for the Parish of East Baton Rouge
David Cassidy
Jacob E. Roussel
Baton Rouge, Louisiana
FA
David M. Lefeve Counsel for Defendant/Appellee
Baton Rouge, Louisiana City of Baton Rouge/ Parish of East
Baton Rouge
Counsel for Defendant/Appellee
Mary G. Erlingson
Catherine S. St. Pierre Sheriff Sid J. Gautreaux, 111,
London B. Smith Sheriff of East Baton Rouge Parish
Baton Rouge, Louisiana
Sheri M. Morris Counsel for Defendant/Appellee
Elisa S. Randall Louisiana Clerks' of Court
Baton Rouge, Louisiana Retirement Fund
Laura Gail Sullivan Counsel for Intervenors/ Appellees
Baton Rouge, Louisiana District Attorneys' Retirement System,
Louisiana Assessors' Retirement Fund,
and Registrars of Voters Employees'
Retirement System
Counsel for Intervenor/Appellee
Larry M. Roedel
Baton Rouge, Louisiana Municipal Employees' Retirement
System of Louisiana
Robert E. Tarcza Counsel for Intervenor/Appellee
New Orleans, Louisiana District Attorneys' Retirement System,
Louisiana Assessors' Retirement Fund,
and Registrars of Voters Employees'
Retirement System
Robert D. Klausner Counsel for Intervenor/Appellee
Plantation, Florida District Attorneys' Retirement System,
Louisiana Assessors' Retirement Fund,
and Registrars of Voters Employees'
Retirement System
BEFORE: THE T, LANIER, AND EDWARDS, JJ.
LANIER, J.
In these consolidated suits, defendant/ appellant, the Clerks' of Court
Retirement and Relief Fund (" the Clerks' Retirement") challenges the district court's
March 26, 2025 judgment denying its motion to withdraw funds. In a related appeal
also handed down this day (this court's Docket Number 2026 CA 0294 c/ w 2026 CA
0295 c/ w 2026 CA 0296), plaintiff, Recreation and Park Commission for the Parish
of East Baton Rouge (" BREC"), challenges the district court's February 3, 2025
judgment denying injunctive and declaratory relief sought by BREC in relation .to
the distribution of a portion of ad valorem taxes levied by BREC to state and
statewide public retirement systems in accordance with La. R. S. 11: 82. See
Recreation and Park Commission for Parish of East Baton Rouge v. Gautreaux,
2026- 0294, 2026- 0295, 2026- 0296 ( La. App. I Cir. (" BREC IF').' In
BREC 11, this court affirmed the district court's decision denying the injunctive and
declaratory relief sought by BREC. Moreover, our decision in BREC 11 ordered the
funds in the registry of the court released to the East Baton Rouge Sheriff for
distribution in accordance with law. BREC 11, -- So. 3d at --.
In the instant case, the motion to withdraw funds and reconventional demand
for damages filed by the Clerks' Retirement remained unadjudicated at the
conclusion of trial on BREC' s principal demand. The Clerks' Retirement motion
was heard on February 24, 2025, by Judge Wilson E. Fields, the district court judge
for the 19th Judicial District Court, Parish of East Baton Rouge. Following
argument of counsel and the proffer of evidence by counsel for the Clerks'
Retirement, the district court ruled from the bench as follows:
All right. The Clerks' Retirement motion to withdraw funds from
the registry of the court -- the court is going to deny. The court will
The factual background and procedural history that led to this appeal are fully detailed in BREC
11.
0
adopt the Recreation and Park Commission memo in opposition as [ its]
reason for judgment. Counsel for the plaintiff, prepare a judgment for
the court' s signature.
There was no mention of the reconventional demand for damages by Judge Fields
in his ruling from the bench. Moreover, the February 24, 2025 minutes are silent
with regard to a ruling on this issue.
Following the hearing, Fields was elected to the Louisiana First Circuit Court
of Appeal, 2nd District and assumed office on March 19, 2025. Accordingly, when
the judgment prepared by counsel for BREC was signed on March 26, 2025, Judge
Fields was no longer in office. Rather, the judgment was signed by his successor
judge, Judge Johnell Matthews, and provides as follows: " IT IS ORDERED,
ADJUDGED AND DECREED that the Motion to Withdraw Funds from Registry
and to Award Damages filed by the Louisiana Clerks of Court Retirement and Relief
Fund is hereby DENIED." The judgment also contains the following notation,
Judgment rendered in open court by Judge Wilson Fields on February 24, 2025,
and judgment conforms to the minute entry."
Generally, the judge who presided over the case must sign the judgment, and
a judgment signed by a judge who did not preside over the hearing does not
constitute a final judgment subject to this court's appellate jurisdiction. See La. Code
Civ. P. art. 1911( A); In re M.L.M., 2019- 1030 ( La. App. I Cir. 4/ 23/ 20), 300 So. 3d
902, 905- 906. However, exceptions exist allowing ajudge who did not hear a matter
to sign ajudgment. See La. Code Civ. P. art. 253. 3; La. R.S. 13: 4209; In re M.L.M.,
300 So. 3d at 905. Louisiana Revised Statutes 13: 4209( B) provides as follows:
B. ( 1)In cases which are heard and in which judgment is rendered, but
not signed, whether the case was taken under advisement or not, if the
judge who rendered the judgment dies, resigns, or is removed from
office, or if his term expires before signing judgment in the case, his
successor in office shall have the authority to sign a judgment which
conforms with the judgment rendered.
5
2) If a prior judge has stated an affirmative intent to sign a judgment
and failed to do so for whatever reason, the successor judge is
empowered to sign the judgment.
In both Henry v. Sullivan, 2016- 1867 ( La. 11/ 18/ 16), 206 So. 3d 858 ( per
curiam), and Donahue v. Donahue, 2016- 1853 ( La. 11/ 18/ 16), 206 So. 3d 858 ( per
curiam), the original trial judge, Dawn Amacker, recused herself after issuing oral
reasons but before signing the final judgments. The cases were re -allotted to Judge
Mary C. Devereux, who signed the written judgments. The supreme court held that
Judge Devereux, " in her capacity as successor judge, [ was] empowered to sign the
judgment[ s]" because the original trial judge, " through her oral reasons, clearly
manifested an affirmative intent to sign [ the] judgment[ s.]" Henry, 206 So. 3d at
858; Donahue, 206 So. 3d at 858 The supreme court reasoned, " Any other result
would be contrary to the statutory intent as well as the interests ofjudicial economy."
Additionally, in Prejean v. McMillan, 2018- 0919 ( La. App. I Cir. 2/ 28/ 19), 274
So. 3d 575, 577 n.4, this court held as follows:
Although the grant of summary judgment was rendered by Judge
Dupont, we find that Judge Janice Clark's signing of the judgment in
conformity with Judge Dupont's ruling was within the ambit of the
Louisiana Supreme Court's November 14, 2017 order assigning Judge
Dupont to sit pro tempore for Judge Clark.
But see Dutruch v. Zurich -American Ins. Co., 95- 1923 ( La. App. I Cir. 4/ 22/ 96),
681 So. 2d 953, 955 ( per curiam) ( judgment signed by successor judge that did not
conform to prior judge' s oral ruling vacated on appeal).
Although we acknowledge Judge Matthews had " authority to sign a judgment
which conforms with the judgment rendered," we find that the judgment signed by
Judge Matthews on March 26, 2025 goes beyond that which the record supports. As
previously noted, neither Judge Fields' oral ruling at the completion of the hearing
nor the hearing minutes made any mention of a ruling on the reconventional demand
for damages. Rather, Judge Fields simply denied the motion to withdraw funds,
adopted BREC' s memorandum in opposition as his reasons for judgment, and
requested that counsel for B EC prepare a judgment for his signature.' The March
26, 2025 judgment signed by Judge Matthews does not conform with Judge Fields'
oral ruling on February 24, 2025. Accordingly, we vacate the March 26, 2025
judgment and remand.' We assess appeal costs in the amount of $5, 634. 00 equally
against the parties, Recreation and Park Commission for the Parish of East Baton
Rouge and the Clerks' of Court Retirement and Relief Fund.
VACATED AND REMANDED; RULE TO SHOW CAUSE RECALLED.
It is a well- settled principal of law that when a district court's oral reasons or minute entry
conflicts with the written judgment, the judgment prevails. Welch v. Planning & Zoning
Commission of East Baton Rouge Parish, 2016- 0751 ( La. App. 1 Cir. 4/ 26/ 17), 220 So. 3d 74,
77. The district court may render a judgment that differs substantially from oral statements made
at the hearing, for such oral reasoning forms no part of the judgment. It is the formal, signed
judgment that governs. Id. As it is the intent of the judge who presided over the hearing in this
matter that is crucial to our decision herein, we must consider the oral reasons and minute entry in
our review. However, we recognize that if Judge Fields had signed the March 26, 2025 judgment,
our analysis herein may be different.
3 Given our ruling herein, the rule to show cause previously issued by this court concerning the
appealability of the March 26, 2025 judgment is rendered moot; the rule to show case is recalled.
7