The Recreation and Park Commission for The Parish of East Baton Rouge v. Sid J. Gautreaux, III
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
Date FiledNovember 20, 2026
Docket2026 CA 0294
StatusUnknown
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
STATE OF LOUISIANA
FIRST CIRCUIT
RECREATION AND PARK COMMISSION FOR
THE PARISH OF EAST BATON ROUGE
VERSUS
SID J. GAUTREAUX, 111, IN HIS CAPACITY AS
SHERIFF OF EAST BATON ROUGE PARISH
Consolidated with
2026 CA 0295
VERSUS
SID J. GAUTREAUX, 111, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY
AS SHERIFF OF EAST BATON ROUGE PARISH AND
EX OFFICIO COLLECTOR OF EAST BATON ROUGE
AD VALOREM TAXES
Consolidated with
2026 CA 0296
SID J. GAUTREAUX9 1119 IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY
AS SHERIFF OF EAST BATON ROUGE PARISH AND
EX OFFICIO COLLECTOR OF EAST BATON ROUGE
VERSUS
THE CITY OF BATON ROUGE/PARISH OF
EAST BATON ROUGE, ET AL.
Judgment Rendered. NOV 2 0 2026
On Appeal from the
19th Judicial District Court
In and for the Parish of East Baton Rouge
State of Louisiana
Case Nos. 725439 c/ w 727552 c/ w 741325
Honorable Wilson E. Fields, Judge Presiding
Murphy J. Foster, III Counsel for Plaintiff/Appellant
Jude C. Bursavich Recreation and Park Commission
Nicole Gould Frey for the Parish of East Baton Rouge
David Cassidy
Jacob E. Roussel
Baton Rouge, Louisiana
2
David M. Lefeve Counsel for Defendant/Appellee
Baton Rouge, Louisiana City of Baton Rouge/Parish of East
Baton Rouge
Mary G. Erlingson Counsel for Defendant/Appellee
Catherine S. St. Pierre Sheriff Sid J. Gautreaux, 111,
London B. Smith Sheriff of East Baton Rouge Parish
Baton Rouge, Louisiana
Sheri M. Morris Counsel for Defendant/ Appellee
Elisa S. Randall Louisiana Clerks' of Court
Baton Rouge, Louisiana Retirement Fund
Laura Gail Sullivan Counsel for Intervenors/ Appellees
Baton Rouge, Louisiana District Attorneys' Retirement System,
Louisiana Assessors' Retirement Fund,
and Registrars of Voters Employees"
Retirement System
Larry M. Roedel Counsel for Intervenor/Appellee
Baton Rouge, Louisiana Municipal Employees' Retirement
System of Louisiana
Robert E. Tarcza Counsel for Intervenor/ Appellee
New Orleans, Louisiana District Attorneys' Retirement System,
Louisiana Assessors' Retirement Fund,
and Registrars of Voters Employees'
Retirement System
Robert D. Klausner Counsel for Intervenor/Appellee
Plantation, Florida District Attorneys' Retirement System,
Louisiana Assessors' Retirement Fund,
and Registrars of Voters Employees'
Retirement System
BEFORE: THERIOT, LANIER, AND EDWARDS, JJ.
LANIER.)J.
In these consolidated suits, plaintiff, the Recreation and Park Commission for
the Parish of East Baton Rouge (" BREC"), challenges the district court' s February
3, 2025 judgment denying injunctive and declaratory relief sought by BREC in
relation to the distribution of a portion of ad valorem taxes levied by BREC to state
After
and statewide public retirement systems in accordance with La. R.S. 11: 82.'
review, we amend in part, affinn as amended, and deny, as moot, the answers to
appeal.
FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
This court is familiar with the underlying facts of this litigation as the case has
previously been before us. See Recreation and Park Commission for Parish of
East Baton Rouge v. Gautreaux, 2023- 0316 ( La. App. 1 Cir. 12/ 27/ 23), 394 So. 3d
280 (" BREC I"). In November 2022, BREC filed a motion for preliminary
injunction and a petition for injunctive and declaratory judgment against the Sheriff.
Therein, BREC asserted that it is a political subdivision of the State of Louisiana
domiciled in East Baton Rouge Parish and that it is a public corporation engaged in
1 BREC' s suit for injunctive and declaratory relief (docket number 725439) was consolidated by
the district court with two other matters -- one filed by Sid J. Gautreaux, III, in his official capacity
as Sheriff of East Baton Rouge and ex officio collector of East Baton Rouge ad valorem taxes (" the
Sheriff") against the City of Baton Rouge/ Parish of East Baton Rouge ( the " City/Parish") ( docket
number 727552) and one filed by the City/Parish against the Sheriff (docket number 741325).
In docket number 727552, the Sheriff filed a concursus proceeding against the City/Parish and
various retirement systems inquiring as to whether an equivalent amount of funds must be
transferred to the retirement systems from the City/Parish's non -dedicated general tax fund if the
BREC tax was not transferred. The Sheriff deposited $ 2, 052,240. 28 from the City/Parish's tax
fund into the registry of the court in the concursus proceeding. The retirement systems filed a
third -party demand against BREC therein.
In docket number 741325, the City/Parish filed suit against the Sheriff seeking injunctive and
declaratory relief that it is entitled to the funds at issue in the concursus proceeding.
0
public recreation and public park purposes.' BREC alleged that pursuant to La.
Const. art. VI, §32 and La. R.S. 33: 4570. 4( B), the voters of East Baton Rouge Parish
were asked, on several occasions, to authorize the levy of ad valorem taxes to fund
BREC' s operations and that on each occasion, the voters authorized the levying of
the taxes (" the BREC taxes"). BREC further averred that the propositions presented
to and approved by the voters limited BRECs use of the taxes to the acquisition,
development, maintenance, and operation of recreational facilities and its operating
budget.
BREC asserted that the Sheriff collects over forty ad valorem taxes levied in
East Baton Rouge Parish by various governmental agencies and that some, but not
all, of these taxes are subject to La. R.S. 11: 82, which requires the Sheriff to remit a
percentage of the taxes collected to certain state and statewide public retirement
systems. BREC contended that the Sheriff, however, treats all of the taxes collected
as taxes under La. R.S. 11: 82, that the Sheriff remits a portion of all taxes collected
to the state and statewide public retirement systems, and that in 2021, the Sheriff
remitted approximately two million dollars of the BREC taxes to the state and
statewide public retirement systems.
2 BREC was created pursuant to La. R.S. 33: 4570, et seq. and is a subdivision of the state of
Louisiana. La. R.S. 33: 4570.4( A). Louisiana Revised Statutes 33: 4570.4( B) provides, in part:
I] n accordance with the provisions of Article VI, Section 32 of the Constitution of
Louisiana and any other applicable provisions of the constitution and laws of the
state, [ BREC] may impose and collect from year to year taxes upon all of the
taxable property carried on the assessment [ rolls] of the parish of East Baton
Rouge[,] ... and the proceeds of any such tax shall be used in acquiring, developing,
maintaining, and operating the public parks and recreational properties and
facilities of the commission and in making available funds for the operating budget.
Article VI, § 32 of the Louisiana Constitution provides that "[ f]or the purpose of acquiring,
constructing, improving, maintaining, or operating any work of public improvement, a political
subdivision may levy special taxes when authorized by a majority of the electors in the political
subdivision who vote thereon in an election held for that purpose."
I
BREC further alleged that the BREC taxes are not La. R.S. 11: 82 taxes
because the purposes to which the BREC taxes are dedicated do not include funding
the state and statewide public retirement systems. Thus, according to BREC, the
Sheriffs application of La. R.S. 11: 82 to the BREC taxes violates La. Const. art. VI,
32 and makes La. R.S. 11: 82 unconstitutional as applied. Therefore, BREC
requested a declaratory judgment that La. R.S. 11: 82 is not applicable to the BREC
taxes or, alternatively, if La. R.S. 11: 82 is applicable to the BREC taxes, a
declaratory judgment that La. R.S. 11: 82 is unconstitutional as applied to the BREC
taxes. BREC filed a motion for preliminary injunction concurrently with its petition,
seeking to enjoin the Sheriff from diverting any of the BREC taxes to the state and
statewide public retirement systems.
In response, the Sheriff filed a dilatory exception objecting to the use of
summary proceedings and two peremptory exceptions raising the objection of
nonjoinder of indispensable parties, 0 one directed to seven state and statewide
public retirement systems' and the other to the City/Parish. See La. Code Civ. P.
arts. 926( A)(3) and 927( A)(4). Following a hearing, the district court signed a
judgment on January 10, 2023, overruling the Sheriffs exceptions; granting the
motion for preliminary injunction; restraining, enjoining, and prohibiting the Sheriff
from remitting any ad valorem tax levied by BREC to any retirement systems; and
requiring the Sheriff to deposit certain taxes levied by BREC into the registry of the
court for 2022 and any subsequent year as long as the preliminary injunction
3 Although the Sheriffs peremptory exceptions referred to " indispensable" parties, we note that
La. Code Civ. P. art. 641 no longer refers to " necessary" and " indispensable" parties and instead
considers those parties needed for just adjudication.
4 The state and statewide public retirement systems identified by the Sheriff as " indispensable"
parties are the Assessors' Retirement Fund; Clerks' of Court Retirement and Relief Fund; District
Attorneys' Retirement System; Municipal Employees' Retirement System of Louisiana; Registrars'
of Voters Employees' Retirement System; Sheriffs' Pension and Relief Fund; and Teachers'
Retirement System of Louisiana.
on
remained in effect. The Sheriff deposited sums totaling $ 4, 247, 535. 95 into the
court' s registry, which represented the 2022 and 2023 disputed BREC taxes that
would have been transferred to the retirement systems.
Subsequently, this court vacated the January 10, 2023 judgment, finding that
the district court abused its discretion and erred as a matter of law in overruling the
Sheriffs exception raising the objection of nonjoinder. See BREC 1, 394 So. 3d at
TI -
9 -11
Thereafter, BREC filed another motion for preliminary injunction and an
amended petition, naming as additional defendants the Louisiana Assessors'
Retirement Fund; Municipal Employees' Retirement System of Louisiana; Parochial
Employees' Retirement System of Louisiana; Sheriffs' Pension and Relief Fund;
District Attorneys' Retirement System; Registrars' of Voters Employees' Retirement
System; and Teachers' Retirement System of Louisiana ( collectively referred to
hereinafter as " the Retirement Systems") and Clerks' of Court Retirement and Relief
Fund (" the Clerks' Retirement"). In addition to the relief sought in its original
petition, BREC alleged that if the Sheriff was permitted to withdraw the funds from
the registry and remit them to the Retirement Systems pursuant to its motion, then
BREC should be awarded damages against the Retirement Systems for the amounts
they received, including any 2022 and 2023 taxes.
Various pleadings and exceptions were filed in response to BREC' s amended
petition, including a second exception raising the objection of nonjoinder of parties
filed by the Teachers' Retirement System of Louisiana. The district court sustained
this exception, prompting BREC to file a second amending petition adding the local
Following our decision in BREC 1, the Sheriff filed a motion to withdraw the funds in the registry
of the court. The motion was passed without date at the scheduled hearing.
7
public -school systems located in East Baton Rouge Parish. BREC did not raise any
new allegations or claims in the second amended petition.
answered the amended petition with
The Clerks' Retirement second
affirmative defenses and a reconventional demand, asserting a damage claim under
La. Code Civ. P. art. 3608 for the wrongful issuance of a preliminary injunction that
required funds to be deposited into the registry of the court and prevented them from
The requested damages included
receiving and investing the registry deposits.
attorney fees pursuant to Article 3608, judicial interest, and costs. Nothing in the
record reflects that leave was obtained prior to the filing of the reconventional
demand. The Clerks' Retirement also filed a Motion to Withdraw Funds from
Registry and to Award Damages (" Motion for Funds/ Damages"). The Motion for
Funds/ Damages sought the release of $417,090. 72, the amount of dedicated ad
valorem taxes from 2022 and 2023, which would have been remitted to it absent the
The Motion for
BREC I decision annulling the January 10, 2023 judgment.
Funds/ Damages further sought a judgment for damages resulting from the wrongful
preliminary injunction requiring funds to be deposited into the registry of the court
including attorney fees and costs.
BREC answered the Clerks' Retirement's reconventional demand, noting, in
part, that it failed to comply with La. Code Civ. P. art. 1033. BREC noted that the
Clerks' Retirement had previously answered BREC' s principal action and, therefore,
leave of court was required to assert an incidental demand pursuant to Article 1033.
Accordingly, BREC asserted there was no proper claim for damages before the
court.
A one -day bench trial on BREC' s request for a permanent injunction and
declaratory judgment ( docket number 725439) was held on December 3, 2024. At
the conclusion of the evidence, counsel for the Clerks' Retirement advised that she
11
had a witness relative to the claim in their reconventional demand, noting, however,
that the reconventional demand raised the same issue that was raised in the Motion
for Funds/ Damages. The district court noted, " After I rule [ on BREC' s claims], then
I'll hear your motion."' The district court then advised the parties that they could
file post -trial briefs, and the matter was submitted.
Thereafter, in open court on December 16, 2024, the district court denied
BREC' s injunction, adopted the Sheriffs post -trial brief as reasons for judgment, and
asked counsel for the Sheriff to prepare a judgment. Counsel for the Clerks'
Retirement noted her pending motion to withdraw funds in the registry of the court
and asked whether it should be set for hearing or if it was included in the judgment.
The district court responded, " Unless B[ REC] is asking that to be set for a hearing
those are the same funds that the court has just ruled upon. That ... money should
go to the retirement system[ s]." The district court continued noting, " the monies that
were in the registry of the court -- with this court's ruling, those monies should be
dispersed to those particular retirement systems."
On February 3, 2025, the district court signed a judgment denying BREC' s
petition for permanent injunction and declaratory relief and providing for the release
of the funds' in the registry of the court as follows:
6
According to the record, after the trial on BREC' s claims, the district court signed a rule to show
cause ordering BREC to appear and show cause on February 24, 2025, why the Motion for
Funds/ Damages filed by the Clerks' Retirement should not be granted.
We note that the judgment originally circulated by counsel for the Sheriff did not include the
language " upon the conclusion of any suspensive appeal or upon the expiration of the delay for
taking a suspensive appeal if no suspensive appeal is taken." That language was added at the
request of BREC and objected to by all other parties.
t° E' 1S ORDERED fl 1, upon t, 3°.; c. estac, lta" io , of any sas: apc.ttsive appeal or itlaatta tile~
expiration of, the ( h,l ay 1`c) dki. i 9 „ „ t! a ae,:; iv;; da} allow eiF no . fc, , ensivet. aappe¢til is taken, the 1 aast
Baton Rotalte Parish Cl ry of %'mlrtr6c.a, e tile funds dcuosited in the registry of the court as
Release v; t} t.' ?.'. ast Baton Rouge 8`.Q. izC'.!` i c̀S for dist$'9bufion to the City of Beton
Rovlg&Parish ,. 1` C. ast 1faices° lt.ouge, 61., 05 2,'240,? 8 deposit€tal on January 31, 2023;
Release to tho is a,,. tt,atetrt :' t uge She- HTS2, 052, 240, 28 deposited on January 113,
202:3 For distribution tri accordance r£sti; 9v. a. R , 11- 82-1 lint
Releasm to „ as° Faa t @a; afo€s • a; oupe ` rho i% f S2, 195, 2` 35. 67 deposked oil Jam,wry
, 4,
2024 for le. i, rihuh n 61with i,a, R -S, 11- 82,
This appeal by BREC followed.$ BREC assigns the following specifications
of error for our review:
1. The district court erred in concluding that the Sheriff is to transfer a
portion of the BREC Taxes to the Retirement Systems under La. R.S.
11: 82.
2. The district court erred by not ordering that the disputed BREC Taxes
currently deposited into the Registry of the Court be dispersed to
BREC.
Two separate answers to the appeal were filed in this case, one by the Clerks'
Retirement and a second one by the Sheriff, District Attorneys' Retirement System,
Louisiana Assessors' Retirement Fund, Municipal Employees' Retirement System of
Louisiana, and Registrars of Voters Employees' Retirement System. The parties
argued that the February 3, 2025 judgment should be modified, revised, or reversed
in part to eliminate the conditional release of the funds held in the registry of the
court. Considering our ruling on the merits herein, the relief sought in the answers
to appeal is denied as moot.
LAW AND ANALYSIS
As background, we note that in the late 1980s, the state experienced a cash
flow crisis. City of New Orleans v. Louisiana Assessors' Retirement and Relief
s In a related appeal also handed down this day ( this court's Docket Number 2026 CA 0297 c/ w
2026 CA 0298 c/ w 2026 CA 0299), the Clerks' Retirement challenges the district court' s March
26, 2025 judgment, which denied the Motion for Funds/ Damages filed by the Clerks' Retirement.
See Recreation and Park Commission for Parish of East Baton Rouge v. Gautreaux, 2026-
0297, 2026- 0298, 2026- 0299 ( La. App. 1 Cir. --/--/--) ( unpublished).
10
Fund, 2005- 2548 ( La. 10/ 1/ 07), 986 So. 2d 1, 9. To ensure the financial soundness
of both state and statewide public retirement systems affected by the crisis, the
legislature proposed amending the state constitution. Pursuant to 1987 Acts No. 947,
2, the proposal to add paragraph E to La. Const. art. X, §29 was submitted to the
voters and ratified on November 21, 1987. Id. The amendment became effective on
December 24, 1987. Id.
As enacted, La. Const. art. X, § 29( E) requires that state and statewide
retirement systems attain and maintain actuarial soundness and that the legislature
establish the particular method of actuarial valuation to be employed for purposes of
With respect to statewide
accomplishing this end. La. Const. art. X, §29( E)( 1).
public retirement systems whose benefits are not guaranteed by the state such as the
Retirement Systems, see La. R.S. 11: 81, subsection ( E)( 3) requires that the
legislature determine all contributions by members, employers, and dedicated taxes
required for sound actuarial maintenance of the retirement systems. La. Const. art.
X, §29( E)( 3); City of New Orleans, 986 So.2d at 9.
In the year following the adoption of La. Const. art. X, §29( E), the legislature
enacted Title 11 of the Louisiana Revised Statutes, the " Louisiana Public Retirement
Law." City of New Orleans, 986 So.2d at 9. In Title 11, the legislature consolidated
the law regarding public retirement systems so as to comply with the constitutional
mandate that public retirement systems be maintained on a sound actuarial basis. Id
With respect to tax contributions, La. R. S. 11: 81 provides that " [t]he purpose of this
Subpart is to comply with the requirements of Article X, Section 29( E)( 3) of the
Constitution of Louisiana that the legislature shall determine dedicated taxes for
statewide public retirement systems not covered by the provisions of Article X,
Section 29( A) or (B) of the Constitution of Louisiana."
11
The statute at issue in this matter, La. R.S. 11: 82, funds state and statewide
public retirement systems via the collection and remission of aggregate ad valorem
taxes. Louisiana Revised Statutes 11: 82 provides as follows:
A. Ad valorem tax contributions to state and statewide public retirement
systems shall be as follows:
1) Assessors' Retirement Fund. Dedicated funds are . 25% ( 1% for
Orleans Parish) of aggregate taxes shown to be collectible by the tax
rolls of each parish.
2) Clerks' of Court Retirement and Relief Fund. Dedicated funds are
25% (. 5% for Orleans Parish) of aggregate taxes shown to be
collectible by the rolls of each parish.
3) Municipal Employees' Retirement System of Louisiana. Dedicated
funds are . 25% of aggregate taxes shown to be collectible by the tax
rolls of each parish except Orleans; funds collected from the parish of
East Baton Rouge are to be distributed pursuant to R.S. 11: 1862. These
amounts are split between Plan A and Plan B based on active member
payroll.
4) Parochial Employees' Retirement System of Louisiana. Dedicated
funds are . 25% of aggregate taxes shown to be collectible by the tax
rolls of each parish except Orleans and East Baton Rouge. These
amounts are split between Plan A and Plan B based on active member
payroll.
5) Sheriffs' Pension and Relief Fund. Dedicated funds are . 5% of
aggregate taxes shown to be collectible by the tax rolls of each parish.
6) District Attorneys' Retirement System. Dedicated funds are . 2% of
aggregate taxes shown to be collectible by the tax rolls of each parish.
7) Registrars' of Voters Employees' Retirement System. Dedicated
funds are . 0625% of aggregate taxes shown to be collectible by the tax
rolls of each parish.
8)( a) Teachers' Retirement System of Louisiana. Dedicated funds are
one percent of aggregate taxes shown to be collectible by the tax rolls
of each parish except Orleans.
b) Effective with the 2004 tax roll payment, the Teachers' Retirement
System of Louisiana shall credit each city, parish, or other local public
school system located completely within East Baton Rouge Parish with
an amount equal to one percent of the aggregate taxes shown to be
collectible by the tax rolls for any millage levied by that school system
plus an amount equal to the percentage of the total aggregate taxes
collected by that school system of all aggregate taxes collected by all
12
school systems within the parish of one percent of the aggregate taxes
shown to be collectible by the tax rolls for any millage levied by an
entity other than a school board remitted to the system from East Baton
Rouge Parish.
c) Within thirty days after the effective date of Subparagraph ( b) of
this Paragraph, the East Baton Rouge Parish School Board, the Baker
City School Board, and the Zachary Community School Board shall
file with the Teachers' Retirement System of Louisiana and the assessor
for East Baton Rouge Parish a formula to be used to calculate the
amount to be credited to each school board.
B. Provided, however, in the event the employer contributions become
zero and employee contributions and dedicated taxes prescribed in this
Section provide more than the total actuarially required contribution to
any system, then the Public Retirement Systems' Actuarial Committee
shall determine the amount of the aggregate taxes shown on the tax rolls
of each parish that shall be remitted to such retirement system.
Standard ofReview
The issuance of a permanent injunction takes place only after a trial on the
merits, in which the burden of proof must be met by a preponderance of the evidence.
State Machinery & Equipment Sales, Inc. v. lberville Parish Council, 2005-
2240 ( La. App. 1 Cir. 12/ 28/ 06), 952 So. 2d 77, 81. The manifest error standard. is
the appropriate standard of review for the issuance or denial of a permanent
injunction. Davenport v. Chew, 2023- 0036 ( La. App. 1 Cir. 9/ 15/ 23), 375 So. 3d
973, 976. However, the proper interpretation of a statute is a question of law, which
is reviewed by an appellate court under the de novo standard of review. Johnson v.
Landry, 2025- 0925 ( La. App. I Cir. 9/ 24/ 25), 421 So. 3d 585, 589- 590. Pursuant to
this standard of review, we render judgment on the record, without deference to the
legal conclusions of the district court. Sharp v. Templet, 2025- 0340 ( La. App. I
Cir. 11/ 7/ 25), 424 So. 3d 804, 808.
The declaratory judgment articles of the Louisiana Code of Civil Procedure
grant courts of record within their respective jurisdictions the authority to declare
rights, status, and other legal relations, regardless of whether further relief is or could
13
be claimed. See La. Code Civ. P. art. 1871. A declaratory judgment simply
establishes the rights of the parties or expresses the opinion of the court on a quest ion
-
of law without ordering anything to be done. MAPP Const., LLC v. Amerisure
Mut. Ins. Co., 2013- 1074 ( La. App. I Cir. 3/ 24/ 14), 143 So. 3d 520, 528.
The scope of appellate review in a declaratory judgment action is confined to
a determination of whether the district court abused its discretion by granting or
Roper v. East Baton Rouge
refusing to render a declaratory judgment.
Metropolitan Council, 2015- 0.178 ( La. App. I Cir. 11/ 6/ 15), 183 So. 3d 550, 55.3,
writ denied, 2015- 2231 ( La. 2/ 5/ 16), 186 So. 3d 1166. However, the judgment itself
is still reviewed under the appropriate standard of review, i.e., questions of law are
reviewed de novo, while questions of fact are subject to a manifest error standard of
review. Westlawn Cemeteries, L.L.C. v. Louisiana Cemetery Board, 2021-
01414 ( La. 3/ 25/ 22), 339 So. 3d 548, 559.
The determination of whether a statute is constitutional presents a question of
law, which is reviewed by this court de novo. State v. Webb, 2013- 1681 ( La.
5/ 7/ 14), 144 So. 3d 971, 975; Mid -City Automotive, L.L.C. v. Department of
Public Safety and Corrections, 2018- 0056 ( La. App. I Cir. 11/ 7/ 18), 267 So. 3d
165, 175. All statutory enactments are presumed to be constitutional until the
contrary is made clear. Carver v. Louisiana Department of Public Safety, 2017-
1340 ( La. 1/ 30/ 18), 239 So. 3d 226, 230. The party challenging the statute bears the
heavy burden of proving it is unconstitutional. It is not enough to show the statute' s
constitutionality is fairly debatable; it must be shown clearly and convincingly that
it was the constitutional aim to deny the legislature the power to enact the statute.
The court must construe the statute so as to preserve its constitutionality when it is
reasonable to do so. Id.; see also Greater New Orleans Expressway Com' nv.
Olivier, 2004- 2147 ( La. 1/ 19/ 05), 892 So.2d 570, 573 ( citing State v. Board of
14
Sup' rs, La. State University & Agr. & Mechanical College, 228 La. 951, 84 So.2d
597, 600 ( 1955)) (" Because legislators owe the same duty to obey and uphold the
constitution as do judges, legislators are presumed to have weighed the relevant
constitutional considerations in enacting legislation, and legislative acts are
constitutional ' until declared otherwise in proceedings brought
presumed
contradictorily between interested persons."').
Statutory Interpretation
Taxes may only be levied under a statute that is clear and unambiguous and,
See
strictly construed, leaves no question but that such tax is due and payable.
Brown v. LaNasa, 244 La. 314, 320, 152 So. 2d 33, 35 ( 1963). In interpreting
statutes that impose a tax, we begin with the well- settled premise that tax statutes
Where a tax statute is
must be strictly construed against the taxing authority.
susceptible of more than one reasonable interpretation, the courts adopt a
construction favorable to the taxpayer. Cleco Evangeline, LLC v. Louisiana Tax
Com' n, 2001- 0561 ( La. App. I Cir. 6/ 22/ 01), 808 So. 2d 740, 744, affd, 2001- 2162
La. 4/ 3/ 02), 813 So. 2d 351.
However, when a law is clear and unambiguous and its application does not
lead to absurd consequences, the law shall be applied as written, and no further
interpretation may be made in search of the intent of the legislature. La. Civ. Code
art. 9. This principle applies to tax statutes. Cleco Evangeline, 808 So. 2d at 744.
Applicability ofLa. R.S. 11: 82
The threshold issue in this case is whether BREC' s ad valorem taxes are
exempt from the provisions of La. R.S. 11: 82 as dedicated or special taxes. BREC
argues on appeal that it has two sources of ad valorem taxing authority under La.
Const. art. VI, §§26 and 32 and that the diversion of taxes dedicated to a specific
purpose is expressly prohibited by these constitutional provisions. BREC further
15
alleges that the propositions presented to and approved by the voters for the levy of
BREC taxes did not authorize any non-BREC use of these taxes and that La. R.S.
11: 82, as applied to the BREC taxes, is unconstitutional. Thus, BREC maintains,
the money currently held in the registry of the court should be dispersed to BREC.
We find no merit to BREC' s arguments.
During the trial on BREC' s petition for permanent injunction and declaratory
judgment, the district court heard testimony from Corey Wilson, Enitra Boykin,
Vivia Van Buren, and Michael Waguespack, and considered the documentary
evidence introduced by the parties including the ballot and proposition language and
the pertinent election notices.
Corey Wilson, BREC' s superintendent, testified that BREC' s budget is
comprised of ad valorem taxes and self g
- enerated revenue. According to Mr.
Wilson, BREC' s ad valorem taxes are distributed according to the law, with some
funds used for capital improvements and some for operating and maintenance
expenses. He added that BREC spends about 40 percent of its budget on salaries
and benefits. Concerning BREC' s ad valorem taxes being remitted to the Retirement
Systems, Mr. Wilson acknowledged he was unaware of any formal complaint or
protest by BREC to the Louisiana Legislative Auditor (" LLA") prior to 2022 when
this lawsuit was initiated.
Regarding the publication of election notices for bond elections, Mr. Wilson
stated that BREC prepares and publishes the notices in the newspaper prior to any
elections as required by law. He further added the law requires that election notices
include language indicating that a portion of the taxes will be remitted to the
Retirement Systems.
Enitra Boykin, Chief Administrative Officer and general counsel for BREC,
testified that her understanding is that pursuant to BREC' s enabling statute, La. R.S.
16
33: 4570.4( 8), BREC is not allowed to use BREC ad valorem taxes for anything
other than BREC purposes. She also acknowledged that pursuant to La. Const. art.
V1, § 32, BREC could levy special taxes for "the purpose of acquiring, constructing,
improving, maintaining, or operating any work of public improvement."
Ms. Boykin testified that BREC' s office of general counsel directs the drafting
of ballot proposals and that BREC drafts the accompanying proces verbals. When
asked about the election notices for the 2014, 2016, and 2024 elections that BREC
posted in the newspaper, Ms. Boykin confirmed the purpose of the notices was to
inform the public of the election' s purpose. She further noted that BREC never
intended to mislead the public with these published election notices and that she was
complying with Louisiana law by including language in the notices that a portion of
the money collected from the ad valorem taxes would be remitted to the Retirement
Systems in the manner prescribed by law. With regard to the 2024 ballot
proposition, Ms. Boykin indicated that the words " solely and exclusively" were not
used anywhere in the ballot provision. She also acknowledged La. R.S.
18: 1299. 1( A), which limits the length of a ballot proposition to 200 words or less.
Tax Director for the East Baton Rouge Sheriffs Office Vivia Van Buren
testified that her duties as tax director include collecting the ad valorem taxes each
year and distributing them to the taxing entities. She explained how pension reports
are used to determine what the LLA deems is collectible for each taxing entity and
what amount will be deducted and remitted to the various retirement systems. She
indicated that the LLA audits the Sheriffs Office every year. Ms. Van Buren
confirmed that since she began her employment with the Sheriffs Office in 1999,
the LLA has never informed her that the Sheriffs Office was incorrectly remitting
taxes to the Retirement Systems. Ms. Van Buren noted further that BREC has never
contacted her to tell her that she was improperly remitting taxes.
17
Michael Waguespack testified that as the LLA, he operates as the fiscal
advisor to the Louisiana State Legislature and audits the fiscal records of the State
and its various agencies and political subdivisions. He further added that his staff
oversees the audit of BREC through BREC' s contracted certified public accountant.
When asked if the words " solely and exclusively" appeared anywhere in BREC' s
audit or whether there was any indication that any of BREC' s revenue sources would
be restricted or expressly dedicated and, therefore, exempt from the taxes, the
following colloquy between Mr. Waguespack and counsel for the Retirement
Systems occurred:
A. My response is -- if I understood the question --- that we do not
see any language in the notes of financial statements -- traditionally
where there would be -- disclosed ... where they discuss the various
millages and their purpose. None of the language of that says solely
and exclusively for a specific acquisition, such as -- a building a jail, or
something of that nature.
So, as for the general operations and maintenance and capital
improvements BREC' s overall mission -- to provide recreation for the
East Baton Rouge [ P] arish residents.
So, nowhere in here do we talk about special tax, or regular ad
valorem taxes as we as auditors subject to the state statutes.
Q. If there were -- in the course of auditing a governmental entity
that collects ad valorem taxes, if a particular income source was
expressly restricted in its use, would you expect to find that reflected in
the audit?
A. I would see that language spelled out [ in the] notes to the
financials.
Q. And do you see that in the BREC audit?
A. I do not.
Q. In order to assure the accuracy and reliability of an audit can you
tell me what steps your office takes?
A. Well, when our office receives its report, we put it through a
checklist to make sure and go through -- that it's got all the proper
1U.,
disclosure, they're following the standards, that the opinion is following
the latest language it should follow, and just do an overall accuracy
check to make sure everything adds and subtracts and ties to the basic
financial statements. I also want to make sure that there are reports with
respect to compliance -- with laws and regulations and a report that
covers the internal structure -- internal control structure of the entity.
Q. So, for example, if a source of income was intended to be used
for a specific purpose only, would the auditor look to see if, in fact, that
revenue source was used as --
A.