Marty Nilest v. Roman Kusyo
CourtCourt of Appeals of Kentucky
Date FiledNovember 20, 2026
Docket2025-CA-0348
JudgeAcree
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
RENDERED: NOVEMBER 20, 2026; 10:00 A.M.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
Commonwealth of Kentucky
Court of Appeals
NO. 2025-CA-0348-MR
MARTY NILEST AND MATT
NILEST APPELLANTS
APPEAL FROM JEFFERSON CIRCUIT COURT
v. HONORABLE SARAH E. CLAY, JUDGE
ACTION NO. 17-CI-002319
ROMAN KUSYO AND NATALIE
KUSYO APPELLEES
OPINION
REVERSING
** ** ** ** **
BEFORE: ACREE, EASTON, AND TAYLOR, JUDGES.
ACREE, JUDGE: Marty and Matt Nilest appeal the Jefferson Circuit Court’s
summary judgment, piercing the Nilests’ limited liability company’s veil resulting
in their personal liability. Because the trial court failed to apply Kentucky Revised
Statute (KRS) 275.185(4), we reverse.
This Court previously set out the history of this case in All That N
More, LLC v. Kusyo, No. 2019-CA-0928-MR, 2021 WL 1240799 (Ky. App. Apr.
2, 2021) (Kusyo I). In Kusyo I, we affirmed the trial court’s entry of default
judgment against the limited liability company but remanded for a re-calculation of
damages.
However, the Kusyos also amended their complaint after remand,
naming the Nilests individually, and seeking to pierce the limited liability
company’s veil. The Kusyos moved for summary judgment on that issue.
The trial court granted summary judgment. This appeal followed.
“Because summary judgments involve no fact finding, this Court will
review the circuit court’s decision de novo.” Associated Ins. Service, Inc. v.
Garcia, 307 S.W.3d 58, 61 (Ky. 2010).
As in prior cases, the parties and the trial court presumed without
deciding that a limited liability company’s veil can be pierced in similar fashion to
a corporation’s veil piercing. See, e.g., Tavadia v. Mitchell, 564 S.W.3d 322, 328
(Ky. App. 2018) (citation omitted). See also Lummus Corporation v. Lighthouse
Transportation Services, LLC, ___ S.W.3d ____, 2026 WL 1189933 (Ky. App.
May 1, 2026) (discretionary review pending) (concluding the LLC veil could be
-2-
pierced).1 The Nilests focus on the trial court’s analysis of the veil-piercing
factors.
“A successful veil-piercing claim requires both this element of
domination and circumstances in which continued recognition of the corporation as
a separate entity would sanction a fraud or promote injustice.” Inter-Tel Techs.,
Inc. v. Linn Station Properties, LLC, 360 S.W.3d 152, 155 (Ky. 2012). The trial
court applied Inter-Tel to conclude the first element of veil piercing–domination–
was satisfied. A significant fact upon which the court based its decision was the
Nilests failure to follow corporate formalities. (Record (R.) 1393). That is an
appropriate factor in determining whether to pierce an entity created pursuant to
KRS Chapter 271B. Inter-Tel, 360 S.W.3d at 163.
But the Nilests operate their business as a limited liability company
created pursuant to KRS 275.001 et seq. That chapter includes KRS 275.185 that
sets record-keeping requirements of limited liability company members, part of
their obligation to observe formalities of creation and continued operation.
Notwithstanding that obligation, the statute also includes the following protection
for members from personal liability: “Failure of the limited liability company to
keep or maintain any of the records or information required pursuant to this section
1
As described in Lummus, the Supreme Court has not affirmatively decided the issue of limited
liability company’s veil piercing but may do so with its decision to grant or deny discretionary
review. Whether to hold this case in abeyance until then is a decision for the trial court.
-3-
shall not be grounds for imposing liability on any member or manager for the debts
and obligations of the limited liability company.” KRS 275.185(4).
As discussed in the not-yet-final Lummus Corporation v. Lighthouse
Transportation Services, LLC, the legislature added language to KRS Chapter 275
in 2010 generally eliminating the liability protection “of a member, manager,
employee, or agent of a limited liability company for his or her own negligence,
wrongful acts, or misconduct.” 2010 Kentucky Laws ch. 133, § 31 (S.B. 150)
(codified as KRS 275.150(3)). However, the legislature did not eliminate or alter
KRS 275.185(4), which is unchanged since its original adoption. 1994 Kentucky
Laws ch. 389, § 37 (S.B. 184).
Although the trial court’s summary judgment itself notes that the
Nilests “claim . . . limited liability companies are not required to follow these
formalities[,]” (R. 1391), it is clear the court failed to consider KRS 275.185(4)
when determining whether, as a matter of law, the veil of the limited liability
company’s existence could be pierced. That was error.
We must reverse the summary judgment. Whether to re-analyze the
Kusyos’ motion for summary judgment in the context of KRS 275.185(4) or to
proceed otherwise is a prerogative of the trial court.
ALL CONCUR.
-4-
BRIEFS FOR APPELLANT: BRIEF FOR APPELLEE:
Thomas E. Roma, Jr. Garry R. Adams
Louisville, Kentucky Abigail V. Lewis
Louisville, Kentucky
-5-