In the Interest of A.G., Minor Child
CourtCourt of Appeals of Iowa
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
Docket26-0436
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF IOWA
_______________
No. 26-0436
Filed November 18, 2026
_______________
In the Interest of A.G., Minor Child,
R.L., Mother,
Petitioner-Appellee,
N.G., Father,
Respondent-Appellant.
_______________
Appeal from the Iowa District Court for Story County,
The Honorable Hunter W. Thorpe, Judge.
_______________
AFFIRMED
_______________
Audra F. Saunders, West Des Moines, attorney for appellant father.
Nicole S. Facio of New Point Law Firm, PLC, Ames, attorney for appellee
mother.
Leah Patton of Patton Legal Services, LLC, Ames, attorney and guardian ad
litem for minor child.
_______________
Considered without oral argument
by Ahlers, P.J., and Chicchelly and Langholz, JJ.
Opinion by Chicchelly, J.
1
CHICCHELLY, Judge.
A father appeals from an order terminating his parental rights under
Iowa Code chapter 600A (2025). The father challenges the statutory
grounds for termination and whether termination is in the child’s best
interests. Because the mother proved the father has failed to contribute to
the support of the child without good cause under Iowa Code
section 600A.8(4) and termination is in the child’s best interests, we affirm.
BACKGROUND FACTS AND PROCEEDINGS
The mother and father were in a relationship when A.G. was born in
2019. A.G. lived with the mother and father until the mother was charged
with domestic-abuse assault and child endangerment in the fall of 2019. A
no-contact order was entered between the mother and A.G., and the father
became the primary caretaker of A.G. However, in December 2019, a
domestic incident occurred between the mother and the father, and the
mother suffered significant injuries. As a result, a no-contact order was
entered between the mother and the father.1
The mother later filed a petition to establish custody. While the father
accepted service of the petition, he later testified that he was unaware of the
proceedings or that he could request visitation. Therefore, the father took
no further action in the case after accepting service. Thus, a default
judgment was entered, and the mother was awarded sole legal custody and
physical care of A.G., while the father was awarded reasonable visitation as
agreed upon by the parties. The father was also ordered to pay $370 a month
1
After the entry of this no-contact order, A.G. resided with the mother. While the
mother was the protected party in the order, A.G. was not included. The order expired in
January 2025.
2
for child support. Following the entry of the custody decree, the father did
not take action to modify it, paid only $20.62 in child support over the
subsequent six-year period, and never sought visitation with the child.
In December 2025, the mother petitioned to terminate the father’s
parental rights. After a February 2026 hearing, the district court found that
the mother proved the grounds for termination under Iowa Code
section 600A.8(3)(b) and section 600A.8(4). The district court further
found that terminating the father’s parental rights was in the child’s best
interests and granted the petition. The father now appeals.
STANDARD OF REVIEW
“Private termination proceedings under chapter 600A are reviewed de
novo.” In re B.H.A., 938 N.W.2d 227, 232 (Iowa 2020). “Although we are
not bound by them, we give weight to the trial court’s findings of fact,
especially when considering credibility of witnesses.” Id. (quoting In re
R.K.B., 572 N.W.2d 600, 601 (Iowa 1998)).
DISCUSSION
Termination proceedings under chapter 600A are a two-step process.
Id. First, the parent petitioning to terminate parental rights must prove the
statutory ground for termination by clear and convincing evidence. See id. If
that burden is met, we then consider whether termination is in the child’s
best interests. See id.
I. Ground for Termination
When the district court finds that the petitioning parent has proved
termination on multiple grounds under Iowa Code section 600A.8, “we may
affirm so long as one ground is supported by sufficient evidence.” In re L.K.,
3
No. 25-0935, 2026 WL 892718, at *2 (Iowa Ct. App. Apr. 1, 2026). We focus
on section 600A.8(4).2
Section 600A.8(4) allows the court to terminate parental rights if “[a]
parent has been ordered to contribute to the support of the child or financially
aid in the child’s birth and has failed to do so without good cause.” “Good
cause” concerns the parent’s ability to pay the court-ordered child support.
See R.K.B., 572 N.W.2d at 602; In re B.L.A., 357 N.W.2d 20, 22 (Iowa 1984)
(noting the key issue is the parent’s ability to pay).
“A parent has a basic obligation to support a minor child.” Klobnock v.
Abbott, 303 N.W.2d 149, 152 (Iowa 1981). A parent’s failure to pay child
support “manifests indifference to a child” and is “akin to abandonment.”
Id.; see also In re Kelley, 262 N.W.2d 781, 785 (Iowa 1978) (“[A]bnegation of
court-ordered financial responsibility to a child [is] the equivalent of
abandonment. A parent who unjustifiably refuses to meet a support
obligation manifests complete indifference to his child.”). But the failure to
pay must be “substantial, and not merely sporadic or insignificant.”
Klobnock, 303 N.W.2d at 152.
As noted, the father was ordered to pay $370 a month for child
support.3 However, at the time of the termination hearing, the father had
paid a total of $20.62, despite being sporadically employed. The district
court found that the father owed more than $24,000 in child support. The
father argues the district court failed to consider the context of his failure to
pay because he was incarcerated and did not have the knowledge or the
2
Although we focus our analysis on this section, it is clear to us that the father has
also abandoned A.G. under Iowa Code section 600A.8(3)(b).
3
The amount was later modified to $50 a month in July 2025.
4
resources to hire legal counsel to advise him on how to ensure that child
support was being paid.
While the father has been incarcerated on various occasions since the
custody decree was entered, including at the time of the termination hearing,
there have been periods when the father was not incarcerated and was
employed. 4 During such periods, the father made no child support
payments. While the father may not have been able to pay the full payment
amounts, it was feasible for him to pay some amount while employed.
Moreover, the $20.62 the father paid was made by two separate payments in
2025 while the father was incarcerated, showing that the father could
contribute financially while incarcerated. Thus, we conclude there is clear
and convincing evidence that the father has failed to contribute to the support
of A.G. without good cause. See In re B.C., No. 24-0680, 2024 WL 4965869,
at *3 (Iowa Ct. App. Dec. 4, 2024) (“Making the decision to not provide your
child any financial support is not ‘good cause.’”).
We acknowledge that the father’s mental-health issues made
consistent employment difficult. But the father’s struggle to stay employed
is also due to his criminal actions that have led to him being incarcerated. See
In re J.B., No. 25-0316, 2026 WL 520486, at *3 (Iowa Ct. App. Feb. 25,
2026) (“Granted, [the father] struggled with mental-health and substance-
use issues throughout his adult life. But much of his failure to pay the court-
4
We note that the father’s incarceration, on its own, did not absolve him from
paying child support. See In re C.J.D., No. 07–0766, 2007 WL 4322213, at *4 (Iowa Ct.
App. Dec. 12, 2007) (“Incarceration alone cannot excuse [the father’s] failure to pay. An
incarcerated parent must take full responsibility for the conduct that resulted in his
confinement. Our courts are generally unsympathetic toward self-created obstacles to
supporting one’s children.” (internal citations omitted)).
5
ordered support can be attributed to willful avoidance or his conscious
decision to commit crimes rather than be a responsible parent.”).
Lastly, the father’s ignorance as to how to pay child support and ensure
that it was being paid does not establish good cause. 5 See Klobnock, 303
N.W.2d at 153 (“The second reason why [the father] claims he failed to pay
support is because he did not know whether to pay it to the clerk of court or
directly to [the mother]. . . . While there may have been some question about
where he was to pay the support, we cannot find that this is good cause for
failing to pay for over two years.”); In re C.T., No. 17-1695, 2018 WL 2731640,
at *2 (Iowa Ct. App. June 6, 2018) (“[The father] simply chose to ignore his
obligation to provide support for this child. That is insufficient to establish
good cause.”). Based on the record, the father’s failure to pay child support
was substantial and not supported by good cause. Therefore, we conclude
the evidence supports termination under section 600A.8(4).
II. Child’s Best Interests
We next turn to the question of the child’s best interests, which is “the
paramount consideration in interpreting” chapter 600A. Iowa Code
§ 600A.1(1). “The best interest of a child requires that each biological parent
affirmatively assume the duties encompassed by the role of being a parent.”
Id. § 600A.1(2). When determining whether a parent has affirmatively
assumed these duties, we consider a parent’s “fulfillment of financial
obligations, demonstration of continued interest in the child, demonstration
of a genuine effort to maintain communication with the child, and
5
Despite the father’s argument here, he successfully modified his child support
obligation to $50 a month while incarcerated.
6
demonstration of the establishment and maintenance of a place of
importance in the child’s life.” Id.
We agree that terminating the father’s parental rights serves the
child’s best interests. As explained above, the father has failed to fulfill his
financial obligations to the child. Additionally, the child has no relationship
with the father. The father has not sent the child a gift or card celebrating
birthdays or other holidays since the entry of the custody decree. What’s
more, the father has not seen the child since 2022, and the father only saw
the child on that occasion because the mother unknowingly took the child to
a convenience store that the father was working at. The record shows that
the child does not really know the father’s identity and would probably not
recognize him. In contrast, the child has developed a relationship with the
mother’s fiancé and refers to him as “dad.” As the district court aptly put it,
“the father has been completely absent from the child’s [life] for over three
years and even prior to that contact was minimal. He has taken no affirmative
assumption of his duties as a parent and has made no genuine effort to be in
the child’s life.”
Nonetheless, the father contends that termination of his parental
rights would not be in the child’s best interests by pointing out that the
mother has been charged with child endangerment and that the mother and
her fiancé have been the subject of child-abuse assessments. We first note
that the child-endangerment charges the father draws our attention to were
filed in 2019. Since then, the mother has had no additional child-
endangerment charges.
As to the child-abuse assessments, two reports were founded. One
involved the mother’s fiancé hitting the child with a backscratcher, causing a
welt. The other involved the mother leaving a lighter accessible to the child,
7
resulting in the child suffering a burn mark.6 Thus, according to the father,
the mother’s and her fiancé’s behavior shows that the child could be put at
risk if the father’s parental rights are terminated.
Regarding the founded report of child abuse involving the mother’s
fiancé, the guardian ad litem reported that “this appears to be a minor,
isolated incident,” that the child feels comfortable around the mother’s
fiancé, and that they appear to have a good relationship. Further testimony
established that the mother and her fiancé plan to marry soon, and the fiancé
wants to adopt the child. And despite the father’s argument, he testified at
the termination hearing: “I think that [the child] has a great mother and a
great stepfather and they have been doing their best to take care of [the
child] . . . .” Thus, we conclude that termination of the father’s parental
rights is in the child’s best interests.
AFFIRMED.
6
As to this assessment, the mother cooperated with the services provided by the
Iowa Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). As a result, HHS has not sought
a child-in-need-of-assistance adjudication or removal of the child from the mother’s
home.
8