Taylor J. Gridley v. Timothy R. Easton
CourtCourt of Appeals of Iowa
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
Docket25-1457
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF IOWA
_______________
No. 25-1457
Filed November 18, 2026
_______________
Taylor J. Gridley,
Petitioner–Appellant,
v.
Timothy R. Easton,
Respondent–Appellee.
_______________
Appeal from the Iowa District Court for Wapello County,
The Honorable Dustin Hite, Judge.
_______________
AFFIRMED
_______________
Bryan Joseph Goldsmith and Carly M. Schomaker of Gaumer, Emanuel &
Goldsmith, P.C., Ottumwa, attorneys for appellant.
Cynthia D. Hucks of Box and Box Attorneys at Law, Ottumwa,
attorney for appellee.
_______________
Considered without oral argument
by Buller, P.J., Langholz, J., and Doyle, S.J.
Opinion by Buller, P.J.
1
BULLER, Presiding Judge.
Taylor Gridley appeals from a ruling ordering shared physical care of
her child with Timothy (Tim) Easton. Finding our resolution of this case is
driven by the district court’s credibility findings, we affirm.
Taylor and Tim share a child born in 2022. Each lives in or near
Ottumwa, are in their early 30s, are gainfully employed, and have children
from previous relationships. They never married, and their relationship was
short-lived.
After the child at issue here was born, both Taylor and Tim were
involved parents, taking staggered parental leave while the baby stayed at
Taylor’s home. When the child was six months old, the parents split up and
arranged child care around their work schedules, with help from Taylor’s
father when they both worked. Although there was conflicting testimony, the
district court found the parents had “a roughly shared care arrangement”
during the first year or so of the child’s life.
In mid-2023, Tim changed jobs, and Taylor filed this custody action
due to their change in schedules. The court found Taylor withheld parenting
time unless Tim agreed to her proposed schedule of one evening during the
week and every other weekend, which led to Tim not seeing the child for
about a month. The parties had some sharp or angry exchanges, but the
district court found they largely had “good, healthy co-parenting
communication” and co-parented effectively. The court also found “more
blame” fell on Taylor than Tim for any bad interactions.
The child is happy and healthy, and the district court found that both
parents’ love for the child was palpable during testimony. Tim was up to a
2
year in arrears on child support earlier in the case but made catch-up
payments.
Following a contested trial, the district court made repeated adverse
credibility findings about Taylor. The court expressly found “Tim’s
testimony more credible than Taylor’s” and credited “Tim’s testimony over
Taylor’s when their testimony [was] in conflict.” The court explained that it
believed “Taylor modified her testimony with the hope of a favorable
outcome” and found “[s]ome of her exhibits were also misleading to the
court by leaving out parts of conversations.” The court stopped short of
finding Taylor intentionally lied under oath, instead finding Taylor’s “lack of
complete candor with the court is more of a defense mechanism and an
attempt for her to gain control over a situation because she feels like she is
losing control over another.” The court noted Taylor’s past relationship with
a man who domestically abused her, and the record shows Tim associated
with that man in the lead-up to trial, even obtaining an affidavit of support
from him to support his custody request.
With this backdrop, the court ordered shared physical care and
imposed an alternating-weeks schedule, reasoning that schedule was “better
for the child” than the 2–2–3 schedule Taylor requested.
Taylor appeals, challenging the shared-physical-care placement and
the parenting-time schedule. We review de novo, but we give deference to
the district court’s credibility findings. In re Marriage of Hansen, 733
N.W.2d 683, 690 (Iowa 2007).
Physical-care determinations are made based on the best interests of
the child, not perceived fairness to the parents. Id. at 695. If a parent requests
shared physical care, the court must consider it and, if denying the request,
3
must explain the basis of that decision. Id. at 692; see Iowa Code § 598.41(5).
When evaluating the possibility of shared physical care, considerations
include: (1) whether both parents have historically contributed to physical
care in roughly the same proportion, (2) if they can “communicate and show
mutual respect,” (3) “the degree of conflict between parents,” and
(4) whether “the parents are in general agreement about their approach to
daily matters.” Hansen, 733 N.W.2d at 696–99; see also Randall v. Trier, 15
N.W.3d 809, 813–15 (Iowa Ct. App. 2024) (applying the Hansen factors in a
paternity action and observing the importance of “whether the party
requesting physical care has been an active and interested parent since the
child’s birth” (cleaned up)).
Applying the factors to this record, as informed by credibility findings,
we must affirm. The district court found the parties had mostly shared
physical care before the custody action, that they could communicate and
show mutual respect, that there was limited conflict, and that they were
generally in agreement on their approach to daily matters. This neatly tracks
Hansen, and Taylor has not identified any circumstance in this record that
justifies disturbing the district court’s shared-care analysis.
As for the parenting-time schedule, we also affirm. Both the 2–2–3
schedule and alternating weeks are ways to offer parents substantially
equivalent parenting time, and the district court is ordinarily in the best
position to assess whether scheduling tweaks are in the best interests of the
child. Absent a failure to serve the child’s best interests, which this record
fails to establish, we decline to tinker with the schedule on appeal. We also
reiterate, as the district court did, that the parents may mutually agree on a
departure from the decree’s schedule.
4
Given the parties’ respective finances, we decline to award attorney
fees. See Iowa Code § 600B.26 (2025).
Last, we conclude by recognizing that, absent the district court’s
credibility findings, we may have come to a different result in this case. The
cold record reads rather differently without the district court’s findings that
Taylor was untruthful—in particular, the cold record strongly suggests she
did the lion’s share of caregiving for the child leading up to the custody
action. We also question some of Tim’s choices—especially his decision to
involve Taylor’s abuser in this custody dispute. But we defer to the district
court’s findings because we hope findings regarding truthfulness are firmly
grounded in the court’s observations at trial and are not made lightly.
AFFIRMED.
5