In the Interest of C.Q. and A.Q., Minor Children
CourtCourt of Appeals of Iowa
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
Docket26-1626
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF IOWA
_______________
No. 26-1626
Filed November 18, 2026
_______________
In the Interest of C.Q. and A.Q., Minor Children,
K.Q., Mother,
Appellant.
_______________
Appeal from the Iowa District Court for Scott County,
The Honorable Michael Motto, Judge.
_______________
AFFIRMED
_______________
Gina L. Kramer of Kramer Law Office, PLLC, Dubuque,
attorney for appellant mother.
Brenna Bird, Attorney General, and Mackenzie Moran, Assistant Attorney
General, attorneys for appellee State.
Barbara E. Maness, Davenport, attorney and guardian ad litem
for minor children.
_______________
Considered without oral argument
by Tabor, C.J., and Greer and Ahlers, JJ.
Opinion by Ahlers, J.
1
AHLERS, Judge.
Following a permanency review hearing, the juvenile court
determined that a mother’s two children—who were twelve and nine at the
time of the hearing—could not be safely returned to her custody and that
termination would not be in the children’s best interests. The court also
determined that the children’s needs could best be met through the
establishment of a subsidized guardianship, with the maternal grandmother
and her husband serving as guardians.
The mother appeals. She contends the juvenile court should have
returned the children to her custody and argues that the guardianship is not
in the children’s best interests.1
We review child-in-need-of-assistance (CINA) proceedings de novo.
In re J.S., 846 N.W.2d 36, 40 (Iowa 2014). “In reviewing the proceedings,
we are not bound by the juvenile court’s fact findings; however, we do give
them weight. Our primary concern is the children’s best interests. CINA
determinations must be based upon clear and convincing evidence.” Id. at
40–41 (citations and footnote omitted).
Following a permanency hearing, the juvenile court may order the
child be returned “to the child’s home”; continue placement for six
additional months if it believes the need for removal will be resolved within
that time; direct the county attorney or child’s attorney to initiate
termination-of-parental-rights proceedings; or transfer custody to certain
individuals, including to an adult relative. Iowa Code § 232.104(2)(a)–(d)
(2025). But before the juvenile court may transfer custody to certain
individuals, it must find by clear and convincing evidence that (1) termination
1
The father’s rights were previously terminated in another state.
2
would not be in the child’s best interests, (2) the family was provided with
services to correct the situation that led to removal, and (3) “[t]he child
cannot be returned to the child’s home.” Id. § 232.104(4). The mother
challenges the court’s determinations that her children could not be returned
to her custody and that placing the children in a guardianship with their
maternal grandmother is in the children’s best interests.
We agree with the juvenile court that the children could not be
returned to the mother’s custody. The most concerning barrier to
reunification is the mother’s lack of protective capacity. The mother met her
current husband on a social media dating site. On their second date, he
revealed that he is a convicted sex offender. Despite that disclosure, the
mother continued to date him and became engaged to him less than a year
later. She also allowed him access to her two daughters, sometimes without
anyone else around.
When confronted about the details of her then-fiancé’s past
convictions, which included committing sex acts on a child, the mother
reported that “she trusts [him] and does not think he would hurt little girls.”2
And she claimed her daughters were not telling the truth when they reported
being left alone with the fiancé. There were also concerns that the fiancé
showed the older child, who was eleven years old, pornography. “Explicit
masturbation videos of [the older child] were found on [the older child]’s
phone during routine checks by the grandmother.” Yet the mother denied
her fiancé did anything wrong or that anything inappropriate occurred
between him and the children. The fiancé, now her husband, was arrested
and charged with six counts of child endangerment and violation of the sex
2
His previous victim is in the same age range as the mother’s children.
3
offender registry. He was transferred back to Illinois for parole violations and
is currently incarcerated there.
Also contributing to the conclusion that the children cannot be
returned to the mother’s custody is the fact that the mother has lost her home
and employment. She lives with her in-laws and is completely dependent on
them. She does not have transportation and does not intend to seek
employment due to some medical conditions, though she has been denied
disability benefits.
The mother completed a psychological evaluation. The evaluator’s
“diagnostic impression[s]” included PTSD, major depressive disorder,
generalized anxiety disorder, panic disorder, borderline personality disorder
with avoidant and paranoid traits. And the evaluator opined that the “tests
also indicate [the mother] is experiencing significant persecutory ideation
and having cynical beliefs of others while being blind to her own unattractive
defects and attributing them to others.” The evaluator also opined that the
mother “will require long-term intensive treatment to progress, as she
struggles to move forward.”
A report to the court from the Iowa Department of Health and Human
Services case worker, filed a little over a month before the permanency review
order, explained that the mother does not understand the need for the
department’s involvement with her family and placed blame on case workers
and her own mother. The report explained that most of the mother’s daily
communication with the department consisted of complaints about the
department’s involvement and her own past trauma she claimed her mother
inflicted upon her. And she reported to workers that she wanted to remain
married and does not believe the factual basis for her husband’s convictions.
She stated she did not believe the facts supporting his original conviction
4
because “that little girl never said he physically raped her. She couldn’t give
any specifics on it.” And she opined that because the young child could not
pinpoint her age when the abuse occurred the child must be lying.
From this, it is apparent that the mother will not prioritize her
children’s safety, would place them in dangerous situations, and would likely
not believe them if they reported some harm to her. See In re D.D., 955
N.W.2d 186, 193 (Iowa 2021) (“It’s folly to think the mother will stand
sentinel to protect against a foe she doesn’t acknowledge exists.”). In short,
we agree with the juvenile court that the children could not be returned to
the mother safely.
We also agree that establishment of a guardianship with the maternal
grandmother and her husband is in the children’s best interests. The
children have been in their care for some time. And the mother has conceded
that the children think highly of their grandmother. And the older child
expressed to the case worker that she wanted to continue to live with her
grandmother but be able to text her mother. The younger child reported the
same and said she feels safe “in GiGi and Papa’s care.” Both the department
and the children’s guardian ad litem recommended establishing a
guardianship. And the grandmother expressed to a worker that she would
permit contact between the children and mother if the children desire that
contact and the mother is appropriate.
Based on these circumstances, establishment of a guardianship
provides the children with much needed permanency and stability while
keeping open the possibility of future involvement of the mother so long as it
is safe. This serves the children’s best interests, so we affirm.
AFFIRMED.
5