Steuben County, Indiana Plan Commission v. 3rd Basin, LLC
CourtIndiana Court of Appeals
Date FiledNovember 16, 2026
Docket26A-PL-00490
JudgeJudge Tavitas
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Pursuant to Ind. Appellate Rule 65(E), the trial court and parties shall not take any
action in reliance upon this Opinion until it is certified.
FILED
Nov 16 2026, 8:57 am
CLERK
Indiana Supreme Court
Court of Appeals
and Tax Court
IN THE
Court of Appeals of Indiana
Steuben County, Indiana Plan Commission,
Appellants-Respondents
Todd and Sara Barile, Husband and Wife; Brian and Terri
Richards, Husband and Wife; Jared and Michelle Widenhoefer,
Husband and Wife; Kameron and Abby Meyer, Husband and
Wife; Jeffrey and Lori Wagner, Husband and Wife; Ronald and
Paula Laurent, Husband and Wife; Dorick Rudolph and
Cynthia Baker, as Joint Tenants with Rights of Survivorship;
Brian W. Strahm Revocable Living Trust, Dated August 7,
2020; and Christopher A. and Nancy E. Graham,
Husband and Wife,
Appellants-Intervening-Respondents
v.
3rd Basin, LLC,
Appellee-Petitioner
Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-490 | November 16, 2026 Page 1 of 21
November 16, 2026
Court of Appeals Case No.
26A-PL-490
Appeal from the Steuben Circuit Court
The Honorable Jeremy T. Musser, Judge
Trial Court Cause No.
76C01-2505-PL-265
Opinion by Chief Judge Tavitas
Judges Bradford and Felix concur.
Tavitas, Chief Judge.
Case Summary
[1] The Steuben County Plan Commission (“Plan Commission”) and a group of
intervening neighboring property owners (“Intervenors”) appeal the trial court’s
grant of a petition for judicial review filed by 3rd Basin, LLC (“3rd Basin”).
This litigation concerns the Plan Commission’s conditional grant of 3rd Basin’s
application for primary approval of a subdivision plat. 3rd Basin argued that
the Plan Commission erred by imposing a condition on the grant of the
application and filed a petition for judicial review. We conclude that the trial
court erred by granting 3rd Basin’s petition for judicial review. Accordingly, we
reverse.
Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-490 | November 16, 2026 Page 2 of 21
Issue
[2] The Plan Commission and Intervenors raise two issues, which we consolidate
and restate as whether the trial court erred by granting 3rd Basin’s petition for
judicial review.
Facts
[3] This litigation involves the Plan Commission’s conditional approval for 3rd
Basin’s proposed subdivision primary plat on the shores of Crooked Lake in
Steuben County. As the matter turns on the interpretation of relevant statutes
and ordinances, we begin by setting out the relevant Steuben County
Ordinances.
A. Relevant Steuben County Ordinances
1. Steuben County Subdivision Control Ordinance
[4] The Steuben County Subdivision Control Ordinance (“Subdivision Control
Ordinance”) provides that the Plan Commission has “all the powers and duties
with respect to primary and secondary plats of subdivisions[.]” Appellants’
App. Vol. III p. 107 (Preamble and Enacting Clause). The Subdivision Control
Ordinance “shall be held to be the minimum requirements for the protection of
the public health, safety, and general welfare . . . .” Id. at 107 (Preamble and
Enacting Clause) (emphasis added); see also id. at 125 (Section 8.1(a)). In
addition to the requirements established in the Subdivision Control Ordinance,
“all subdivision plats shall comply with” all applicable state and local statutory
provisions and “[t]he County Zoning Ordinance[.]” Id. at 109 (Section
Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-490 | November 16, 2026 Page 3 of 21
3.1(a)(2)). Where any provision of the Subdivision Control Ordinance
“imposes restrictions [different] from those imposed by any other provision of
this Ordinance, any other ordinance, rule or regulation, or other provision of
Law, whichever provisions are more restrictive or impose higher standards,
shall control.” Id. at 125 (Section 8.1(b)(1)) (emphasis added). Section 3.1(b) of
the Subdivision Control Ordinance provides: “Plat approval may be withheld if
a subdivision is not in conformity with the above guides and requirements, or
with the policies and purposes of these Regulations.” Id. at 109.
[5] In general, the approval process for a major subdivision, which is at issue here,
requires several steps. First, an application for primary approval of a
preliminary plat is submitted, and public hearings are held. The Subdivision
Control Ordinance provides that the Plan Commission shall “grant primary
approval, primary approval with conditions, disapprove the plat, or table the
plat for more information.” Appellants’ App. Vol. III p. 61. If the Plan
Commission approves the primary plat, construction plans are submitted, and
the Plan Director “shall immediately refer these plans to the appropriate
agencies of the participating jurisdictions for review.” Id. If the construction
plans are approved by the appropriate agencies, an application for secondary
approval of the plat is submitted and considered by the Plan Commission. The
secondary approval request must “[t]otally comply with the Ordinance and
terms and conditions of primary approval.” Id. at 62.
Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-490 | November 16, 2026 Page 4 of 21
2. Steuben County Zoning Ordinance
[6] 3rd Basin’s property at issue here is zoned Lake Residential. The Steuben
County Zoning Ordinance (“Zoning Ordinance”) establishes the following
regarding this zoning district:
The LR, Lake Residence District, is established to include
residential neighborhoods in the proximity of bodies of water.
These areas are characterized by environmental sensitivity and
are subject to heavy recreational use. Uses in the LR District are
limited to residential and certain water-related and recreational-
related uses compatible with both the nearby development and
the local, environmentally sensitive land. The regulations of this
district are intended to ensure infill development is consistent
with the character of established lakefront neighborhoods, is
compatible with the size, scale, setback, and architectural
character of surrounding homes, does not overbuild small lots
and minimizes impacts to views.
Id. at 70.
[7] In the Lake Residential district, common use lake access lots require “Special
Exception approval” from the Board of Zoning Appeals (“BZA”). Id. at 70-71.
Section 17.01 of the Zoning Ordinance provides: “A use listed in a zoning
district as a special exception use may only be established or expanded with the
approval of the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) following the procedures and
requirements of this chapter.” Id. at 74. Section 9.10(b) concerns common use
lake access lots and provides:
Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-490 | November 16, 2026 Page 5 of 21
Common Use Riparian/Lake Access Lots
(1) The intent of this provision is to minimize the impacts of
Back lot Development on the Shoreline. Further, it is the intent
of this provision to:
a. discourage the funneling of lake access for multiple
residences through narrow access points,
b. establish a balanced and orderly relationship between
development and the amount of Shoreline available for use
by residents, and
c. assure responsible “lake access” for Lakefront
Development.
(2) This section shall apply to lakefront or back lot development,
including, lake front access points, lake front recreational areas,
beaches, parks, [and] playgrounds that have been designated as a
common area or access point, in all zoning districts. This section
shall apply to common areas lakefront or back lot developments
created as part of a residential subdivision . . . .
(3) Where a parcel of land contiguous to a natural body of water
is proposed for residential development, a commonly owned area
bordering on the body of water may be dedicated for recreational
purposes.
*****
Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-490 | November 16, 2026 Page 6 of 21
(4) Common use waterfront lots shall not be used for public
marinas, public beaches or commercial recreational use operated
for profit.
(5) The design, operation and use of the common waterfront lot
shall not impair the natural appearance of the land, overcrowd
the lake surface or produce unreasonable noise or annoyance to
surrounding properties.
*****
Id. at 72.
B. 3rd Basin’s Proposed Plat Application
[8] 3rd Basin owns 23.63 acres in Steuben County near Crooked Lake
(“Property”), and the Property is zoned Lake Residential. 3rd Basin desires to
subdivide the Property into a thirty-two-lot major subdivision entitled Shores of
Crooked Lake. The lots would share access to the lake through a single access
point, designated as “Common Area A,” together with a large, proposed pier.
Appellants’ App. Vol. II p. 33. Only two of the lots would have direct lake
access. Id. The proposed plat presents a “funneling” configuration in which
lake access for the non-waterfront lots is concentrated to one common access
point.
[9] On March 6, 2025, 3rd Basin filed an application with the Plan Commission for
primary approval of a preliminary subdivision plat. A hearing was held before
the Plan Commission on April 2, 2025. Funneling was a concern raised by
remonstrators. During the hearing, 3rd Basin’s counsel stated:
Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-490 | November 16, 2026 Page 7 of 21
We were advised today that there would be needed a special
exception for the common use dock. We understand that. That
was the first we had heard of it. But that is the part of the
ordinance where all of your anti-funneling provisions are in, and
so those are the criteria upon which that special exception is to be
reviewed. This was never flagged before really earlier as an extra
step, but we’re willing to go through with that.
Id. at 133. Ultimately, at the hearing, the Plan Commission approved the
primary plat on the condition that 3rd Basin obtain a special exception as
required by the Zoning Ordinance. The Plan Commission later issued the
following written findings:
5. The Plat submitted by 3rd Basin, LLC, complies with the
improvement standards of the Steuben County Subdivision
Control Ordinance and there has been no evidence presented that
they are not in compliance.
6. The Petitioners, 3rd Basin, LLC, have consented to a special
exception for a common-use dock.
The Steuben County Plan Commission gives primary plat
approval conditioned upon 3rd Basin, LLC, obtaining a special
exception for a common-use dock.
Id. at 186-88.
[10] In May 2025, 3rd Basin filed its petition for judicial review, challenging the
condition imposed by the Plan Commission. 3rd Basin argued that Indiana
Code Section 36-7-4-702 did not allow the Plan Commission to impose the
special exception condition on the primary plat and that it was prejudiced by
Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-490 | November 16, 2026 Page 8 of 21
the Plan Commission’s decision. Intervenors filed a motion to intervene, which
the trial court granted. Additionally, the trial court took judicial notice of the
Zoning Ordinance and the Subdivision Control Ordinance in existence as of
March 6, 2025.
[11] After briefing and a hearing on 3rd Basin’s petition for judicial review, the trial
court granted the petition. The trial court found:
40. As noted above, the Plan Commission stated in its findings
that 3rd Basin complied with the plat procedures for primary
approval. The Plan Commission further found that the
submitted plat complied with the improvement standards of the
Subdivision Control Ordinance, and that no evidence was
presented that 3rd Basin was not in compliance.
41. The Court agrees with 3rd Basin that the plain reading of IC
§ 36-7-4-702(d) indicates the General Assembly intended to limit
the conditions that may be placed upon a primary plat approval
to the enumerated subsections. “May specify” is construed to
mean that the imposition of a condition is discretionary, but if
the commission chooses to impose a condition, it must fall
within subjections [sic] (1) – (5). The Court finds that the
Respondents’ interpretation of the statute is not reasonable.
42. If the General Assembly intended to allow the commission
to impose any condition not specifically enumerated or found in
other ordinances, it would have used a phrase such as
“reasonable conditions.” As noted by 3rd Basin, the General
Assembly has employed similar language in other statutes. (See
IC § 36-7-4-918.2, IC § 36-7-4-918.4, IC § 36-7-4-1405, and IC §
36-7-4-1512).
Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-490 | November 16, 2026 Page 9 of 21
43. While 3rd Basin may be required to obtain such a special
exception for a common-use dock from the BZA, it is not
authorized at the primary plat approval stage under the specific
provisions of IC § 36-7-4-702(d).
44. In making a finding of 3rd Basin’s compliance, but then
imposing the condition at the primary plat approval stage, the
Plan Commission acted arbitrarily, capriciously, and in excess
of its statutory authority.
45. The Plan Commission had a ministerial duty to review, and
once it found that the plat complied, it had a mandatory duty to
approve.
46. Because the Plan Commission imposed an unauthorized
condition, 3rd Basin’s plat was not granted the primary approval
required for it to proceed to secondary plat approval. As such,
3rd Basin has been prejudiced.
Appellants’ App. Vol. III pp. 198-99 (emphasis in original). The trial court also
found that 3rd Basin did not consent to the special exception requirement. The
trial court remanded with instructions that the Plan Commission “remove from
its findings any reference to: (1) conditioning approval on obtaining a special
exception for the common-use dock; and (2) 3rd Basin’s purported consent to
that condition.” Id. at 202. The Plan Commission and Intervenors now appeal.
Discussion and Decision
I. Standard of Review
[12] The Plan Commission and Intervenors bring this appeal from the trial court’s
grant of judicial review of the Plan Commission’s decision. Indiana Code
Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-490 | November 16, 2026 Page 10 of 21
Section 36-7-4-715(a) provides that the “[p]rimary approval or disapproval of a
plat” and the “[i]mposition of a condition on primary approval of a plat” are
“final decisions of the plan commission that may be reviewed as provided by”
Indiana Code Section 36-7-4-1016. Such final decisions of a plan commission
under the subdivision control statutes are subject to judicial review “in the same
manner as that provided for the appeal of a final decision of the board of zoning
appeals[.]” Ind. Code § 36-7-4-1016.
[13] The appeal of a decision of a board of zoning appeals is subject to Indiana Code
Section 36-7-4-1614(d), which provides:
The court shall grant relief under section 1615 of this chapter
only if the court determines that a person seeking judicial relief
has been prejudiced by a zoning decision that is:
(1) arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not
in accordance with law;
(2) contrary to constitutional right, power, privilege, or
immunity;
(3) in excess of statutory jurisdiction, authority, or limitations, or
short of statutory right;
(4) without observance of procedure required by law; or
(5) unsupported by substantial evidence.
Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-490 | November 16, 2026 Page 11 of 21
3rd Basin had the “burden of demonstrating the invalidity of [the Plan
Commission] decision[.]” Ind. Code § 36-7-4-1614(a).
[14] The trial court and this Court both review the Plan Commission’s decision with
the same standard of review. St. Charles Tower, Inc. v. Bd. of Zoning Appeals of
Evansville-Vanderburgh Cnty., 873 N.E.2d 598, 600 (Ind. 2007). “For questions
of fact, we uphold agency findings that are supported by substantial evidence.”
Noblesville, Indiana Bd. of Zoning Appeals v. FMG Indianapolis, LLC, 217 N.E.3d
510, 513 (Ind. 2023). “For mixed questions of law and fact, we review agency
conclusions for their reasonableness.” Id. “And for questions of law, we decide
independently whether the agency action is contrary to law, including whether
the agency ‘stayed within its jurisdiction and conformed to the statutory
standards and legal principles involved in producing its decision, ruling, or
order.’” Id. (quoting Ind. Off. of Util. Consumer Couns. v. S. Ind. Gas & Elec. Co.,
200 N.E.3d 915, 918 (Ind. 2023)).
[15] The issues presented here require this Court to interpret the relevant statutes
and ordinances. “[W]e do not defer to agency decisions on legal questions,”
and we review the relevant statutes and ordinances de novo. Id. at 514. We use
the same methodology to interpret ordinances as we do to interpret statutes.
Siwinski v. Town of Ogden Dunes, 949 N.E.2d 825, 828 (Ind. 2011). “The first
step in statutory interpretation is determining if the legislature has spoken
clearly and unambiguously on the point in question.” Id. “‘When those words
are clear and unambiguous, we simply apply their plain meaning, without
resorting to other canons of statutory construction.’” Willow Haven on 106th St.,
Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-490 | November 16, 2026 Page 12 of 21
LLC v. Nagireddy, 252 N.E.3d 418, 425 (Ind. 2025) (quoting Ind. Right to Life
Victory Fund v. Morales, 217 N.E.3d 517, 524 (Ind. 2023)). “If possible, every
word must be given effect and meaning, and no part should be held to be
meaningless if it can be reconciled with the rest of the ordinance [or statute].”
Siwinski, 949 N.E.2d at 828. “[I]f a statute contains ambiguity that allows for
more than one interpretation, it opens itself up to judicial construction to effect
the legislative intent.” Id.
II. The trial court erred by granting 3rd Basin’s petition for judicial
review.
A. The Plan Commission’s Order implicates the common use lake
access provisions of the Zoning Ordinance.
[16] Before addressing the parties’ arguments, we must address a point of contention
in the parties’ briefing. The Plan Commission gave “primary plat approval
conditioned upon 3rd Basin, LLC, obtaining a special exception for a common-
use dock.” Appellants’ App. Vol. II p. 188 (emphasis added). The Zoning
Ordinance, however, requires special exception approval of “common use
riparian/lake access lots” in Lake Residential Zoning Districts and does not
specifically mention common use docks. Appellants’ App. Vol. III pp. 70-72.
3rd Basin argues that only the Department of Natural Resources can regulate a
common use dock and contends that the anti-funneling provision is inapplicable
here because the common use lake access lot provision was not mentioned in
the Plan Commission’s order.
Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-490 | November 16, 2026 Page 13 of 21
[17] The Plan Commission argues that 3rd Basin’s argument is “simply form over
substance,” and we agree. Appellants’ Reply Br. p. 30. The intent of the
special exception requirement and Section 9.10(b) of the Zoning Ordinance is to
“discourage the funneling of lake access for multiple residences through narrow
access points[.]” Appellants’ App. Vol. III p. 72. The provision applies to
lakefront developments, including lakefront access points, lakefront recreational
areas, beaches, parks, and playgrounds, that have been designated as a common
area or access point. During the hearing before the Plan Commission, concerns
about funneling, lake access, and the common use dock were specifically raised.
The entire disagreement regarding the proposed subdivision focused on
Common Area A funneling the lake access for multiple residences through one
access point.
[18] 3rd Basin’s primary plat shows Common Area A as providing the only
lakefront access to almost all of the lots in the proposed subdivision with a
single common dock attached to Common Area A serving the lots. Although
the order refers to a special exception for a common use dock, the parties were
well aware that the anti-funneling provision of the Zoning Ordinance was at the
heart of the issue. Accordingly, we focus our attention on the common use lake
access provision of Section 9.10(b) of the Zoning Ordinance.
B. Consideration of the special exception is required under Indiana
Code Section 36-7-4-702.
[19] The dispute here centers on the timing of BZA approval of a special exception.
The Plan Commission granted 3rd Basin’s primary plat on the condition that it
Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-490 | November 16, 2026 Page 14 of 21
obtain a special exception from the BZA regarding the common use lake access
provision of Section 9.10(b) of the Zoning Ordinance. 3rd Basin concedes that
“[t]he anti-funneling provisions and the special exception they require come
into play later on in the process, not as a condition of primary approval.”
Appellee’s Br. p. 23. Accordingly, 3rd Basin concedes that the special
exception requirement is applicable later in the process; 3rd Basin merely argues
that the special exception was not required for the primary plat approval. We
disagree.
[20] Under Indiana Code Section 36-7-4-701, the Plan Commission “has exclusive
control” over the approval of plats within its jurisdiction. The parties’
arguments here focus on Indiana Code Section 36-7-4-702, which governs the
Plan Commission’s consideration of primary approval of plats and provides:
(a) In determining whether to grant primary approval of a plat,
the plan commission (or plat committee acting on the
commission’s behalf) shall determine if the plat or subdivision
qualifies for primary approval under the standards prescribed by
the subdivision control ordinance.
(b) The subdivision control ordinance must specify the standards
for determining whether a plat qualifies for primary approval.
The ordinance must include standards for:
(1) minimum width, depth, and area of lots in the
subdivision;
Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-490 | November 16, 2026 Page 15 of 21
(2) public way widths, grades, curves, and the
coordination of subdivision public ways with current and
planned public ways; and
(3) the extension of water, sewer, and other municipal
services.
The ordinance may also include standards for the
allocation of areas to be used as public ways, parks,
schools, public and semipublic buildings, homes,
businesses, and utilities, and any other standards related to
the purposes of this chapter.
(c) The standards fixed in the subdivision control ordinance
under subsection (b) may be waived at the discretion of the plan
commission (or plat committee acting on the commission’s
behalf); however, to be approved, the plat must still meet all
applicable standards prescribed in the zoning ordinance (other
than standards modified by variance in accordance with the 900
series of this chapter). As a condition of granting a waiver under
this subsection, the commission or committee may allow or
require a commitment to be made under section 1015 of this
chapter.
(d) As a condition of primary approval of a plat, the commission
or committee may specify:
(1) the manner in which public ways shall be laid out,
graded, and improved;
(2) a provision for water, sewage, and other utility services;
(3) a provision for lot size, number, and location;
Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-490 | November 16, 2026 Page 16 of 21
(4) a provision for drainage design; and
(5) a provision for other services as specified in the
subdivision control ordinance.
[21] The parties focus their arguments exclusively on Indiana Code Section 36-7-4-
702(d). 3rd Basin argues that the special exception is not an allowable
condition under Indiana Code Section 36-7-4-702(d), while the Plan
Commission argues that the language of Subsection (d) does not limit
conditions to the list in Subsection (d)(1)-(5). Inexplicably, however, the parties
do not mention Indiana Code Section 36-7-4-702(c) (“Subsection (c)”), which
we conclude resolves the issue here. Accordingly, we need not address the
parties’ arguments regarding Indiana Code Section 36-7-4-702(d).
[22] Indiana Code Section 36-7-4-702 specifically applies to the primary plat
approval process. Subsection (a) of the statute requires the Plan Commission to
determine if the plat “qualifies for primary approval under the standards
prescribed by the subdivision control ordinance.” Subsection (b) specifies the
standards that the subdivision control ordinance must include and also notes
other standards that may be included. Subsection (c) then addresses the waiver
of standards from the subdivision control ordinance and provides:
The standards fixed in the subdivision control ordinance under
subsection (b) may be waived at the discretion of the plan
commission (or plat committee acting on the commission’s
behalf); however, to be approved, the plat must still meet all
applicable standards prescribed in the zoning ordinance (other
than standards modified by variance in accordance with the
Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-490 | November 16, 2026 Page 17 of 21
900 series of this chapter). As a condition of granting a waiver
under this subsection, the commission or committee may allow
or require a commitment to be made under section 1015 of this
chapter.
(emphasis added). Accordingly, the Plan Commission may waive subdivision
control ordinance standards, but the Plan Commission may not waive zoning
standards, other than standards already modified by variance. The statute,
thus, unambiguously presupposes that the zoning standards have already been
met when the primary plat approval is submitted.
[23] Consistent with Subsection (c), the Subdivision Control Ordinance at issue here
provides that “all subdivision plats shall comply with” all applicable state and
local statutory provisions and “[t]he County Zoning Ordinance.” Appellants’
App. Vol. III p. 109 (emphasis added). The Zoning Ordinance required a
special exception for common use lake access lots, like Common Area A at
issue here. Accordingly, 3rd Basin was required to have a special exception to
meet the Zoning Ordinance standards prior to primary approval of its plat. See,
e.g., LBL Dev., LLC v. St. John Plan Comm’n, Town of St. John, 224 N.E.3d 947,
953 (Ind. Ct. App. 2023) (noting in a case involving primary approval that the
plan commission is “responsible for determining whether proposed subdivision
plats comply with the technical requirements of that zoning”), trans. denied.
[24] Although the Plan Commission would have been within its authority to simply
deny or table 3rd Basin’s primary plat application due to the failure to have a
special exception, the Plan Commission instead conditioned its approval on 3rd
Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-490 | November 16, 2026 Page 18 of 21
Basin obtaining the special exception. The Plan Commission merely required
3rd Basin to perform a step that 3rd Basin was already required to do. Given
the requirements of Subsection (c), we conclude that the Plan Commission’s
decision was not arbitrary or capricious, in excess of its statutory authority, or
unsupported by substantial evidence. The trial court, accordingly, erred by
granting 3rd Basin’s petition for judicial review.
C. 3rd Basin was not prejudiced by the Plan Commission’s decision.
[25] Alternatively, even if Subsection (c) did not require 3rd Basin to satisfy the
special exception prior to requesting primary plat approval, we conclude that
3rd Basin cannot show that it was prejudiced by the Plan Commission’s
decision. Indiana Code Section 36-7-4-1614(d) required 3rd Basin to
demonstrate that it was “prejudiced” by the Plan Commission’s decision.
[26] The Subdivision Control Ordinance required that the secondary plat approval
request must “[t]otally comply with the Ordinance and terms and conditions of
primary approval.” Appellants’ App. Vol. III p. 62. Compliance with the
Subdivision Control Ordinance requires compliance with the Zoning
Ordinance, including the common use lake access provision and the need for a
special exception. It is clear that secondary approval of the plat could not be
granted until 3rd Basin obtained the special exception. The Plan Commission’s
conditional approval merely imposed a condition that 3rd Basin was already
required to meet.
Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-490 | November 16, 2026 Page 19 of 21
[27] 3rd Basin argues that it was prejudiced because the special exception condition
“discounts the possibility that 3rd Basin may proceed with its approval without
a common-use dock.” Appellee’s Br. p. 40. 3rd Basin, thus, contends that it
could remove the dock, eliminate the need for the special exception, and
proceed with secondary plat approval. We do not find support for 3rd Basin’s
argument in the Zoning Ordinance. As we have noted, the concern with the
common dock related to Section 9.10(b), which addresses funneling concerns
and required a special exception for common use lake access lots. Section
9.10(b) applies to lakefront development areas, including lakefront access
points, like Common Area A. Even if 3rd Basin removed the dock, Common
Area A remains and would require a special exception.
[28] Under these circumstances, we cannot ascertain how 3rd Basin was prejudiced
by the conditional approval of its primary plat. Regardless of the timing, 3rd
Basin was required to obtain a special exception before requesting secondary
approval of its plat. Accordingly, we conclude that the trial court erred when it
determined that 3rd Basin was prejudiced and erred by granting 3rd Basin’s
petition for judicial review.
Conclusion
[29] The trial court erred by granting 3rd Basin’s petition for judicial review.
Accordingly, we reverse.
[30] Reversed.
Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-490 | November 16, 2026 Page 20 of 21
Bradford, J., and Felix, J., concur.
ATTORNEYS FOR APPELLANTS
Robert W. Eherenman
Hannah L. Alderks
HallerColvin PC
Fort Wayne, Indiana
Donald J. Stuckey
Auburn, Indiana
ATTORNEYS FOR APPELLEE
Patrick R. Hess
Brian C. Heck
Caleb R. Patterson
Beckman Lawson, LLP
Fort Wayne, Indiana
Court of Appeals of Indiana | Opinion 26A-PL-490 | November 16, 2026 Page 21 of 21