In re Parentage of E.H.
CourtAppellate Court of Illinois
Date FiledNovember 16, 2026
Docket5-26-0484
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
NOTICE
2026 IL App (5th) 260484-U
NOTICE
Decision filed 11/16/26. The
This order was filed under
text of this decision may be NO. 5-26-0484 Supreme Court Rule 23 and is
changed or corrected prior to
not precedent except in the
the filing of a Petition for IN THE limited circumstances allowed
Rehearing or the disposition of
under Rule 23(e)(1).
the same.
APPELLATE COURT OF ILLINOIS
FIFTH DISTRICT
______________________________________________________________________________
In re PARENTAGE OF E.H., a Minor ) Appeal from the
) Circuit Court of
(Shawn P. Harvey, ) Champaign County.
)
Petitioner-Appellee, )
)
v. ) No. 22-FA-268
)
Audrey C. Durrant, ) Honorable
) Chad S. Beckett,
Respondent-Appellant). ) Judge, presiding.
______________________________________________________________________________
JUSTICE HACKETT delivered the judgment of the court.
Justice Clarke concurred in the judgment.
Justice Sholar dissented.
ORDER
¶1 Held: We affirm the order of the circuit court denying the mother’s petition to relocate
and allocating the majority of parenting time to the father where mother did not
sustain her burden of proving that the proposed relocation was in the best interest
of the child.
¶2 The petitioner, Shawn P. Harvey (Father), and the respondent, Audrey C. Durrant
(Mother), are the parents of one child, E.H. Mother appeals an order of the circuit court of
Champaign County denying her petition to relocate to Canada with the child and allocating the
1
majority of parenting time to Father. She argues that both rulings were against the manifest weight
of the evidence. We affirm. 1
¶3 I. BACKGROUND
¶4 Mother and Father were involved in a long-term relationship but never married. Their son,
E.H., was born in October 2015. During the course of their relationship, the parties moved several
times due to Mother’s job opportunities as a pediatric surgeon. Their relationship ended in late
2020 or early 2021. At that time, the parties were living in Tampa, Florida. In February 2021 Father
filed a petition to establish paternity and for allocation of parental responsibility and parenting
time with a Florida court. In March 2022 while Father’s petition remained pending, Mother sought
leave to relocate to Illinois with the child because she had received a job offer from a hospital in
Champaign County.
¶5 On October 12, 2022, the Florida court entered a final order finding that the proposed move
to Illinois would be in E.H.’s best interest. The order incorporated a long-distance parenting plan
pursuant to which Mother had 270 overnights with E.H. and Father had 95. It provided that each
parent was entitled to daily communication with the child during the other parent’s parenting time
through telephone, FaceTime, or other electronic means, and the parties were ordered to facilitate
such contact and to keep their contact information current. The parties were to provide each other
with written notice 21 days before traveling internationally with E.H. or 10 days before traveling
out of state with the child. The parenting plan further provided that if Father moved to the
Champaign-Urbana area on or before May 1, 2023, the parties agreed to a 50/50 allocation of
1
This cause involves an accelerated appeal under Illinois Supreme Court Rule 311(a) (eff. July 1,
2018). Under Rule 311(a)(5), the appellate court is required to issue a decision within 150 days after
the filing of a notice of appeal, except for good cause shown. Ill. S. Ct. R. 311(a)(5) (eff. July 1, 2018). Our
decision in this case was due on or before October 19, 2026. However, we granted the appellant’s requests
for two extensions of time to file her brief, and the case involves complex issues. Under these circumstances,
we find that good cause exists to issue our disposition outside the 150-day deadline.
2
parenting time. The order further provided that if Father moved to Champaign-Urbana after that
date, he would not be required to show a change in circumstances to request a modification of
parenting time, and the “presumptive” allocation would be equal.
¶6 A. Initial Proceedings in Illinois
¶7 On October 24, 2022, Mother filed with the Champaign County circuit court a petition to
enroll foreign judgment for purposes of enforcement or modification. She requested “full custodial
rights” to E.H. Initially, Father filed a motion to dismiss Mother’s petition, arguing that the Florida
parenting order was not a final judgment because the Florida court reserved jurisdiction to
determine certain issues. However, in March 2023 Father moved to Champaign County and filed
a motion for leave to withdraw his motion to dismiss, acknowledging that Champaign County was
the proper forum in which to litigate the parties’ parenting issues.
¶8 On March 30, 2023, Father filed a petition for adjudication of indirect civil contempt. He
alleged that Mother violated the provisions of the Florida judgment that provided for an equal
division of parenting time in the event Father moved to Champaign and daily electronic
communication between Father and the child during Mother’s parenting time.
¶9 At an April 27, 2023, hearing, the circuit court granted Mother’s motion to enroll the
Florida judgment without objection. The court subsequently entered an agreed order registering
the Florida judgment on May 15, 2023.
¶ 10 On June 2, 2023, Mother filed a petition to modify parenting time. She alleged that prior
to moving to Illinois, Father lived in Texas and refused to provide her with his address or tell her
where E.H. would reside during Father’s parenting time. She further alleged that Father often
disparaged her in E.H.’s presence and was unable to control his anger.
3
¶ 11 The circuit court held a hearing over two days on June 2 and 3, 2023. In a docket sheet
entry, the court found that Mother violated the Florida parenting order, as enrolled in the Illinois
court, and that her violations were willful and contumacious. The court ordered each parent to
facilitate electronic communication with the other parent each night at 7:00 p.m. and to encourage
the child to participate. The court further ordered both parties to refrain from disparaging each
other and “to confine their communications strictly to those necessary to carry out the orders of
the court.” The court ordered the parties to enroll E.H. in Champaign public schools for the 2023-
2024 school year and set forth an interim parenting time schedule.
¶ 12 On August 11, 2023, the court held a hearing on temporary allocation of parenting time.
The record does not contain a transcript or bystander’s report of the hearing. The circuit court
found that the parties should share parenting time and parental responsibilities equally on a
temporary basis. The court set forth a temporary parenting time schedule in a docket entry, which
also provided that both parties were to exercise all parenting time within Champaign County “until
further order.” The court ordered the parties to use the Talking Parents app for all non-emergency
communications. The court entered a written order on temporary parenting time incorporating
these provisions on September 5, 2023.
¶ 13 On November 17, 2023, the circuit court appointed William Culp as a limited guardian
ad litem (LGAL) for E.H. Specifically, the court found that it would be in E.H.’s best interest for
the LGAL to interview the parties and the child “and conduct such other investigation as
appropriate” to determine “the child’s perspective” as to the statutory best interest factors in
4
sections 602.5(c) and 602.7(b) of the Illinois Marriage and Dissolution of Marriage Act (750 ILCS
5/602.5(c), 602.7(b) (West 2022)). 2
¶ 14 On January 3, 2024, Mother filed a petition for adjudication of indirect civil contempt
alleging that Father traveled to Texas with E.H. on December 23, 2023, in violation of the
requirement that he exercise parenting time in Champaign County, and he had not returned to
Illinois as of the date she filed the petition. Mother further alleged that Father refused to allow her
to exercise her parenting time that was scheduled for the periods of December 25 to 27, 2023, and
December 29, 2023, to January 3, 2024. There is no indication in the record of how this petition
was resolved.
¶ 15 B. Modifications of Parenting Time in 2024
¶ 16 On February 20, 2024, Mother filed a petition for a finding of serious endangerment and
to restrict Father’s parenting time. She alleged that Father picked E.H. up from school on February
15 and drove with the child while “intoxicated and significantly impaired.” During the drive home,
Father was involved in a motor vehicle accident. He struck another vehicle, then passed out in his
own vehicle with E.H. still in the car. Mother further alleged that when she arrived at the scene to
retrieve her child, she witnessed Father resisting arrest and being verbally abusive to the
responding officers.
¶ 17 The matter was set for a March 19, 2024, hearing. Father requested a continuance, alleging
that he would be in an inpatient substance abuse treatment program in Ohio at the time and would
not be able to leave to attend the hearing. At the March 19 hearing, the circuit court continued the
Specifically, the court cited section 605.5(c)(1), (2), (3), (4), (8), (12), (13), and (15), and section
2
602.7(b)(2), (3), (5), (6), (7), (8), (11), (14), and (17). Those factors relate to the allocation of parenting
time and parental responsibility for decision-making. See 750 ILCS 5/602.5(c), 602.7(b) (West 2022).
5
matter over Mother’s objection and entered an order suspending Father’s parenting time and
allocating all parenting time to Mother on a temporary basis.
¶ 18 On June 4, 2024, Father filed a motion to vacate the March 2024 order suspending his
parenting time and to modify the September 2023 temporary parenting order. He alleged that he
successfully completed inpatient treatment for his substance abuse issues between March 4 and
May 10, 2024. He further alleged that he was then working in Indiana as a sound technician on a
one-week-on, one-week-off basis. He requested parenting time be allocated equally on an
alternating weekly basis.
¶ 19 On August 8, 2024, the circuit court held a hearing on Mother’s motion for a finding of
serious endangerment and to restrict Father’s parenting time and Father’s motion to modify the
previous parenting order. Several witnesses testified about the motor vehicle accident that occurred
on February 15, 2024. Anne Odom, whose car was rear-ended by Father, testified that after her car
was struck, she went to talk to the other driver, who did not respond. The back window opened
“and a small child leaned out and said, ‘My dad’s not okay and he hasn’t been okay for like the
last week and I don’t know what’s wrong.’ ” Odom identified Father as the driver. She testified
that he never spoke to her and appeared to have lost consciousness. However, when he was
subsequently taken from his vehicle to the ambulance, Odom heard him screaming. According to
Odom, there was minimal damage to both vehicles, and neither she nor the child were injured in
the accident.
¶ 20 Deputy Kyle Selleck and Deputy Derek Rasmussen, who responded to the accident, also
testified. Both deputies observed indications that Father was intoxicated, such as slurred speech,
lethargy, and bloodshot, glassy eyes. Deputy Rasmussen also smelled alcohol on Father’s breath.
According to Deputy Selleck, E.H. reported that his father had been “loopy” and “sick” over the
6
last few weeks before the accident. He confirmed Odom’s testimony that no injuries resulted from
the accident. Deputy Rasmussen stated that Father was “very belligerent” when he was carried to
an ambulance. As a result, Deputy Rasmussen rode in the ambulance at the request of staff. He
later learned that Father’s blood alcohol content (BAC) was .39 when his blood was drawn at the
hospital. He noted that the legal limit is .08. Emergency room treatment records were admitted
into evidence without objection. The records confirmed that Father’s BAC was .392.
¶ 21 Mother testified that E.H. told her Father “had been acting loopy” for a few weeks before
the accident. Asked about E.H.’s emotional response to the accident, Mother testified that he was
scared and “was concerned about his father.” In addition, E.H. was “somewhat clingier than
normal” the day of the accident.
¶ 22 Father testified that he attended an inpatient substance abuse program from early March to
mid-May of 2024 and that, as of the time of the hearing, he attended weekly Alcoholics
Anonymous (AA) meetings in Champaign on Saturdays. Father further testified that a breathalyzer
device with an ignition lock had been installed in his vehicle the previous month. He was willing
to submit to additional alcohol monitoring as a condition of exercising parenting time.
¶ 23 During a recess, the parties came to an agreement regarding temporary parenting time.
They agreed that Father would have parenting time on two Saturdays in August, and that,
beginning on September 7, 2024, Father would have parenting time on alternating weekends from
11:00 a.m. on Saturday to 5:00 p.m. on Sunday. They further agreed that Father was not to consume
alcohol during his parenting time or during the 12 hours before his parenting time began. He would
be subject to one alcohol test one hour before his parenting time was to begin, and Mother would
be permitted to request one additional test during each weekend. The circuit court found this
agreement to be fair and in the child’s best interest.
7
¶ 24 The circuit court entered a written modified temporary parenting time order on October 16,
2024, incorporating the parties’ agreed terms. The order required Father to sign up for alcohol
testing and monitoring through the BACtrack program and to list Mother as a monitor with full
access to his compliance. The order further provided that any positive results would lead to
Father’s parenting time being terminated.
¶ 25 On November 27, 2024, the circuit court entered a second modified temporary parenting
time order expanding Father’s parenting time to alternating weekends from Friday at 6:00 p.m. to
Sunday at 5:00 p.m. The order maintained the requirements that Father abstain from alcohol and
submit to breathalyzer tests.
¶ 26 Also on November 27, 2024, Father filed a petition for parenting time abuse by Mother.
He alleged that Mother refused to allow his scheduled parenting time on the weekend of November
22, 2024. He requested a finding of contempt, sanctions, and make-up parenting time. On the same
date, Father filed a petition seeking holiday parenting time.
¶ 27 On December 9, 2024, the circuit court held a hearing on Father’s petitions. The court
denied the petition for parenting time abuse, finding that the allegations therein were not proven.
In a docket entry, the court set forth a schedule of holiday parenting time. A written holiday
parenting time order was entered on December 27, 2024.
¶ 28 C. LGAL Report, Father’s Petition to Modify the November 2024 Order
¶ 29 On December 30, 2024, Mother filed an emergency petition for adjudication of civil
contempt. She alleged that she arrived late to pick the child up from parenting time with Father
due to a misunderstanding and that Father then refused to return the child to her.
¶ 30 On January 6, 2025, Mother notified Father of her intent to relocate to the New York City
area due to a job offer. On January 10, 2025, she filed a petition for temporary and permanent
8
relocation. She alleged that (1) she had been unemployed since July 30, 2024; (2) she had been
unable to find employment as a pediatric surgeon in Champaign; (3) she had an offer of a job in
New York that would begin on January 31, 2025; (4) neither party was employed in Illinois;
(5) neither party had family members or other significant ties to the Champaign area; and (6) the
New York metropolitan area offered E.H. better educational opportunities, more cultural and
extracurricular activities, and more racial diversity than the Champaign area. 3
¶ 31 On February 18, 2025, the LGAL filed a three-page report with the court. In describing his
investigation, the LGAL noted that he conducted two interviews with E.H. in December of 2023,
one in the presence of each parent, and observed E.H. with each parent in January 2024. In
addition, he reviewed the court records, the police report from Father’s arrest for driving under the
influence (DUI), and correspondence from White Light Behavioral Health, where Father
underwent inpatient treatment for alcohol abuse.
¶ 32 The LGAL described E.H. as a “bright and curious” child. He stated that E.H. “clearly
views [Mother] as a devoted mother,” and his time with her “is enriching and he does well in
school while in her care.” The LGAL noted, however, that E.H. seemed “more relaxed and
expressive” when he was with Father and that he “may not be as open” with Mother. E.H. told the
LGAL that he loved both his parents and enjoyed spending time with both of them. The LGAL
opined that E.H. would adjust well to the proposed relocation to New York City. He recommended
that, if the court allowed Mother to relocate, E.H. should spend as much time as possible with
Father during school breaks.
¶ 33 Mother withdrew her petition for temporary and permanent relocation at a status hearing
on April 3, 2025. The matter came for a hearing on all pending temporary parenting issues on April
3
Mother is black and Father is white.
9
9 and 10, 2025. The court first inquired about the status of Mother’s December 2024 contempt
petition. Mother’s counsel informed the court that Mother was no longer requesting a finding of
contempt because Father had returned the child to her. Counsel noted, however, that he would
present evidence concerning the allegations of the contempt petition during the hearing and that
Mother may be entitled to attorney fees as a result.
¶ 34 Father was called as a witness by Mother. He testified that he worked for Markey’s Audio
Visual, which was based in Indianapolis. However, as of November 2024 he no longer worked at
Markey’s warehouse in Indianapolis. Instead, he had been taking “traveling gigs.” Father
explained that this meant he traveled to work at events throughout the country. He testified that,
in addition, he would “be working with the Local 482 Stagehand Union here in Champaign.”
¶ 35 When asked about the DUI accident that occurred in February of 2024, Father
acknowledged that he had “too much” to drink before picking E.H. up from school that day. Father
recalled that he drank whiskey, but he did not remember how many drinks he had. He also could
not recall whether he recognized at the time that he was impaired.
¶ 36 Father testified that at the time of the hearing, he attended multiple AA meetings at two
different locations in Champaign. However, he did not see a professional substance abuse
counselor “any longer.”
¶ 37 Next, Father testified about the BACtrack testing required of him under the parenting order
then in effect. He stated that Mother requested an additional test every Saturday whether it was his
parenting time or not. He further testified that neither the BACtrack device nor the breathalyzer
device in his vehicle had yielded a positive result for alcohol use.
¶ 38 Mother testified that she is a pediatric surgeon. At the time of the hearing, she worked for
Harlem Hospital in New York on a per diem basis, having begun her employment there in February
10
of 2025. She explained that she worked there in person while E.H. was with Father over his spring
break and otherwise worked remotely performing chart reviews. In addition, Mother did “locum”
work for various agencies. She explained that locum work involved working as a “visiting
surgeon” as needed for different hospitals. Previously, she worked for the Judge Group from May
to December of 2024, conducting physical examinations for physicians seeking Veterans
Administration insurance. Before that, Mother was employed as a pediatric surgeon at Carle
Hospital from June 2022 to July 2023.
¶ 39 Mother testified that Father called E.H. every night during her parenting time, and she did
nothing to prevent them from talking to each other. She did not call E.H. during Father’s parenting
time.
¶ 40 Next, Mother testified about the events described in her December 2024 contempt petition.
She noted that, pursuant to court order, Father had parenting time from December 27 through
December 29, 2024, but there was a misunderstanding about the time she was to pick E.H. up on
December 29. She explained that, under a holiday parenting time order, Father’s parenting time
ended at 6:00 p.m., while the general temporary parenting time order provided for Father’s
weekend parenting time to end at 5:00 p.m. Mother mistakenly believed that the holiday order was
still in effect, providing for a 6:00 p.m. exchange, but in fact, they had reverted to the previous
schedule, which provided for a 5:00 p.m. exchange. She testified that when she attempted to pick
up E.H. on December 29, Father informed her that he had gone to the park where exchanges
normally took place at 5:00 p.m. and that, because she did not show up, he brought E.H. back to
his house. Mother acknowledged that she was the one who had made a mistake. As such, she
decided to wait until the following day to pick E.H. up rather than involve the police. However,
11
when she attempted to pick up E.H. on December 30, Father refused to answer the door or send
E.H. out of the house.
¶ 41 When Mother filed her contempt petition on December 30, 2024, Father still had not
returned E.H. to her. Asked when Father returned the child, Mother testified, “I believe I got him
back at school the next day. I picked him up from his after-school program.”
¶ 42 Mother’s counsel asked if Mother ever denied Father parenting time. She replied, “Only
when he was noncompliant with the blowing into the BACtrack one hour prior to parenting time.”
She noted that Father failed to comply with this requirement two or three times. However, on one
occasion, he later completed the test, and she allowed him to have parenting time. Mother testified
that she did not refuse to allow Father parenting time on any other occasions.
¶ 43 When asked if she still had concerns about Father’s alcohol abuse, Mother replied, “He
seems to have that in control. And I’d like to believe that it will continue.” She confirmed that all
BACtrack results to date had been negative. Mother was concerned, however, about conduct
captured on videos recorded when Father submitted to BACtrack testing. She explained that the
video recordings showed Father cursing at her and giving her the finger. She testified, “That is a
lot of venom to be directed at the mother of your child.” Mother was concerned that E.H. was
being exposed to bad language.
¶ 44 On cross-examination, Mother testified that she suffered from epilepsy and was on
medication for the condition. She noted that her first epileptic seizure occurred in 2001 after she
was struck by a vehicle as a pedestrian. Mother explained that the type of seizures she suffered
were “absence” seizures, which lasted approximately three or four seconds. She described them as
causing her to essentially black out while awake.
12
¶ 45 Mother was asked about a motor vehicle accident that occurred on February 9, 2025, while
she was driving home from New York with E.H. The accident occurred on the highway near
Indianapolis. Mother testified that it happened toward the end of a long drive, and she was tired.
The drive takes approximately 16 to 18 hours, and Mother made the drive in one day, with stops
to recharge her electric vehicle and take naps. According to Mother, she lost control of her vehicle
when she hit black ice. The vehicle left the road and struck a tree. Asked if she fell asleep at the
wheel, Mother acknowledged, “It’s possible.” She denied that she had a seizure.
¶ 46 Mother testified that she had a driver’s license, but she acknowledged that she did not have
a car. She explained that at the time of the accident, her intent was to move to New York City,
where having a car would not be beneficial. Father’s counsel showed Mother Petitioner’s Exhibit
8, which she identified as a disclosure form from the Illinois Secretary of State for drivers to
identify conditions affecting their ability to drive. Reading the form, Mother noted that one of the
conditions on the form was seizures. She acknowledged that she never completed and submitted
this form, noting that she had never seen it before.
¶ 47 Mother testified that on December 3, 2024, a judgment of foreclosure had been entered
against her involving her home in Champaign County. Her testimony concerning the status of the
home was somewhat confusing. She indicated that the home had been sold, but she stated that the
sheriff’s sale had not occurred. She testified that she was still living in the home and that she
intended to remain there until E.H. completed the current school year. She intended to move once
the school year ended, but she had not decided where. She noted that, at the time, she had two
potential job offers.
¶ 48 Mother further testified that she completed her medical residency in 2012. Since that time,
she had held five full-time positions in addition to performing locum work. She acknowledged that
13
Carle Hospital’s medical executive committee had investigated her for “looking concerningly
hungry” and “walking in socks.” She asserted that Carle Hospital had a history of targeting
physicians of color, noting that the hospital was currently under investigation as a result.
¶ 49 Gregory Renshaw testified on Father’s behalf. Renshaw was Father’s sponsor from AA.
He first met Father in late November or early December of 2024. He explained that, as Father’s
sponsor, he met with Father every other week. Their meetings lasted “at least an hour,” but could
last up to three hours. Renshaw had no doubts about Father’s commitment to remaining sober.
¶ 50 Father’s next witness was his mother, Renee Mallett. Mallett lived in Lakeway, Texas,
which is near Austin. Her other son and his family lived in Buda, Texas, which is also near Austin,
while E.H.’s grandfather lived in Iowa. 4 Mallett noted that Champaign was approximately 1,500
miles away from her home. She testified that Father and Mother “lived all over the place” with
E.H. during their relationship.
¶ 51 Mallett frequently visited Father and Mother while they were together, and she stayed in
their house during these visits. Asked to describe her observations of both parents’ interactions
with E.H., Mallett noted that Father played with E.H. and read him bedtime stories, while Mother
often “stood back” and let Father do most of the household chores and interaction with E.H. She
noted that Mother was around less than Father due to work. Mallett acknowledged that the last
time she saw Mother with E.H. was in May of 2021.
¶ 52 Next, Father testified on his own behalf. Asked where the parties lived over the course of
their relationship, Father stated they initially lived in San Antonio. When E.H. was an infant, they
moved to Edinburg, Texas. Approximately six months to one year later, they moved to Des
Moines, Iowa. According to Father, the family then moved back to Edinburg, where they still
4
Father specified that his father lived in Des Moines.
14
owned a home, when Mother began doing locum work. During this period, Mother traveled for
work most of the time. Father stated that he did not work, and instead cared for E.H. He testified
that the family remained in Edinburg for approximately one and one-half to two years and then
moved to Tampa in 2019 for Mother’s work.
¶ 53 Father next described the seizures Mother experienced. He explained that during a seizure,
Mother’s eyes opened wide and she bit her top lip. According to Father, the seizures lasted “a
minute, minute-and-a-half maybe” and happened often. He asserted that he helped Mother “cover
up the seizure disorder on a multitude of occasions.”
¶ 54 In rebuttal, Mother confirmed that Father did not work from the time E.H. was born until
the parties separated. She testified, however, that E.H. was in daycare full time while they lived in
Edinburg, Texas. Regarding her seizures, Mother noted that before the parties moved to Tampa,
the seizures “were accelerating.” However, the neurologist she saw in Tampa told Mother that the
medications she had been taking were not appropriate for her condition. Mother switched to a
different medication in 2021, and since that time, her seizures had been fully controlled “as far as
[she was] aware.”
¶ 55 Announcing its ruling on Father’s petition to modify parenting time, the circuit court first
addressed the statutory best interest factors for the allocation of parenting time. See 750 ILCS
5/602.7(b) (West 2024)). The court found that most of these factors were neutral or inapplicable.
However, the court discussed two of the factors at length—specifically, the mental and physical
health of all individuals involved (id. § 602.7(b)(7)) and the needs of the child (id. § 602.7(b)(8)).
¶ 56 Regarding the mental and physical health of all individuals involved, the circuit court found
that Father had “anger issues.” The court stated that Father’s anger at Mother sometimes impaired
his judgment. The court likewise found that Mother’s struggles to find a permanent position
15
affected her judgment, noting that “for reasons other than just racism, or lack of being able to find
the right fit, [Mother] simply has not been able to establish herself professionally in one location.”
The circuit court also addressed Mother’s seizure disorder, opining that she still experienced
occasional seizures. Regarding Mother’s February 2025 vehicle accident, the court stated, “I
haven’t heard enough evidence to suggest it was anything other than a bad experience on the—in
icy conditions.”
¶ 57 Addressing the needs of the child, the circuit court found that gainful employment with a
substantial salary for at least one parent would benefit E.H. In addition, the court found that
spending significant time with both of his parents would be in the child’s best interest. The court
further found that E.H. needed stability and noted that moving around as much as the parties had
done made it difficult to provide him with the stability he needed. The court stated, “I think that
his parents, if they don’t find it here, wherever the next place is, it—it better be pretty compelling
testimony that someplace else is gonna provide that stability.”
¶ 58 The circuit court denied Father’s petition to modify its November 2024 temporary
parenting order. The court indicated it would give Father the majority of summer parenting time
while E.H. was out of school, but it would otherwise maintain the existing schedule of alternating
weekends. The court found that no restriction on parenting time was necessary as the evidence
showed that Father was remaining sober. However, the court indicated that it would continue to
require BACtrack testing as a condition. The court subsequently set forth these provisions in a
written third modified temporary parenting order in July 2025.
¶ 59 D. Mother’s Move to Canada, Modification of Temporary Parenting
¶ 60 On June 23, 2025, Father filed an emergency petition for a temporary restraining order
(TRO), alleging that he observed Mother and E.H. at the airport early that morning with Mother’s
16
boyfriend and her dog. He further alleged that Mother sold her home on June 9 and that he believed
she was seeking to “leave this jurisdiction” and go to Canada with the child. He requested a TRO
prohibiting Mother from leaving Champaign County and ordering her to appear in court with the
parties’ child the next day. The following day, the circuit court denied the emergency petition,
finding that because Mother appeared to have already left Champaign County, it was not possible
for the court to grant the specific relief requested. At a July 17, 2025, status hearing, Father’s
counsel informed the court that E.H. had been returned to Father in Champaign County on July 6,
2025.
¶ 61 On July 18, 2025, Father filed a petition for adjudication of indirect civil contempt,
parenting time abuse, and restriction of parental responsibilities. He alleged that Mother violated
the terms of the Florida parentage judgment, as enrolled in Illinois, by (1) failing to provide him
with a new address after selling her home on June 9, 2025; (2) traveling outside the United States
to Canada with E.H. from June 23 to July 6, 2025, without providing him with an itinerary or a
location where E.H. could be reached; and (3) failing to allow Father to have telephone contact
with E.H. between June 23 and July 5, 2025. Father further alleged that Mother failed to provide
him with parenting time the weekend of April 25 to April 27, 2025, as scheduled. He argued that
these actions created a risk of serious endangerment justifying a suspension of Mother’s parenting
time.
¶ 62 On July 30, 2025, Father filed a petition to modify the third modified parenting time order.
He alleged that Mother had moved with E.H. to Etobicoke, Ontario, Canada. Father requested that
the court allocate the majority of parenting time to him. Although the timing is not clear from
Father’s pleadings, Mother later testified that she moved to Ontario in June 2025 after her
Champaign County home was sold.
17
¶ 63 On August 1, 2025, Mother’s attorney was allowed to withdraw as counsel with Mother’s
agreement. On August 19, 2025, the matter came for a status hearing. Mother appeared remotely
via the Zoom video conferencing platform. The court allowed Mother 21 days to retain counsel or
enter her appearance pro se. The court ordered that the child “remain in Champaign County until
further order of the court.”
¶ 64 The matter proceeded to a hearing on Father’s motions on September 9, 2025. At the outset,
Mother entered her appearance as a pro se litigant.
¶ 65 Father testified that E.H. was then in fourth grade at Westview Elementary School, the
same school he had attended for the past three years. Father stated that he planned to stay in
Champaign “for as long as it takes for [E.H.] to, to grow up and graduate here.”
¶ 66 At the time of the hearing, Father worked for the stagehand union, Local 482, through the
local university. He explained that through an agreement between the union and the university, he
worked at the university, which paid the union for his services, and the union paid Father. In
addition, he continued to work for Markey’s, which was based in Indianapolis. However, Father
no longer worked at the company’s Indianapolis location. He traveled to work at events for
Markey’s approximately every other month. He noted that his mother came to Champaign to care
for E.H. when he traveled for work.
¶ 67 Father acknowledged that he was then on probation for DUI, which would continue until
November 2026. He testified that he had a restricted driving permit that allowed him to drive from
7:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m. Sunday through Friday. He was also required to use a breath-testing device
installed in his vehicle.
¶ 68 Mother testified about her decision to move to Canada. She stated that she was living with
her mother in Etobicoke, Ontario, a suburb of Toronto where she grew up. Mother testified that
18
under the current political climate, the United States did not feel welcoming to people of color,
“especially a male child of color” like E.H. She stated, “I did what many people do when they find
themselves in times of trouble, they go home.” Explaining why she believed moving to Canada
would be in E.H.’s best interest, Mother stated that she did not feel the same burden of racism
growing up in Canada that she felt in the United States, and she wanted E.H. to have the same
freedom. She further testified that Canadian children do better than children in the United States
in terms of “academic placement” and that university tuition is less expensive there.
¶ 69 Ruling from the bench, the court first noted that if Mother wanted to relocate to Canada
with E.H., she must first file a petition to relocate, which she had not yet done. The court stated,
“I certainly would entertain that request, if it was presented.” The court noted that, although it
could allow relocation with a fleshed-out record, “the most stable placement that [E.H.] has had
has been in Illinois from what I’ve seen.” Addressing Mother’s concerns about racism, the court
stated, “I agree with you. I’m terrified about what’s going on in my country.” The court stated,
however, “Illinois has especially demonstrated a resistance to the kind and quality of racism that
[Mother] is referencing.”
¶ 70 The circuit court went on to state that Father was not the only parent who gave the court
concerns about potentially dangerous decisions regarding the use of an automobile. The court
pointed to Mother’s February 2025 vehicle accident which, according to the court, occurred “under
circumstances that at least appear to be related to her continued problems with epilepsy.” The court
stated, “I don’t have any testimo