Torres v. Horner
CourtAppellate Court of Illinois
Date FiledNovember 17, 2026
Docket5-26-0161
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
NOTICE
2026 IL App (5th) 260161-U
NOTICE
Decision filed 11/17/26. The
This order was filed under
text of this decision may be NO. 5-26-0161
Supreme Court Rule 23 and is
changed or corrected prior to
the filing of a Petition for not precedent except in the
Rehearing or the disposition of
IN THE limited circumstances allowed
the same. under Rule 23(e)(1).
APPELLATE COURT OF ILLINOIS
FIFTH DISTRICT
______________________________________________________________________________
ANTHONY IRIZARRY TORRES, ) Appeal from the
) Circuit Court of
Plaintiff-Appellee, ) Fayette County.
)
v. ) No. 22-LM-2
)
BRENT HORNER, ) Honorable
) Joshua C. Morrison,
Defendant-Appellant. ) Judge, presiding.
______________________________________________________________________________
PRESIDING JUSTICE CATES delivered the judgment of the court.
Justices Barberis and Boie concurred in the judgment.
ORDER
¶1 Held: The circuit court’s judgment was not against the manifest weight of the evidence.
¶2 The appellant, Brent Horner, appeals the circuit court’s finding that the appellee, Anthony
Torres, met his burden to establish that a valid and enforceable contract existed between the parties
for each of 43 transactions. The appellant further contends that the circuit court’s ruling was against
the manifest weight of the evidence. For the following reasons, we affirm.
¶3 I. BACKGROUND
¶4 Brent and Anthony were in a romantic relationship that began in February 2019 and ended
in October 2020. During the course of their relationship, several transfers of money were made
from Anthony to Brent, and there were several purchases made by Anthony that he alleged
1
were on Brent’s behalf. The parties also purchased a share in a lake lot during their
relationship.
¶5 After the relationship ended, Anthony alleged that he asked Brent to pay back all of the
money that Anthony had loaned Brent throughout their relationship. Anthony indicated to Brent
via email that the original total amount owed was $38,948. Following verbal conversations, Brent
began paying Anthony $250 every two weeks. The first payment was made on April 1, 2021. Brent
made payments over the span of four months totaling $2,000. The last payment from Brent to
Anthony was on July 18, 2021. After Brent ceased making the payments, Anthony asked Brent
why payments had stopped. Eventually, Anthony emailed Brent with an itemized list which
indicated the total amount of outstanding debt Anthony claimed was owed by Brent. When there
was no response from Brent, Anthony sent a demand letter. Brent again failed to respond, so
Anthony initiated this litigation.
¶6 On April 3, 2024, Anthony filed a complaint that was subsequently amended which alleged
breach of contract (count I), unjust enrichment (count II), and in the alternative, account stated
(count III). In the first amended complaint, Anthony alleged that Brent was indebted to Anthony
for an amount exceeding $34,000. Anthony further alleged that he loaned Brent money with the
understanding and promise by Brent that Anthony would be repaid. On February 19, 2021,
Anthony emailed Brent requesting repayment of the loan. Following that email, the complaint
alleged that Anthony and Brent verbally agreed to a repayment plan wherein Brent would make a
bi-weekly payment in the amount of $250.
¶7 On July 16, 2021, Anthony emailed Brent an itemized list with a breakdown of Brent’s
outstanding debt. Brent made payments for approximately four months and subsequently ceased
making payments. Anthony sent Brent an email regarding the payment plan, notifying Brent that
2
he had not received any payment since July 18, 2021. Anthony sent a demand letter on November
30, 2021, that included an itemized list for the outstanding debt that Anthony claimed was still
owed from Brent. Finally, according to the allegations in the amended complaint, Brent failed to
respond or repay Anthony the outstanding debt that he was owed.
¶8 Following his answer, Brent filed an amended answer denying the allegations made in the
first amended complaint. Specifically, Brent alleged that he only verbally agreed to repay Anthony
$250 “every two weeks for his one-half of the boat and his share of the lake lot.”
¶9 On October 28, 2024, the circuit court convened a bench trial. During trial, Anthony
testified that he repeatedly lent Brent money during the course of their relationship. Anthony
frequently sent Brent money through bank transfers and Venmo. Brent also used Anthony’s credit
card. Further, Anthony stated that he loaned Brent money with an expectation that Anthony was
going to be repaid, whenever Brent got into a “better financial situation.” In support of Anthony’s
claim that he was owed repayment for 43 transactions, Anthony introduced into evidence several
text message chains, email threads, and financial statements as plaintiff’s exhibits.
¶ 10 In his defense, Brent testified that he had never “borrowed” money from Anthony during
their romantic relationship. Brent stated that he did not have any conversations with Anthony about
paying him back any of the money that Brent received until the relationship ended. According to
Brent, Anthony told him, “I will always take care of you, so don’t be so self-conscious about not
earning as much; eventually you’ll earn more, you’re going to be in a good place someday.” Brent
and Anthony spoke following their separation about Brent buying Anthony “out of the lake lot and
the boat.” Brent stated that he was paying $250 every two weeks for his share that was owed on
the lake lot and boat. Brent received an itemized list that he disagreed with, so he stopped making
payments. Brent reiterated throughout his testimony that Anthony was frequently giving him
3
money because Anthony often said, “we were building a life together, we were a couple, and he
wanted me to have a good life and nice things.” During his testimony, Brent did admit that there
were several instances, as reflected in the exhibits he was shown, where Anthony texted and
emailed Brent that his outstanding debt was “36, 35, $34,000.” Brent agreed that this amount was
“substantially different” than the $8,000 that he believed he owed Anthony for the lake lot and
boat.
¶ 11 Following the close of evidence and arguments, the circuit court found that there were 43
transactions from Anthony to Brent and that each of these transactions was a valid and enforceable
contract. The circuit court found that there was an offer, acceptance, and consideration for each
transaction. Ultimately, the circuit court found that Brent was liable and entered judgment in favor
of Anthony. This appeal followed.
¶ 12 II. ANALYSIS
¶ 13 On appeal, Brent alleges that the circuit court’s finding that Anthony met his burden to
establish a valid and enforceable contract for each of the 43 transactions was against the manifest
weight of the evidence. Brent requests that this court reverse the circuit court’s finding that a valid
and enforceable contract existed between the parties as to all 43 transactions. Finally, Brent claims
that he only owes Anthony $1,334 for the remaining amount due on the lake lot.
¶ 14 Under the common law, the basic ingredients of a contract are an offer, acceptance, and
consideration. Melena v. Anheuser-Busch, Inc., 219 Ill. 2d 135, 151 (2006). Generally, the law
“does not presume a gift if someone transfers property to a friend, even a close friend.” Barnes v.
Michalski, 399 Ill. App. 3d 254, 269 (2010). Regarding repayment, “[i]f someone writes a friend
a check, the law presumes the check is not a gift but the payment of an antecedent debt.” Barnes,
399 Ill. App. 3d at 269. However, a claim that the transferred money was a gift rebuts the
4
presumption that the check was for an antecedent debt. Barnes, 399 Ill. App. 3d at 269. Therefore,
“[t]he presumption next in line, after payment of an antecedent debt, is the making of a loan.”
Barnes, 399 Ill. App. 3d at 269. “When a person writes a check to a payee who is neither the spouse
nor a relative of that person, rather than presume that the check was a gift—which must be proved
by clear and convincing evidence—the law will presume that the parties engaged in a contractual
transaction: the law will presume that the check was in payment of a debt, or, if that presumption
is rebutted, the law will presume the check was a loan.” Barnes, 399 Ill. App. 3d at 270. Simply
stated, where one person gives money to another who is not related or a spouse then a presumption
arises that the money was for repayment of a debt. If this presumption is rebutted by a claim that
the money was a gift, then the presumption arises that the money was a loan.
¶ 15 The standard of review following the judgment of the circuit court after a bench trial is
whether the judgment was against the manifest weight of the evidence. Chicago’s Pizza, Inc. v.
Chicago’s Pizza Franchise Ltd. USA, 384 Ill. App. 3d 849, 859 (2008). A judgment is against the
manifest weight of the evidence when the opposite conclusion is apparent or when the findings are
unreasonable, arbitrary, or not based on the evidence. Chicago’s Pizza, Inc., 384 Ill. App. 3d at
859. “We will not disturb a trial court’s judgment as long as there is evidence to support the
judgment.” Northwestern Memorial Hospital v. Sharif, 2014 IL App (1st) 133008, ¶ 25.
¶ 16 In the instant case, Anthony introduced evidence of 43 transactions, wherein Brent received
money or its equivalent. There was no written agreement that memorialized the terms for each of
the individual transactions. Under the common law, however, where there is an offer of money,
and an acceptance by an individual who is not a spouse or otherwise related, the presumption arises
that the money was for the repayment of a debt. Here, Brent acknowledges that he received the
money or its equivalent in each of the 43 transactions and that the money was not for the repayment
5
of a debt. Therefore, under the common law, there was a valid contract and a presumption arose
that the money received was for a loan.
¶ 17 Having determined that there was a valid contract for each transaction, the remaining
question is whether Brent rebutted the presumption that the money tendered was a loan. Brent
began making repayment of $250 every two weeks after Anthony had informed Brent of the total
amount owed, which was approximately $36,000. The circuit court found that Brent did not rebut
the presumption by clear and convincing evidence that the money was instead a gift and not a loan.
Therefore, we agree with the circuit court that Anthony is entitled to the outstanding balance, as
determined by the circuit court regarding each of the 43 contractual transactions between the
parties. Therefore, we find that the judgment of the circuit court did not go against the manifest
weight of the evidence.
¶ 18 III. CONCLUSION
¶ 19 The judgment of the circuit court is affirmed.
¶ 20 Affirmed.
6