D.F. v. M.B.
CourtHawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals
Date FiledNovember 16, 2026
DocketCAAP-24-0000308
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
NOT FOR PUBLICATION IN WEST'S HAWAIʻI REPORTS AND PACIFIC REPORTER
Electronically Filed
Intermediate Court of Appeals
CAAP-XX-XXXXXXX
16-NOV-2026
08:24 AM
Dkt. 141 SO
NO. CAAP-XX-XXXXXXX
IN THE INTERMEDIATE COURT OF APPEALS
OF THE STATE OF HAWAIʻI
D.F., Plaintiff-Appellant,
v.
M.B., Defendant-Appellee.
APPEAL FROM THE FAMILY COURT OF THE FIRST CIRCUIT
(CASE NO. 1DV201000187)
SUMMARY DISPOSITION ORDER
(By: Nakasone, Chief Judge, Wadsworth and McCullen, JJ.)
Plaintiff-Appellant D.F. (Wife) appeals from the
Family Court of the First Circuit's March 19, 2024 Divorce
Decree and various underlying and post-decree orders. 1
1 The Honorable Courtney N. Naso presided. Wife appeals from the
following orders:
(1) July 14, 2023 "Order Granting [Defendant-Appellee M.B.
(Husband)]'s Motion to Amend Pretrial Order No. 1, Filed
June 15, 2023" (Pretrial Order No. 1);
(2) October 9, 2023 "Stipulation Resolving Divorce Issues and
Order" (October 9, 2023 Stipulation);
(continued . . .)
NOT FOR PUBLICATION IN WEST'S HAWAIʻI REPORTS AND PACIFIC REPORTER
On appeal, Wife raises four points of error,
ultimately challenging the family court's determination that
Section 2 of the prenuptial agreement unambiguously excluded
property that Wife owned before marriage, and that Husband was
thus entitled to an equalization payment. 2
(. . . continued)
(3) January 19, 2024 "Decision and Order Following Trial"
(January 19, 2024 Decision and Order);
(4) February 20, 2024 "Order Denying [Wife]'s 'Motion for
Reconsideration, or Alteration and/or Amendment of the
Decision and Order Following Trial Filed on January 19,
2024 and/or in the Alternative, for a New Trial on Limited
Issues,' Filed on 1/29/2024";
(5) May 17, 2024 "Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law"; and
(6) June 17, 2024 "Order Denying '[Wife]'s Non-Hearing Motion
1) for Correction, Clarification, and/or Reconsideration of
This Court's [sic] Findings of Fact [(FOF)] and Conclusions
of Law, DV Dkt 745, FOF, and/or 2) for Findings of Fact and
Conclusions [sic] of Law in Accordance with Rule 10(f)
[sic] of the [Hawaiʻi] Rules of Appellate Procedure
Memorandum,' Filed on 5/27/2024" (June 17, 2024 Order
Denying Wife's Motion for Correction). (Second, fourth and
fifth brackets in original.)
2 Wife's points of error are presented as follows:
I. The lower court erred by finding that seven
words of provision two of the [Agreement] were unambiguous,
thereby clearly excluding the [Kāneʻohe] Property from the
[Agreement], while the court completely disregarded the
remainder of provision two, the remainder of the
[Agreement], the clear intent of the parties, and the
findings of the previous judge that [Husband] understood
the purpose of the [Agreement] and that provision two was
ambiguous.
II. The lower court erred where it denied [Wife]'s
Motion to Reconsider where the court did not grant [Wife]
credits for her contributions to the [Kāneʻohe] Property,
where the court did not allow [Wife] a further trial on the
(continued . . .)
2
NOT FOR PUBLICATION IN WEST'S HAWAIʻI REPORTS AND PACIFIC REPORTER
Upon careful review of the record and the briefs
submitted by the parties, and having given due consideration to
the issues raised and the arguments advanced, we resolve this
appeal as discussed below and affirm.
In 2012, before the marriage, Wife bought a house
located at 45-744 Kamehameha Highway, Kāneʻohe, Hawaiʻi 96744
(the Kāneʻohe Property).
On the day of their marriage, Wife and Husband
executed a prenuptial agreement (the Agreement) that Wife had
obtained online. Neither Husband nor Wife consulted an attorney
before entering into the Agreement.
Under Section 1 of the Agreement, property then-owned
or later acquired by either party was to "remain and be their
separate property," unless the Agreement provided otherwise.
Section 2 expressly provided that the Kāneʻohe Property would
(. . . continued)
issue of said credits, and where the court issued its
Decree excluding the [Kāneʻohe] Property from the
[Agreement] and ordering a consequent equalization payment
to [Husband] sans any credits to [Wife].
III. The lower court erred by amending the pre-trial
order, thereby allowing [Husband] to present evidence and
argument as to whether the parties' [Agreement] covered
[Wife]'s [Kāneʻohe] Property.
IV. The lower court erred where it entered findings
that were clearly erroneous, and/or where it entered
conclusions that were wrong.
(Formatting altered.)
3
NOT FOR PUBLICATION IN WEST'S HAWAIʻI REPORTS AND PACIFIC REPORTER
"not be affected by this Agreement," and that Wife and Husband
would treat it "as their principal residence in sole ownership
of [Wife]":
2. RESIDENCE. It is the intention of the parties that the
residence presently owned by [Wife] located at 45-744
Kamehameha Hwy, [Kāneʻohe], [Hawaiʻi] 96744, shall not
be affected by this Agreement. The parties plan to
maintain such property as their principal residence in
sole ownership of above mentioned party.
(Emphasis added.) And Section 3 stated that "except for this
Agreement, such earning[s] []and accumulations of the other
throughout the marriage would be joint property."
Wife and Husband separated in 2018. Two years later,
Wife filed a complaint for divorce on the grounds that their
marriage was irretrievably broken. Litigation concerning the
enforceability of the Agreement occurred throughout 2022,
resulting in the family court's determination that it was valid
and enforceable. 3
In April 2023, the family court entered Pretrial Order
No. 1, which set forth all of the issues in dispute. Regarding
the Kāneʻohe Property, Pretrial Order No. 1 identified Husband's
"request for payment for home renovations for 45-744 Kamehameha
Hwy" as the only disputed issue. Otherwise, Pretrial Order
No. 1 identified issues related to property division as "not
applicable."
3 The Honorable Dyan M. Medeiros presided over the enforcement
proceedings related to the Agreement.
4
NOT FOR PUBLICATION IN WEST'S HAWAIʻI REPORTS AND PACIFIC REPORTER
In June 2023, Husband moved to amend Pretrial Order
No. 1, arguing that Section 2 of the Agreement placed the
division of the Kāneʻohe Property in dispute. Husband contended
the Kāneʻohe Property "should be awarded to Wife, [and] Husband
should be entitled to one half of the increased value of the
property during the marriage." The family court granted
Husband's motion and amended Pretrial Order No. 1 in July 2023.
Following an August 2023 settlement conference, the
family court entered the October 9, 2023 Stipulation, in which
Wife and Husband agreed that Wife would be awarded her interest
in the Kāneʻohe Property "as her sole and separate property," and
that "[w]hether [Husband] has an interest in the [Kāneʻohe
P]roperty and the value of that interest (if any) are issues for
trial."
After a four-day trial, the family court entered its
January 19, 2024 Decision and Order, in which it determined that
(1) Husband's testimony was more credible than Wife's with
respect to Section 2 of the Agreement; (2) Section 2's plain
language "clearly exclude[d] the [Kāneʻohe P]roperty from the
[Agreement]"; and (3) Husband was therefore entitled to half of
the "increase in value from the date of marriage to the current
5
NOT FOR PUBLICATION IN WEST'S HAWAIʻI REPORTS AND PACIFIC REPORTER
fair market value." 4 Ultimately, the family court ordered Wife
to pay Husband an equalization payment in the amount of
$234,135.79 within ninety days of the Divorce Decree's effective
date. 5
Wife filed a motion for reconsideration (January 29,
2024 Motion for Reconsideration), which the family court denied
after determining she had "not presented an adequate basis" for
reconsideration.
4 FOF 41 in the January 19, 2024 Decision and Order provides in
relevant part:
After reviewing the [Agreement], considering the
testimony of the parties, assessing and weighing the
credibility of the testimony, considering the evidence in
the record, finding [Husband]'s testimony more credible
than [Wife]'s testimony regarding this provision in the
[Agreement], and interpreting the [Agreement] according to
the plain, ordinary and accepted common speech, the Court
does not deem the provision ambiguous, but the Court does
find the parties had different understandings of the
provision. The Court finds the provision, in its plain
language, to clearly exclude the property from the
[Agreement] by stating the property "shall not be affected
by this Agreement." . . . [T]he parties shall equally share
the Category 2 value (increase in value from the date of
marriage to the current fair market value).
(Emphases added.)
5 FOF 42 in the January 19, 2024 Decision and Order provides in full:
[FOF] 42. Property Division Payment/Equalization Payment:
The result is Wife owes an equalization payment to Husband
in the amount of TWO HUNDRED FORTY-EIGHT THOUSAND EIGHT
HUNDRED FIFTY-FOUR DOLLARS AND TWENTY-ONE CENTS
[$248,854.21], from which $10,000.00 shall be deducted
(reflecting the advance of attorney's fees Wife paid to
Husband) and from which $4,718.42 shall be deducted
(reflecting Husband's one-half share of Teo's veterinary
expenses due and owing). Therefore, Wife shall pay Husband
an equalization payment in the amount of TWO HUNDRED
THIRTY-FOUR THOUSAND ONE HUNDRED THIRTY-FIVE DOLLARS AND
SEVENTY-NINE CENTS [$234,135.79] within ninety (90) days of
the effective date of the parties' final divorce decree.
6
NOT FOR PUBLICATION IN WEST'S HAWAIʻI REPORTS AND PACIFIC REPORTER
On March 19, 2024, the family court entered the
Divorce Decree.
Wife timely appealed.
On May 17, 2024, the family court entered post-decree
Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, in which it determined
that Wife did not comply with Hawaiʻi Family Court Rules Rule 72
or Hawaiʻi Rules of Appellate Procedure (HRAP) Rule 10. On
May 27, 2024, Wife filed a non-hearing motion for correction,
clarification, and/or reconsideration of the May 17, 2024
Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law, which the family court
denied.
(1) Wife first contends the family court erred by
finding that Section 2 of the Agreement, "in its plain language,
. . . clearly exclude[d] the [Kāneʻohe P]roperty from the
[Agreement] by stating the property 'shall not be affected by
this Agreement.'" Wife asserts the family court read Section 2
out of context and neglected to consider Sections 1 and 3 of the
Agreement.
Principles of contract law govern the enforceability
of premarital agreements. E.g., Lewis v. Lewis, 69 Haw. 497,
500-01, 748 P.2d 1362, 1365-66 (1988). "To determine whether
ambiguity exists" in a contract, the supreme court has explained
that "the test lies not necessarily in the presence of
particular ambiguous words or phrases but rather in the purport
7
NOT FOR PUBLICATION IN WEST'S HAWAIʻI REPORTS AND PACIFIC REPORTER
of the document itself, whether or not particular words or
phrases in themselves be uncertain or doubtful in meaning."
Found. Int'l, Inc. v. E.T. Ige Constr., Inc., 102 Hawaiʻi 487,
496-97, 78 P.3d 23, 32-33 (2003) (citation modified). "A court
should look no further than the four corners of the document to
determine whether an ambiguity exists." Id. at 497, 78 P.3d at
33 (citation modified). Importantly, disagreement between the
parties "as to the meaning of a contract or its terms does not
render clear language ambiguous." Id. (citation modified).
Here, looking no further than the four corners of the
Agreement and reading all of the relevant provisions together,
Section 2 is not ambiguous. See Found. Int'l, Inc., 102 Hawaiʻi
at 497, 78 P.3d at 33. Section 1 begins with the proviso,
"Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement," before stating
that the parties' property — both present (as identified in
Exhibits A and B) and future — would "remain and be their
separate property," and neither party would acquire an interest
in the other's property during the marriage. (Emphasis added.)
Section 2 then provided otherwise by stating, "It is
the intention of the parties that the residence presently owned
by [Wife] located at 45-744 Kamehameha Hwy, [Kāneʻohe], [Hawaiʻi]
96744, shall not be affected by this Agreement." (Emphasis
added.) And though Section 2's remaining sentence states the
Kāneʻohe Property would remain in Wife's "sole ownership," that
8
NOT FOR PUBLICATION IN WEST'S HAWAIʻI REPORTS AND PACIFIC REPORTER
provision does not require Husband to forfeit his interest in
any earnings or accumulations arising from the Kāneʻohe Property
during the marriage. In fact, Section 3 explicitly provides,
"Each of the parties understand that except for this Agreement,
such earning[s] []and accumulations of the other throughout the
marriage would be joint property." (Emphasis added.) Because
Section 2 excepted the Kāneʻohe Property from the Agreement, any
earnings and accumulations arising from the Kāneʻohe Property
during the marriage were, pursuant to Section 3, joint property.
Moreover, the family court determined that Wife and
Husband "had different understandings of the provision." But
this alone does not render otherwise clear language ambiguous.
See Found. Int'l, Inc., 102 Hawaiʻi at 497, 78 P.3d at 33.
Because substantial evidence supports the family
court's determination that Section 2 of the Agreement was not
ambiguous, the family court did not err. See LC v. MG, 143
Hawaiʻi 302, 310, 430 P.3d 400, 408 (2018).
(2) Wife next contends the family court "erroneously
denied" her January 29, 2024 Motion for Reconsideration.
It is well-settled that the "purpose of a motion for
reconsideration is to allow the parties to present new evidence
and/or arguments that could not have been presented during the
earlier adjudicated motion," and not to "relitigate old matters
or to raise arguments or evidence that could and should have
9
NOT FOR PUBLICATION IN WEST'S HAWAIʻI REPORTS AND PACIFIC REPORTER
been brought during the earlier proceeding." Tagupa v. Tagupa,
108 Hawaiʻi 459, 465, 121 P.3d 924, 930 (App. 2005).
Here, Wife's January 29, 2024 Motion for
Reconsideration attempted to relitigate whether she was entitled
to credits for her contributions to the Kāneʻohe Property. But,
as Wife acknowledges in her opening brief, the family court,
having been "presented with ample evidence" regarding her and
Husband's contributions, determined that the parties'
"contribution of labor and payment in the [Kāneʻohe Property]'s
renovations" did not entitle either party to credits, because
those contributions were "the parties' agreement for division of
labor for their household." Thus, the family court specifically
considered and entered findings on the arguments and evidence
that Wife contends merited reconsideration.
Accordingly, the family court did not abuse its
discretion by denying Wife's January 29, 2024 Motion for
Reconsideration.
(3) Wife next contends the family "court should have
denied [Husband]'s request to amend [Pretrial Order No. 1] based
on Judicial Estoppel[.]" (Formatting altered.) Alternatively,
Wife argues the family "court should have denied [Husband]'s
request to amend [Pretrial Order No. 1], given that [Pretrial
Order No. 1] was the product of a settlement agreement following
mediation." (Formatting altered.)
10
NOT FOR PUBLICATION IN WEST'S HAWAIʻI REPORTS AND PACIFIC REPORTER
The doctrine of judicial estoppel operates to prevent
parties from "maintain[ing] inconsistent positions or to take a
position in regard to a matter which is directly contrary to, or
inconsistent with, one previously assumed by [them], at least
where [they] had, or [were] chargeable with, full knowledge of
the facts, and another will be prejudiced by [their] action[s]."
Roxas v. Marcos, 89 Hawaiʻi 91, 124, 969 P.2d 1209, 1242 (1998)
(quoting Rosa v. CWJ Contractors, Ltd., 4 Haw. App. 210, 218,
664 P.2d 745, 751 (App. 1983)).
Here, Husband's aim to enforce Section 2 of the
Agreement as written and thereby obtain his one-half interest in
the Kāneʻohe Property's increase in value during the marriage is
not inconsistent with his position that, in dividing assets,
Wife was and should remain the sole owner of the Kāneʻohe
Property. See Roxas, 89 Hawaiʻi at 124, 969 P.2d at 1242.
The record indicates Husband has consistently
(1) maintained that Wife should receive the Kāneʻohe Property and
(2) claimed some interest in the Kāneʻohe Property, be it
reimbursement for his renovation work or an equalization
payment.
Moreover, following an August 2023 settlement
conference, Wife and Husband "stipulate[d] and agree[d] that"
Wife would be "awarded her interest in the [Kāneʻohe Property] as
11
NOT FOR PUBLICATION IN WEST'S HAWAIʻI REPORTS AND PACIFIC REPORTER
her sole and separate property," but "whether [Husband] ha[d] an
interest in the [Kāneʻohe] Property and the value of that
interest (if any) [were] issues for trial." Section VI of the
October 9, 2023 Stipulation, titled "Other Disputed Issues Which
Are Not Resolved," reiterated that "whether [Husband] is
entitled to a payment for renovations to the [Kāneʻohe] Property
in 2013-2014 and/or a property equalization payment related to
the [Kāneʻohe] Property" remains an unresolved issue to be
determined at trial. (Formatting altered.)
In other words, Wife stipulated that the issue was one
for trial; now that the trial has occurred and the family court
has determined that Husband was entitled to a property
equalization payment, Wife cannot challenge the terms to which
she stipulated. See Roxas, 89 Hawaiʻi at 124, 969 P.2d at 1242.
Considering "the family court possesses wide
discretion in making its decisions," we decline to hold the
family court abused its discretion by amending Pretrial Order
No. 1. See Fisher v. Fisher, 111 Hawaiʻi 41, 46, 137 P.3d 355,
360 (2006).
(4) Finally, Wife disputes various statements,
findings, and conclusions in the October 9, 2023 Stipulation;
January 19, 2024 Decision and Order; March 19, 2024 Divorce
Decree; May 17, 2024 Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law;
and June 17, 2024 Order Denying Wife's Motion for Correction.
12
NOT FOR PUBLICATION IN WEST'S HAWAIʻI REPORTS AND PACIFIC REPORTER
HRAP Rule 28(b)(7) requires appellants to present an
"argument, containing the contentions of the appellant on the
points presented and the reasons therefor, with citations to the
authorities, statutes and parts of the record relied on."
Without the above, "[p]oints not argued may be deemed waived."
HRAP Rule 28(b)(7). And, as Hawaiʻi appellate courts have
consistently held, "an appellant's mere challenge of a finding
does not place the onus of justifying it on this court. The
party seeking to overthrow findings has the burden of pointing
out specifically wherein the findings are clearly erroneous."
E.g., Tone v. Hashimoto, 156 Hawaiʻi 299, 574 P.3d 319, No. CAAP-
XX-XXXXXXX, 2025 WL 2418487, at *3 (App. Aug. 21, 2025)
(citation modified).
Here, Wife asserts only that she "disputes" the
laundry list of challenged findings and conclusions; she does
not present "reasons therefor, with citations to the
authorities" relied on. See HRAP Rule 28(b)(7) (emphasis
added).
Because Wife's "argument does not contain any
reasoning, supported by citations to case law or authority to
constitute a discernible argument," this court need not address
13
NOT FOR PUBLICATION IN WEST'S HAWAIʻI REPORTS AND PACIFIC REPORTER
these contentions. See Taomae v. Lingle, 108 Hawaiʻi 245, 257,
118 P.3d 1188, 1200 (2005).
Based on the foregoing, we affirm the family court's
March 19, 2024 Divorce Decree.
DATED: Honolulu, Hawaiʻi, November 16, 2026.
On the briefs: /s/ Karen T. Nakasone
Chief Judge
Kai Lawrence,
for Plaintiff-Appellant. /s/ Clyde J. Wadsworth
Associate Judge
Francis T. O'Brien,
for Defendant-Appellee. /s/ Sonja M.P. McCullen
Associate Judge
14