LEAH CALDWELL v. KRISTIN POLAND, PROBATE JUDGE
CourtCourt of Appeals of Georgia
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
DocketA27O0025
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Court of Appeals
of the State of Georgia
ATLANTA,____________________
November 18, 2026
The Court of Appeals hereby passes the following order:
A27O0025. LEAH CALDWELL v. KRISTIN POLAND, PROBATE JUDGE et
al.
In March 2026, Leah Caldwell appealed pro se to this Court from a probate
court order refusing her request to participate in a hearing on a petition for
appointment of a guardian for an adult ward. After the appeal was docketed, she
moved to supplement the record with various filings and transcripts. On May 29,
2026, we remanded the case with instruction that the probate court “should ensure
a complete record is prepared and transmitted with a verification that the items
included were relied upon when it issued the judgment being considered on appeal.”
Following remand, proceedings ensued in the probate court regarding appellate costs
and the procurement of hearing transcripts. The opposing parties moved to dismiss
Caldwell’s appeal for unreasonable and inexcusable delay in filing the transcript, and
the probate court scheduled a hearing on the matter for November 17, 2026. Caldwell
then filed an original mandamus petition in this Court against the probate court judge
and clerk, a motion to supplement the mandamus petition with several filings from the
probate court, and an emergency motion pursuant to Court of Appeals Rule 40(b)
requesting that we grant relief to the extent necessary to preserve our jurisdiction to
consider the issues raised in petition.
In the original mandamus petition, Caldwell asks this Court to direct the
probate court clerk to issue an amended appellate-cost assessment, clarify the filing
status of the transcripts, and transmit the existing appellate record, and to direct the
probate judge to complete the verification required by our May 29 order. We lack
jurisdiction to grant such relief.
Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy available only when “(1) no other
adequate legal remedy is available to effectuate the relief sought; and (2) the applicant
has a clear legal right to such relief.” Bibb County v. Monroe County, 294 Ga. 730,
734(2) (755 SE2d 760) (2014). Generally, superior courts are empowered to issue
process in the nature of mandamus, “and hence the need to resort to the appellate
courts for such relief by petition filed in the appellate courts will be extremely rare.”
Brown v. Johnson, 251 Ga. 436, 436 (306 SE2d 655) (1983), disapproved in part on
other grounds, Arnold v. Alexander, 321 Ga. 330, 336(1) (914 SE2d 311) (2025). See
also Ga. Const. of 1983, Art. VI, Sec. I, Par. IV. By contrast, an appellate court’s
authority to issue such writs “is connected only to such powers as necessary in aid of
its jurisdiction or to protect or effectuate its judgments,” and it lacks jurisdiction “to
issue process as an original matter wholly unconnected to its appellate jurisdiction.”
Arnold, 321 Ga. at 334(1) (quotation marks omitted). Thus, except in the rarest of
cases, the procedure to be followed before seeking to invoke this Court’s original
mandamus jurisdiction is to file the petition in the appropriate lower court first. See
Graham v. Cavender, 252 Ga. 123, 123 (311 SE2d 832) (1984), disapproved in part on
other grounds by Arnold, 321 Ga. at 336(1) & n.7; Expedia, Inc. v. City of Columbus, 305
Ga. App. 450, 455(2)(b) (699 SE2d 600) (2010), disapproved on other grounds by
Arnold, 321 Ga. at 336(1) & n.7.
Here, Caldwell does not assert that she petitioned the superior court for
mandamus relief, and she does not seek to supplement her petition with any filings
showing otherwise. Nor has she demonstrated that extraordinary intervention is
necessary in aid of our jurisdiction or to protect or effectuate our May 29 remand
order. To the contrary, Caldwell recognizes that judicial action is required before the
clerk can transmit the record, concedes that the probate court has not refused to
comply with our order, and acknowledges that her motion to compel the probate court
to verify the record remains pending below. Under these circumstances, this is not
one of the extremely rare instances in which this Court will exercise its original
jurisdiction, and we thus decline to exercise our emergency powers under Rule 40(b),
as there is no jurisdiction to preserve.
Accordingly, this petition is hereby DISMISSED, the motion to supplement is
hereby DENIED as MOOT, and the Rule 40(b) motion is hereby DENIED.
Court of Appeals of the State of Georgia
Clerk’s Office, Atlanta,____________________
11/18/2026
I certify that the above is a true extract from
the minutes of the Court of Appeals of Georgia.
Witness my signature and the seal of said court
hereto affixed the day and year last above written.
, Clerk.