Valer Caldwell v. Rock Rose Stoneridge Property LLC Dba the Park at Stonehaven
CourtCourt of Appeals of Georgia
Date FiledOctober 21, 2026
DocketA27D0200
StatusPublished
๐ฐ News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Court of Appeals
of the State of Georgia
ATLANTA,____________________
October 21, 2026
The Court of Appeals hereby passes the following order:
A27D0200. VALER CALDWELL v. ROCK ROSE STONERIDGE PROPERTY
LLC d/b/a THE PARK AT STONEHAVEN.
Plaintiff Rock Rose Stoneridge Property LLC d/b/a The Park at Stonehaven
brought this dispossessory action against Valer Caldwell in magistrate court. On
September 2, 2026, the magistrate court entered a consent order awarding the plaintiff
a monetary judgment and a writ of possession. That same day, Caldwell filed a pro se
application for discretionary review in this Court, seeking to appeal the September 2
order. We dismissed that application for lack of jurisdiction because: (i) appeals from
magistrate court judgments lie in state or superior court, not this Court; and
(ii) Caldwell waived her appellate rights by consenting to the magistrate court
judgment. Caldwell v. Rock Rose Stoneridge Prop., Case No. A27D0115 (Sept. 21, 2026).
In the interim, the plaintiff applied for an immediate writ of possession in
magistrate court, which granted the request in an order signed on September 29,
2026.1 Caldwell filed this pro se application for discretionary review on September 30.
We again lack jurisdiction.
1
The copy of the September 29 order included in the application materials is
not file-stamped, in violation of Court of Appeals Rule 31(c). On October 1, 2026, this
Court ordered Caldwell to supplement her current application within ten days with
a stamped โfiledโ copy of the order to be appealed. Caldwell has not yet complied
with this directive. Regardless, the current application was timely filed the day after
the magistrate court signed the September 29 order. See OCGA ยง 44-7-56(b)(1);
Stubbs v. Local Homes, 375 Ga. App. 513, 514โ16 (915 SE2d 91) (2025).
As we explained in our dismissal order in Case No. A27D0115, the only avenue
of appeal available from a magistrate court judgment is governed by OCGA
ยง 15-10-41(b)(1), which provides for appellate review in state or superior court. See
Tate v. Habif, 367 Ga. App. 435, 438โ39(2) (886 SE2d 389) (2023). โThus, this Court
has jurisdiction to address a magistrate court order only if the order has been reviewed
by a state or superior court.โ Harris v. Reserve at Hollywood, 376 Ga. App. 553, 553
(920 SE2d 163) (2025). The Georgia Constitution provides that โ[a]ny court shall
transfer to the appropriate court in the state any civil case in which it determines that
jurisdiction or venue lies elsewhere.โ Ga. Const. of 1983, Art. VI, Sec. I, Par. VIII.
Accord Ga. Ct. App. R. 11(b). โAs such, this Court at times has transferred
applications seeking review of magistrate court orders back to the magistrate court
with direction to send the case to state or superior court.โ Harris, 376 Ga. App. at 553.
Here, however โ as we also explained in our dismissal order in Case
No. A27D0115 โ Caldwell waived her appellate rights by consenting to the magistrate
court judgment. See Hurt v. Norwest Mtg., 260 Ga. App. 651, 656(1)(c) (580 SE2d
580) (2003) (โ[N]o litigant will be heard to complain of an order or judgment of the
court which he procures or assists in procuring, unless it be made plainly to appear
that the consent of the party seeking to complain was obtained by fraud or mistake.โ
(quotation marks omitted)). We therefore again decline to transfer this case to
magistrate court with direction to send it to state or superior court. Rather, this
improper application is also hereby DISMISSED. See id. at 657(1)(c).
We may impose sanctions upon parties who file frivolous applications to appeal.
See Ga. Ct. App. R. 7(e)(2). For the reasons stated above, we find this application to
be frivolous. We caution Caldwell that any future frivolous filings in this Court may
result in the imposition of sanctions.
Court of Appeals of the State of Georgia
Clerkโs Office, Atlanta,____________________
10/21/2026
I certify that the above is a true extract from
the minutes of the Court of Appeals of Georgia.
Witness my signature and the seal of said court
hereto affixed the day and year last above written.
, Clerk.