Full Opinion

Cite as 2026 Ark. App. 551 ARKANSAS COURT OF APPEALS DIVISION IV No. CV-25-657 EMERALD VALLEY, LLC; E. KIRK Opinion Delivered November 18, 2026 NEELY, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS MANAGING MEMBER OF EMERALD APPEAL FROM THE BENTON VALLEY, LLC; AND ANN YANCEY COUNTY CIRCUIT COURT APPELLANTS [NO. 04CV-24-1143] V. HONORABLE GARY ARNOLD, JUDGE BENTON COUNTY PLANNING BOARD AND CONTENTMENT ON BEAVER LAKE, LLC APPELLEES AFFIRMED BRANDON J. HARRISON, Judge The circuit court dismissed this appeal from the Benton County Planning Board’s 20 March 2024 decision approving a site plan for Contentment on Beaver Lake, LLC (Contentment) to operate a “glampground” or “glamping site” on 209 acres near Beaver Lake. The appellants, including Emerald Valley, LLC (collectively “Emerald Valley”), are neighbors who want no glamping there. Emerald Valley filed a timely notice of appeal to circuit court April 19; for some reason, all Benton County circuit judges recused sua sponte. That notice of appeal identified the date of the Board’s decision and attached a one- page legal description of the site. A certificate of service recites that Emerald Valley served the notice by email and “first-class regular U.S. Mail” on the Board’s director and Contentment’s counsel. But only the Board was named a party. Contentment moved to intervene, which Emerald Valley could not reasonably oppose. See, e.g., Nolan v. 2600 Holdings, LLC, 2024 Ark. 50, 686 S.W.3d 499 (no, you cannot sue to cancel someone’s valuable permit without joining him). After the circuit court granted intervention, Contentment moved to dismiss the appeal for failure to comply with the service and record- filing requirements in District Court Rule 9. The circuit court dismissed with prejudice on both grounds after a hearing. Emerald Valley timely appealed to this court; and the parties renew their arguments here. The interpretation of a court rule is a question of law we review de novo. Mullenix v. Mayberry, 2023 Ark. App. 139, 662 S.W.3d 691. Since October 2008, the procedure to appeal a county planning board decision under Ark. Code Ann. § 14-17-211 (Repl. 2013) has been governed by District Court Rule 9(f): (f) Administrative Appeals. (1) If an applicable statute provides a method for filing an appeal from a final decision of any governmental body or agency and a method for preparing the record on appeal, then the statutory procedures shall apply. (2) If no statute addresses how a party may take such an appeal or how the record shall be prepared, then the following procedures apply. (A) Notice of Appeal. A party may appeal any final administrative decision by filing a notice of appeal with the clerk of the circuit court having jurisdiction of the matter within thirty (30) days from the date of that decision. The notice of appeal shall describe the final administrative decision being appealed and specify the date of that decision. The date of decision shall be either the date of the vote, if any, or the date that a written record of the vote is made. The party shall serve the notice of appeal on all other parties, including the governmental body or agency, by serving any person described in Arkansas Rule of Civil Procedure 4(d)(7), by any form of mail that requires a return receipt. (B) The Record on Appeal. Within thirty (30) days after filing its notice of appeal, the party shall file certified copies of all the materials the party has 2 or can obtain that document the administrative proceeding. Within thirty (30) days after these materials are filed, any opposing party may supplement the record with certified copies of any additional documents that it believes are necessary to complete the administrative record on appeal. At any time during the appeal, any party may supplement the record with a certified copy of any document from the administrative proceeding that is not in the record but the party believes the circuit court needs to resolve the appeal. (C) Procedure on Appeal. As soon as practicable after all the parties have made the initial filing of record materials, the court shall establish a schedule for briefing, hearings, and any other matters needed to resolve the appeal. Ark. Dist. Ct. R. 9(f); see also In re Ark. District Court Rules, 374 Ark. App’x 653 (2008) (amending rule). Briefly, Contentment argued first that Emerald Valley did not strictly comply with the requirement to serve the notice of appeal “by serving any person described in Arkansas Rule of Civil Procedure 4(d)(7), by any form of mail that requires a return receipt.” Ark. Dist. Ct. R. 9(f)(2)(A) (emphasis added). Unlike for the court-to-court appeals described elsewhere in the rule, Rule 9(f) prescribes no other way to serve a notice of appeal from an administrative decision and does not state that failing to serve it is harmless. Compare Ark. Dist. Ct. R. 9(a) & (e). On the other hand (Emerald Valley noted), the incorporated Arkansas Rule of Civil Procedure 4(d)(7) no longer exists, and a provision added to Rule 4 later can forgive merely substantial compliance with some service-related rules if the party served received actual notice. Ark. R. Civ. P. 4(k). It’s also noteworthy that an oft-used rule of (civil) appellate procedure does not punish a party for failing to properly serve a notice of appeal. See Ark. R. App. P.–Civ. 3(f) (“Failure to serve notice shall not affect the validity of the appeal.”). 3 We leave those service-related issues for another case. Serving the notice of appeal was not the only fumbled Rule 9(f) requirement Contentment identified. Despite the rule’s command to file “certified copies of all the materials the party has or can obtain that document the administrative proceeding” within thirty days after the notice of appeal is filed, Ark. Dist. Ct. R. 9(f)(2)(B), more than three months had passed and nothing from the administrative proceeding, certified or not, had been filed. Nor would it ever be: Emerald Valley attached an April 2024 email requesting copies of some administrative materials to its response opposing dismissal. But almost a year later, it still had filed no administrative materials, nor any proof that “no material” was nonetheless all it could obtain. Ark. Dist. Ct. R. 9(f)(2)(B). Emerald Valley relies on the reporter’s note to the 2008 amendment to Rule 9, which characterizes that record-filing provision as a “housekeeping matter, not a jurisdictional requirement” in part because recordkeeping practices among the covered entities can vary widely. Ark. Dist. Ct. R. 9 addition to rep. notes 2008 amend; In re Ark. Dist. Ct. Rules, 374 Ark. App’x at 660. We imagine many hiccups or delays completing the administrative record could be ignored in that spirit if the party who appealed to circuit court had begun to comply before the court ruled. 1 But even for a housekeeping matter, house must eventually be kept. Filing whatever administrative record the appellant can obtain permits a court to at least assess the effort to obtain it and allows an appellee to supplement that record so the appeal has a fighting chance to begin, and efficiently so. Ark. 1 See Pettry v. State, 2020 Ark. App. 162, 595 S.W.3d 442 (noting our supreme court’s move away from hyper-technical rules that restrict access to courts). 4 Dist. Ct. R. 9(f)(2)(B). This appeal stalled out of the gate. It remained stalled fifteen months later, with no indication of when that might change. Like teachers, courts cannot give even a passing grade if no required work is ever attempted to be turned in; especially given the delay here. The circuit court did not err by dismissing on that ground. Affirmed. ABRAMSON, J., agrees. KLAPPENBACH, C.J., concurs. N. MARK KLAPPENBACH, Chief Judge, concurring. I would affirm the circuit court’s dismissal of the appeal due to Emerald Valley’s failure to strictly comply with District Court Rule 9(f)’s requirements for service of its notice of appeal. Our supreme court has been abundantly clear that compliance with Rule 9 must be strict; substantial compliance will not suffice. Mountain Pure, LLC v. Little Rock Wastewater Util., 2011 Ark. 258, 383 S.W.3d 347. Rule 9(f)(2)(A) requires service of the notice of appeal “by any form of mail that requires a return receipt.” In Motor Cars of Nashville, Inc. v. Chronister, 2014 Ark. App. 430, 439 S.W.3d 101, we addressed a very similar requirement in Rule 9(b), which governs appeals from district court and stated—before it was amended—that the appealing party shall serve a copy of the certified docket sheet “by any form of mail that requires a signed receipt.” We rejected Motor Cars’ argument that mailing in a particular form was not a jurisdictional requirement for perfecting the appeal to circuit court. Rule 9 was last amended in 2014, and Rule 9(b) now states that the failure to serve 5 certified copies “shall not affect the validity of the appeal.” 1 Rule 9(f), however, has never been amended to include such a statement. Emerald Valley argues that the strict-compliance standard was revoked by the 2019 amendment to Rule 4 of the Arkansas Rules of Civil Procedure, which provides that [a]ny error as to the sufficiency of process or the sufficiency of service of process shall be disregarded if the court determines that the serving party substantially complied with the provisions of this rule and that the defendant received actual notice of the complaint and filed a timely answer. Ark. R. Civ. P. 4(k). Rule 4(k) applies to any error regarding the “sufficiency of process or the sufficiency of service of process.” Rule 4(c)(1) states that the term “process” means the summons and a copy of the complaint, which shall be served together. Rule 9(f) governs service of the notice of appeal, not a summons and complaint. Accordingly, by its own terms, Rule 4(k) does not apply to this situation. Emerald Valley’s additional argument that Contentment waived any objection to the manner of service is not preserved. See Smith v. Sidney Moncrief Pontiac, Buick, GMC Co., 353 Ark. 701, 120 S.W.3d 525 (2003) (holding that waiver argument was not preserved). Therefore, I would affirm the circuit court’s dismissal under Rule 9(f)(2)(A). Richard Mays Law Firm PLLC, by: Richard H. Mays, for appellants. Matthews, Campbell, Rhoads, McClure & Thompson, P.A., by: Sarah L. Waddoups and Brent A. Johnson, for separate appellee Contentment on Beaver Lake, LLC 1 This amendment was noted in the Motor Cars opinion but was not in effect at the time of the appeal to circuit court. 6