J. L. Wagner v. Pike Co. Commissioners
CourtCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania
Date FiledNovember 16, 2026
Docket1067 C.D. 2025
JudgeFizzano Cannon
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA
Judy Leary Wagner, :
Appellant :
:
v. :
:
Pike County Commissioners, :
Matthew M. Osterberg, Ronald M. : No. 1067 C.D. 2025
Schmalzle, and Christa L. Caceres : Argued: October 13, 2026
BEFORE: HONORABLE RENÉE COHN JUBELIRER, President Judge
HONORABLE CHRISTINE FIZZANO CANNON, Judge (P.)
HONORABLE BONNIE BRIGANCE LEADBETTER, Senior Judge
OPINION
BY JUDGE FIZZANO CANNON FILED: November 16, 2026
Judy Leary Wagner (Wagner), one of three elected Auditors of Pike
County (County), appeals from a July 23, 2025 order of the Pike County Court of
Common Pleas (Trial Court) that sustained a preliminary objection in the form of a
demurrer to her civil complaint against the Pike County Commissioners, Matthew
M. Osterberg, Ronald M. Schmalzle, and Christa L. Caceres (Commissioners), and
dismissed the complaint. After careful review, we affirm the Trial Court’s order.
I. Background and Issue
There are no disputed facts, and the legal issue in this case is
straightforward. Wagner asserts that as one of three County Auditors, she has legal
authority to issue a subpoena to the Commissioners requiring them to produce
records she claims are needed for an audit. Neither of the other two Auditors agreed
to the issuance of a subpoena. Wagner filed a declaratory judgment action against
the Commissioners, seeking to establish her authority to issue a subpoena to them
without the agreement of either of the other two Auditors. Thus, the legal issue is
whether a single Auditor, rather than a majority of the County Auditors, may issue
a subpoena.
The Commissioners filed several preliminary objections, only one of
which is pertinent here. The Commissioners challenged the legal sufficiency of the
complaint by demurring pursuant to Rule 1028(a)(4) of the Pennsylvania Rules of
Civil Procedure, Pa.R.Civ.P. 1028(a)(4). The Trial Court sustained the demurrer
and dismissed the complaint, holding that Wagner lacked authority to act alone in
issuing a subpoena. Wagner appealed the dismissal to this Court.
II. Discussion
On appeal,1 Wagner insists the Trial Court committed “a glaring error
of law” in concluding that she could not act alone to issue a subpoena. Wagner Br.
at 7. We disagree.
Wagner observes that although there are three Auditors, Section
12901(a) of The County Code2 allows the County’s electors to vote for no more than
two Auditor candidates, “intentionally creating a power split between political
parties.” Wagner Br. at 9; see 16 Pa.C.S. § 12901(a). From this premise, Wagner
posits that “The County Code would not have created a minority [A]uditor had it
intended the minority [A]uditor to have no power absent concurrence with the
1
“Because the issue on appeal is purely a question of law, our standard of review is de
novo and our scope of review is plenary.” Watts Twp. Bd. of Auditors v. Raudensky, 200 A.3d
129, 132 n.7 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2018) (citing In re Appeal of 2012 Fin. Audit of Greene Twp., 113 A.3d
372, 374 n.5 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2015)).
2
16 Pa.C.S. §§ 101-17509.
2
majority [A]uditors.” Id. Wagner offers no citation of relevant authority for her
proposition, and we are unaware of any legal support for her reasoning concerning
legislative intent. Moreover, its logical extension would be contrary to or negatively
impact other statutory and regulatory provisions that require commissions and other
entities to be comprised of politically diverse groups. See, e.g., 25 Pa.C.S. § 1203(b)
& (d) (providing that generally, a county’s commissioners act as its voter registration
commission, but that “there must be minority representation on the commission,”
such that if all of the commissioners are from the majority party, one member of the
commission must be appointed from the minority party, even though acts of the
commission are by majority vote); 51 Pa.C.S. § 9809(a)(2) & (3) (providing that the
National Guard Youth Challenge Program advisory council shall include three state
senate members, two from the majority party and one from the minority party, and
three state house members, two from the majority party and one from the minority
party); 101 Pa. Code § 7.13 (requiring conference committees established to resolve
differences between the two legislative chambers must include three members of the
state senate, two from the majority party and one from the minority party, and three
state house members, two from the majority party and one from the minority party).
By Wagner’s reasoning, every member of such a group who is also a member of the
minority political party would be free to engage in unconstrained activity contrary
to the majority’s will. This would be an absurd result. For these reasons, we reject
Wagner’s argument.
“Auditors comprise a quasi-judicial body having powers which are
statutorily derived from The County Code. . . . These powers enable Auditors to
discharge their official duties. . . .” DeGeorge v. Young, 892 A.2d 48, 53 n.8 (Pa.
Cmwlth. 2006). Wagner acknowledges that Section 12903(d) of The County Code
3
provides that “[a]ny two [A]uditors when duly convened shall be a quorum for the
purpose of transacting business.” 16 Pa.C.S. § 12903(d). Wagner suggests that the
Trial Court improperly “conflated interpretation” of Section 12903(d) with Section
14925(a) of The County Code, 16 Pa.C.S. § 14925(a), authorizing subpoenas by
Auditors, and that the quorum provision of Section 12903(d) is unrelated to the
purported authority of one Auditor to act alone in issuing a subpoena pursuant to
Section 14925(a). Wagner Br. at 7. This assertion implicates the question of
whether issuing a subpoena constitutes “transacting business” within the meaning of
Section 12903(d). However, we need not answer that question, as we dispose of this
appeal on another basis, as explained below.
Nonetheless, it is notable that the other references to “[A]uditors” in
Section 12903 clearly refer to the three Auditors as a group, not just one of them
acting alone. See 16 Pa.C.S. § 12903(a) (directing that “[t]he [A]uditors shall meet
at the county seat on the first Monday of January in each year . . .”); 16 Pa.C.S.
§ 12903(b) (providing that “[t]he [A]uditors shall meet as necessary for the
completion of the audit under subsection (a) by the following July 1. The [A]uditors
may petition the court of common pleas for additional time for the completion of the
audit and the filing of the report”).
Although this is a statutory construction matter, neither the parties nor
the Trial Court cited or discussed the statutory provision that actually controls our
disposition of this appeal.3 Section 1905(a) of the Statutory Construction Act of
1972 provides that “[w]ords in a statute conferring a joint authority upon three or
3
We observe, however, that we may affirm the Trial Court’s decision on any basis
appearing from the record. See Washington v. Dep’t of Transp., Bureau of Driver Licensing, 301
A.3d 982, 986 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2023) (citing Feldman v. Lafayette Green Condo. Ass’n, 806 A.2d
497, 502 n.3 (Pa. Cmwlth. 2002)).
4
more public officers or other persons shall be construed to confer authority upon a
majority of such officers or persons.” 1 Pa.C.S. § 1905(a). We conclude that Section
1905(a) is dispositive of the legal issue Wagner presents.
Section 14925(a) of The County Code provides, in pertinent part, that
“[t]he controller or [A]uditors may issue a subpoena to obtain the attendance of an
officer whose accounts the controller or [A]uditors are required to adjust, including
an executor or administrator of the officer, and of any person whom it may be
necessary to examine as a witness. . . .” 16 Pa.C.S. § 14925(a). By its plain
language, Section 14925(a) confers joint authority on the County Auditors, of whom
there are three. This is also consistent with references to “[A]uditors” in Section
12903(a) and (b), 16 Pa.C.S. § 12903(a) & (b), discussed above, which require the
Auditors to meet and which, therefore, would make no sense if one Auditor could
act alone, inasmuch as one Auditor cannot “meet” with herself. Thus, we have no
difficulty in determining that Section 14925(a) “shall be construed to confer
authority upon a majority” of the three Auditors, pursuant to 1 Pa.C.S. § 1905(a).
We accordingly conclude that issuing a subpoena requires action by a majority of
the Auditors and that Wagner lacks authority to do so acting alone.
III. Conclusion
Based on the foregoing discussion, we affirm the Trial Court’s order.
__________________________________
CHRISTINE FIZZANO CANNON, Judge
5
IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA
Judy Leary Wagner, :
Appellant :
:
v. :
:
Pike County Commissioners, :
Matthew M. Osterberg, Ronald M. : No. 1067 C.D. 2025
Schmalzle, and Christa L. Caceres :
ORDER
AND NOW, this 16th day of November, 2026, the July 23, 2025 order
of the Pike County Court of Common Pleas is AFFIRMED.
__________________________________
CHRISTINE FIZZANO CANNON, Judge