Joint Successions of Neil E. Moore and Doris Helena Ward Moore
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
Date FiledNovember 18, 2026
Docket57,073-CA
JudgePitman
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Judgment rendered November 18, 2026.
Application for rehearing may be filed
within the delay allowed by Art. 2166,
La. C.C.P.
No. 57,073-CA
COURT OF APPEAL
SECOND CIRCUIT
STATE OF LOUISIANA
*****
JOINT SUCCESSIONS OF NEIL E. MOORE
AND DORIS HELENA WARD MOORE
*****
Appealed from the
Twenty-Sixth Judicial District Court for the
Parish of Bossier, Louisiana
Trial Court No. P-22837
Honorable Douglas M. Stinson, Judge
*****
BROUSSARD & NEWLEN Counsel for Appellants,
LAW FIRM, LLC Karen Moore and Sandra
By: Christopher D. Broussard Moore Graves
Pamela King Newlen
MIRAMON LAW, INC. Counsel for Appellees,
By: Julia Miramon Todd Susan Moore Rush and
Bruce Moore
*****
Before PITMAN, STONE, and ELLENDER, JJ.
PITMAN, C. J.
Karen Moore and Sandra Moore Graves appeal the trial court’s
finding that the purported last wills and testaments (the “Wills”) of their
parents, Neil E. Moore and Doris Helena Ward Moore, are null. For the
following reasons, we reverse the trial court’s denial of Karen and Sandra’s
motion to continue, vacate its judgment nullifying the Wills and remand for
further proceedings.
FACTS
On November 22, 2021, Susan Moore Rush filed a petition to be
appointed administrator of her parents’ successions. She noted that her
parents, Neil and Doris Moore, were married once, to each other, and that
five children were born of the marriage—Karen, Bruce, Kathryn, Sandra and
Susan. She stated that her father died on April 17, 2017; her mother died on
February 18, 2021; and both died intestate. She filed an interim detailed
descriptive list showing the combined value of their estates to be
$155,042.50, consisting entirely of their house and vehicle. Decedents also
maintained bank accounts, but she was unaware of their values.
On August 12, 2022, Karen filed a petition to record and execute her
parents’ Wills. She alleged that the Wills, dated November 11, 2016, were
in statutory form and named her as executrix. She requested that the trial
court name her independent executrix and remove Susan as administrator.
On September 22, 2022, Susan and Bruce filed a petition to annul the
purported Wills. They alleged that one witness did not witness the signing
of the Wills; that the notary signed that witness’s name; and that the notary
did not see Neil in person or witness him sign his Will.
On June 21, 2023, Karen and Kathryn filed a motion to continue.
Their counsel, John McWilliams, stated that he suffered injuries in a motor
vehicle accident that left him unable to properly prepare for the trial
scheduled for July 13, 2023. He also stated that he worked from home and
was without power for nine days in June 2023. Counsel for Susan and Bruce
agreed to the continuance, and the trial court stated that a new trial date
would be fixed by agreement of the parties.
On February 9, 2024, Susan and Bruce filed a motion for summary
judgment.1 They contended that as the decedents did not sign the Wills
purporting to bear their signatures, the Wills were invalid. They attached to
their motion the report and affidavit of Robert Foley, a forensic document
examiner who confirmed that Neil and Doris’s signatures were forgeries.
On April 2, 2024, Karen and Kathryn filed an opposition. They
argued that the allegation that Neil and Doris did not sign the Wills was
false. They attached to their opposition the depositions of Karen, Kathryn,
Sandra, the witnesses to the signings of the Wills, the notary, a family friend
and the decedents’ primary care physician. They also attached the report of
Brenda Petty, a certified questioned document examiner, who opined that
the decedents’ signatures on the Wills were authored by the same hands that
authored their known comparison signatures.
On December 23, 2024, Karen and Kathryn filed a motion to continue
the trial set for March 6, 2025. They stated that Mr. McWilliams could not
properly prepare for trial due to vision loss.
1
Susan and Bruce later withdrew this motion.
2
On January 6, 2025, Susan and Bruce filed an opposition to the
motion to continue. They stated that the case had been pending for three
years and detailed the times that Karen, Kathryn and their counsel delayed
the proceedings. They also alleged that Mr. McWilliams filed a petition in
Richland Parish, naming them as defendants, at the same time he was unable
to prepare for trial in this case. They contended that if Mr. McWilliams was
continually ill or unable to prepare, he had a duty to withdraw and advise his
clients to obtain other counsel.
On January 9, 2025, the parties filed a joint motion to modify the
discovery period. They acknowledged Mr. McWilliams’s health concerns
and agreed to modify the end of the period of discovery from 60 days prior
to trial to 40 days.
On January 31, 2025, Mr. McWilliams filed a response to the
opposition to continue trial. He stated that he advised Karen, Kathryn and
Sandra to seek other counsel to assist him. On February 10, 2025, he filed a
motion to withdraw as counsel. The trial court signed an order allowing him
to withdraw; granted Karen, Kathryn and Sandra 30 days to enroll new
counsel; and continued the trial to a future date agreed to by the parties.
On March 5, 2025, Karen, Kathryn2 and Sandra filed a motion for
David White to enroll as their counsel. The trial court allowed him to enroll.
Following a scheduling conference on April 29, 2025, trial was
scheduled for September 26, 2025.
On September 22, 2025, Mr. White filed a motion to withdraw as
counsel. He stated that information was brought to his attention which led
2
The record suggests that Kathryn passed away in March 2025.
3
him to doubt the legitimacy of the Wills such that to continue to advocate for
their validity would violate Louisiana Rules of Professional Conduct 3.1.
He stated that he explained to his clients that he could not proceed and noted
that he secured permission from opposing counsel to withdraw.
On September 25, 2025, Karen and Sandra, pro se, filed a motion to
continue. They noted that there were four days between Mr. White’s
withdrawal and trial. They contended that it was impossible to obtain new
legal representation and prepare the case for trial. They alleged that
Ms. Petty changed her opinion and that it was difficult to secure another
document examiner.
On September 25, 2025, Susan and Bruce filed an opposition to the
motion to continue. In the alternative, they requested that the court grant
Karen and Sandra 30 days to obtain new counsel, that the scheduling order
remain in place and that the matter be set for the court’s earliest date with no
further continuances.
Following a hearing on September 26, 2025, the trial court allowed
Mr. White to withdraw, granted Karen and Sandra’s motion to continue and
reset the trial for December 12, 2025. It also gave Karen and Sandra 30 days
to retain counsel and 45 days to hire an expert, notify opposing counsel of
the hire and provide the expert report.
On October 27, 2025, Karen and Sandra, pro se, filed a motion to
continue. They stated that despite their diligent and good faith efforts, they
were unable to secure new counsel within the time allowed. They noted that
on September 29, 2025, Sandra’s husband was hospitalized, which limited
their ability to attend to legal matters.
4
On November 6, 2026, Susan and Bruce filed an opposition to the
motion to continue.
On November 10, 2026, Karen and Sandra, pro se, filed a notification
that they retained an expert witness. They noted that they had not secured
legal representation and alleged that potential counsel indicated that the
complexity of the case required additional preparation time to ensure
effective representation.
A hearing was held on November 18, 2025. The trial court denied
Karen and Sandra’s October 27, 2025 motion to continue and explained:
Mr. White filed a motion to withdraw due to I think he put
forward ethical concerns continuing to represent y’all, so I
granted your request for a continuance on September 26th, but I
set the trial date for December 12th. I understand that an
attorney may not want to take over a case that’s been pending
since 2021, however, I’ve got to weigh that against the side’s
right to have the case heard. And I felt like in September they
had a good argument for me not to grant your continuance, but
out of caution I granted it to give y’all time to hire someone.
But I can’t just give y’all an indefinite amount of time and so
with that, your motion for continuance is going to be denied.
On December 12, 2025, the day of trial, Karen and Sandra stated that
they had been working with an attorney, Curtis Shelton, for the past month,
but he needed a minimum of 90 days to prepare. They noted that other
attorneys they contacted needed four to six months to prepare. The trial
court responded:
I’ve reviewed the record and this matter was originally set for
trial sometime in 2023, got continued through no fault of
y’all’s. I think Mr. McWilliams had a car accident. But it’s
been set for trial several times and the last time y’all had Mr.
David White as counsel and on the day of trial he withdrew and
. . . I hear a lot of cases but I feel like y’all were here on that
day and y’all agreed to let me allow him to withdraw and I told
y’all today would be the trial date and I gave y’all time, I even
gave y’all time to hire a new expert which Ms. Todd did not
want me to give y’all. I gave y’all time to do that and I gave
y’all at least 60 days to hire a new attorney. And although this
5
case has been pending a long time, I don’t necessarily think the
issues are that complicated. It’s one side says the wills are
forged, the other side says they aren’t. And I told you that back
in September, that they have just as much of a right to have the
case brought to a conclusion as y’all did to the continuance, but
I granted a continuance. But I can’t just keep granting a
continuance and so I’m not continuing the case.
Trial then commenced.
On December 30, 2025, the trial court signed a judgment ordering that
the Wills filed were null for noncompliance with the formalities of Louisiana
law.
Karen and Sandra, now represented by new counsel, appeal.
DISCUSSION
In their first assignment of error, Karen and Sandra argue that the
district court abused its discretion under La. C.C.P. art. 1601 and denied
them a meaningful opportunity to be heard by refusing to continue the
December 12, 2025 trial after their counsel withdrew. They state that they
diligently but unsuccessfully sought replacement counsel for a complex
succession trial and did not cause the delays. They allege that Mr. White
withdrew without subpoenaing witnesses, filing a pretrial brief or indicating
to them that he had ethical concerns about the case. They argue that the trial
court compelled them to undertake in weeks the work that attorneys advised
would require at least 90 days. They state that they do not claim an
unlimited right to delay but contend that they requested a reasonable
continuance that did not prejudice Susan and Bruce.
Susan and Bruce argue that the trial court did not abuse its discretion
in denying an additional continuance. They contend that Karen and Sandra
had years to prepare, were represented by successive counsel, received
multiple continuances and were given additional time to obtain new counsel
6
and expert assistance before trial. They argue that further delays would have
prejudiced them and frustrated the orderly administration of the successions.
A continuance may be granted in any case if there is good ground
therefor. La. C.C.P. art. 1601.
The trial judge has wide discretion in acting upon a motion for
continuance. Wilkerson v. Darden Direct Distribution, Inc., 53,263 (La.
App. 2 Cir. 3/4/20), 293 So. 3d 146. The ruling will not be disturbed on
appeal in the absence of a clear showing of abuse of that discretion. Id. An
abuse of discretion occurs when such discretion is exercised in a way that
deprives a litigant of his day in court. Id.
The trial court must consider the particular facts in each case in
deciding whether to grant or deny a discretionary continuance. Wilkerson v.
Darden Direct Distribution, Inc., supra. Some factors to consider are
diligence, good faith and reasonable grounds. Id. Equally important is the
defendant’s corollary right to have his case heard as soon as is practicable.
Id. The trial court may also weigh the condition of the court docket, fairness
to both parties and other litigants before the court and the need for orderly
and prompt administration of justice. Id.
Generally, a litigant whose lawyer withdraws at or near trial may be
entitled to a continuance to employ another attorney. Howard v. Lee, 50,366
(La. App. 2 Cir. 1/13/16), 185 So. 3d 144. However, because the
defendant’s desire to have the case against him tried is also a factor, the
claimant is not entitled to indefinite continuances simply because he is
unable to secure counsel. Id. Because the discharge of one’s lawyer is not,
by itself, grounds for the postponing of another party’s access to the courts
7
for a decision in a pending action, the client bears the burden of showing
other circumstances that would justify a continuance. Id.
Under the particular circumstances of this case, the trial court abused
its discretion in denying Karen and Sandra’s October 27, 2025 motion to
continue the December 12, 2025 trial. This case is distinguishable from In
re Ginger Evelyn Brazzel 2011 Inter Vivos Tr., 56,702 (La. App. 2 Cir.
12/10/25), 427 So. 3d 335, where this court found that the trial court did not
abuse its discretion in denying a motion to continue but emphasized that the
parties did not avail themselves of counsel during the four years the suit was
pending. See also Johnson v. Bhandari, 52,545 (La. App. 2 Cir. 2/27/19),
266 So. 3d 961, writ denied, 19-0658 (La. 6/17/19), 274 So. 3d 572. Here,
Karen and Sandra were represented by counsel from when they filed their
original petition until Mr. White withdrew. They did not discharge either of
their counsel—Mr. McWilliams withdrew due to health concerns, and
Mr. White withdrew pursuant to Louisiana Rules of Professional Conduct
3.1. The record suggests that they exercised diligence and good faith to
obtain new counsel after Mr. White’s withdrawal. In their October 27, 2025
motion to continue, they noted that they worked with the Louisiana State Bar
Association to secure new representation but had not been successful. In
their November 10, 2026 filing, they stated that they had not yet hired a new
attorney because potential counsel required additional time to effectively
prepare for trial. On December 12, 2025, they named the attorney they had
been working with for a month to prepare for trial but explained he needed a
minimum of 90 days to represent them.
This court recognizes the considerations of fairness to Susan and
Bruce and of the orderly and prompt administration of justice. We
8
emphasize that Karen and Susan are not entitled to indefinite continuances.
However, the record in this case suggests that with a continuance of 90 days,
Karen and Susan could have had their day in court and been represented by
counsel who had a reasonable amount of time to prepare for trial.
Accordingly, this assignment of error has merit. This finding
pretermits discussion of Karen and Sandra’s remaining assignments of error.
CONCLUSION
For the foregoing reasons, we reverse the trial court’s denial of Karen
Moore and Sandra Moore Graves’s motion to continue, vacate its judgment
nullifying the last wills and testaments of Neil E. Moore and Doris Helena
Ward Moore and remand for further proceedings. Costs of this appeal are
assessed to Susan Moore Rush and Bruce Moore.
JUDGMENT REVERSED; JUDGMENT VACATED;
REMANDED FOR FURTHER PROCEEDINGS.
9