Jason Danial Louie, V. Valerie Smith
CourtCourt of Appeals of Washington
Date FiledNovember 16, 2026
Docket87499-3
StatusUnpublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON
IN THE MATTER OF THE PARENTING No. 87499-3-I
AND SUPPORT OF
DIVISION ONE
V.L.S.
UNPUBLISHED OPINION
JASON DANIAL LOUIE,
Respondent,
v.
VALERIE CHRISTAL SMITH,
Appellant.
FELDMAN, J. — Valerie Smith appeals a superior court order concluding that
Jason Louie was in compliance with the court’s previous order arising out of a
parenting plan and ordering Smith to pay Louie’s attorney fees based on
intransigence. Concluding that Louie failed to comply with those recommendations
in accordance with the superior court’s order, we reverse and remand.
I
Smith and Louie share one child together, born in 2018. After the parties
separated, Louie filed a motion to establish parentage and request for a temporary
parenting plan. A temporary parenting plan was entered in August 2021.
Following a contested hearing in July 2023, the superior court entered a
final parenting plan and a final order and findings for a parenting plan, residential
No. 87499-3-I
schedule and/or child support. The parenting plan ordered that the child live with
Smith except for every other weekend, Thursday to Monday, when the child would
live with Louie. The court found that Louie had a history of domestic violence and
that “Mr. Louie’s mental health conditions continue to require treatment, and that
the best interests of the child require a mechanism to ensure continued compliance
with treatment.” The court therefore ordered that Louie be evaluated for mental
health conditions within sixty days of entry of the order and “start (or continue) and
comply with treatment . . . as recommended by the evaluation.” The court also
ordered Louie to provide to Smith or her attorney a copy of the evaluation and
quarterly compliance reports. The court further ordered that if Louie did not follow
the evaluation or treatment requirements, his residential time “shall be limited to
supervised contact of up to four hours on Saturday and Sunday every other week.”
Louie subsequently provided Smith a July 17, 2023 mental health
evaluation, which Smith believed was “insufficient” to address the court’s mental
health concerns. Smith then filed a motion requesting that the superior court clarify
its requirement for a mental health evaluation contained in the parenting plan. The
superior court granted the motion and issued a written order (referred to herein as
the December 2023 Clarification Order) clarifying the mental health evaluation
requirement as follows:
1. The father is required to do a new full mental health evaluation,
which shall include consideration of collateral information
provided by the mother as well as the father’s prior mental health
care providers. The evaluator shall consider any collateral
information provided by the mother, including final orders in this
case or any other relevant pleadings.
-2-
No. 87499-3-I
2. Medication management for the father should be addressed in
the Mental health evaluation in the context of the father’s medical
history.
3. The Mental health evaluation should be conducted by a mental
health professional qualified to identify and diagnose bipolar
disorder and ADHD and other potential mental health conditions
that may require treatment for the child’s safety.
4. The father is required to disclose the full Mental health evaluation
to the mother and mother’s counsel as well as proof of immediate
compliance with recommendations from the evaluation and any
resulting additional providers.
Critical to our analysis, number 4 above required Louie to disclose to Smith and
her counsel both the full mental health evaluation and “proof of immediate
compliance with recommendations from the evaluation.”
In March 2024, Smith petitioned to modify the parenting plan and for an
immediate restraining order. The petition alleged that Louie “has refused to comply
with a court ordered mental health evaluation with collateral information from
Valerie Smith for a protracted period.” The petition further alleged that Louie had
taken the child for an unsupervised visit, violating the final parenting plan, and
“[t]he child has also reported extremely unsanitary conditions in the father’s home
and she has also disclosed behaviors by the father consistent with sexual abuse.”
An immediate restraining order was entered which limited Louie’s visitation to
supervised visits of up to four hours on Saturday and Sunday every other week,
as per the court’s final parenting plan.
Following an adequate cause hearing in June 2024, the superior court
issued a written order finding there was not adequate cause to hold a full hearing
or trial on the petition to modify the parenting plan and denied a restraining order.
-3-
No. 87499-3-I
The written order stated that “[b]oth attorneys confirmed on the record that their
understanding is that petitioner’s visitation is required to be supervised until he
completes a MH [mental health] eval[uation] that complies with [the December
2023 Clarification Order].” Smith also sought a domestic violence protection order,
based on mostly the same issues, which was denied in July 2024.
On July 19, 2024, Louie provided to Smith’s counsel a mental health
evaluation completed by evaluator Cimberleigh McLean. In relevant part, the
evaluation recommended a domestic violence assessment and a parenting
evaluation. On August 7, 2024, Louie filed a motion to enforce the parenting plan.
The motion asserted that Louie had provided the court-required mental health
evaluation to Smith and was following the parenting plan. Louie stated he had not
had an “unsupervised visit” with the child since March 2024 nor any “direct contact”
with her since June 2024. Louie requested that the court order Smith to comply
with the parties’ parenting plan “and stop withholding the parties’ child from
residential visits” with him, order that Louie be allowed make-up time with the child,
and order Smith to pay Louie’s attorney fees.
In response to Louie’s motion, Smith requested that the court order that
Louie “must substantially comply with the recommendations from Cimberleigh
McLean’s Mental Health Evaluation of July 11, 2024 before he may move to
unsupervised visits with the child.” Smith argued that Louie needed to obtain the
domestic violence assessment and parenting evaluation recommended by the
mental health evaluation before Louie returned to unsupervised visits. Smith
-4-
No. 87499-3-I
further asked that the court deny Louie’s request for make-up time and deny
Louie’s request for attorney fees and instead order him to pay her attorney fees.
On September 16, 2024, a superior court commissioner issued a written
order granting Louie’s motion to enforce and ordering that Louie “will immediately
begin his full visitation—every other weekend without supervision.” Relevant to
this appeal, the commissioner found that Louie had complied with the requirement
for a mental health evaluation and disclosed it to Smith and her counsel as per the
December 2023 Clarification Order. Regarding the recommendations from the
evaluation, the commissioner wrote: “As of the hearing, Father has begun the
steps to do the DV assessment and a parenting evaluation, but they have not been
completed. However, the Court does not find that [the December 2023
Clarification Order] envisioned these further types of recommendations.” The
commissioner also ruled that they could order Louie to pay Smith’s attorney fees
based on Smith’s intransigence or pursuant to RCW 26.26B.060.
Smith filed a motion for revision. On October 14, 2024, the superior court
issued a written order denying Smith’s motion, stating:
After reviewing the record de novo, being apprised of all relevant law,
and having determined that oral argument is not required, the Court
adopts the findings and conclusions contained in the September 16,
2024 Order in their entirety. The Commissioner’s findings and
conclusions were thorough, took into consideration the relevant facts
and law, and correctly construed this Court’s Final Parenting Plan
and subsequent Order Clarifying Final Parenting Plan.
The superior court also ordered Smith to pay Louie’s attorney fees. Smith appeals.
-5-
No. 87499-3-I
II
Smith argues the superior court erred in concluding that Louie was in
compliance with the December 2023 Clarification Order. We agree.
When an appeal is taken from an order denying revision of a court
commissioner’s decision, we review the superior court’s decision, not the
commissioner’s. In re Marriage of Maldonado, 197 Wn. App. 779, 789, 391 P.3d
546 (2017). “We review challenged findings of fact for substantial evidence and
the conclusions of law de novo.” In re Guardianship of Knutson, 160 Wn. App.
854, 863, 250 P.3d 1072 (2011) (citing In re Marriage of Dodd, 120 Wn. App. 638,
644, 86 P.3d 801 (2004)). Here, the superior court, in denying Smith’s motion for
revision, indicated that it “adopt[ed] the findings and conclusions contained in the
September 16, 2024 Order in their entirety.” For this reason, we refer to the
findings and conclusions set forth in the commissioner’s decision, notwithstanding
that we review the decision of the superior court.
We review the interpretation of a court order de novo. See In re Marriage
of Thompson, 97 Wn. App. 873, 877, 988 P.2d 499 (1999). We interpret trial court
orders to effectuate the issuing court’s intent. Id. at 878. To determine that intent,
we employ the ordinary rules of construction for statutes and contracts. Id. When
interpreting statutes and contracts, we give effect to the plain meaning of the text.
Matter of Dependency of C.E.C.L., 30 Wn. App. 2d 352, 355, 545 P.3d 329 (2024);
Panorama Vill. Condo. Owners Ass'n Bd. of Directors v. Allstate Ins. Co., 144
Wn.2d 130, 140, 26 P.3d 910 (2001). Also critical here, “We interpret only what
-6-
No. 87499-3-I
was written in the agreement, not what the parties intended to write.” Martin v.
Smith, 192 Wn. App. 527, 532, 368 P.3d 227 (2016).
Thus, we begin with the plain language of the December 2023 Clarification
Order. As noted previously, the order states in relevant part that Louie “is required
to disclose the full Mental health evaluation to the mother and mother’s counsel as
well as proof of immediate compliance with recommendations from the evaluation
. . . .” (Emphasis added.) Turning to those recommendations, McLean’s
evaluation recommends as follows:
• Engage in a domestic violence assessment with a state certified
provider and follow recommendations. While the court did not find
for a DV assessment in 2023, this clinician was given information
that indicates this would be an appropriate next move.
Advantages Plus Counseling recommended.
• To resolve questions of Mr. Louie’s ability to parent appropriately,
it appears it would be in the best interest for Mr. Louie to engage
in a parenting evaluation and follow recommendations. It is never
in the best interest of the child for the parents to remain in conflict
and utilize courts to obstruct parenting and relationship
development. Advantages Plus Counseling recommended.
Therefore, under the plain language of the December 2023 Clarification Order,
Louie was required to provide “proof of immediate compliance” with both a
domestic violence assessment and parenting evaluation.
But he did not. To the contrary, the superior court found that “[a]s of the
hearing [on Louie’s motion to enforce], Father has begun the steps to do the DV
assessment and a parenting evaluation, but they have not been completed.”
Louie does not challenge this finding, so it is a verity on appeal. In re Marriage of
Laidlaw, 2 Wn. App. 2d 381, 386, 409 P.3d 1184 (2018). Accordingly, it is
undisputed that Louie has not provided to Smith and her counsel “proof of
-7-
No. 87499-3-I
immediate compliance” with the recommendations for a domestic violence
assessment and parenting evaluation and, consequently, he is not in compliance
with this requirement as set forth in the December 2023 Clarification Order.
Louie’s contrary arguments lack merit. He argues:
Judge Campagna [the superior court judge] issued the initial orders
requiring a mental health evaluation and he conducted a de novo
review of the commissioner’s decision. Having written the orders,
Judge Campagna was certainly capable of interpreting his own
orders—which did not . . . extend the evaluation to other matters . . . .
To the extent the appellant argues that the recommendations were
not followed, again, the Judge who issued the order was in the best
place to make that determination and this court should not second
guess those findings.
This argument ignores the applicable standard of review, which requires us to
interpret the December 2023 Clarification Order de novo, without deference to the
superior court. The plain language of the order, addressed above, contradicts the
superior court’s ruling.
The superior court erred in excusing Louie’s noncompliance with the
recommendations from mental health evaluation on specious grounds. In doing
so, the court adopted the commissioner’s determination that “the Court does not
find that Judge Campagna’s December 2023 Order envisioned these further types
of recommendations.” But under controlling Washington law, we interpret written
contracts (and hence the superior court’s order) based on “the objective
manifestations of the agreement, rather than on the unexpressed subjective intent
of the parties.” Hearst Commc'ns, Inc. v. Seattle Times Co., 154 Wn.2d 493, 503,
115 P.3d 262 (2005). Where, as here, the plain language of a superior court order
is clear, “only a plain language analysis . . . is appropriate.” Cerrillo v. Esparza,
-8-
No. 87499-3-I
158 Wn.2d 194, 201, 142 P.3d 155 (2006). The superior court’s reliance on what
may have been “envisioned” by the drafter is legally erroneous.
Any such attempt to rewrite the December 2023 Clarification Order in this
manner is also procedurally improper. Upon receiving the mental health evaluation
from McLean, if either party objected to the treatment recommendations they could
have raised that issue in the superior court, as Smith did in moving to clarify the
final parenting plan after receiving the initial mental health evaluation that she
believed was “insufficient.” Neither party did so. Instead, Louie filed a motion to
enforce the parenting plan. That is not an appropriate way to modify the plain
language of the December 2023 Clarification Order.
In short, because it is undisputed that Louie did not submit proof of
compliance with the recommendations from the mental health evaluation to
engage in a domestic violence assessment and parenting evaluation, he failed to
comply with the December 2023 Clarification Order. The superior court erred in
concluding otherwise.
III
Given our reversal of the superior court’s order concluding that Louie was
in compliance with the December 2023 Clarification Order, we vacate its related
order requiring Smith to pay Louie’s attorney fees. Louie also requests an award
of attorney fees on appeal pursuant to RCW 26.26B.060 or RAP 18.1 or 18.9,
arguing that Smith’s appeal is frivolous, in bad faith, or intransigent. As we agree
with Smith that Louie has not complied with the December 2023 Clarification
-9-
No. 87499-3-I
Order, and Smith’s appeal plainly is not frivolous, in bad faith, or intransigent, we
deny Louie’s request for attorney fees on appeal.
Reversed and remanded.
WE CONCUR:
- 10 -