Howard Ross v. West Wind Condominium Association
CourtCourt of Civil Appeals of Alabama
Date FiledNovember 20, 2026
DocketCL-2026-0533
JudgeMoore, P.J.
StatusPublished
📰 News Coverage: Read the LAWS.com news report on this case
Full Opinion
Rel: November 20, 2026
Notice: This opinion is subject to formal revision before publication in the advance sheets of Southern Reporter.
Readers are requested to notify the Reporter of Decisions, Alabama Appellate Courts, 300 Dexter Avenue,
Montgomery, Alabama 36104-3741 ((334) 229-0650), of any typographical or other errors, in order that corrections
may be made before the opinion is published in Southern Reporter.
ALABAMA COURT OF CIVIL APPEALS
OCTOBER TERM, 2026-2027
_________________________
CL-2026-0533
_________________________
Howard Ross
v.
West Wind Condominium Association
Appeal from Madison Circuit Court
(CV-22-146)
MOORE, Presiding Judge.
Howard Ross appeals from a judgment entered by the Madison
Circuit Court ("the trial court"), on remand by this court, against Ross
and in favor of West Wind Condominium Association ("West Wind"), in
CL-2026-0533
the amount of $29,721.83, plus interest and costs. We reverse the trial
court's judgment.
Background
This case has previously been before this court. Ross v. West Wind
Condo. Ass'n, 426 So. 3d 1212 (Ala. Civ. App. 2025) ("Ross"), and Ross v.
West Wind Condo. Ass'n, [Ms. CL-2025-0534, Feb. 13, 2026] ___ So. 3d
___ (Ala. Civ. App. 2026) ("Ross I"). We take judicial notice of the records
in Ross and Ross I. See City of Mobile v. Matthews, 220 So. 3d 1061,
1063-64 & n.3 (Ala. Civ. App. 2016) (explaining the circumstances under
which an appellate court may take judicial notice of its own records in a
different appeal). In Ross, this court outlined the relevant procedural
history as follows:
"The West Wind Condominiums consists of two buildings, one
containing 10 units, including Unit J, and one containing 12
units, including Unit D. Ross owns Unit D and Unit J. West
Wind charges $115 per month for homeowners' dues on each
unit; despite repeated demands, Ross has not paid the total
dues that have accumulated since 2017.
"On November 30, 2018, the building containing Unit D
was declared to be unsafe by the City of Huntsville due to an
electrical problem, and West Wind was ordered to repair the
unsafe building. West Wind raised the approximately
$60,000 needed to pay for the repair work by assessing the
owners of the units in the unsafe building. For his part, Ross,
as the owner of Unit D, was assessed $4,980, which he did not
2
CL-2026-0533
pay. The repairs were completed, and the City of Huntsville
allowed the building to be reoccupied in December 2022.
"On August 2, 2021, West Wind filed a complaint
against Ross in the Madison District Court ('the district
court'), asserting that Ross owed West Wind homeowners''
dues for Unit D and Unit J in addition to condominium
assessments for Unit D. Following a trial, the district court
entered a judgment in favor of West Wind and against Ross
in the amount of $7,964.32. On November 28, 2022, Ross
timely appealed the district court's judgment to the trial
court.
On appeal, West Wind amended its complaint to
increase its claim for damages; Ross counterclaimed for lost
rent during the period in which the building housing Unit D
was uninhabitable and for ejectment. The trial court
conducted a bench trial on September 18, 2023. On the
following day, the trial court entered a final judgment
awarding West Wind $29,267.29, plus interest. On October
14, 2023, Ross filed a postjudgment motion; the trial court
entered an order denying that motion on October 19, 2023.
Ross timely appealed."
426 So. 3d at 1216.
In Ross I, this court explained:
"In Ross [v. West Wind Condo. Ass'n, 426 So. 3d 1212
(Ala. Civ. App. 2025) ('Ross')], this court, on November 8,
2024, initially reversed in part and affirmed in part a
judgment entered by the trial court against Ross for unpaid
homeowners' dues and assessments totaling $29,267.29. On
November 22, 2024, Ross filed an application for rehearing,
which this court granted. On February 7, 2025, this court
issued a substituted opinion reversing the judgment for the
unpaid assessments and affirming the judgment for the
unpaid homeowners' dues. We remanded the case to the trial
3
CL-2026-0533
court with instructions that it 'recalculate the amount of its
judgment,' and we affirmed the trial court's judgment in all
other respects. Ross, ___ So. 3d at ___. On February 21, 2025,
Ross filed a second application for rehearing; on March 21,
2025, this court entered an order overruling Ross's application
for rehearing. On April 9, 2025, this court issued its certificate
of judgment.
"Meanwhile, on November 20, 2024, the trial court, in
response to our opinion on original submission in Ross,
purported to enter an amended judgment against Ross in the
amount of '$29,721.83, plus interest[] and costs.' On February
14, 2025, in response to our opinion on application for
rehearing in Ross, West Wind filed a motion requesting that
the trial court reenter its amended judgment reflecting the
recalculated amount owed by Ross to West Wind. On that
same date, the trial court entered an order granting West
Wind's motion, and, in a separate order, it again purported to
render a judgment against Ross in the amount of '$29,721.83,
plus interest[] and costs.' On May 6, 2025, Ross filed a motion
to vacate the trial court's February 14, 2025, amended
judgment; the trial court entered an order denying Ross's
motion on May 15, 2025. On April 17, 2025, the trial court
ordered the clerk of the court to satisfy the February 14, 2025,
amended judgment, along with postjudgment interest and
costs, out of a cash bond that Ross had submitted as security
for his appeal in Ross, and, on May 1, 2025, a document was
filed indicating that a $36,584.12 check had been disbursed
from Ross's cash bond. On June 26, 2025, Ross filed a notice
of appeal from the February 14, 2025, amended judgment."
Ross I, ___ So. 3d at ___.
This court determined in Ross I that the trial court lacked
jurisdiction to enter its February 14, 2025, amended judgment because
this court had not yet entered its certificate of judgment in Ross and that,
4
CL-2026-0533
because that judgment was void, the trial court's subsequent order to
release funds from Ross's cash bond to West Wind, to the extent that that
order was based on the trial court's February 14, 2025, amended
judgment, was also void. Ross I, ___ So. 3d at ___. On March 3, 2026,
this court entered its certificate of judgment in Ross I.
On March 11, 2026, the trial court entered an order that states, in
pertinent part:
"4. Of the $29,267.29 Judgment, $5,000 was assessed as
a judgment against [Ross] pursuant to the $60,000 work done
on the condominium.
"5. The Appellate Court directed that said $60,000
should be divided among all units and therefore there are a
total of 22 units in the West Wind Condominiums two
buildings.
"6. Dividing $60,000 between the two units results in a
amount of $2,727.27 per unit.
"7. The Court finds that … Ross owned two units in the
condominiums therefore his portion of the $60,000 totals
$5,454.54."
The trial court concluded that a judgment remains in effect against Ross
in the amount of $24,267.29, and it rendered a judgment against Ross
"for $5,454.54, for a total judgment of $29,721.83, plus interest and
costs." (Footnote omitted.) On March 12, 2026, Ross filed a postjudgment
5
CL-2026-0533
motion; on May 1, 2026, the trial court entered an order denying the
motion. Ross timely filed a notice of appeal to this court.
Discussion
Ross argues on appeal that, on remand, the trial court failed to
comply with this court's instructions in Ross and that the damages
awarded to West Wind for assessments are due to be vacated. Ross
asserts that the law-of-the-case doctrine required the trial court to
comply with this court's mandate in Ross.
In Ross, this court considered Ross's argument on appeal "that the
assessment for the repair work done to the building containing Unit D
was invalid because," among other things, "the assessment was not
apportioned among the owners of all the units in both buildings of the
West Wind Condominiums." Id. at1217. We recounted the evidence
indicating that the approximately $60,000 that had been assessed
against the unit owners in the unsafe building had been used primarily
to repair common elements, that West Wind's declaration provided that
each unit owner was to be allocated an equal liability for common
expenses, and that West Wind's vice president had testified that West
6
CL-2026-0533
Wind had levied assessments against only the owners of the units in the
unsafe building. Id. We concluded, in pertinent part:
"Based on its own declaration and bylaws, West Wind could
not levy assessments against only the owners of the units in
the unsafe building; thus, the assessment levied against Ross
was not valid and enforceable. We, therefore, reverse the
judgment to the extent that it awarded West Wind damages
for Ross's nonpayment of the assessment, which West Wind
calculated to be $5,840.12 with late fees and interest."
Id. In our conclusion, we "reverse[d] the trial court's award insofar as it
awarded West Wind damages for Ross's failure to pay the assessment,
which we … concluded was improperly apportioned amongst less than all
the unit owners of both buildings, and we remand[ed] the case to the trial
court to recalculate the amount of its judgment." Id. at 1222. We
otherwise affirmed the trial court's judgment. Id.
In its March 11, 2026, judgment, the trial court stated, in pertinent
part, that this court "directed that said $60,000 should be divided among
all units and therefore there are a total of 22 units in the West Wind
Condominiums two buildings." In West Wind's brief, it asserts that, in
Ross, this court "reversed the trial court's award insofar as it awarded
West Wind damages for Ross's failure to pay the assessment and
remanded the case to the trial court to recalculate its judgment for only
7
CL-2026-0533
the assessment." West Wind's brief, p. 10. It is apparent that both the
trial court and West Wind have misconstrued this court's remand order.
In Honda Manufacturing of Alabama, LLC v. Alford, 47 So. 3d 1283,
1285-86 (Ala. Civ. App. 2010), this court stated, in pertinent part:
" 'When a case is remanded to a trial court after a decision on
appeal, "issues decided by the appellate court become law of
the case and the trial court's duty is to comply with the
appellate mandate...." ' Erbe v. Eady, 447 So. 2d 778, 779 (Ala.
Civ. App. 1984) (quoting Walker v. Carolina Mills Lumber
Co., 441 So. 2d 980, 982 (Ala. Civ. App. 1983)). We further
noted in Erbe that '[t]he trial court is not free to reconsider
issues finally decided in the mandate.' Id. (emphasis added).
The decisions of the Alabama Supreme Court are in accord
with Erbe. See Gray v. Reynolds, 553 So. 2d 79, 81 (Ala.
1989); Auerbach v. Parker, 558 So. 2d 900, 902 (Ala. 1989)
(noting principles set forth in Erbe and further noting
authorities for the proposition that when a cause is remanded
with directions as to the judgment to be entered, that
judgment should be entered without a new trial).
"… It is well settled that '[t]he issues decided by an
appellate court become the law of the case on remand to the
trial court, and the trial court is not free to reconsider those
issues'; further, ' "whatever is once established between the
same parties in the same case continues to be the law of that
case, whether or not correct on general principles, so long as
the facts on which the decision was predicated continue to be
the facts of the case." ' Ex parte S.T.S., 806 So. 2d 336, 341
(Ala. 2001) (emphasis added; quoting Blumberg v. Touche
Ross & Co., 514 So. 2d 922, 924 (Ala. 1997))."
In the present case, this court concluded that the assessment levied
against Ross was "not valid and enforceable;" we reversed the trial court's
8
CL-2026-0533
award insofar as it awarded West Wind damages for Ross's failure to pay
the assessment, and we directed the trial court to recalculate the amount
of its judgment. Ross, 426 So. 3d at 1218. The issue of the validity of
the assessment having been decided by this court, the trial court was not
free to reconsider that issue. See Alford, supra. On remand, however,
rather than recalculate the judgment in light of this court's
determination that the assessment was invalid and would not support an
award of damages against Ross, the trial court recalculated the
assessment. Because the issue of the assessment's validity had been
decided in Ross, the trial court erred by awarding West Wind damages
based on a recalculated amount of the assessment. Accordingly, we
reverse the trial court's judgment, and we remand the case for the entry
of a final judgment in accordance with this court's mandate in Ross,
excluding any amounts purporting to be based on the invalid assessment
that was levied against Ross.
Ross also argues on appeal that he should receive a credit toward
the total amount of the judgment against him based on rental amounts
that he claims were owed to him and which West Wind had seized and
based on a judgment that had been entered in a previous action in favor
9
CL-2026-0533
of Ross and against West Wind in the amount of $9,800. Ross fails,
however, to cite any authority in support of his argument that the trial
court was required to award him a credit for those amounts against the
judgment that was entered in favor of West Wind based on the claims at
issue in the present action between the parties. See Rule 28(a)(10), Ala.
R. App. P. Accordingly, we decline to further consider that argument.
Conclusion
Because the trial court failed to comply with this court's remand
instructions in Ross, we reverse the trial court's March 11, 2026,
judgment and remand the case for the trial court to recalculate its
judgment in accordance with Ross, as outlined in this opinion.
REVERSED AND REMANDED WITH INSTRUCTIONS.
Edwards, Hanson, Fridy, and Bowden, JJ., concur.
10